# Blind-Spot Analysis: School Policy vs. Learner Reality

Blind-spot analysis sets a school's rules beside what learners live. Steps, a template, DepEd's rules on learner voice (PPSSH 1.6), and four worked examples.

This is the Markdown copy of [Blind-Spot Analysis: School Policy vs. Learner Reality](https://nash.com.ph/blog/learner-voice-school-policy-blind-spot-analysis), an article on the NASH Reviewer Blog by Mark Anthony Llego, published Nov 18, 2026. Topics: School leadership, Aspiring school heads. NASH Reviewer is an independent practice platform not affiliated with DepEd, BHROD, or NEAP.

A blind-spot analysis compares a school's policies, and the assumptions of the adults who run it, with what its learners actually live and report. The school head takes one rule, writes down what the rule takes for granted about learners, and tests each assumption against what learners say and what can be seen at the hour the rule applies. Whatever learners know about the rule that the adults do not is a blind spot.

As of November 18, 2026, no DepEd order uses the term. The work it names is DepEd's all the same. The Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads (PPSSH) expect a school head to "Utilize learner voice, such as feelings, views and/or opinions to inform policy development and decision-making towards school improvement" ([DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2020/09/07/september-7-2020-do-024-s-2020-national-adoption-and-implementation-of-the-philippine-professional-standards-for-school-heads/), indicator 1.6.2). The guidebook for the School Improvement Plan (SIP) tells a school's project team to draw "What you think the process is" and "What the process really is" as separate maps ([DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/09/29/do-44-s-2015-guidelines-on-the-enhanced-school-improvement-planning-sip-process-and-the-school-report-card-src/), Annex 7).

The two can be far apart. In 2022, 43% of girls and 53% of boys aged 15 in Philippine schools said they were bullied at least a few times a month. In the same years the Second Congressional Commission on Education (EDCOM II) found official databases with "many schools reporting 'zero cases'".

## Key findings

- **A blind-spot analysis tests one rule against the learners it governs.** It sets what the rule assumes beside what learners report and what can be observed. No DepEd order uses the name; the SIP Guidebook's own words for the two sides are "What you think the process is" and "What the process really is" (DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 7).
- **The PPSSH asks for the work in two strands.** Strand 1.6 has the school head use learner voice "to inform policy development and decision-making", and Strand 1.3 is policy implementation and review. The PPSSH glossary defines policy review as "the evaluation of a policy to ascertain its impact with regards to the issue it sought to address" (DO 024, s. 2020).
- **Listening to learners is a step of the SIP that "should not be skipped".** The project team is to "talk to the learners and stakeholders" so that "the real needs and problems of the learners and stakeholders can be identified" (DO 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Activity 3.3).
- **DepEd now requires a feedback channel on a school's safety rules.** Schools "shall establish official channels, physical or online, for learners, parents, and staff to provide feedback – anonymously or named – on M&E, interventions, and protocols", and that feedback "shall be incorporated into school guidelines" ([DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/03/24/march-24-2026-do-006-s-2026-guidelines-on-ensuring-a-safe-and-motivating-learning-environment-esmle/), dated March 24, 2026, Sec. VII.C.3). The order's "protocols" are the code of conduct, the learner handbook and security measures.
- **A clean record can hide the gap.** In PISA 2022, 43% of girls and 53% of boys in the Philippines "reported being the victim of bullying acts at least a few times a month" (OECD country note, p. 6), while "Official databases continue to show many schools reporting 'zero cases'" (EDCOM II Final Report, p. 199). The anti-bullying rules now say that zero reporting "shall not automatically be construed as a reflection of positive performance of the school" (Revised IRR of RA 10627, Sec. 24.1).
- **Some of the school's own tools record the adults' view.** The Child-Friendly School Survey is "to be accomplished by the School Planning Team", which has at least seven members and one "Student representative" (DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 11 and Activity 1.2).
- **Being responsive goes with slightly better results, in one study.** Among 5,584 ninth graders in 86 Chicago high schools, those who rated adults as most responsive to students' concerns (the 90th percentile) had an expected grade point average of 2.83 and an expected absence rate of 6.2%; for those who rated them least responsive (the 10th percentile) the figures were 2.69 and 6.9%. The study is observational and from one district (Kahne and others, 2022).

## What is a blind-spot analysis?

A blind-spot analysis is a check on one school policy at a time. It has two columns. The first holds the rule as written and what the school's adults believe about how it works. The second holds what learners report and what an observer sees where the rule applies. The analysis is the comparison of the two.

Three things can come out of it:

1. **The rule works as the adults believe.** The school now has evidence for that, and learners have been asked.
2. **The rule is sound but is not being carried out as written.** The canteen is supposed to have food through recess and runs out in ten minutes.
3. **The rule rests on something that is not true for some learners.** A reminder to "come on time" assumes that arriving on time is in the learner's hands.

Take a school that runs the Physical Fitness Test and records each learner's body mass index, as [DepEd Order No. 034, s. 2019](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2019/12/09/december-9-2019-do-034-s-2019-revised-physical-fitness-test-manual/) requires. The same learners walk out of the gate each afternoon past a row of stalls selling soft drinks and chips. The test is in the school's records and the stalls are not. Or take a school that keeps its gate closed at recess so that learners buy from the canteen, and has never timed the line or counted the learners who buy nothing.

The name comes from the Johari window, a model that Joseph Luft and Harrington Ingham presented in 1955. It sorts what is known about a person into four areas, and the blind area holds what others can see and the person cannot. The [guide to the school head as a person](https://nash.com.ph/blog/school-head-personal-vision-values-philosophy) applies it to a school head's own leadership. Here it is drawn for a school: the adults who make and apply a rule on one side, and the learners who live under it on the other.

**The window: one rule, four panes.** A junior high school of 1,400 learners keeps its gate closed at recess, so the only food on sale to its learners is the canteen’s. The school, the rule and every fact below are invented. The four quadrants are Luft and Ingham’s Johari window, set here for a school’s adults and its learners.

**Shared** (known to the school’s adults and to learners; Luft’s “open” quadrant)

- The rule itself, and the recess bell at 9:30.
- The guard closes the gate at recess.

**Blind spot** (known to learners, not to the adults; Luft’s “blind” quadrant)

- The rice meals are sold out before the last sections reach the counter. *Shared once the school “adds a learner survey”.*
- Most of the 20-minute recess goes to standing in line. *Shared once the school “adds a learner survey”.*
- Some learners skip recess food because the cheapest canteen meal costs more than their daily allowance. *Shared once the school “adds interviews and group discussions”.*
- Learners buy through the fence from the vendors outside, where the food costs less. *Shared once the school “adds interviews and group discussions”.*

**Untold** (known to the adults, not to learners; Luft’s “hidden” quadrant)

- The rule was made after a learner was sideswiped by a tricycle outside the gate. *Shared once the school “explains the rule and its reason”.*
- The canteen may sell only what DepEd’s healthy food rules allow, which is why the soft drinks went. *Shared once the school “explains the rule and its reason”.*
- After the survey the canteen opened a second counter and moved two grade levels to a later recess. *Shared once the school “reports back what it changed”.*

**Unknown** (known to neither; Luft’s “unknown” quadrant)

- Whether the sections that eat last are the ones whose marks dip in the period after recess. *Shared once the school “adds interviews and group discussions” and the school “reports back what it changed”.*

Asking learners moves facts out of the blind spot, and telling learners moves facts out of the untold pane. At the start 2 of 10 facts are shared; when the school has asked through a survey, interviews and group discussions, and has explained the rule and reported back, all 10 are.

