# PRIME-HRM and PRAISE: CSC's Four HR Systems and Awards

PRIME-HRM's four core HR systems, maturity levels and Bronze to Gold awards, its 2026 shift to PRIME-ESG, and how PRAISE rewards DepEd personnel.

This is the Markdown copy of [PRIME-HRM and PRAISE: CSC's Four HR Systems and Awards](https://nash.com.ph/blog/prime-hrm-praise-hr-systems-awards), an article on the NASH Reviewer Blog by Mark Anthony Llego, published Nov 17, 2026. Topics: School leadership, Aspiring school heads. NASH Reviewer is an independent practice platform not affiliated with DepEd, BHROD, or NEAP.

The Civil Service Commission's (CSC) Program to Institutionalize Meritocracy and Excellence in Human Resource Management (PRIME-HRM) measured a government office's people work in four core human resource (HR) systems: recruitment, selection and placement (RSP); learning and development (L&D); performance management (PM); and rewards and recognition (R&R). The CSC rated each system at one of four maturity levels, from Transactional to Strategic HRM, and an office that reached Level 2, 3 or 4 in all four received the Bronze, Silver or Gold Award ([CSC Memorandum Circular (MC) No. 1, s. 2021](https://www.csc.gov.ph/phocadownload/userupload/irmo/mc/2021/MC%20No.%2001,%20s.%202021.pdf), Part III).

The Program on Awards and Incentives for Service Excellence (PRAISE) is the rule behind the fourth system. Since [CSC MC No. 1, s. 2001](https://csguide.org/items/show/436), "Every department or agency shall establish its own employee suggestions and incentive awards system" and run it through a PRAISE committee (items 1 and 8). DepEd's is set by [DepEd Order (DO) No. 9, s. 2002](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2002/03/05/do-9-s-2002-establishing-the-program-on-awards-and-incentives-for-service-excellence-praise-in-the-department-of-education/) and [DO 78, s. 2007](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2007/11/26/do-78-s-2007-strengthening-the-program-on-awards-and-incentives-for-service-excellence-praise-of-the-department-of-education/), and it covers teachers.

The two fared differently in 2026. PRIME-HRM's cycle of assessments and awards has stopped: the CSC redesigned the program as PRIME-ESG, published the resolution on October 2, 2026 and announced that it takes effect on October 18, 2026. PRAISE goes on, and two of the thirteen minimum controls PRIME-ESG sets for agencies awaiting enrollment are a "Functional PRAISE/R&R Committee" and "Performance-Linked PRAISE/R&R Awards" ([CSC MC No. 11, s. 2026](https://www.csc.gov.ph/downloads/memorandum-circulars/category/600-mc-no-11-s-2026), Annex B, Sec. 6). The rules below are stated as of November 17, 2026. How the four systems meet in a school's HR action plan is in [Strategic HRM for School Heads](https://nash.com.ph/blog/strategic-hr-management-school-heads), and hiring, induction and welfare are in [Human Resource Management for DepEd School Heads](https://nash.com.ph/blog/school-head-human-resource-management).

## Key findings

- **Four systems at four levels, and the lowest system set the award.** A Certificate of Recognition at Level 3 in any system needed all four systems at Level 2, and the Bronze, Silver and Gold Awards needed all four at Level 2, 3 or 4 (CSC MC No. 1, s. 2021, Part III).
- **Level 2 in RSP and PM alone earned CSC Accreditation,** the authority to take final action on appointments. The CSC's field offices then reviewed 75% of the appointments an accredited agency issued, and 50%, 25% and 15% for Bronze, Silver and Gold awardees (MC No. 1, s. 2021, table of incentives).
- **PRIME-ESG ended the cycle in October 2026.** "No new action under the former cycle shall be initiated", while "A previously conferred status, privilege, or related authority shall remain valid according to its terms" (MC No. 11, s. 2026, Annex B, Secs. 7.1 and 7.2). Governance Levels replace maturity levels as agencies enroll in a government HR and payroll system from 2026 to 2030 (Secs. 8 and 10).
- **PRAISE favors non-monetary awards.** A monetary award for a suggestion, invention or other effort is granted only when it produces savings, and the award "shall not exceed 20% of the savings generated"; at least 5% of HR development funds go to PRAISE, and the agency reports to the CSC by January 30 each year (CSC MC No. 1, s. 2001, items 6, 7 and 15).
- **DepEd's PRAISE committees sit in the Central, Regional and Schools Division Offices, not in schools.** The division committee is chaired by the Schools Division Superintendent (SDS) and includes a representative of the teachers' association, and it may give six named awards, from the Best Employee Award to the Service Award (DO 78, s. 2007).
- **The national awards have new names.** The CSC's Honor Awards Program is now the Gawad Lingkod Bayani: the Gawad Lingkod Bayan ng Pangulo, Gawad Dangal ng Bayan and Gawad Pagasa. Each pays ₱200,000 to an individual awardee, and the first two add automatic promotion to the next higher position (CSC MC No. 2, s. 2026; DepEd Memorandum No. 013, s. 2026, item 3).
- **The loyalty award is ₱1,000 for each year of service.** DepEd pays ₱10,000 at ten years of continuous, satisfactory government service and ₱5,000 at every fifth year after, with a service pin, ring or medallion (DO 54, s. 2015; CSC MC No. 6, s. 2002).

## Where PRIME-HRM came from

The CSC adopted PRIME-HRM through CSC Resolution No. 1200241 of February 1, 2012 and issued it as [MC No. 3, s. 2012](https://www.csc.gov.ph/downloads/memorandum-circulars/category/62-2012). It merged two older CSC programs, the CSC Agency Accreditation Program of 1991 and the Personnel Management Assessment and Assistance Program of 2004. The CSC's PRIME-HRM Guidebook, printed in 2016, states its aim: "to elevate public sector human resource management to a level of excellence through the assessment, assistance, and awarding processes of HRM Systems, Practices, and Competencies using HRM maturity level indicators that are at par with global HRM standards" (p. 12). Its philosophy is "People Excellence for Service Excellence" ([CSC MC No. 19, s. 2016](https://csc.gov.ph/phocadownload/userupload/irmo/mc/2016/MC%202016.pdf), Guidelines).

| Date | Issuance | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| February 16, 2012 | CSC MC No. 3, s. 2012 (Resolution No. 1200241) | Adopted PRIME-HRM, merging the 1991 accreditation program and the 2004 assessment program |
| March 5, 2014 | CSC Resolution No. 1400376 | Adopted HR maturity level indicators to "be used as guide for the assessment, assistance and award under the PRIME-HRM" |
| December 22, 2014 | CSC MC No. 30, s. 2014 | Issued the indicators as its Annex A |
| August 23, 2016 | CSC MC No. 19, s. 2016 (Resolution No. 1600730) | Guidelines on HR recognition and awards by maturity level (MC No. 3, s. 2012, Part E, had set the earlier statuses and recognitions) |
| October 24, 2016 | CSC MC No. 24, s. 2016 (Resolution No. 1601209) | The "PRIME-HRM Enhanced Maturity Level Indicators" |
| January 26, 2021 | CSC MC No. 1, s. 2021 (Resolution No. 2000359) | Revised the awards: CSC Accreditation for Level 2 in RSP and PM |
| January 4, 2023 | DepEd announcement | DepEd's Central Office received the Bronze Award |
| January 16, 2026 | CSC MC No. 4, s. 2026 (Resolution No. 2501089) | Mid-term and full-term reviews of awardees |
| June 24, 2026 | CSC advisory | Deferred PRIME-HRM activities |
| July 29, 2026 | CSC Resolution No. 2600988 | Adopted PRIME-ESG as PRIME-HRM's "Redesigned Governance Framework" |
| August 17, 2026 | CSC MC No. 11, s. 2026 | Issued the resolution with the PRIME-ESG Implementing Guidelines (Annex B) |
| October 2 and 18, 2026 | CSC | Resolution published; the CSC's announced date of effect |

PRIME-HRM covered national agencies, local governments, government corporations and state universities, "as well as the regional offices of agencies with Human Resource Management offices/units" (Guidebook, p. 14). In DepEd, the offices with HR units of their own are the Central Office, the Regional Offices and the Schools Division Offices (SDOs); schools have none. Divisions brought their schools into the work: in May 2020 the Schools Division of Rizal formed a PRIME-HRM steering committee and one technical committee for each core system, with school heads among the memorandum's recipients (Division Memorandum No. 179, s. 2020).

### Assess, assist, award

The CSC worked in three stages (Guidebook, pp. 29 to 32).

