# What? So What? Now What? Reflection Model: DepEd Examples

The What? So What? Now What? reflection model from Borton (1970) to Rolfe, with examples for DepEd post-observation conferences, LAC sessions and test results.

This is the Markdown copy of [What? So What? Now What? Reflection Model: DepEd Examples](https://nash.com.ph/blog/what-so-what-now-what-reflection-model), an article on the NASH Reviewer Blog by Mark Anthony Llego, published Nov 21, 2026. Topics: School leadership, Aspiring school heads. NASH Reviewer is an independent practice platform not affiliated with DepEd, BHROD, or NEAP.

The What? So What? Now What? model is a way to reflect in three questions: what happened, what it means, and what to do next. Terry Borton set it out in 1970, in *Reach, Touch, and Teach*, a book about teaching high school students. Nursing educators later used the same three questions: John Driscoll reached them on his own in 1994, for learner nurses, and Gary Rolfe, Dawn Freshwater and Melanie Jasper built their 2001 framework on Borton's, with cue questions under each step.

A DepEd school head already runs meetings that ask the same questions. The post-observation conference held "within three (3) days" of a classroom observation lets the teacher "reflect on his or her strengths and areas for improvement" ([DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/10/01/october-1-2025-dm-089-s-2025-guidelines-on-the-multi-year-performance-management-and-evaluation-system-for-teachers-from-school-years-2025-2026-to-2027-2028/), item 57). A learning action cell (LAC) session ends in "individual and group action planning" ([DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2016/06/07/do-35-s-2016-the-learning-action-cell-as-a-k-to-12-basic-education-program-school-based-continuing-professional-development-strategy-for-the-improvement-of-teaching-and-learning/), item 18). Every lesson plan closes with Ways Forward, where the teacher reflects on "evidence of learning" and identifies "next instructional steps" ([DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/06/04/june-4-2026-do-016-s-2026-guidelines-on-lesson-planning-and-learning-design/), item 7.d.i). As of November 21, 2026, no DepEd order or memorandum names the model itself.

The rules below are those in force on November 21, 2026. The schools, teachers and results in the examples are invented.

## Key findings

- **The model is Borton's, from 1970, not Thomas Gilovich's.** Borton called it a sequence for "increasing awareness (What), evaluating intention (So What), and experimenting with new behavior (Now What)" (Borton, 1970, p. 93). A widely shared infographic credits it to Gilovich, a psychologist known for the spotlight effect, and no source connects him to it.
- **Each question has one job.** Driscoll's version calls What? "a description of the event", So what? "an analysis of the event" and Now what? "proposed actions following the event" (Driscoll, 2000, p. 27).
- **Now what? is the step most often skipped.** Looking back at the thirty or forty lessons described earlier in his book, most of which stopped at What, Borton wrote: "Consistently, the part of the lesson which got the shortest shrift was Now What" (1970, p. 128).
- **Most reflection stays shallow.** In a University of Sydney study of student teachers' writing, 60% to 70% of the coded units were "descriptive reflection", and critical reflection appeared in only eight reports over two cohorts (Hatton and Smith, 1994, p. 8).
- **Structured debriefs improve performance.** Across 46 samples and 2,136 people, debriefs improved effectiveness over control groups "by approximately 25%" (Tannenbaum and Cerasoli, 2013, p. 231).
- **DepEd's rules ask the three questions without naming them.** The teachers' Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form (PMCF) has columns for "SIGNIFICANT INCIDENTS DESCRIPTION", "IMPACT ON JOB" and "FEEDBACK/ RECOMMENDATION" (DM 089, s. 2025, Annex D, PMCF-Teaching sheet). The SIP's Project Monitoring Report Form has "Accomplishments/ Status to Date", "Issues/Problems/ Challenges" and "Recommendations/ Action Points" ([DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/09/29/do-44-s-2015-guidelines-on-the-enhanced-school-improvement-planning-sip-process-and-the-school-report-card-src/), SIP Guidebook, Step 11).
- **Two routines leave Now what? out.** DM 089's items on the post-observation conference name no next step, and the School Report Card "is not for planning and accountability" (DO 44, s. 2015, Encl., Sec. V.B). The next step has to be written somewhere else: the PMCF for the teacher, the Annual Implementation Plan (AIP) for the school.
- **The PPSSH asks school heads to reflect.** Indicator 4.2.2 reads "Apply professional reflection and learning to improve one's practice" ([DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2020/09/07/september-7-2020-do-024-s-2020-national-adoption-and-implementation-of-the-philippine-professional-standards-for-school-heads/)).