The window shows that the gap runs in two directions. Some facts are known to learners and not to the adults, and those come over only when the school asks. Other facts are known to the adults and not to learners: why the rule exists, what it allows, what was changed after the last complaint. Those come over only when the school tells. A school that surveys its learners and never reports back has closed half the gap.

## Why a rule on paper and a learner's day differ

### A rule reaches learners through people

Looking back in 1990 at a study of federally funded change projects in United States schools, carried out from 1973 to 1978, one of its researchers wrote a sentence that is still quoted: "Policy cannot mandate what matters. What matters most to policy outcomes are local capacity and will" (McLaughlin, 1990, p. 12). The study had found, she wrote, that "local choices about how (or whether) to put a policy into practice have more significance for policy outcomes than do such policy features as technology, program design, funding levels, or governance requirements".

Curriculum researchers have a vocabulary for the same distance. They separate the intended curriculum (what the documents say), the implemented curriculum (what teachers do with it) and the attained curriculum, which includes the "Learning experiences as perceived by learners" (Thijs and van den Akker, 2009, Table 2). A school rule has the same three levels: the handbook, the guard at the gate, and the learner in the line. A review that reads only the handbook has reviewed one level of three.

### Adults and learners describe different schools

In a 2008 survey of 11,674 students and 1,027 staff in 44 schools of one Maryland district, staff "were 4.6 times as likely to report feeling safe, as compared to students" and 2.4 times as likely to report a sense of belonging (Waasdorp and others, 2011). The staff were not blind to bullying. They reported witnessing it more often than students did. They simply experienced a safer building than the learners in it.

People also tend to trust their own view. In three studies, people saw bias "much more in others than in themselves". In one, those who had rated themselves above average held to their self-assessments "even after reading a description of how they could have been affected by the relevant bias" (Pronin, Lin and Ross, 2002). A school head who is sure a rule works has the same reason as anyone else to check with someone who stands in a different place.

### Learners often do not tell

Among 2,766 pupils aged 9 to 11 in 32 Dutch elementary schools, "Almost half of the bullied children did not tell their teacher that they were being bullied" (Fekkes and others, 2005). In the United States' national survey for school year 2021-2022, an adult at school was notified for 44.2% of students aged 12 to 18 who reported being bullied (National Center for Education Statistics, 2024). The nearest Philippine figure is about violence of every kind. In the 2016 National Baseline Study on Violence against Children, ten percent of the 2,495 respondents aged 13 to 24 who reported physical violence had "disclosed their experiences to someone prior to this survey". An incident log can hold only what someone told.

### A count bends when a school is judged by it

"The more any quantitative social indicator is used for social decision-making," the psychologist Donald Campbell wrote, "the more subject it will be to corruption pressures and the more apt it will be to distort and corrupt the social processes it is intended to monitor" (Campbell, 1979; 2011 reprint, p. 34). He called it a pessimistic law and his evidence anecdotal. One of his examples was police crime figures, where "Failure to record all citizens' complaints" is among the "simple evasions which are hard to check".

The school-based management self-assessment asks each school to rate itself on the indicator "The school has zero bullying incidence" ([DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2024](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2024/05/20/may-16-2024-do-007-s-2024-policy-guidelines-on-the-implementation-of-the-revised-school-based-management-sbm-system/), Annex A, indicator 9). EDCOM II reported the pressure a count like this can bring: "School heads and CPC members describe strong informal pressure to keep official bullying counts low because high case numbers can be interpreted as poor performance in division monitoring" (Final Report, p. 199). A year earlier the commission had noted that "zero bullying cases are included as an indicator in the Individual Performance Commitment and Review Form and the Office Performance Commitment and Review Form" (Year Two Report, 2025, p. 161). The [guide to the EDCOM II findings on bullying](https://nash.com.ph/blog/school-mental-health-bullying-ra-12080-edcom-ii) has the rest of that evidence.

## What DepEd's rules say about learner voice and policy review

"Learner voice" appears in the PPSSH and is not defined in its glossary. The indicators give the only gloss: "feelings, views and/or opinions". Other orders ask for the same thing in other words: participation, feedback, the right to be heard.

| Source | What it says |
|---|---|
| PPSSH, Strand 1.6, Learner voice (DO 024, s. 2020) | Career Stage 1: "Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of utilizing learner voice to inform policy development and decision-making towards school improvement." Career Stage 2: "Utilize learner voice, such as feelings, views and/or opinions". Career Stage 3: "Design and apply effective strategies in utilizing learner voice". Career Stage 4: "Systematize processes in utilizing learner voice". |
| PPSSH, Strand 1.3, Policy implementation and review | Career Stage 2: "Undertake policy implementation and review in the school to ensure that operations are consistent with national and local laws, regulations and issuances." Career Stage 4: "Recommend to higher authorities the enhancement of policies relevant to school operations based on implementation and review." |
| SIP Guidebook (DO 44, s. 2015), Activity 3.3 and Annex 6 | "listening to the voice of the learners and stakeholders is crucial in the SIP and should not be skipped". It "can be done through one-on-one or dyads/triads interviews, surveys, or Focus Group Discussions (FGD)". |
| Child Protection Policy ([DepEd Order No. 40, s. 2012](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2012/05/14/do-40-s-2012-deped-child-protection-policy/)), Secs. 7, 10 and 11 | The school head is to "Ensure that the participatory and other rights of children are respected and upheld in all matters and procedures affecting their welfare". The Child Protection Committee has a "Representative of pupils, students and learners". Schools' programs include "Setting up child-friendly mechanisms for obtaining children's views and participation in the formulation, monitoring and assessment of school rules and policies related to student discipline." |
| Child Rights Policy ([DepEd Order No. 031, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/06/28/june-27-2022-do-031-s-2022-child-rights-policy-adopting-the-rights-based-education-framework-in-philippine-basic-education/)) | "Policies, programs, and activities should, as far as necessary and appropriate, be formulated after soliciting the views of the learners." Its examples of mechanisms include "child-led assemblies", a "comments box for children to make suggestions" and student governments. |
| Safe and motivating learning environment (DO 006, s. 2026), Sec. VII.C | Schools' monitoring includes "gathering feedback from learners, parents, and staff", and "M&E results shall inform policy adjustments and implementation improvements." Schools "shall review and audit their protocols and procedures regularly", with stakeholders' feedback. |
| School Governance Council ([DepEd Order No. 026, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/06/17/june-17-2022-do-026-s-2022-implementing-guidelines-on-the-establishment-of-school-governance-council/)) | The council is "a feedback link between the school stakeholders (learners, parents, and other school stakeholders) and school management", and a representative of the student government is one of its four ex-officio members. |
| Revised IRR of the Anti-Bullying Act ([DepEd Memorandum No. 090, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/10/10/october-9-2025-dm-090-s-2025-dissemination-of-the-revised-implementing-rules-and-regulations-of-republic-act-no-10627-otherwise-known-as-the-anti-bullying-act-of-2013/)), Secs. 6 and 19 | The anti-bullying policy provides for "enabling students to anonymously report". Prevention programs may include "Periodic assessment and monitoring of the nature, extent, and perceptions of bullying behaviors and attitudes of learners". |
| UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 12 | States "shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting the child, the views of the child being given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child." The Philippines ratified the Convention on August 21, 1990. |

Three points follow from these texts.