1. **Assess.** The agency first rated itself with the CSC's self-assessment tool. The CSC looked through three lenses: systems, the documented policies and tools ("the 'show me' part"); practices, how the systems actually run ("the 'tell me' part"); and the competencies of the HR office (p. 22). The self-assessment used the systems and competencies lenses, and the on-site assessment added practices. The CSC also checked records management and programs such as "the Grievance Machinery, Health and Wellness Program, and Employee Welfare and Discipline" for compliance (p. 30).
2. **Assist.** The agency set a target maturity level and wrote an Action Plan for its gaps, and the CSC Field Office, as "Assistor", wrote an Assist Plan to support it (p. 31). The CSC's 2021 guidelines expected the gaps to take "three (3)/six (6) to twelve (12) months from the period of initial assessment" (MC No. 1, s. 2021, Part I).
3. **Award.** Validated levels earned certificates, accreditation and awards (below).

Inside the agency the Guidebook gave each group a role: the agency head promotes, the HR management officer (HRMO) reinforces, the HRMO and HR committees implement, managers move their teams, and the rank and file are the "enablers" who "Embrace change and aspire for their own development" (p. 37).

## The four core HR systems and their pillars

The Guidebook calls the four systems "the heart of PRIME-HRM because they cover all the essential people requirements of Attraction, Engagement, Performance, Motivation, and Retention of any organization" (p. 21). Each system has pillars, and each pillar had its own indicators at every level.

| System | Pillars (Guidebook, p. 23) | What Level 2 asked for, for example (CSC workbooks) | DepEd's rules today | PRIME-ESG's minimum controls (Annex B, Sec. 6) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Recruitment, selection and placement (RSP) | Governance; talent planning; talent sourcing; talent selection and placement | A selection board with functions beyond the minimum; an annual recruitment plan; an orientation program for new employees | [DO 019, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/04/22/april-22-2022-do-019-s-2022-the-department-of-education-merit-selection-plan/); [DO 007, s. 2023](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2023/03/23/march-22-2023-do-007-s-2023-guidelines-on-recruitment-selection-and-appointment-in-the-department-of-education/), as amended | RSP-01, a functioning selection board; RSP-02, vacancies published with at least 95% compliance; RSP-03, plantilla compliance |
| Learning and development (L&D) | Governance; planning and monitoring and evaluation; execution | An annual L&D plan based on a needs assessment; pre-tests and post-tests; guidelines for judging learning service providers | [DO 32, s. 2011](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2011/03/31/do-32-s-2011-policies-and-guidelines-on-training-and-development-td-programs-and-activities/); [DO 35, s. 2016](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2016/06/07/do-35-s-2016-the-learning-action-cell-as-a-k-to-12-basic-education-program-school-based-continuing-professional-development-strategy-for-the-improvement-of-teaching-and-learning/) | LD-01, a training and development plan aligned with competencies; LD-02, at least half of the training budget used |
| Performance management (PM) | Governance; performance planning and commitment; performance monitoring and coaching; performance review and evaluation; development planning | A performance management team with functions beyond the minimum; supervisors validating self-ratings against documented accomplishments; a calibration process; development plan templates | [DO 2, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/02/06/do-2-s-2015-guidelines-on-the-establishment-and-implementation-of-the-results-based-performance-management-system-rpms-in-the-department-of-education/); for teachers, [DM 089, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/10/01/october-1-2025-dm-089-s-2025-guidelines-on-the-multi-year-performance-management-and-evaluation-system-for-teachers-from-school-years-2025-2026-to-2027-2028/) | PM-01, "CSC-Approved SPMS — IPCR/OPCR Submitted"; PM-02, "Performance Rating Distribution — Not Uniformly Outstanding" |
| Rewards and recognition (R&R) | Governance; planning; execution | An R&R committee with functions beyond the minimum; an annual R&R plan with a budget for each activity; planned and on-the-spot recognition | CSC MC No. 1, s. 2001; DO 9, s. 2002; DO 78, s. 2007; [DO 030, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/09/29/september-29-2025-do-030-s-2025-inclusive-employment-policy-in-the-department-of-education/) | RR-01, "Functional PRAISE/R&R Committee"; RR-02, "Performance-Linked PRAISE/R&R Awards" |

Each pillar has a short definition. The R&R pillars, for example, are governance, which sets the R&R system's policies and budget; planning, "Processes for developing Rewards and Recognition plans and programs that promote individual and team motivation and performance to achieve Agency's strategic goals"; and execution, "Processes for screening nominees and selecting awardees based on their extraordinary achievements, contributions and performance that contribute to the attainment of Agency's strategic goals" (Guidebook, p. 27).

The CSC's workbooks for each system listed the Level 2 indicators with the evidence an assessor would ask for: 13 for RSP, 12 for L&D, 12 for PM and 8 for R&R. They open with the same five governance indicators in every system: customized policies with guidelines on the equal opportunity principle, a committee with added functions, a review of the process's efficiency, a computer-based record, and documentation of the process. The figure below lists every one of them.

## The four maturity levels

The Guidebook describes the levels as below (p. 19); [CSC MC No. 24, s. 2016](https://csc.gov.ph/phocadownload/userupload/irmo/mc/2016/MC%202016.pdf) sets out the same levels in nearly the same words.

| Level | Name | How the HR processes look |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Transactional HRM | "Processes are compliant with CSC and other relevant authorities regulations and guidelines"; some are "often reactive"; outputs "frequently exceed prescribed timelines"; "Success depends on competence of people, and not by using proven processes" |
| 2 | Process-Defined HRM | "Processes are attuned to the Agency's requirements"; "Programs are performed and managed according to documented processes"; some are automated, "but the integration of data is not fully in place" |
| 3 | Integrated HRM | "Quantitative objectives are used to measure the quality and performance of process for continuous improvement"; HR "partners with the Agency leadership"; measures support "data-driven decision-making"; the agency "Has developed an HR Management Toolkit" |
| 4 | Strategic HRM | Continual improvement "through both incremental and innovative improvements"; "HR helps to drive agency business decision on people, data, and insight"; "HR strategy is part of Agency strategy" |

The difference between the first two levels is a matter of paper and habit. A division whose hiring works because one experienced HR officer knows every step is at Level 1. One where the steps, timelines and responsible offices are written in a process flow that anyone on the selection board can follow, and the board's deliberations are minuted, has the documents Level 2 asks for. Level 3 adds measurement: the division tracks how long each vacancy takes to fill and what each recruitment costs, and changes its process because of what the numbers show.

The same levels were applied to the HR office's people. MC 24, s. 2016 aligns four proficiency levels with them: Basic, Intermediate, Advanced ("can coach or teach others") and Superior ("Considered an expert in performing tasks; can teach and lead others").

## How the CSC recognized and awarded the levels

MC No. 1, s. 2021 set three kinds of recognition.

- **A Certificate of Recognition for each system** that met Level 2, 3 or 4. Recognition at Level 3 or 4 "requires meeting the Maturity Level 2 and 3, respectively in all the four (4) core HRM system", on "the principle that an integrated HR presupposes a process-defined HR" (Part III.1).
- **CSC Accreditation** for agencies "found to have met all the Maturity Level 2 indicators in RSP and PM", with no appointment invalidated or disapproved in the last two years (Parts III.2 and V.B.1). The two systems were singled out because they "are critical in ensuring compliance with Civil Service laws, rules, and regulations on appointments and other human resource actions" (CSC MC No. 4, s. 2026, Part I).
- **The Bronze, Silver and Gold Awards** for Level 2, 3 or 4 in all four systems. Gold came with the Seal of HR Excellence, a trophy (Part III.2, Table 2).

Set the four systems below and watch what the agency earns. The example opens with R&R a level behind the others: the agency is accredited but has no Bronze Award, because the award follows the weakest system.

**PRIME-HRM's four systems at four maturity levels, and what the CSC conferred**

Under CSC MC No. 1, s. 2021, an agency at Level 2 in a core system received a Certificate of Recognition in that system. A certificate at Level 3 needed all four systems at Level 2, and one at Level 4 needed all four at Level 3. Level 2 in RSP and PM earned CSC Accreditation; Level 2, 3 or 4 in all four systems earned the Bronze, Silver or Gold Award.

| Award | What earned it | Appointments the CSC Field Offices review | Privileges (MC No. 1, s. 2021) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| CSC Accreditation (CSC Resolution on Accreditation) | Level 2 in RSP and PM, with no appointment invalidated or disapproved in the last two years (Part V.B.1) | 75% of appointments issued | Authority to take final actions on appointments |
| PRIME-HRM Bronze Award (Plaque) | Level 2 in all four systems | 50% of appointments issued | Authority to take final actions on appointments; Exemption from Section 96 of the 2017 ORAOHRA, as amended |
| PRIME-HRM Silver Award (Plaque) | Level 3 in all four systems | 25% of appointments issued | Authority to take final actions on appointments; Exemption from Section 96 of the 2017 ORAOHRA, as amended; Establishment and Implementation of their own HR mechanisms without prior approval of the Commission |
| PRIME-HRM Gold Award (Seal of HR Excellence (Trophy)) | Level 4 in all four systems | 15% of appointments issued | Authority to take final actions on appointments; Exemption from Section 96 of the 2017 ORAOHRA, as amended; Establishment and Implementation of their own HR mechanisms without prior approval of the Commission; Cash Award (TBD) for sustainable HR projects |

The maturity levels (PRIME-HRM Guidebook, p. 19):

- **Level 1, Transactional HRM:** Processes are compliant with CSC and other relevant authorities regulations and guidelines; Some processes are characterized by projects and are often reactive; Often produces services and outputs that work but frequently exceed prescribed timelines; Success depends on competence of people, and not by using proven processes.
- **Level 2, Process-Defined HRM:** Processes are attuned to the Agency's requirements; Programs are performed and managed according to documented processes; Some processes are proactively managed through the use of automated systems, but the integration of data is not fully in place.
- **Level 3, Integrated HRM:** Quantitative objectives are used to measure the quality and performance of process for continuous improvement; HR partners with the Agency leadership to drive HR systems in order to support the agency's business needs; Quality and process performance measures are used to support data-driven decision-making; Has developed an HR Management Toolkit.
- **Level 4, Strategic HRM:** Focuses on continually improving process performance through both incremental and innovative improvements; Has quantitative process improvement objectives which are regularly updated to reflect changes in Agency objectives; used to manage process improvements; HR helps to drive agency business decision on people, data, and insight; HR strategy is part of Agency strategy.