## What is the What? So What? Now What? model?

It is three questions asked in order about one event: a lesson, a meeting, a set of test results, a decision that went wrong.

| Question | What it asks | What the answer holds |
| --- | --- | --- |
| What? | What happened? | Facts: what was seen, heard, counted or done, with no judgment yet |
| So what? | What does it mean, and why does it matter? | The reading of the facts: causes, patterns, effects on learners |
| Now what? | What will we do next? | An action, with who does it, by when, and how anyone will know it worked |

Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper call the three steps levels of reflection. At the first, the practitioner reflects "in order to describe" the situation. At the second, she reflects again "in order to construct personal theory and knowledge about the situation, that is, to learn from it". At the third, "she plans how she might improve the situation through her actions", and then she goes back to the first level to work through the sequence again with the situation her action has changed (Rolfe and others, 2001, p. 34).

That return is what makes it a cycle. A Now what? that is carried out produces new facts, and those facts are the next What?. Borton compared the sequence to a scientific experiment: "observing data, building interpretations, applying the interpretations, and checking the results—a continuous cycle of inquiry" (1970, p. 93).

### The cue questions under each step

Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper print a set of questions under each step in their "framework for reflexive practice" (2001, p. 35). They wrote it for nurses, so some questions name "the patient". A few of them:

| Step | Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper's cue questions (2001, p. 35) |
| --- | --- |
| What … | "… was my role in the situation?" "… was I trying to achieve?" "… actions did I take?" "… was the response of others?" |
| So what … | "… was going through my mind as I acted?" "… did I base my actions on?" "… could/should I have done to make it better?" "… is my new understanding of the situation?" |
| Now what … | "… broader issues need to be considered if this action is to be successful?" "… might be the consequences of this action?" |

They meant the list as a guide, not a form to fill in: it is "merely an ordered set of cues", and the questions "are intended to be open to change and revision" (p. 34). A school head can swap "the patient" for "the learners" or "the class" and keep the rest.

## Who created What? So What? Now What?

### Terry Borton, 1970

Borton taught high school in Richmond, California, and later developed curriculum for the Philadelphia public schools. In *Reach, Touch, and Teach* he described the three questions as part of a curriculum meant to make students aware of how they think and act:

> "In building curriculum, we found that an effective way to think about each of these intentional processes was to use the colloquial question which best seemed to catch its meaning: "What?" for Sensing out the differences between response, actual effect, and intended effect; "So What?" for Transforming that information into immediately relevant patterns of meaning; "Now What?" for deciding on how to Act on the best alternative and reapply it in other situations." (Borton, 1970, p. 88)

He also said the model could be used to plan "a semester's course, a unit within the semester, or a lesson within the unit" (p. 90). A year earlier, in 1969, he had recorded a half-hour audio seminar with the title "Process Education: The What, So What, Now What Sequence" (p. 89, note).

### Driscoll, and Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper

John Driscoll published his "What? model of structured reflection" in 1994, in answer to "learner nurses asking 'how do you reflect in practice?'" (Driscoll, 2000, pp. 27-28). He reached the headings on his own: they came out of discussions with a fellow student in teacher training, and he found "almost seven years later" that Borton had used them in 1970 (Driscoll, 2007, pp. 43-44). In his book on clinical supervision he lists trigger questions under each step, from what the nurse saw and did to "Which aspect should be tackled first?" (2000, p. 28).

Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper took "Borton's model as its macro structure" and filled it with questions from three other sets of guidelines, Gibbs's among them (2001, p. 34). Their 2001 book is the source most university guides cite as "Rolfe's reflective model".

### Liberating Structures' W³

A group version, "What, So What, Now What (W3)", was written by Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless for their collection of meeting methods, Liberating Structures. It takes about 20 to 40 minutes. Each person writes an answer to the first question for one minute, groups of five to seven share for three to eight minutes, and the whole group hears the most important facts; the same steps are then repeated for So what? and Now what? Their tip for the facilitator: "Intervene quickly if someone jumps up the Ladder of Inference", which means jumping from a fact straight to a conclusion.