**Review means impact, not only compliance.** The indicators of Strand 1.3 speak of keeping school operations "consistent with national and local laws, regulations and issuances". The PPSSH glossary goes further. It defines policy review as "the evaluation of a policy to ascertain its impact with regards to the issue it sought to address", a definition it takes from [DepEd Order No. 13, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/04/13/do-13-s-2015-establishment-of-a-policy-development-process-at-the-department-of-education/), which requires that "All policies shall be subject to periodic evaluation" (item 27). That order covers policies "issued by the DepEd Central Office" (para. 1), not a school's own rules, but its definition is the one the standards for school heads adopt. A school can follow a rule to the letter and still fail this test, because the rule did not solve the problem it was written for.

**Listening is the method, and the SIP already teaches it.** Annex 6 of the SIP Guidebook says "It is critical to have the stakeholders themselves help in identifying their own needs", and that the real needs "may have to be inferred or extracted from what they actually say during interviews". Annex 7 adds that "Direct observations allow you to determine what the process really is from what you think the process is." As of November 18, 2026, no DepEd order has replaced DO 44, s. 2015. The [SIP guide](https://nash.com.ph/blog/deped-school-improvement-plan) and the [guide to root cause analysis](https://nash.com.ph/blog/root-cause-analysis-school-improvement-plan) cover the steps before and after this one.

**Learners are heard, and the school head decides.** None of these texts lets learners decide a school rule. The learner government exists to "provide a channel for learners' opinions, suggestions, grievances, and other concerns affecting their rights and welfare in the school" (2023 interim Constitution and By-Laws of the SELG and SSLG, Art. IV, Sec. 10). Its representative has a seat, and a vote, in the School Planning Team and in the School Governance Council, and both bodies plan and recommend. The council "shall not directly manage the school because it is the responsibility of the School Head" (DO 026, s. 2022). The school head, in turn, must "explain to the SGC members the reasons, potential risks, or effects of matters in case of disapproval, partial approval or modification of the recommendations". The guides to the [learner government](https://nash.com.ph/blog/deped-learner-government-selg-sslg) and the [School Governance Council](https://nash.com.ph/blog/deped-school-governance-council-sgc) set out both bodies.

## Six things a school rule takes for granted

Every school rule rests on beliefs about learners that the rule itself never states. This guide sorts them into six. The list is a working tool and not DepEd's.

| The rule assumes | The question that tests it |
|---|---|
| **Know.** Learners know the rule. | Can learners say the rule, and the reason for it, in their own words? |
| **Can.** Learners can follow it. | Does every learner have the money, the time and the means the rule takes for granted? |
| **There.** What the rule needs is there. | Is the thing the rule depends on (food, water, a seat, a ride, an adult) there when learners need it? |
| **Fit.** The rule fits every learner. | Does it work the same for learners with disabilities, learners from far sitios, working learners, girls and boys? |
| **Tell.** Learners will say when it fails. | Would a learner tell an adult in the school, and is it safe to? |
| **Count.** The record shows what happens. | Does the school's count match what learners live? |

Records, teachers and a school head's own observation can test some of these. In this sorting, two of them, Know and Tell, are tested by asking learners, because they are about what is in a learner's mind. The figure below lets you try this on a rule in your own school.

**The assumption check.** A school rule takes six things for granted about learners. Each can be tested by some of the places a school can look, and is a blind spot until one of them has been used. The six assumptions and the pairing of sources are this guide’s own; no DepEd issuance lists them.

| The rule assumes | The question that tests it | Where the school can look | A first step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Learners know the rule | Can learners say the rule, and the reason for it, in their own words? | a learner survey, interviews and group discussions and the learner government | Ask five learners from different grade levels to say the rule and why the school has it. |
| Learners can follow it | Does every learner have the money, the time and the means the rule takes for granted? | the adults who apply the rule, a learner survey and interviews and group discussions | Ask what following the rule costs a learner in pesos, minutes and travel. |
| What the rule needs is there | Is the thing the rule depends on (food, water, a seat, a ride, an adult) there when learners need it? | school records, the adults who apply the rule, your own eyes and a learner survey | Stand where the rule applies for one whole recess, arrival or dismissal. |
| The rule fits every learner | Does it work the same for learners with disabilities, learners from far sitios, working learners, girls and boys? | school records, the adults who apply the rule and interviews and group discussions | Break the record down by group, then ask the groups the rule is hardest on. |
| Learners will say when it fails | Would a learner tell an adult in the school, and is it safe to? | a learner survey, interviews and group discussions and the learner government | Ask without names: if this went wrong for you, would you tell an adult here, and whom? |
| The record shows what happens | Does the school’s count match what learners live? | your own eyes, a learner survey and interviews and group discussions | Set the school’s count for one month beside what learners report for the same month. |

The places a school can look: school records (the attendance register, the incident log, the canteen’s sales, the clinic’s log); the adults who apply the rule (class advisers, the guard at the gate, the canteen staff); your own eyes (standing where the rule applies, at the hour it applies); a learner survey (answered without names, with a blank for what the choices missed); interviews and group discussions (learners from different grade levels and situations, in their own words); the learner government (the elected officers, asked what learners bring to them).

Records, the adults who apply the rule and the school head’s own eyes do not test “Learners know the rule” and “Learners will say when it fails” in this sorting: those are tested by asking learners.

## How to do a blind-spot analysis, step by step

**1. Choose one rule, and write what it promises a learner.** Begin where there is a signal: a complaint that keeps returning, a number that does not move however many programs are launched, a zero that looks too clean, or a rule older than every learner now enrolled. A rule that DepEd has just added is also worth an early look. Under DO 006, s. 2026, for example, schools prohibit cellphones "during instructional periods" and school heads carry out "a monthly random routine bag inspection across all grade levels" (Sec. VI.A). Write the promise as one sentence about the learner: "Every learner eats a safe, affordable snack at recess."

**2. List what the rule takes for granted.** Go through the six assumptions and write, for this rule, what each one would mean.

**3. Read what the school already holds.** Look at the records, speak with the adults who apply the rule, and stand where it applies at the hour it applies. The SIP Guidebook is firm on the last one: "Direct observations are a must if you want to validate how the process works" (Activity 3.4). Note what each record is able to show. School Form 2 counts each learner's days absent and times tardy for the month; none of its data elements is the reason ([DepEd Order No. 4, s. 2014](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2014/01/30/do-4-s-2014-adoption-of-the-modified-school-forms-sfs-for-public-elementary-and-secondary-schools-eeffective-end-of-school-year-2013-2014/)).

**4. Ask learners.** Use more than one way, because each shows a different thing (see the section on listening, below). Ask the learners the rule is hardest on, and go to the ones who cannot come to you: "home visits are necessary" for learners "who are habitually absent" (DO 44, s. 2015, Activity 3.3).

**5. Set the two columns side by side and name each gap.** Four kinds turn up:

- a **practice gap**: the rule is sound and is not being carried out;
- an **assumption gap**: the rule takes for granted something untrue for some learners;
- a **record gap**: the school's count does not see what happens;
- an **untold gap**: learners do not know the rule, its reason, or what it allows.