**What Maturity Level 2 asked of Recruitment, Selection and Placement (RSP)** (CSC PRIME-HRM Workbook):

- Governance, Policy: Agency’s RSP policies and processes are customized to Agency’s requirements and include specific guidelines in the application of EEOP
- Governance, Structure and Roles: Agency has a HRMPSB that performs additional functions to address RSP needs (e.g. formulates customized screening criteria, guidelines and tools)
- Governance, Review Mechanism: The Agency tracks the efficiency of RSP processes and uses data to improve system: (Turn-around time (ie., time to source and fill up vacant positions) (Cost of sourcing and hiring/placement)
- Governance, Information & Communication (Use of Technology): The Agency uses computer-based system to maintain RSP data and documents
- Governance, Information & Communication (Database Content): The Agency maintains documentation and records on: (RSP process flow) (System review data on RSP efficiency) (System implementation (e.g., HRMPSB minutes of meetings deliberations, comparative assessment data, selection criteria, etc.))
- Talent Planning, Staffing/ Workforce Plan: The Agency has an updated staffing plan reflecting recommended staffing modifications (e.g. deployment, conversion of positions, reclassification) based on planned annual HR needs
- Talent Sourcing, Recruitment Plan: The Agency has a Recruitment Plan based on anticipated vacancies within the year and includes possible candidate sources (e.g. qualified next-in-rank employees as well as submitted applications/referrals, etc.)
- Talent Sourcing, Talent Attraction: The Agency recruits possible candidates for existing and anticipated vacancies within the year through posting in other appropriate publication modes (e.g. CSC bulletin of vacancies, newspapers, Agency website, social networking, etc.)
- Talent Sourcing, EEOP: The Agency’s annual recruitment activities are planned to attract diverse applicants regardless of gender, civil status, age, disability, ethnicity, religion, etc.
- Talent Selection & Placement, Selection Criteria: The Agency’s selection criteria are based on updated Job Description (JDs) and approved/prescribed QS specific for the position to be filled
- Talent Selection & Placement, Assessment & Selection Process: Assessment & selection process uses appropriate additional tools to evaluate candidate’s functional/technical qualifications for the job (e.g. trade test, paper and pencil test of functional knowledge, etc) and background investigation for short-listed candidates
- Talent Selection & Placement, EEOP: The Agency’s assessment and selection criteria and processes are responsive to applicants with special needs (e.g. auxiliary aids and services to visually or hearing impaired)
- Talent Selection & Placement, On-boarding: The Agency has an orientation program that helps employees understand performance expectations, reporting relationships & information networks needed to perform job

**What Maturity Level 2 asked of Learning and Development (L&D)** (CSC PRIME-HRM Workbook):

- Governance, Policy: Agency’s L & D policies and/or processes are customized to Agency’s requirements and include specific guidelines on the application of EOP
- Governance, Structure & Roles: Agency has a HRDC that performs additional functions to address specific L & D needs (e.g. develops customized criteria and screening process for selecting nominees to scholarships and conferences)
- Governance, Review Mechanism: The Agency tracks the efficiency of L & D processes and uses data to improve system: (Percentage of employees provided L & D intervention (ie., compliance with required 1 HR intervention per employee)) (Budget utilization) (Participants’ feedback on conduct of L & D interventions (Level 1 Evaluation))
- Governance, Information & Communication (Use of Technology): The Agency uses computer-based system to maintain L & D data and documents
- Governance, Information & Communication (Database Content): The Agency maintains documentation & records on: (L & D process flow) (System review data on L & D efficiency) (System implementation (e.g., HRDC Recommendations, L & D documentation and reports, etc.) (Learning Service Provider (LSP) management system (e.g. profile of internal and external resource persons))
- Planning and Monitoring & Evaluation, L & D Planning: The Agency has an annual L & D Plan based on a needs assessment of employees regardless of gender, civil status, age, disability, ethnicity, etc.
- Planning and Monitoring & Evaluation, L & D Monitoring & Evaluation: The Agency uses L & D evaluation tools/processes to assess participants’ acquisition of learning vis-à-vis learning objectives (i.e. Level 2 or Learning Level evaluation)
- Execution, Design: The Agency has a training design process that involves developing terminal and session objectives aligned with validated learning needs of targeted learners, to guide training activity plan preparation and implementation
- Execution, Design: The Agency designs training programs that use a mix of methodologies that are learner-centered (i.e. experiential and participative) to facilitate achievement of learning objectives. The design is captured in a training activity plan.
- Execution, Development: The Agency develops customized learning materials and training aids to support delivery of L & D programs
- Execution, Delivery: The agency’s L & D interventions are executed, monitored, and evaluated based on activity plan
- Execution, LSP Management: The Agency has guidelines for identifying, monitoring and evaluating efficiency and effectiveness of L & D service providers

**What Maturity Level 2 asked of Performance Management (PM)** (CSC PRIME-HRM Workbook):

- Governance, Policy: Agency’s PM policies and/or processes are customized to Agency’s requirements and include specific guidelines in the application of EOP
- Governance, Structure and Roles: Agency has a PMT that performs additional functions to address PM needs (e.g. formulates customized criteria, guidelines and tools for setting performance standards)
- Governance, Review Mechanism: The Agency tracks the efficiency of PM processes and uses data to improve system: (Completion of the Performance Review Summary of Ratings supported by signed Office and Individual Commitment and Performance Review forms) (Timely submission of required PM forms and reports)
- Governance, Information & Communication (Use of Technology): The Agency uses computer-based system to maintain PM data and documents
- Governance, Information & Communication (Database Content): The Agency maintains documentation and records on: (PM process flow) (MFOs and Success Indicators) (System review data on PM efficiency) (System implementation (e.g., PMT minutes of meetings deliberations, performance review calibration results, etc.)) (Individual Development Plan)
- Planning & Commitment, Target Setting: The Agency’s individual target-setting process is guided by performance standards agreed upon by managers/supervisors and employees
- Planning & Commitment, Standard Setting: The Agency has a process for establishing/clarifying specific performance standards for individual positions vis-à-vis unit
- Performance Monitoring & Coaching, Performance Tracking: The Agency has processes (e.g. periodic review) that managers/supervisors and employees use to track individual performance
- Performance Monitoring & Coaching, Providing Performance Support: The Agency has performance coaching mechanism that is linked to performance tracking
- Performance Review & Evaluation, Performance Review & Evaluation: The Agency’s individual performance review and evaluation process involves validation of employee’s self-rating by managers/supervisors based on documented accomplishments
- Performance Review & Evaluation, Calibrating Performance Assessments: The Agency has a customized process for reviewing performance assessments to ensure agreed performance standards have been applied
- Development Planning, Development Planning: The Agency uses customized planning templates (e.g. individual development plan) to discuss and document employee’s development areas and to recommend interventions

**What Maturity Level 2 asked of Rewards and Recognition (R&R)** (CSC PRIME-HRM Workbook):

- Governance, Policy: Agency’s R & R policies and/or processes are customized to Agency’s requirements and include specific guidelines in the application of EOP
- Governance, Structure & Roles: Agency has an R & R Committee that performs additional functions to address specific R & R needs (e.g. develops customized R & R programs and guidelines)
- Governance, Review Mechanism: The Agency tracks the efficiency of R & R processes and uses data to improve system: (Annual R & R budget utilization vis-à-vis R & R implemented programs)
- Governance, Information & Communication (Use of Technology): The Agency uses computer-based system to maintain R & R documents
- Governance, Information & Communication (Database Content): The Agency maintains documentation & records on: (R & R process flow) (System review data on R & R efficiency) (System implementation (e.g., R & R Committee Minutes))
- Planning and Monitoring & Evaluation, Planning: The Agency has customized annual R & R plans and programs, which indicates budget for each program/activity
- Planning and Monitoring & Evaluation, Planning: The Agency’s R & R programs include planned and “on the spot” incentives and recognition (both monetary and non-monetary) for innovative ideas and exemplary behaviour of employees
- Implementation, Screening & Selection Criteria & Processes: The Agency has screening and selection criteria and processes for customized R &R programs apply to all employees, consistent with EOP

Since PRIME-ESG took effect in October 2026, no new assessment, recognition or award under this cycle is initiated; an award already conferred stays valid according to its terms (CSC MC No. 11, s. 2026, Annex B, Secs. 7.1 and 7.2).