### Why the infographic credits Thomas Gilovich

It is a mistake. The infographic, a list of six communication tools, credits both its fifth panel, the spotlight effect, and its sixth, this model, to Gilovich. The spotlight effect is his: he and his colleagues measured it at Cornell in 2000. The model is Borton's; Rolfe's version is built on it, and Driscoll reached the same questions independently. None of their books credits Gilovich. The other five tools are checked in [Effective Communication in School Leadership: 6 Tools](https://nash.com.ph/blog/effective-communication-school-leadership).

## How to write a What? So What? Now What? reflection

1. **Pick one event.** One lesson, one meeting, one set of results. A reflection on "the first term" has too many Whats to hold.
2. **Write What? as facts.** Counts, times, words said, work produced. "Eleven of the 14 questions were answered by the same five learners" is a What. "The learners were passive" is already a So what, and an untested one.
3. **Write So what? from those facts.** Say what they mean for learners, and name the fact each reading rests on. If a reading rests on no fact on the page, either find the fact or drop the reading.
4. **Write Now what? as an action someone can check.** Who does what, by when, and what will show whether it worked. "I will improve my questioning" names no action. "From Monday I will call on learners by name sticks, and the school head will count who answers in a 15-minute visit on Thursday" does.
5. **Return to What? after the action.** The count on Thursday is the next reflection's first fact.

Gibbs, writing about debriefings in 1988, described the two ways this goes wrong. Discussions "often lurch from superficial descriptions of what happened to premature conclusions about what to do next, without adequate reflection or analysis". And when an experience was powerful, "discussion may never get further than description of what happened or of the feelings associated with the experience" (Gibbs, 1988, p. 46). Borton warned against the opposite habit too: "An incessant 'Well, so what?' can dissect a feeling, a value, or a rational structure to the point of disintegration" (1970, p. 96).

The figure below is one review of test results.

**Build the reflection** (an interactive figure)

Two days after the first summative test of Term 2, the four Grade 5 teachers bring their item results to the LAC session, and the school head leads the review.

**What?** The facts that can go on the table:

- The grade's 152 learners answered 74% of the fraction items correctly and 41% of the decimal items.
- In each of the four sections, more than half the learners chose 0.45 as larger than 0.5.
- Section D scored 6 percentage points below the other three sections on the decimal items.
- Two of the eight planned lessons on decimals were lost to class suspensions during a typhoon.
- 29 learners left the last four items blank.
- Grade 5 learners are weak in mathematics. *A judgment, not a What: it names no item, no count and no class, so nothing can rest on it.*
- Section D's teacher does not teach decimals well. *A judgment, not a What: it says who is to blame before anyone has asked why.*

**So what?** What the facts may mean:

- Many learners compare decimals by their length, reading the longer decimal as the larger. The error runs across the grade, not one class. Rests on: "The grade's 152 learners answered 74% of the fraction items correctly and 41% of the decimal items." and "In each of the four sections, more than half the learners chose 0.45 as larger than 0.5.". It rests on the decimal items' low score and on one item every section got wrong in the same way.
- The decimal lessons were cut short, so the learners met the test with two lessons missing. Rests on: "Two of the eight planned lessons on decimals were lost to class suspensions during a typhoon.". It rests on the lessons lost to the suspensions, which every section lost alike.
- Some learners ran out of time, so the last items say less about what they know than the rest. Rests on: "29 learners left the last four items blank.". It rests on the blank items at the end of the test.
- Section D's teacher needs help teaching decimals. Rests on: "Section D scored 6 percentage points below the other three sections on the decimal items." and "Section D's teacher does not teach decimals well.". Only the judgment holds it up. Section D's 6 points are real, but every section missed the same item, so the bigger story is the grade's.
- The test was too hard. No fact on the table can show it: there is no other test or other year to compare with, and the fraction items went well.