**6. Decide, with the people the rule touches.** First check whose rule it is. A school may change its own rule. It may not waive a DepEd rule, but under Strand 1.3 a school head at Career Stage 4 is to "Recommend to higher authorities the enhancement of policies". Check also whether the school's rule is one DepEd permits. A canteen-only rule that turns back food from home is not: "Compelling the pupils/students to buy or consume all food items from the canteen and prohibiting them to bring their own 'baon' or food to school" is among the acts the canteen order counts as "detrimental and prejudicial to the students and pupils", a ground for ending the canteen's operation ([DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2007](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2007/02/06/do-8-s-2007-revised-implementing-guidelines-on-the-operation-and-management-of-school-canteens-in-public-elementary-and-secondary-schools/), item 9.2(g)). The school may still keep junk food out: learners "shall not bring unhealthy foods and beverages to school", and schools "shall advise parents and guardians to provide healthy foods and beverages to be consumed in schools (baon)" (DO 13, s. 2017, Sec. V.A.2.c). Then bring the findings to the bodies that already have learners in them: the planning team, the Child Protection Committee, the School Governance Council. Hear the teachers who apply the rule too. The decision is the school head's.

**7. Tell learners what changed, and check again.** The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child holds that a decision maker "has to inform the child of the outcome of the process and explain how her or his views were considered" (General Comment No. 12, para. 45). Set a date to look again. The school's child protection policy "shall be reviewed every three (3) years" (DO 40, s. 2012, Sec. 10), reports of bullying are reviewed "on a quarterly basis" (Revised IRR of RA 10627, Sec. 11.1), and the school's own [monitoring, evaluation and adjustment sessions](https://nash.com.ph/blog/deped-smea-school-monitoring-evaluation-adjustment) are the natural place for the rest.

### A blind-spot analysis sheet

The sheet below is not a DepEd form. The school and its figures are invented.

| Part | Sample entry |
|---|---|
| The rule | The gate stays closed at recess. Learners buy from the canteen or bring food from home. |
| What it promises a learner | Every learner eats a safe, affordable snack at recess, inside the school. |
| What it takes for granted | Can: every learner has ₱20 for a snack. There: the canteen can serve 1,400 learners in 20 minutes. Tell: a learner who goes hungry will say so. |
| What the school holds | Canteen sales average 610 snacks a day. No complaint is on file. The guard reports learners buying through the fence. |
| What learners report | Survey, 412 answers: 31% did not eat at recess on three or more days last week. Top reasons: the line (44%), no money (38%), sold out (11%). Group discussions: Grades 9 and 10 are dismissed last and reach an empty counter. |
| The gaps | Practice: one counter for 1,400 learners. Assumption: ₱20 is more than many learners carry. Record: sales do not show who bought nothing. |
| Decision, and who acts | Second counter and staggered recess (canteen teacher, by January). A ₱10 rice snack on the menu (canteen teacher). Names of learners who often go without food referred, with their consent, to the feeding focal person. |
| Told to learners | Flag ceremony and the learner government's page, with the survey results. |
| Check again | Same survey in March; line timed on three days. |

## Four rules beside what learners report

The figure sets four rules that every public school works under beside what Filipino students themselves reported on the same subject in two international surveys. The figures are national. They tell a school head where to look, not what will be found.

**The rule and the day.** Four rules a public school works under, each beside what Filipino learners reported on the same subject. The rules and the survey figures are quoted from their sources; what each rule takes for granted, the blind spot and the questions are this guide’s own.

**The bullying report: The report says zero.**

*On paper:*

- “The school has zero bullying incidence” (DO 007, s. 2024, Annex A, indicator 9 of the SBM self-assessment)
- “The schools shall also submit to the Division Office within the first week of each school year a report on cases of bullying” (Revised IRR of RA 10627, Sec. 23)

*What it takes for granted:* A learner who is bullied tells an adult in the school. Every case an adult hears of reaches the report.

*What the record shows:* EDCOM II found that “Official databases continue to show many schools reporting ‘zero cases’ despite international assessments ranking the Philippines among countries with the highest bullying prevalence” (Final Report, p. 199).

*What learners report:*

- 43% of girls, 53% of boys “reported being the victim of bullying acts at least a few times a month” (OECD average: 20% of girls and 21% of boys). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 country note, Philippines, p. 6.
- 19% reported not feeling safe “at other places at school (e.g. hallway, cafeteria, restroom)” (OECD average: 10%). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 country note, Philippines, p. 6.

*The blind spot:* A report of zero can mean no bullying, or no reporting. The form cannot tell the two apart. Learners can.

*What the rules already say:* “the zero reporting of incidents of bullying shall not automatically be construed as a reflection of positive performance of the school” (Revised IRR of RA 10627, Sec. 24.1)

*Ask your own learners:*

- In the past month, did any of these happen to you at school? (List the acts. Ask for no names.)
- Did you tell an adult here? If you did not, what stopped you?
- Where in the school does it happen, and at what hour?

**The canteen: Only healthy food is sold inside the gate.**

*On paper:*

- “These foods and drinks contain high amounts of saturated fat or sugar or salt and should not be served in healthy school canteens.” (DO 13, s. 2017, Sec. V.A.1, on the RED category)
- “Vendors shall not be allowed to bring in food items inside the school canteen/premises.” (DO 8, s. 2007, item 4.9)

*What it takes for granted:* Every learner has the money for what the canteen sells. The food is there, and can be reached, in the minutes recess gives.

*What the record shows:* A canteen’s books record what was sold and what was earned. They hold no line for the learner who bought nothing.

*What learners report:*

- 38.5% answered that, in the past 30 days, they did not eat at least about once a week “because there was not enough money to buy food” (OECD average: 8.2%). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 Results (Volume I), Table I.B1.4.46. This figure is 100 less the 61.5% who answered “Never or almost never”.
- 11.8% answered “Every day or almost every day” to the same question (OECD average: 3.1%). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 Results (Volume I), Table I.B1.4.46.
- 21.8% “did not drink carbonated soft drinks during the 7 days before the survey”. The rest did, though a school canteen may not sell them. Global School-based Student Health Survey, Philippines 2019: WHO, GSHS Philippines 2019 fact sheet.

*The blind spot:* The rules govern what is sold inside the gate. Whether a learner eats at recess turns on money, the line and what is sold outside, and no canteen record shows those.

*What the rules already say:* “School officials are encouraged to advocate, and work with their local government units in issuing local legislation to limit the marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages within at least 100 meter radius of the school.” (DO 13, s. 2017, Sec. V.A.3.c)

*Ask your own learners:*

- On how many days last week did you eat at recess?
- On the days you did not, why not? (No money, sold out, the line, not hungry, other: ____)
- Where do you buy food on a school day, and what does it cost you?

**Late arrivals: The register counts the days.**

*On paper:*

- “Total number of times a learner was late or spent less than the required time in school (under time including cutting of classes) during the month being reported.” (DO 4, s. 2014, School Form 2, data element 10, “Total number of Days Tardy”)
- “Teachers shall monitor learner attendance and provide timely interventions in coordination with parents or guardians, particularly by the end of Term 1 or when a learner reaches approximately twelve (12) absences.” (DO 015, s. 2026, para. 70)

*What it takes for granted:* Arriving by the first period is within the learner’s power. A talk with the parents reaches the cause.

*What the record shows:* School Form 2 counts each learner’s days absent and times tardy for the month. Among its data elements there is one “Remarks” column and none for the reason a learner came late.

*What learners report:*

- 55.6% “arrived late for school” at least once in the two weeks before the test (OECD average: 45.3%). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 Results (Volume II), Table II.B1.3.43.
- 25.4% “skipped a whole day of school” at least once in the same two weeks (OECD average: 19.8%). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 Results (Volume II), Table II.B1.3.43.

*The blind spot:* The register records that a learner was late and how often. The cause may be a river crossing, a fare or work before class, and the count shows none of them.

*What the rules already say:* “In some instances when the learners or other stakeholders who are important to your assigned PIA cannot come to school (e.g. students who are habitually absent), home visits are necessary.” (DO 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Activity 3.3)

*Ask your own learners:*

- What time do you leave home, and how do you get to school?
- On the days you came late, what made you late?
- What would have to change for you to arrive before the first period?