Each step up brought privileges (MC No. 1, s. 2021, table of incentives):

| Privilege | Accreditation | Bronze | Silver | Gold |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Authority to take final action on appointments | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Exemption from Sec. 96 of the 2017 Omnibus Rules on Appointments: filling a vacancy left by a promotion before the CSC approves the promotion | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Share of appointments issued that the CSC Field Offices review | 75% | 50% | 25% | 15% |
| Its own HR mechanisms "without prior approval of the Commission" | No | No | Yes | Yes |
| Cash award "for sustainable HR projects" | No | No | No | Yes, amount to be determined |
| Automatic nomination to the CSC's Pagasa Award, or by the CSC to the People Management Association of the Philippines' People Program of the Year, Employer of the Year or People Manager of the Year awards | No | No | No | Yes |

DepEd carries the promotion exemption in its own Merit Selection Plan: a vacancy left by a promotion waits for the CSC's approval of the promotion, except for "Those conferred with the PRIME-HRM Bronze/Silver/Gold award", for "Teaching positions pursuant to CSC Resolution No. 1800582 dated June 13, 2018", and for other meritorious cases the Commission authorizes (DO 019, s. 2022, para. 68). The teaching exception applies in every division, whatever its award. The CSC's [2025 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and Other Human Resource Actions](https://csc.gov.ph/phocadownload/userupload/irmo/mc/2025/MC%20No.%2008%20s.%202025.pdf) keep the same exception for agencies "conferred with PRIME-HRM Bronze or Silver or Gold award" (CSC MC No. 8, s. 2025, Sec. 98.a).

### Who decided, and how long an award lasted

A recommendation started with the CSC Field Office director as Assistor. For a certificate, the Regional Office's Policies and Systems Evaluation Division (PSED) validated it and the CSC Regional Director approved it. For accreditation and the Bronze and Silver Awards, the PSED assessed the agency on site, the Human Resource Policies and Standards Office (HRPSO) validated the evidence, and the Commission promulgated a resolution. A Gold Award also went before a Certifying Board, chaired by a CSC Assistant Commissioner, for an on-site "revalida" (MC No. 1, s. 2021, Parts IV and V).

An award was not permanent. MC No. 4, s. 2026 set a mid-term review "one and a half (1½) years from the date of conferment" and a full-term review "after three (3) years", which ended in a Certificate of Revalidation or a recommendation to revoke the agency's accreditation or deregulated status (Parts III and IV). It covered agencies awarded from 2017 onward (Part III) and took effect on January 4, 2026 (cover memorandum). Under that circular an "Accredited" agency holds the Accreditation or the Bronze Award, and a "Deregulated" agency the Silver or Gold Award (Part IV).

## PRIME-ESG: what replaced the cycle in October 2026

On July 29, 2026, CSC Resolution No. 2600988 adopted the "Program to Institutionalize Meritocracy and Excellence: Embedded Systems Governance for the Civil Service" (PRIME-ESG). The CSC's review had found the need to move PRIME-HRM "from an episodic and documentary assessment model into a continuous, evidence-based, and system-embedded governance framework". MC No. 11, s. 2026, dated August 17, 2026, issued the resolution with the PRIME-ESG Implementing Guidelines as Annex B. The CSC announced on October 2, 2026 that the resolution "was published on the Philippine Star today, 2 October 2026 and will take effect on 18 October 2026" ([CSC news release](https://csc.gov.ph/csc-adopts-prime-esg-as-framework-for-modernizing-government-hr-systems)). The old cycle ends "Upon the effectivity of these Guidelines", which take effect fifteen days after the complete package is published (Annex B, Secs. 7.1 and 20).

### What stopped and what stayed

- **The cycle stopped.** The "periodic documentary assessment, validation, recognition, accreditation, and award-processing cycle shall cease to operate to the extent inconsistent with PRIME-ESG", and activities deferred by the CSC's advisory of June 24, 2026 "shall not resume unless expressly authorized through a subsequent formal CSC issuance" (Annex B, Sec. 7.1).
- **Existing awards stayed.** An award, recognition or accreditation already conferred "shall remain valid according to its terms" unless a separate issuance modifies, suspends or revokes it after due process (Sec. 7.2). It does not convert into a Governance Level or exempt the agency from the new requirements (Sec. 7.3).
- **The substantive rules stayed.** Nothing in the guidelines "repeals or modifies substantive civil service laws and rules governing appointments and other human resource actions, performance management, learning and development, rewards and recognition" (Sec. 17). The earlier PRIME-HRM circulars, MC No. 4, s. 2026 among them, are superseded "only to the extent of the inconsistency".

### The minimum floor before enrollment

PRIME-ESG works through a government-wide HR and payroll system, the HRMIS-PS. The guidelines provide for "the phased enrollment of covered agencies from 2026 to 2030" (Sec. 10). Until its activation, an agency keeps the thirteen controls of the Transitional HR Governance Model (THGM), "the minimum pre-enrollment governance floor" (Sec. 6):

| Tier | Code | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Governance integrity | GOV-01 | Administrative Case, DIBAR, and Eligibility Compliance |
| | GOV-02 | HR Action Data Integrity |
| | GOV-03 | HRMO Designation, Qualification, and Certification Readiness |
| | GOV-04 | Pre-Action Validation (Plantilla, QS, Compensation) |
| Core HR system | RSP-01 | HRMPSB Functionality (PSB Constitution) |
| | RSP-02 | Vacancy publication with at least 95% compliance |
| | RSP-03 | Plantilla Compliance (Track A/B) |
| | PM-01 | CSC-Approved SPMS — IPCR/OPCR Submitted |
| | PM-02 | Performance Rating Distribution — Not Uniformly Outstanding |
| | LD-01 | TDP with Competency Alignment |
| | LD-02 | Training budget utilization of at least 50% |
| | RR-01 | Functional PRAISE/R&R Committee |
| | RR-02 | Performance-Linked PRAISE/R&R Awards |

DIBAR is the CSC's Database of Individuals Barred from Entering Government Service and Taking Civil Service Examinations, and the HRMPSB is the Human Resource Merit Promotion and Selection Board. The SPMS is the Strategic Performance Management System; IPCR and OPCR are the individual and office performance commitment and review forms; and the TDP is the training and development plan (Sec. 6). The CSC's Operations Manual "may specify evidence, validation, correction, and gap-resolution procedures for these controls". A control finding "shall not automatically establish personal administrative liability" (Sec. 6).

### Governance Levels

After activation, Governance Levels replace maturity levels (Sec. 8):

| Level | Name | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| GL1 | Baseline HR Governance | "Minimum reliable HR data, controls, opening records, and initial system-based compliance evidence are established and creditable." |
| GL2 | Operational HR Governance | "Required HR workflows operate regularly and traceably through applicable system functions with validated transactions and approval trails." |
| GL3 | Cross-System HR Governance | "HR systems, functions, data, and decisions operate across one another with validated cross-function linkage and traceability." |
| GL4 | Evidence-Led HR Governance | "Validated HR data, analytics, and outcome evidence guide HR policy, workforce planning, resource allocation, risk management, and service improvement." |

The levels "are not permanent awards or assessor-scored recognitions", "No CSC office may manually assign, raise, lower, suspend, or override a Governance Level", and none "confers autonomy, reduced CSC oversight, additional authority, or exemption from civil service laws and rules" unless another issuance says so (Sec. 8). Before enrollment an agency passes four readiness checks: current compliance with the thirteen controls, an accepted data migration package, trained HR users, and ICT and system-administration readiness (Sec. 9).

The guidelines place the work on the head of office. PRIME-ESG "is an agency governance responsibility led by the Agency Head or Local Chief Executive and is not the sole responsibility of the human resource management office" (Sec. 2.1), and the head must ensure "coordinated participation of HR, ICT, records, payroll or finance, planning, internal control, and other concerned units" (Sec. 12.1).

### Where DepEd stands

DepEd [announced](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2023/01/04/deped-receives-prime-hrm-bronze-award-from-csc/) on January 4, 2023 that its Central Office "met the PRIME-HRM Level 2-Maturity Indicators of all the four (4) core HRM areas" and received the Bronze Award. Two DepEd targets were set in PRIME-HRM's terms before the cycle stopped. The Quality Basic Education Development Plan 2025-2035 tracks the "Percentage of Schools Division Offices conferred with level 3 PRIME-HRM accreditation", from 0% in School Year 2023-2024 (Annex 6). Memorandum [DM-OUHRODI-2026-3701](https://region8.deped.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/DM-OUHRODI-2026-3701-92326.pdf) of September 4, 2026 orients performance management teams on a draft revision of DO 2, s. 2015 to "support the attainment of Civil Service Commission (CSC) Program to Institutionalize Meritocracy and Excellence in Human Resource Management (PRIME-HRM) Level III".