**The child-friendly score: The planning team ticks the boxes.**

*On paper:*

- “Your school has a mechanism or mechanisms – such as a school publication, students’ bulletin board, or opinion box – for pupils to express their opinions about school and community issues.” (DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 2A, Child-Friendly School Survey, Goal 1)
- “Survey to be accomplished by the School Planning Team” (DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 11, item 12)

*What it takes for granted:* The adults’ ticks describe the school that learners attend. A box on the wall means learners use it, and are answered.

*What the record shows:* The team that ticks has at least seven members, and one of them is a learner (SIP Guidebook, Activity 1.2). A tick records that a mechanism exists.

*What learners report:*

- 84% “felt that they belong at school” (OECD average: 75%). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 country note, Philippines, p. 5.
- 28% reported feeling “like an outsider or left out of things at school” (OECD average: 17%). PISA 2022: OECD, PISA 2022 country note, Philippines, p. 5.

*The blind spot:* A tick says the opinion box is there. Whether learners use it, and whether anything changes when they do, is known to learners.

*What the rules already say:* “Setting up child-friendly mechanisms for obtaining children’s views and participation in the formulation, monitoring and assessment of school rules and policies related to student discipline.” (DO 40, s. 2012, Sec. 11)

*Ask your own learners:*

- Have you ever put a concern in the box, or brought one to an officer of the learner government?
- What happened after you did?
- Which items of the survey would you tick differently from your teachers?

These are national figures. They say what to ask about in your school, not what your learners will answer. PISA 2022: 7,193 students aged 15 in 188 Philippine schools, in Grade 7 or higher, answering about themselves. Global School-based Student Health Survey, Philippines 2019: 10,175 students, of whom those aged 13 to 17 are counted here, answering about themselves.

**The bullying report.** The form asks for cases, and a case exists on paper only if a learner told an adult and the adult wrote it down. EDCOM II recommended that divisions "use spot checks and learner surveys to validate data" (Final Report, p. 200). A school does not need to wait for its division. The Revised IRR already lets its prevention program include a periodic assessment of "the nature, extent, and perceptions of bullying". A count that rises after learners are asked can be a sign that reporting has started to work. The surveys in the figure asked high school students, and younger learners report it too. In a cohort of Filipino children followed since 2016, 40% of those then about 10 years old said a friend or classmate had physically hurt them in the past six months, and 46% that one had hurt their feelings (Herrin and others, 2024, Table 3). The [guide to child protection and anti-bullying duties](https://nash.com.ph/blog/child-protection-anti-bullying-school-heads) covers what happens to each report.

**The canteen.** DepEd's rules on what may be sold stop at the gate. [DepEd Order No. 13, s. 2017](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2017/03/14/do-13-s-2017-policy-and-guidelines-on-healthy-food-and-beverage-choices-in-schools-and-in-deped-offices/) bars RED-category food from the canteen and says its consumption "outside the school premises is at the discretion of their parents". The working group it creates for the policy has the school head, the canteen teacher, the cooperative's chairperson and the Parent-Teacher Association. Learners are to be oriented. The canteen order itself names the constraint: "Profit shall only be secondary since the clientele are pupils/students who are dependent only on their meager allowance from their parents" (DO 8, s. 2007, item 1.5). The [guide to school canteens](https://nash.com.ph/blog/deped-school-canteen-operations-funds) has the rules on prices and funds.

**Late arrivals.** DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2015 had teachers meet the parents of a learner with "5 consecutive days of tardiness". [DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/06/04/june-4-2026-do-015-s-2026-revised-guidelines-on-classroom-assessment-grading-system-and-awards-and-recognition-for-the-k-to-12-basic-education-program/), issued June 4, 2026, repealed that order, and its own text speaks of absences and does not mention tardiness. Neither order set a penalty for coming late. A penalty for lateness in a school's handbook is the school's own addition, to be kept within the Child Protection Policy and DO 006, s. 2026, and it is the school's to review. By the schools' 2023 reports, no four-wheel vehicle reaches 767 public schools with a high school level; the [report on how learners reach public high schools](https://nash.com.ph/blog/how-learners-reach-public-high-schools) has the figures by region.

**The child-friendly score.** The survey's first goal is "Encourage children's participation in school and community", and the team that scores it is mostly adults. The [guide to the Child-Friendly School Survey](https://nash.com.ph/blog/child-friendly-school-survey-deped) suggests the fix: let learners answer the items that are about them, and compare.

## How to listen so that learners tell you what is true

The SIP Guidebook names three ways and says "In most cases, tools need to be used in combination" (Annex 6).

| Way | What it shows | Its limit | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Survey | How many learners, and which ones | It returns only what its choices allow | Keep it nameless. Add "Other: ____" to every list of choices. |
| Interview | One learner's experience, in depth | Slow, and the learner is facing the principal | "Interview questions should be open-ended", with no "biased, leading, or loaded questions" (Annex 6). |
| Focus group discussion | Why something happens, as learners explain it to each other | The loudest voice can lead | Group learners of the same grade level; let a teacher they trust, not their adviser, take notes. |
| Walking and talking | What nobody thought to put on a form | It reaches the learners who are easy to reach | A question at the gate or in the canteen line, then a note the same day. |
| The learner government | What learners bring to their own officers | Officers are not a sample of all learners | Ask what they have been told, not only what they think. |

The Guidebook's order is interviews and group discussions first, then "surveys to quantify and verify the responses from the interviews". It also asks that learners' words be written down "verbatim, or word for word", because "The use of their own language is important." The guides to [interviews and focus groups](https://nash.com.ph/blog/interview-fgd-guide-action-research), [surveys with Google Forms](https://nash.com.ph/blog/survey-research-google-forms-action-research) and [Covey's five levels of listening](https://nash.com.ph/blog/covey-5-levels-listening-school-heads) go further into each.

DepEd already has one instrument in which learners do the looking. In student-led school watching, a team of at least ten members, chosen with the learner government's help, walks "each building, classroom, office, laboratory, workshop, play area, garden, and any open area of the school" and maps its hazards for the planning team (DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 2C). The [guide to school watching and hazard mapping](https://nash.com.ph/blog/student-led-school-watching-hazard-mapping) has the steps.

Four safeguards apply to all of them.

- **Taking part is the learner's choice.** The UN Committee's requirements for hearing children include that the process be "Voluntary" and "Safe and sensitive to risk": "children should never be coerced into expressing views against their wishes" (General Comment No. 12, para. 134). In a school this takes care, because learners are used to doing what adults ask: "It may therefore be difficult for children to decline the request to participate" (Graham and others, 2013, p. 62). Say plainly that a learner may skip a question or stop.
- **Ask about the rule, not about a named person.** A complaint against a particular teacher or learner is not survey material. It goes to the process the rules set for it, which the [guide on where a complaint goes](https://nash.com.ph/blog/grievance-or-administrative-case-deped) sorts out.
- **Say beforehand what you must act on.** A learner who discloses abuse or bullying in an interview has made a report, and the school must document and refer it (DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A.2). Tell learners this before they speak.
- **Keep only what you need.** Answers that can identify a learner are personal information. The [guide to the Data Privacy Act in schools](https://nash.com.ph/blog/data-privacy-act-ra-10173-deped-schools) covers consent and safekeeping.