Under PRIME-ESG no new Level III is conferred (Annex B, Sec. 7.1). The work has moved to enrollment: the CSC's Leyte Field Office II scheduled a visit to DepEd's Region VIII office on November 4, 2026 "to assist you in preparing for enrollment to PRIME-ESG", with the selection board's members and the HR management officer asked to attend ([Region VIII Office Memorandum AD-2026-577](https://region8.deped.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/OM-No.-577-s.-2026-AD-PS-EDR-111026.pdf), November 3, 2026).

## PRAISE: the awards system every agency must have

PRAISE rests on the Administrative Code of 1987: "There shall be established a government-wide employee suggestions and incentive awards system which shall be administered under such rules, regulations, and standards as may be promulgated by the Commission" ([Executive Order No. 292](https://lawphil.net/executive/execord/eo1987/eo_292_1987.html), Book V, Title I, Subtitle A, Sec. 35). The CSC's annual search for outstanding workers goes back further, to 1965, under Section 27 of the Civil Service Act of 1959 (CSC Resolution No. 2100501, Part I).

CSC MC No. 1, s. 2001, issued on January 26, 2001 under Resolution No. 010112, gave the system its present name and sixteen policies. It repealed MC 42 and 48, s. 1992 and the other rules on the Employees Suggestions and Incentive Awards System inconsistent with it. The policies that shape an agency's program:

| Policy | What the circular says | Item |
|---|---|---|
| Each agency has its own | "Every department or agency shall establish its own employee suggestions and incentive awards system." | 1 |
| What it rewards | "incentives and awards based on performance, innovative ideas and exemplary behavior" | 4 |
| Timeliness | "Aside from conferment of awards during the traditional or planned awarding ceremonies, the spirit of on-the-spot grant of recognition shall be institutionalized." | 5 |
| Money | "the System shall encourage the grant of non-monetary awards. Monetary awards shall be granted only when the suggestions, inventions, superior accomplishments and other personal efforts result in monetary savings which shall not exceed 20% of the savings generated." | 6 |
| Funding | "At least 5 % of the HRD Funds shall be allocated for the PRAISE" in the agency's work and financial plan and budget | 7 |
| Committee | A PRAISE Committee in every agency, "preferably" the head of agency or a representative as chair, the heads of finance and planning, the highest-ranking HR officer, and two rank-and-file representatives, one from the first level and one from the second, serving two years | 8 and 9 |
| Approval | Each agency submits its PRAISE and amendments to the CSC Regional or Field Office, which may give technical assistance | 14 |
| Reporting | "The Annual PRAISE Report should be submitted by the agency to the Civil Service Commission Regional Office concerned on or before the thirtieth day of January to enable their employees to qualify for nomination to the CSC sponsored national awards." | 15 |
| Complaints | Issues on awards go to the PRAISE Committee, "which shall address the same within fifteen (15) days from the date of submission" | 16 |

The circular's model program distinguishes two kinds of contribution. An idea-type contribution is "an idea, a suggestion or an invention or discovery for improvement to effect economy in operation, to increase production and improve working conditions". A performance-type contribution is an extraordinary act or service, outstanding community service or a heroic act, "or sustained work performance for a minimum period of one year which is over and above the normal position requirement of the individual or group" (Model, Part IV).

## DepEd's PRAISE: DO 9, s. 2002 and DO 78, s. 2007

DO 9, s. 2002 issued the DepEd PRAISE "as approved by the Civil Service Commission" under MC No. 1, s. 2001 (item 1). Its enclosure follows the CSC's model almost word for word. It applies to "all officials and employees in the career and non-career service of this department including public and elementary school teachers and the administrative support personnel in the central, regional and division offices and public schools" (Encl., Part III).

DO 9 created committees in the Central and Regional Offices. DO 78, s. 2007, issued "to strengthen the implementation" of DO 9, directed regional directors and schools division superintendents "to organize their respective PRAISE committees and institute the program in their respective offices", and gave the regional and division committees their members:

| Office | Chair | Members | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Central Office | The Secretary or an authorized Undersecretary or equivalent | Head of the financial unit; head of planning; the highest-ranking HR employee; two representatives of the accredited employees' union (first and second level), for two years | DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 5.1 |
| Regional Office | The Regional Director or an authorized representative | Head of the Budget and Finance Division as co-chair; the highest administrative officer in charge of personnel; a chief of the Elementary, Secondary, ALS or Health and Nutrition Division; a representative of the employees' or teachers' association | DO 78, s. 2007 |
| Schools Division Office | The SDS or an authorized representative | Head of the Budget and Finance Unit; the highest administrative officer in charge of personnel; a chief of the Elementary, Secondary, ALS or Health and Nutrition Unit; a representative of the teachers' association | DO 78, s. 2007 |

The technical chiefs and the association representatives serve two years. The regional and division committees implement "the welfare and benefit programs in the regional and division offices to include the granting of awards and incentives to teachers/employees who have rendered meritorious services or excellent performance", and each writes "their respective internal rules, policies and procedures" with the guidelines for evaluating nominees (DO 78, s. 2007). The Regional and Division Offices set aside at least 5% of their HR development funds for PRAISE, and the Central Office's Employee Welfare and Benefits Division, as PRAISE Secretariat, monitors them (DO 78, s. 2007).

No order creates a PRAISE committee in a school. A school head's staff are covered by the division's committee, and the school's own recognition program sits beside it.

### What PRAISE can give

DO 9 sorts its awards into national awards, which DepEd searches for and nominates to (item 6.1); department and regional awards (item 6.2), which DO 78 lets the regional and division committees give; incentives, which follow from service, performance or study (Part VII); and forms of recognition (Part VIII). The forms include "Compensatory Time-Off", "Flexiplace", a "'Salu-salo' Together" ("meal hosted by superiors or supervisors for employees who have made significant contributions"), "Personal Growth Opportunities" such as conferences, memberships and books, "Trophies, Plaques and Certificates", "Monetary Award", "Travel Packages", and recognition "posted at the Wall of Fame" (Encl., items 8.1 to 8.8).

Pick something that happened in a school, and the cabinet shows where it leads.

**Which PRAISE award fits?**

*National awards.* The Civil Service Commission confers them, from nominations each agency's PRAISE committee screens.

- **Gawad Lingkod Bayan ng Pangulo** (in DO 9, s. 2002: Presidential or Lingkod Bayan Award): “For individuals or groups of up to five (5) members with extraordinary contributions that impact public interest, security, and patrimony. The achievement and impact should be nationwide in scope” (CSC MC No. 2, s. 2026) “Cash reward in the amount of Two Hundred Thousand Pesos (PHP200,000) for individual awardees and One Hundred Thousand Pesos (PHP100,000) for each member of a group awardee with a maximum five (5) members” (DM 013, s. 2026, item 3.a.2)
- **Gawad Dangal ng Bayan** (in DO 9, s. 2002: Outstanding Public Official/Employee or Dangal ng Bayan Award): “For individuals who demonstrated extraordinary public service and exemplary ethical behavior, in line with the eight norms outlined in RA No. 6713” (CSC MC No. 2, s. 2026) “Cash reward in the amount of Two Hundred Thousand Pesos (PHP200,000)” (DM 013, s. 2026, item 3.b.2)
- **Gawad Pagasa** (in DO 9, s. 2002: Civil Service Commission or the PAGASA Award): “For individuals or groups of up to five (5) members for outstanding teamwork and innovations that improved public service delivery, operations, or workplace conditions that directly benefit more than one department of the government.” (CSC MC No. 2, s. 2026)

*Division and regional PRAISE awards.* The Schools Division Office's or Regional Office's PRAISE committee decides, under its own internal rules.

- **Best Employee Award**: “granted to an individual or individuals who excelled among peers in a functional group, position or profession” (DO 78, s. 2007, item 5.1)
- **Gantimpala Agad Award**: “given outright to employees commended by clients for their courtesy, promptness, efficiency and dedication to duty” (DO 78, s. 2007, item 5.2)
- **Exemplary Behavior Award**: “based on the eight norms of conduct provided in RA 6713 (code of Conduct and Ethical Standards)” (DO 78, s. 2007, item 5.3) “The awardee will be automatically nominated by the DepEd PRAISE Committee to the Dangal ng Bayan Award.” (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 6.2.3)
- **Best Organizational Unit Award**: “granted to the top organizational unit on the basis of meeting the organization’s performance targets and other pre-determined criteria” (DO 78, s. 2007, item 5.4)
- **Cost Economy Measure Award**: “granted to an employee or team whose contributions such as ideas, suggestions, inventions, discoveries or performance of functions result in savings in terms of manhours and cost, or otherwise benefit the DepED and government as a whole” (DO 78, s. 2007, item 5.5) “The monetary award shall not exceed 20% of the monetary savings generated from the contribution.” (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 6.2.5)
- **Service Award**: “conferred on retirees whether under optional or compulsory retirement schemes held during a fitting ceremony on or before the date of their retirement” (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 6.2.6)

*Incentives that follow from the rules.* Earned by meeting a condition the rules set, such as years of service.