One model puts the whole of this in four words. Laura Lundy's reading of Article 12 names four things a child's view needs: space, voice, audience and influence. Ireland's national participation strategy prints them this way: "Children must be given safe, inclusive opportunities to form and express their view", "Children must be facilitated to express their view", "The view must be listened to", and "The view must be acted upon, as appropriate" (Department of Children and Youth Affairs, 2015, p. 21). A suggestion box gives learners a voice. Whether it has an audience and any influence depends on who opens it, and on what happens next.

## What learner voice does not do

**It does not replace the school head's judgment.** One comment is a signal to look further, and it is not yet a finding. The SIP Guidebook asks the team to separate needs from wants: "Needs are what stakeholders expect to receive from a concept or service. Wants are preferences of a stakeholder on how to receive a concept or service", and "We have to make sure to address the needs first before the wants" (Annex 6).

**Asking about a rule does not lift it.** Until the school head changes a rule, learners are still expected to follow it: they are to "Comply with the school's regulations, as long as they are in harmony with their best interests" (DO 40, s. 2012, Sec. 9). A rule that goes against a DepEd order, like the canteen-only rule in step 6, is the exception. It is corrected at once.

**It is not a rating of teachers.** A blind-spot analysis looks at a rule and how it works. Teachers are heard in it as the people who apply the rule, and a finding about a rule is not a finding about them.

**Asking without answering does harm.** Roger Hart, whose "ladder" of children's participation is widely used, counted it as manipulation, his lowest rung, when "children are consulted but given no feedback at all" (Hart, 1992, p. 9). A second survey after a first that changed nothing is likely to be answered with less care.

**The evidence for it is real and modest.** A review of 32 publications on student participation in school decisions found "moderate evidence of positive effects" on students' life skills, self-esteem, democratic skills, relationships with adults and school ethos, and only "limited evidence of positive effects on academic achievement, facilities, rules or policies, and health" (Mager and Nowak, 2012). The Chicago study cited in the key findings measured whether students felt that adults respond, with two items, one of them "If students express concerns about a school policy, school leaders are responsive". Its authors caution that it "cannot test the causal relationship" (Kahne and others, 2022).

## What this means for school heads

1. **Pick one rule each term.** Start with a rule that has a clean record and a persistent rumor.
2. **Write the promise and the assumptions before you look at any data.** It keeps the analysis on what the rule is for.
3. **Read your records for what they cannot show.** A sales ledger, an attendance register and an incident log each count something, and each is silent on the learner who did not buy, did not explain and did not report.
4. **Put the feedback channel that DO 006, s. 2026 requires to work, and open it to other rules too.** Empty it on a schedule, log what comes in, and answer in public what can be answered in public.
5. **Ask learners in two ways at least,** and ask those the rule is hardest on. Keep their words.
6. **Take the findings to the bodies that have learners in them:** the planning team, the Child Protection Committee and the School Governance Council. Hear the teachers who apply the rule.
7. **Decide, record the reason, and tell learners.** Where the rule is DepEd's, send the evidence up through the division.
8. **Enter the date of the next check** in the school's monitoring calendar.

These are the practices of [PPSSH Domain 1, Leading Strategically](https://nash.com.ph/blog/ppssh-domain-1-leading-strategically): Strand 1.3 on policy implementation and review, Strand 1.6 on learner voice, and Strand 1.7 on monitoring and evaluation. The [guide to strategic leadership](https://nash.com.ph/blog/strategic-leadership-school-heads-policy-to-sip) shows how they connect to the SIP.

## How the NASH may test this

The National Assessment for School Heads (NASH) covers the PPSSH, and strands 1.3 and 1.6 ask how a school head reviews a policy and uses what learners say. The items below are original practice items, scored 3 (Relational), 2 (Multistructural), 1 (Unistructural) or 0 (Prestructural). An option that breaks a rule scores 0.

### Question 1

*Indicator 1.6.2, Learner voice. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.*

You are the school head of a public junior high school. For the third year in a row, the school's annual report to the division shows no case of bullying, and the faculty takes this as proof that the anti-bullying program works. A nameless learner survey for the School Improvement Plan now shows that many Grade 8 learners were teased or shoved in the past month and told no adult. Some teachers ask you to set the survey aside because it names no one and cannot be verified. What should you do?

- **A.** Present the survey to the faculty, direct the advisers to record every incident they witness, and repeat the same survey next term to see whether the reported figure has gone down by then.
- **B.** Call the Grade 8 learners to the office one section at a time and require each to name who teased or shoved them, so that the cases can be documented and acted on.
- **C.** Follow up the survey with group discussions among Grade 8 learners on where it happens and why they do not report, and review the reporting channels with the Child Protection Committee.
- **D.** Keep the report as it was filed, since only documented cases are counted, and ask the learner government to remind learners that every case of bullying must be reported.

**Answer and explanation**

**Best answer: C.** Points: A = 2, B = 0, C = 3, D = 1.

- **A (2 points, Multistructural).** It accepts the survey, improves the record and checks again, but it never asks learners why they told no adult, so the reason the report reads zero stays unknown.
- **B (0 points, Prestructural).** It makes learners name others in front of their section, which breaks the confidentiality the Revised IRR requires, undoes the anonymous reporting it tells schools to enable, and exposes those who answered to retaliation.
- **C (3 points, Relational).** It uses what learners said as evidence to be checked, goes back to learners for the reasons, and connects the findings to the school's reporting channels and the Child Protection Committee.
- **D (1 point, Unistructural).** It reminds learners of one duty and leaves the survey unused, treating the report as the truth and the learners' answers as noise.

**Why.** This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 1.6.2 asks the school head to use learners' feelings, views and opinions in decisions. The Revised IRR of RA 10627 says the zero reporting of incidents "shall not automatically be construed as a reflection of positive performance of the school", lets prevention programs include periodic assessment of learners' "perceptions of bullying", and has the policy enable students "to anonymously report". The SIP Guidebook has interviews and group discussions find the reasons and surveys quantify them. The 2-point option stops at the numbers.

*Indicator 1.6.2: Utilize learner voice, such as feelings, views and/or opinions to inform policy development and decision-making towards school improvement.*

*Sources: DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020; Revised IRR of RA 10627 (DM 090, s. 2025), Secs. 6, 19, 22 and 24.1; DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, Annex 6; DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.C.*

### Question 2

*Indicator 1.3.2, Policy implementation and review. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.*

You are the newly assigned school head of a public elementary school. To promote healthy eating, the previous school head ruled that pupils may eat at recess only what they buy from the school canteen, and food brought from home is turned back at the gate. The canteen sells only the food DepEd's guidelines allow. Advisers now report that some pupils go through recess without eating, and several parents have complained. Teachers point out that the rule has kept junk food out of the school for two years. What should you do?

- **A.** Allow food from home again, and tell the faculty that the canteen's menu, prices and serving will stay as they are for the rest of the school year.
- **B.** Allow food from home but not junk food, keep the canteen's healthy menu, and ask pupils and parents why some go without eating so that prices and serving can be reviewed.
- **C.** Keep the rule that has kept junk food out of the school, and advise the parents of pupils who cannot buy to give them money or a heavier breakfast at home.
- **D.** Allow food from home but not junk food, and ask parents why their children go without eating so that the canteen teacher can adjust the menu at the start of the next term.

**Answer and explanation**

**Best answer: B.** Points: A = 1, B = 3, C = 0, D = 2.

- **A (1 point, Unistructural).** It ends the ban and stops there. It does not keep unhealthy food out, and it does not find out why pupils are going without food.
- **B (3 points, Relational).** It allows food from home while keeping unhealthy food out, as DepEd's food guidelines provide, keeps what the rule was for, and asks the pupils themselves so that the review reaches the problem.
- **C (0 points, Prestructural).** It keeps a rule the canteen guidelines count as detrimental to pupils, a ground for ending the canteen's operation, and leaves pupils without food at recess.
- **D (2 points, Multistructural).** It corrects the rule and consults, but it asks parents only and looks only at the menu, so what pupils would say about price and serving time may be missed, and the change waits a term.

**Why.** This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 1.3.2 asks the school head to review school policy so that operations are consistent with issuances. DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2007 lists "Compelling the pupils/students to buy or consume all food items from the canteen and prohibiting them to bring their own 'baon' or food to school" among the acts "detrimental and prejudicial to the students and pupils" (item 9.2(g)). The teachers' concern has its own rule: schools "shall advise parents and guardians to provide healthy foods and beverages to be consumed in schools (baon)", and learners "shall not bring unhealthy foods and beverages to school" (DepEd Order No. 13, s. 2017, Sec. V.A.2.c). The PPSSH glossary defines policy review as evaluating a policy's "impact with regards to the issue it sought to address", which here is whether pupils eat well. The 2-point option consults adults only.

*Indicator 1.3.2: Undertake policy implementation and review in the school to ensure that operations are consistent with national and local laws, regulations and issuances.*

*Sources: DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2007, items 1.5 and 9.2(g); DepEd Order No. 13, s. 2017, Secs. V.A.1 and V.A.2.c; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, glossary.*

Nothing in this guide reproduces or predicts examination content.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is a blind-spot analysis in school leadership?

It is a comparison of one school policy, and what the adults assume about it, with what learners actually experience and report. The school head writes down what the rule takes for granted, checks records and observes, asks learners, and names where the two sides differ. The SIP Guidebook describes the same comparison as "What you think the process is" against "What the process really is" (DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 7).

### Is a blind-spot analysis required by DepEd?

Not by that name. As of November 18, 2026, no DepEd order uses the term. What DepEd requires are its parts: listening to learners in the SIP "should not be skipped" (DO 44, s. 2015, Activity 3.3), schools must keep feedback channels on their protection rules and procedures and put the feedback into school guidelines (DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.C.3), and the PPSSH expects school heads to use learner voice in policy and decisions (indicator 1.6.2).

### What is learner voice in the PPSSH?

It is Strand 1.6 of Domain 1, Leading Strategically. The PPSSH does not define the term in its glossary; the indicators describe it as learners' "feelings, views and/or opinions", used "to inform policy development and decision-making towards school improvement" (DO 024, s. 2020). At Career Stage 1 a school head shows knowledge of it, and at Career Stage 2 uses it.

### How do you gather learner voice?

Through interviews, focus group discussions and surveys, used together (DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 6), and through the learner government, feedback channels and ordinary conversation. Interviews and group discussions show why something happens; a survey shows how many learners it happens to. Keep surveys nameless and add a blank for answers the choices missed.

### Do learners get to decide school policy?

No. Learners have the right to express their views and to have them given "due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child" (Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 12). The decision stays with the school head, who is accountable for the school, and DepEd asks the school head to explain to the School Governance Council when a recommendation is not adopted (DO 026, s. 2022).

## Sources

**DepEd issuances**

- [DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2020/09/07/september-7-2020-do-024-s-2020-national-adoption-and-implementation-of-the-philippine-professional-standards-for-school-heads/), National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads, September 7, 2020. Strands 1.3 and 1.6; glossary.
- [DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/09/29/do-44-s-2015-guidelines-on-the-enhanced-school-improvement-planning-sip-process-and-the-school-report-card-src/), Guidelines on the Enhanced School Improvement Planning (SIP) Process and the School Report Card (SRC), September 29, 2015. SIP Guidebook, Activities 1.2, 3.3 and 3.4; Annexes 2A, 2C, 6, 7 and 11.
- [DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/03/24/march-24-2026-do-006-s-2026-guidelines-on-ensuring-a-safe-and-motivating-learning-environment-esmle/), Guidelines on Ensuring a Safe and Motivating Learning Environment, March 24, 2026. Secs. IV.F, VI.A, VII.A.2 and VII.C.
- [DepEd Memorandum No. 090, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/10/10/october-9-2025-dm-090-s-2025-dissemination-of-the-revised-implementing-rules-and-regulations-of-republic-act-no-10627-otherwise-known-as-the-anti-bullying-act-of-2013/), Dissemination of the Revised Implementing Rules and Regulations of Republic Act No. 10627, October 9, 2025. Revised IRR, Secs. 6, 11.1, 19, 22, 23 and 24.1.
- [DepEd Order No. 40, s. 2012](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2012/05/14/do-40-s-2012-deped-child-protection-policy/), DepEd Child Protection Policy, May 14, 2012. Secs. 7, 9, 10 and 11.
- [DepEd Order No. 031, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/06/28/june-27-2022-do-031-s-2022-child-rights-policy-adopting-the-rights-based-education-framework-in-philippine-basic-education/), Child Rights Policy: Adopting the Rights-Based Education Framework in Philippine Basic Education, June 27, 2022. Sec. VI.A, right to participation.
- [DepEd Order No. 026, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/06/17/june-17-2022-do-026-s-2022-implementing-guidelines-on-the-establishment-of-school-governance-council/), Implementing Guidelines on the Establishment of School Governance Council, June 17, 2022.
- [DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2024](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2024/05/20/may-16-2024-do-007-s-2024-policy-guidelines-on-the-implementation-of-the-revised-school-based-management-sbm-system/), Policy Guidelines on the Implementation of the Revised School-Based Management (SBM) System, May 16, 2024. Annex A, indicator 9.
- [DepEd Order No. 13, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/04/13/do-13-s-2015-establishment-of-a-policy-development-process-at-the-department-of-education/), Establishment of a Policy Development Process at the Department of Education, April 13, 2015. Para. 1 and item 27.
- [DepEd Order No. 13, s. 2017](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2017/03/14/do-13-s-2017-policy-and-guidelines-on-healthy-food-and-beverage-choices-in-schools-and-in-deped-offices/), Policy and Guidelines on Healthy Food and Beverage Choices in Schools and in DepEd Offices, March 14, 2017. Secs. V.A.1, V.A.2.c, V.A.3.c, V.B.2 and V.E.4.
- [DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2007](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2007/02/06/do-8-s-2007-revised-implementing-guidelines-on-the-operation-and-management-of-school-canteens-in-public-elementary-and-secondary-schools/), Revised Implementing Guidelines on the Operation and Management of School Canteens in Public Elementary and Secondary Schools, February 6, 2007. Items 1.5, 4.9 and 9.2(g).
- [DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/06/04/june-4-2026-do-015-s-2026-revised-guidelines-on-classroom-assessment-grading-system-and-awards-and-recognition-for-the-k-to-12-basic-education-program/), Revised Guidelines on Classroom Assessment, Grading System, and Awards and Recognition for the K to 12 Basic Education Program, June 4, 2026. Paras. 6 and 70.
- [DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/04/01/do-8-s-2015-policy-guidelines-on-classroom-assessment-for-the-k-to-12-basic-education-program/), Policy Guidelines on Classroom Assessment for the K to 12 Basic Education Program, April 1, 2015. Repealed by DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026.
- [DepEd Order No. 4, s. 2014](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2014/01/30/do-4-s-2014-adoption-of-the-modified-school-forms-sfs-for-public-elementary-and-secondary-schools-eeffective-end-of-school-year-2013-2014/), Adoption of the Modified School Forms (SFs) for Public Elementary and Secondary Schools Effective End of School Year 2013-2014, January 30, 2014. School Form 2, data elements 9 to 11.
- [DepEd Order No. 034, s. 2019](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2019/12/09/december-9-2019-do-034-s-2019-revised-physical-fitness-test-manual/), Revised Physical Fitness Test Manual, December 9, 2019.
- [Interim Guidelines of the Learner Government Program (LGP) for School Year 2023-2024](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2023/05/05/interim-guidelines-of-the-learner-government-program-lgp-for-school-year-2023-2024/), Office of the Undersecretary for Operations, May 5, 2023. Annex A, Art. IV, Sec. 10.