- **Loyalty Award**: “The loyalty cash award is given to an official/employee who has completed at least 10 years, and every five years thereafter, of continuous and satisfactory service in the government.” (DO 54, s. 2015, item 4) “the payment of such cash gift to all officials and employees of the Department shall be increased to P 1,000.00 for every year of service of the qualified official/employee.” (DO 54, s. 2015, item 2) “10 and 15 years - bronze service pin” (CSC MC No. 6, s. 2002, item 5)
- **Career and Self-Development Incentive**: “granted in recognition of an individual who has satisfactorily completed a course or degree within or outside the country at one's own expense. A plaque of recognition may be given to qualified individuals during the DepEd's anniversary celebration.” (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 7.4)

*In the school.* The school head recognizes good work at once; the school has no PRAISE committee of its own.

- **On-the-spot recognition**: “Aside from conferment of awards during the traditional or planned awarding ceremonies, the spirit of on-the-spot grant of recognition shall be institutionalized.” (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 1.4) “For this purpose, the System shall encourage the grant of non-monetary awards.” (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 1.5)

Eight deeds from a school, and where each leads (the deeds are invented to fit the rules):

1. **A parent's thank-you letter.** A parent writes to the division office to thank the school's Administrative Assistant, who released a learner's records the same day and explained every step politely. **Gantimpala Agad Award.** The school head adds a note on what the employee did and sends it with the letter. The division's PRAISE committee gives the award outright, under its internal rules.
2. **An idea that saves money.** A Teacher III proposes printing learning activity sheets on both sides, two pages to a side. Over the school year the school spends ₱40,000 less on paper and toner. **Cost Economy Measure Award.** The school head documents the savings: what was bought before and after, with the amounts. The school head nominates the teacher to the division's PRAISE committee, which evaluates the nomination. A cash award, if the committee gives one, stays within 20% of the savings. 20% of ₱40,000 is ₱8,000, the most a cash award can be.
3. **Ten years of service.** A Master Teacher I completes ten years of continuous, satisfactory service in government this month, with no leave without pay. **Loyalty Award.** The service record shows the ten years. Up to 50 days of authorized vacation leave without pay in the period does not break them. DepEd grants the cash award and the bronze service pin; no committee has to choose the teacher. Every five years after, the award comes again: ₱5,000, with a bronze pin again at 15 years and a silver service ring at 20. ₱1,000 for each of the ten years: ₱10,000.
4. **A retirement in June.** A Head Teacher III reaches the compulsory retirement age in June. **Service Award.** The division's PRAISE committee confers the Service Award. The ceremony is held on or before the retirement date, not after it.
5. **A master's degree.** A Teacher I finishes a master's degree that they paid for themselves. **Career and Self-Development Incentive.** The teacher submits proof of the completed degree. A plaque of recognition may be given during the anniversary celebration.
6. **A gift refused.** A teacher-in-charge of a small school refuses a supplier's gift, reports it, and has a long record of honest, careful service. **Exemplary Behavior Award, then Gawad Dangal ng Bayan.** The division's PRAISE committee gives the Exemplary Behavior Award. DepEd's PRAISE makes that awardee a nominee to the national award for ethical conduct. To be nominated, the teacher needs three years of continuous service, a Very Satisfactory rating or better in each of the last three annual periods, no pending case, and no finding of guilt for an offense involving moral turpitude. The PRAISE committee's chair certifies its deliberation, the agency head endorses the nomination, and the CSC receives it by March 31.
7. **A program adopted nationwide.** Four teachers built a reading program and ran it for three years; schools across the country now use it. **Gawad Lingkod Bayan ng Pangulo.** The school head helps the team document three years of results and who did what. The division's PRAISE committee screens the nomination, and its chair signs it. DepEd's Central Office reviews and endorses it to the CSC; in 2026 the uploads closed on March 6 and the CSC's deadline was March 31. The CSC's search decides; the award carries ₱100,000 for each member of a group.
8. **A night in a storm.** When a typhoon hits during a class suspension, a utility worker stays to move the school's learning materials away from the leaking roof. **On-the-spot recognition.** The school head thanks the worker by name at the next flag ceremony and gives a certificate. The school head writes the act into the school's recognition record, ready for a nomination later.

A Cost Economy Measure Award's cash "shall not exceed 20% of the monetary savings generated from the contribution" (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 6.2.5): a suggestion that saves a school ₱40,000 of paper and toner in a year supports a cash award of at most ₱8,000. The Exemplary Behavior Award, based on the eight norms of conduct in [Republic Act No. 6713](https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1989/ra_6713_1989.html), sends its awardee on: "The awardee will be automatically nominated by the DepEd PRAISE Committee to the Dangal ng Bayan Award" (item 6.2.3).

### The loyalty award

The loyalty award comes to every long-serving employee without a nomination. Under CSC MC No. 6, s. 2002 (Resolution No. 02-0295, February 26, 2002), it goes to every government official and employee "who rendered ten (10) years of continuous and satisfactory service in the government" (item 1).

- **Who grants it:** "The particular agency where the employee or official completed the ten (10) years of continuous and satisfactory service shall grant the award" (item 2). Since January 1, 2002, service in "one or more government agencies without any gap" counts (item 4).
- **Leave without pay:** no more than 50 days of authorized vacation leave without pay in the ten years, or 25 days in a five-year period, keeps the service continuous (item 3).
- **How much:** DepEd pays "P 1,000.00 for every year of service of the qualified official/employee" ([DO 54, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/12/08/do-54-s-2015-amendment-to-deped-order-no-55-2003-increase-of-payment-of-loyalty-cash-gift/), item 2, amending [DO 55, s. 2003](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2003/07/01/do-55-s-2003-increase-of-payment-of-loyalty-cash-gift-amended-by-do-54-s-2015-amendment-to-deped-order-no-55-2003-increase-of-payment-of-loyalty-cash-gift/)), to an employee "who has completed at least 10 years, and every five years thereafter" (item 4). That is ₱10,000 at ten years and ₱5,000 at 15, 20, 25 years and on, the rates in Commission on Audit Circular No. 2013-003A, which DO 54 encloses.
- **The memento:** a bronze service pin at 10 and 15 years, a silver service ring at 20 and 25, and a gold service medallion at 30, 35 and 40, "or other memorabilia/souvenir as may be provided in the agency PRAISE" (MC No. 6, s. 2002, item 5).

## Gawad Lingkod Bayani: the CSC's national awards

The CSC's Honor Awards Program is now the Gawad Lingkod Bayani, which DepEd calls "the highest recognition given by the Civil Service Commission (CSC) to public servants who exemplify *dangal, puso, at galing*" (DM 013, s. 2026, item 1). Its three awards carry new names ([CSC MC No. 2, s. 2026](https://csguide.org/items/show/1561)):

| Award | Name in DO 9, s. 2002 | For | Rewards (DM 013, s. 2026, item 3) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gawad Lingkod Bayan ng Pangulo | Presidential or Lingkod Bayan Award | "individuals or groups of up to five (5) members with extraordinary contributions that impact public interest, security, and patrimony", nationwide in scope | Automatic promotion to the next higher position; ₱200,000 for an individual, ₱100,000 for each member of a group of up to five; a gold-gilded medallion; a presidential plaque; a scholarship grant; an executive check-up |
| Gawad Dangal ng Bayan | Outstanding Public Official/Employee or Dangal ng Bayan Award | "individuals who demonstrated extraordinary public service and exemplary ethical behavior, in line with the eight norms outlined in RA No. 6713" | Automatic promotion; ₱200,000; a gold-gilded medallion; a trophy; a scholarship grant; an executive check-up |
| Gawad Pagasa | Civil Service Commission or the PAGASA Award | "outstanding teamwork and innovations that improved public service delivery, operations, or workplace conditions that directly benefit more than one department of the government" | ₱200,000 for an individual, ₱100,000 for each member of a group of up to five; a gold-gilded medallion; a plaque signed by the CSC Chairperson; a scholarship grant; an executive check-up |

The promotion comes from RA 6713 for the ethical conduct award: awardees "shall likewise be automatically promoted to the next higher position with the commensurate salary suitable to their qualifications" (Sec. 6). Where the next higher position is not available, DM 013 restates the rule that "a salary increase equivalent to the next higher position shall be given and incorporated in the basic pay" (item 3.a.1).