**Laws and international instruments**

- [Convention on the Rights of the Child](https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/convention-rights-child), adopted November 20, 1989. Article 12. Ratified by the Philippines on August 21, 1990.
- Committee on the Rights of the Child. (2009). [General Comment No. 12: The right of the child to be heard](https://docs.un.org/en/CRC/C/GC/12). CRC/C/GC/12, July 20, 2009. Paras. 45 and 134.
- [Republic Act No. 10627](https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2013/ra_10627_2013.html), Anti-Bullying Act of 2013.

**Reports and data**

- Second Congressional Commission on Education (EDCOM II). (2026). [Final Report](https://edcom2.gov.ph/media/2026/01/EDCOM-II-Y03-for-web-012626_final.pdf), pp. 199 and 200.
- Second Congressional Commission on Education (EDCOM II). (2025). [Year Two Report](https://edcom2.gov.ph/media/2025/01/EDCOM-2-Year-2-Report-Fixing-the-Foundations-2025.pdf), p. 161.
- OECD. (2023). [PISA 2022 Results: Factsheets, Philippines](https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/11/pisa-2022-results-volume-i-and-ii-country-notes_2fca04b9/philippines_dbf92b65/a0882a2d-en.pdf), pp. 5, 6 and 8.
- OECD. (2023). *PISA 2022 Results (Volume I): The State of Learning and Equity in Education*. Paris: OECD Publishing. Table I.B1.4.46. [doi:10.1787/53f23881-en](https://doi.org/10.1787/53f23881-en)
- OECD. (2023). *PISA 2022 Results (Volume II): Learning During – and From – Disruption*. Paris: OECD Publishing. Table II.B1.3.43. [doi:10.1787/a97db61c-en](https://doi.org/10.1787/a97db61c-en)
- Council for the Welfare of Children and UNICEF Philippines. (2016). [National Baseline Study on Violence against Children: Philippines. Executive Summary](https://www.unicef.org/philippines/media/491/file/National%20Baseline%20Study%20on%20Violence%20Against%20Children%20in%20the%20Philippines:%20Results%20(executive%20summary).pdf).
- World Health Organization. [Global School-based Student Health Survey, Philippines 2019 Fact Sheet](https://cdn.who.int/media/docs/default-source/ncds/ncd-surveillance/data-reporting/philippines/2019-philippines-fact-sheet.pdf).
- National Center for Education Statistics. (2024). [Digest of Education Statistics 2023, Table 230.60](https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d23/tables/dt23_230.60.asp).
- Department of Children and Youth Affairs. (2015). *National Strategy on Children and Young People's Participation in Decision-making, 2015-2020*. Dublin: Government Publications, p. 21.

**Research**

- Campbell, D. T. (1979). Assessing the impact of planned social change. *Evaluation and Program Planning*, 2(1), 67-90. [doi:10.1016/0149-7189(79)90048-X](https://doi.org/10.1016/0149-7189(79)90048-X) Reprinted in *Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation*, 7(15), 3-43 (2011); the page cited is the reprint's.
- Fekkes, M., Pijpers, F. I. M., and Verloove-Vanhorick, S. P. (2005). Bullying: who does what, when and where? Involvement of children, teachers and parents in bullying behavior. *Health Education Research*, 20(1), 81-91. [doi:10.1093/her/cyg100](https://doi.org/10.1093/her/cyg100)
- Graham, A., Powell, M., Taylor, N., Anderson, D., and Fitzgerald, R. (2013). *Ethical Research Involving Children*. Florence: UNICEF Office of Research - Innocenti, p. 62.
- Hart, R. A. (1992). *Children's Participation: From Tokenism to Citizenship*. Innocenti Essays No. 4. Florence: UNICEF International Child Development Centre.
- Herrin, A. N., Alegado, J. L. G., Borja, J. B., Mayol, N. L., Largo, F. M., Bas, I. N., and Abrigo, M. R. M. (2024). [Examining the Role of Bullying on Schooling Outcomes: Findings from the Longitudinal Cohort Study on the Filipino Child](https://pidswebs.pids.gov.ph/CDN/document/pidsdps2442.pdf). PIDS Discussion Paper Series No. 2024-42. Quezon City: Philippine Institute for Development Studies. Table 3.
- Kahne, J., Bowyer, B., Marshall, J., and Hodgin, E. (2022). Is responsiveness to student voice related to academic outcomes? Strengthening the rationale for student voice in school reform. *American Journal of Education*, 128(3), 389-415. [doi:10.1086/719121](https://doi.org/10.1086/719121)
- Luft, J., and Ingham, H. (1955). The Johari window, a graphic model of interpersonal awareness. *Proceedings of the Western Training Laboratory in Group Development*. Los Angeles: University of California, Los Angeles.
- Lundy, L. (2007). 'Voice' is not enough: conceptualising Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. *British Educational Research Journal*, 33(6), 927-942. [doi:10.1080/01411920701657033](https://doi.org/10.1080/01411920701657033)
- Mager, U., and Nowak, P. (2012). Effects of student participation in decision making at school. A systematic review and synthesis of empirical research. *Educational Research Review*, 7(1), 38-61. [doi:10.1016/j.edurev.2011.11.001](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2011.11.001)
- McLaughlin, M. W. (1990). The Rand Change Agent study revisited: Macro perspectives and micro realities. *Educational Researcher*, 19(9), 11-16. [doi:10.3102/0013189X019009011](https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X019009011)
- Pronin, E., Lin, D. Y., and Ross, L. (2002). The bias blind spot: Perceptions of bias in self versus others. *Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin*, 28(3), 369-381. [doi:10.1177/0146167202286008](https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167202286008)
- Thijs, A., and van den Akker, J. (Eds.). (2009). *Curriculum in development*. Enschede: Netherlands Institute for Curriculum Development (SLO).
- Waasdorp, T. E., Pas, E. T., O'Brennan, L. M., and Bradshaw, C. P. (2011). A multilevel perspective on the climate of bullying: Discrepancies among students, school staff, and parents. *Journal of School Violence*, 10(2), 115-132. [doi:10.1080/15388220.2010.539164](https://doi.org/10.1080/15388220.2010.539164)

*Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020; DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015; DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2026; the Revised IRR of RA 10627; EDCOM II Final Report (2026); OECD, PISA 2022.*

---

© 2026 Mark Anthony Llego, NASH Reviewer. All rights reserved. You may quote up to 100 words from this article with the author's name, its title and a link. In research, cite it as: Llego, M. A. (2026, November 18). *Blind-Spot Analysis: School Policy vs. Learner Reality*. NASH Reviewer. https://nash.com.ph/blog/learner-voice-school-policy-blind-spot-analysis. Any other reuse of the article, its charts or its data needs written permission: ask through our [contact form](https://nash.com.ph/contact). Terms of Service: https://nash.com.ph/terms#website-content-and-data