### Who may be nominated

Appointive officials and employees of every status, elective and barangay officials and military personnel may be nominated; those on extension of service may not (DM 013, s. 2026, item 4). The CSC's guidelines for "the 2021 Search for Outstanding Government Workers and the Years Thereafter" add three qualifications (CSC Resolution No. 2100501, Part III):

1. At least three years of continuous government service as of the deadline, with the accomplishments made within the last three years.
2. A performance rating of at least Very Satisfactory "for six (6) semestral or three (3) annual rating periods prior to the nomination".
3. No finding of guilt for "any administrative or criminal offense involving moral turpitude", and no pending case at the time of nomination.

For the Gawad Dangal ng Bayan, the guidelines weigh "Risk or Temptation Inherent in the Work" and "Obscurity of the Position", "The lowliness or insignificance of the position in relation to the degree of performance and extraordinary norm/s manifested" (Part IV.B). A utility worker or a teacher-in-charge of a remote school is as eligible as a division chief.

### How a DepEd nomination moves

PRAISE committees "screen and evaluate all nominations based on the criteria set forth in the guidelines by the CSC", and every nomination is signed by the committee's chair "as constituted under DO No. 9, s. 2002 and DO No. 78, s. 2007" (DM 013, s. 2026, item 5). The nomination carries a certification from the PRAISE committee's chair "stating that the nomination has undergone deliberation by the Committee" and the agency head's endorsement (Resolution No. 2100501, Part V.C and V.D), and its write-up may not exceed ten A4 pages (Part V.A).

In 2026, DepEd's offices uploaded their nominations by March 6 for the Central Office to review and endorse to the CSC by March 31, the CSC's deadline, and the accomplishments counted were those of fiscal years 2023 to 2025 (DM 013, s. 2026, items 4 and 6). The CSC has asked agency heads since 2019 "to automatically nominate their PRAISE awardees to the Search", adding that "Submission of nominations must not be later than March 31 of each year" ([CSC MC No. 2, s. 2019](https://csguide.org/items/show/1351)).

## Equal opportunity in DepEd's rewards

DepEd's Inclusive Employment Policy sets rules for every R&R program in the department (DO 030, s. 2025, Encl. No. 2, Part D):

- "Each personnel has the independence to nominate anyone without fear of judgment and intimidation" (item 1).
- Recognition "shall be based on merit, performance and accomplishments" and not on age, gender, disability, religion, ethnicity, political affiliation or other personal circumstances (item 2).
- The Central, Regional and Division Office PRAISE committees "shall guarantee the adoption of the Equal Opportunity Principle in all stages and process of the search and awarding" (item 4).
- Calls for nominations "must be properly disseminated to all individuals and those belonging to marginalized groups" (item 10).
- Nominees from marginalized groups who have difficulty preparing their documents receive reasonable accommodation, such as help "in writing required narratives" or transportation support (item 12).

## How ratings feed rewards

Performance ratings decide who is nominated. DO 2, s. 2015 makes evaluation results the input for the "PMT in identifying potential PRAISE Awards nominees for various awards categories such as Lingkod Bayan Award and Metrobank Outstanding Teachers" and for the "PRAISE Committee in determining top performers of the agency who qualify for awards and incentives" (para. 54). For teachers, "The final performance ratings of teachers shall be used as basis for recognition, rewards, and further development opportunities, ensuring alignment with merit-based systems" (DM 089, s. 2025, para. 85).

PRIME-ESG measures the same link from both ends: PM-02 asks for a rating distribution that is "Not Uniformly Outstanding", and RR-02 for "Performance-Linked PRAISE/R&R Awards" (Annex B, Sec. 6). When every teacher in a division is rated Outstanding, the ratings no longer tell a PRAISE committee who stands out.

## What this means for school heads

The school head has no PRAISE committee to chair. In the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads ([DO 024, s. 2020](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2020/09/07/september-7-2020-do-024-s-2020-national-adoption-and-implementation-of-the-philippine-professional-standards-for-school-heads/)), this is strand 4.8, Rewards and recognition mechanism, whose Career Stage 2 indicator asks the school head to "Implement a school rewards system to recognize and motivate learners, school personnel and other stakeholders for exemplary performance and/or continued support" (4.8.2). Performance management is strand 4.4 and management of staff strand 2.4 (see the [Domain 4](https://nash.com.ph/blog/ppssh-domain-4-developing-self-and-others) and [Domain 2](https://nash.com.ph/blog/ppssh-domain-2-managing-school-operations) guides).

1. **Recognize at once, and mostly without money.** On-the-spot recognition and non-monetary awards are PRAISE's own principles (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., items 1.4 and 1.5): a word at the flag ceremony, a certificate, a chance to lead a learning action cell session. Cash awards are the division committee's to give under its rules, and the loyalty award follows from the years served.
2. **Keep a recognition record.** Write down who was recognized, for what, when and in what form. It is the evidence a division nomination needs, and the R&R workbook asked agencies for the same kind of record, "planned and on the spot recognition based on performance and ethical behavior".
3. **Know the division's PRAISE rules.** Each division committee writes its own criteria and procedures (DO 78, s. 2007). Ask for them early in the year, with the dates of the division's searches and of DepEd's call for the Gawad Lingkod Bayani, whose CSC deadline is March 31.
4. **Nominate with evidence.** A national nominee needs three years of service, Very Satisfactory ratings or better for three annual periods and no pending case (CSC Resolution No. 2100501, Part III). A Cost Economy Measure Award needs the savings in pesos.
5. **Rate honestly.** Ratings select nominees (DO 2, s. 2015, para. 54), and PRIME-ESG's PM-02 control asks for a rating distribution that is "Not Uniformly Outstanding".
6. **Open nominations to everyone.** Announce calls to all staff, and help a nominee with a disability or from a marginalized group prepare the documents (DO 030, s. 2025, Encl. No. 2, Part D, items 10 and 12).
7. **Watch service milestones.** A teacher reaching 10, 15 or 20 years of continuous service is due a loyalty award, and a retiring teacher's Service Award is held "on or before the date of their retirement" (DO 9, s. 2002, Encl., item 6.2.6).

## Frequently asked questions

### What are the four core HR systems of PRIME-HRM?

They are recruitment, selection and placement (RSP); learning and development (L&D); performance management (PM); and rewards and recognition (R&R). The CSC's PRIME-HRM Guidebook calls them "the heart of PRIME-HRM" (p. 21), and PRIME-ESG's minimum controls are still coded by them (CSC MC No. 11, s. 2026, Annex B, Sec. 6).

### Is PRIME-HRM still in effect?

Not as an assessment and award program. PRIME-ESG, adopted by CSC Resolution No. 2600988 and taking effect on October 18, 2026 by the CSC's announcement, ends the former cycle and starts no new action under it (MC No. 11, s. 2026, Annex B, Sec. 7.1). Awards already conferred remain valid according to their terms, and the four systems and the substantive rules on each remain (Secs. 7.2 and 17).

### What is the difference between PRIME-HRM and PRAISE?

PRIME-HRM assessed how mature an agency's HR systems were and awarded the agency. PRAISE is each agency's own program for recognizing and rewarding its employees, required by CSC MC No. 1, s. 2001. In PRIME-HRM, PRAISE was the core of the rewards and recognition system; under PRIME-ESG, a functional PRAISE committee and performance-linked PRAISE awards are two of the thirteen minimum controls (Annex B, Sec. 6).

### Is there a PRAISE committee in every school?

No. DO 9, s. 2002 created PRAISE committees in the Central and Regional Offices, and DO 78, s. 2007 in the Regional and Schools Division Offices. A school's teachers and staff are nominated through the division's committee, which includes a representative of the teachers' association.

### How much is the loyalty award in DepEd?

₱1,000 for each year of service: ₱10,000 after ten years of continuous, satisfactory government service and ₱5,000 at every fifth year after (DO 54, s. 2015, items 2 and 4). A bronze service pin, silver service ring or gold service medallion goes with it, depending on the years served (CSC MC No. 6, s. 2002, item 5).

## Sources

**DepEd issuances**

- [DepEd Order No. 9, s. 2002](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2002/03/05/do-9-s-2002-establishing-the-program-on-awards-and-incentives-for-service-excellence-praise-in-the-department-of-education/), Establishing the Program on Awards and Incentives for Service Excellence (PRAISE) in the Department of Education, March 5, 2002, and its enclosure, Parts I to IX.
- [DepEd Order No. 78, s. 2007](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2007/11/26/do-78-s-2007-strengthening-the-program-on-awards-and-incentives-for-service-excellence-praise-of-the-department-of-education/), Strengthening the Program on Awards and Incentives for Service Excellence (PRAISE) of the Department of Education, November 26, 2007.
- [DepEd Order No. 55, s. 2003](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2003/07/01/do-55-s-2003-increase-of-payment-of-loyalty-cash-gift-amended-by-do-54-s-2015-amendment-to-deped-order-no-55-2003-increase-of-payment-of-loyalty-cash-gift/), Increase of Payment of Loyalty Cash Gift, July 1, 2003, with CSC MC No. 6, s. 2002 enclosed.
- [DepEd Order No. 54, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/12/08/do-54-s-2015-amendment-to-deped-order-no-55-2003-increase-of-payment-of-loyalty-cash-gift/), Amendment to DepEd Order No. 55, s. 2003 (Increase of Payment of Loyalty Cash Gift), December 8, 2015, items 2 and 4, with Commission on Audit Circular No. 2013-003A enclosed.
- [DepEd Order No. 2, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/02/06/do-2-s-2015-guidelines-on-the-establishment-and-implementation-of-the-results-based-performance-management-system-rpms-in-the-department-of-education/), Guidelines on the Establishment and Implementation of the Results-Based Performance Management System (RPMS) in the Department of Education, February 6, 2015, para. 54.
- [DepEd Order No. 019, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/04/22/april-22-2022-do-019-s-2022-the-department-of-education-merit-selection-plan/), The Department of Education Merit Selection Plan, April 22, 2022, para. 68.
- [DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2023](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2023/03/23/march-22-2023-do-007-s-2023-guidelines-on-recruitment-selection-and-appointment-in-the-department-of-education/), Guidelines on Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment in the Department of Education.
- [DepEd Order No. 32, s. 2011](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2011/03/31/do-32-s-2011-policies-and-guidelines-on-training-and-development-td-programs-and-activities/), Policies and Guidelines on Training and Development (T&D) Programs and Activities.
- [DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2016/06/07/do-35-s-2016-the-learning-action-cell-as-a-k-to-12-basic-education-program-school-based-continuing-professional-development-strategy-for-the-improvement-of-teaching-and-learning/), The Learning Action Cell as a K to 12 Basic Education Program School-Based Continuing Professional Development Strategy.
- [DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2020/09/07/september-7-2020-do-024-s-2020-national-adoption-and-implementation-of-the-philippine-professional-standards-for-school-heads/), National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads, strands 2.4, 4.4 and 4.8.
- [DepEd Order No. 030, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/09/29/september-29-2025-do-030-s-2025-inclusive-employment-policy-in-the-department-of-education/), Inclusive Employment Policy in the Department of Education, September 29, 2025, Encl. No. 2, Part D.
- [DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/10/01/october-1-2025-dm-089-s-2025-guidelines-on-the-multi-year-performance-management-and-evaluation-system-for-teachers-from-school-years-2025-2026-to-2027-2028/), Guidelines on the Multi-Year Performance Management and Evaluation System for Teachers from School Years 2025-2026 to 2027-2028, October 1, 2025, para. 85.
- [DepEd Memorandum No. 013, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/02/27/february-27-2026-dm-013-s-2026-2026-gawad-lingkod-bayani-search-for-outstanding-government-workers/), 2026 Gawad Lingkod Bayani (Search for Outstanding Government Workers), February 27, 2026, items 1 to 6.
- [Memorandum DM-OUHRODI-2026-3701](https://region8.deped.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/DM-OUHRODI-2026-3701-92326.pdf), September 4, 2026.
- [DepEd Region VIII Office Memorandum AD-2026-577](https://region8.deped.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/OM-No.-577-s.-2026-AD-PS-EDR-111026.pdf), Enrollment to Program to Institutionalize Meritocracy and Excellence - Embedded Systems Governance (PRIME-ESG), November 3, 2026.
- Schools Division of Rizal, Division Memorandum No. 179, s. 2020, Composition of Steering and Technical Committees on the Implementation of PRIME-HRM, May 13, 2020.
- DepEd, Quality Basic Education Development Plan 2025-2035, Annex 6.
- DepEd, ["DepEd receives PRIME-HRM Bronze Award from CSC"](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2023/01/04/deped-receives-prime-hrm-bronze-award-from-csc/), January 4, 2023.

**Civil Service Commission issuances**

- [CSC Memorandum Circular No. 1, s. 2001](https://csguide.org/items/show/436), Program on Awards and Incentives for Service Excellence (PRAISE), January 26, 2001, pursuant to CSC Resolution No. 010112, items 1 to 16 and the model agency PRAISE.
- CSC Memorandum Circular No. 6, s. 2002, Revised Policies on the Grant of Loyalty Award, pursuant to CSC Resolution No. 02-0295, February 26, 2002, items 1 to 6.
- [CSC Memorandum Circular No. 3, s. 2012](https://www.csc.gov.ph/downloads/memorandum-circulars/category/62-2012), Program to Institutionalize Meritocracy and Excellence in Human Resource Management (PRIME-HRM), February 16, 2012.
- CSC Resolution No. 1400376, Adoption of the HR Maturity Level Indicators for the PRIME-HRM Assessment of Agency HRM Systems, March 5, 2014.
- [CSC Memorandum Circulars No. 19 and No. 24, s. 2016](https://csc.gov.ph/phocadownload/userupload/irmo/mc/2016/MC%202016.pdf), PRIME-HRM Guidelines on the Conferment of HR Recognition and Awards (August 23, 2016) and PRIME-HRM Enhanced Maturity Level Indicators (October 24, 2016).
- [CSC Memorandum Circular No. 2, s. 2019](https://csguide.org/items/show/1351), PRAISE Winners as Nominees to the Search for Outstanding Government Workers for 2019 and Years Thereafter.
- [CSC Memorandum Circular No. 1, s. 2021](https://www.csc.gov.ph/phocadownload/userupload/irmo/mc/2021/MC%20No.%2001,%20s.%202021.pdf), PRIME-HRM: Revised Guidelines on the Conferment of HR Recognition and Award, January 26, 2021, pursuant to CSC Resolution No. 2000359, Parts I to VII and the table of incentives.
- CSC Resolution No. 2100501, Guidelines on the 2021 Search for Outstanding Government Workers and the Years Thereafter, June 24, 2021, Parts I to V.
- [CSC Memorandum Circular No. 8, s. 2025](https://csc.gov.ph/phocadownload/userupload/irmo/mc/2025/MC%20No.%2008%20s.%202025.pdf), 2025 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and Other Human Resource Actions, Sec. 98.
- [CSC Memorandum Circular No. 2, s. 2026](https://csguide.org/items/show/1561), Call for Nominations to the 2026 Gawad Lingkod Bayani, January 14, 2026.
- CSC Memorandum Circular No. 4, s. 2026, Guidelines on the Conduct of the Mid-Term and Full-Term Review of Awardees of the PRIME-HRM, January 16, 2026, pursuant to CSC Resolution No. 2501089.
- [CSC Memorandum Circular No. 11, s. 2026](https://www.csc.gov.ph/downloads/memorandum-circulars/category/600-mc-no-11-s-2026), Guidelines on the Implementation of PRIME-ESG Pursuant to CSC Resolution No. 2600988, August 17, 2026, with CSC Resolution No. 2600988 of July 29, 2026 (Annex A) and the PRIME-ESG Implementing Guidelines (Annex B), Secs. 2, 6 to 10, 12 and 17.
- Civil Service Commission, ["CSC Adopts PRIME-ESG as Framework for Modernizing Government HR Systems"](https://csc.gov.ph/csc-adopts-prime-esg-as-framework-for-modernizing-government-hr-systems), October 2, 2026.
- Civil Service Commission, *PRIME-HRM Guidebook*, printed 2016 with support from the Philippines Australia Human Resource and Organisational Development Facility, pp. 12 to 37.
- Civil Service Commission, PRIME-HRM Workbooks for RSP, L&D, PM and R&R, version 5.

**Laws**

- [Executive Order No. 292](https://lawphil.net/executive/execord/eo1987/eo_292_1987.html), Administrative Code of 1987, Book V, Title I, Subtitle A, Sec. 35.
- [Republic Act No. 6713](https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1989/ra_6713_1989.html), Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees, Sec. 6.

*Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: CSC MC No. 1, s. 2001, MC No. 6, s. 2002, MC No. 3, s. 2012, MC Nos. 19 and 24, s. 2016, MC No. 1, s. 2021, MC Nos. 2, 4 and 11, s. 2026, CSC Resolution Nos. 1400376, 2100501 and 2600988, the PRIME-HRM Guidebook and workbooks; DepEd Orders No. 9, s. 2002, No. 78, s. 2007, No. 54, s. 2015, No. 2, s. 2015, No. 019, s. 2022 and No. 030, s. 2025; DepEd Memoranda No. 089, s. 2025 and No. 013, s. 2026; RA 6713 and EO 292.*

---

© 2026 Mark Anthony Llego, NASH Reviewer. All rights reserved. You may quote up to 100 words from this article with the author's name, its title and a link. In research, cite it as: Llego, M. A. (2026, November 17). *PRIME-HRM and PRAISE: CSC's Four HR Systems and Awards*. NASH Reviewer. https://nash.com.ph/blog/prime-hrm-praise-hr-systems-awards. Any other reuse of the article, its charts or its data needs written permission: ask through our [contact form](https://nash.com.ph/contact). Terms of Service: https://nash.com.ph/terms#website-content-and-data