**Now what?** What the teachers may do:

- Reteach comparing decimals in all four sections next week with place-value charts, then give the same five comparison items again in two weeks. It aims at the error itself, in every section, and sets a date to check whether it worked.
- Adjust the next two weeks' lesson plans so the two lost decimal lessons are taught before the next summative test. It gives back the lost lessons before the next test, in the teachers' own plans.
- Shorten the next summative test or give more time, and count the blank items again. It tests the guess about time, with a count to compare.
- Observe Section D's next mathematics lesson and hold a coaching conference with its teacher. It follows only from a meaning the facts do not support, and it singles out one teacher for a grade-wide error.
- Remind all teachers to give more attention to difficult topics. It names no topic, no person and no date, so no one can do it or check it.

The school, the sections, the results and every sentence are invented. Which facts a meaning rests on, and which meaning an action follows from, are the figure's reading.

Two of the seven statements on the What? side are judgments dressed as facts. "Grade 5 learners are weak in mathematics" names no item, count or class, so nothing can rest on it. "Section D's teacher does not teach decimals well" decides who is to blame before anyone asks why, and the facts point elsewhere: in every section most learners chose 0.45 as larger than 0.5, so the problem belongs to the whole grade. The summative test (ST) in the figure is the kind [DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/06/04/june-4-2026-do-015-s-2026-revised-guidelines-on-classroom-assessment-grading-system-and-awards-and-recognition-for-the-k-to-12-basic-education-program/) has teachers give within each term: "teacher-made, competency-aligned, and based on the lessons actually covered" (para. 26).

## What? So What? Now What? reflection examples for DepEd

### Example 1: a teacher's reflection at the post-observation conference

DM 089, s. 2025 has the observer "conduct a post-observation conference with the ratee immediately after the observation or within three (3) days thereafter to discuss his or her experience and performance during the classroom observation, allowing the ratee to reflect on his or her strengths and areas for improvement" (item 57). The reflection is the teacher's. The school head's questions lead it.

| Step | The school head asks | The teacher's answer |
| --- | --- | --- |
| What? | "Walk me through the group work. What did the learners do?" | "I gave the instructions once, orally. Two of the six groups finished the task in the 20 minutes. Three groups asked me what to do after five minutes." |
| So what? | "What do you make of that?" | "The groups that finished had a member who wrote the steps down. The others lost the instructions, not the content. The slower groups never reached the part of the task that used today's competency." |
| Now what? | "What will you try, and how will we know?" | "In Thursday's lesson I will put the steps on a task card for each group. You can drop by for the group work and count how many groups finish." |

The answer to What? describes, and the answer to So what? explains. The answer to Now what? names a lesson, a change and a way to check it. The rated observation is already over; the visit on Thursday is a walkthrough, which DM 089 makes "non-rated, formative, and developmental" (item 37). The [STAR template for observation notes](https://nash.com.ph/blog/classroom-observation-notes-star-template) shows how to write the notes that give the conference its facts.

### Example 2: closing a LAC session

DO 35, s. 2016 sets the shape of a session: a "stimulus" such as a lecture or workshop, "followed by collaborative discussion of possible ways forward", and at the end "individual and group action planning in order to implement agreed activities in the classroom" (item 18). After the session, members "should be prepared to report back on the success of these activities in future LAC sessions" (item 19).

The last 20 minutes of a session on reading comprehension could run this way:

- **What?** Each teacher says what they tried since the last session. "I used think-alouds in two lessons. Seven of my 38 Grade 6 learners wrote a prediction before reading; last month it was two."
- **So what?** The group asks what the reports show together. Four of the six classes saw more learners predicting, and both classes that did not had skipped the modeling step.
- **Now what?** Each teacher writes one action for the next two weeks, with the evidence they will bring back: three think-aloud lessons, modeled first, and the count of learners who predict.

The documenter records the actions, so the next session can open with the report back. The [guide to LAC sessions](https://nash.com.ph/blog/deped-learning-action-cell) sets out the rest of DO 35, and [a fishbowl LAC](https://nash.com.ph/blog/fishbowl-discussion-lac-sessions-deped) uses Liberating Structures' version of the three questions to close its discussion.

### Example 3: reviewing summative test results

This is the figure above, written out. The Grade 5 teachers bring their item results to the LAC session two days after the first summative test of Term 2.

- **What?** The 152 learners answered 74% of the fraction items correctly and 41% of the decimal items. In each of the four sections, more than half chose 0.45 as larger than 0.5.
- **So what?** Many learners read the longer decimal as the larger. The error runs across the grade, not in one class.
- **Now what?** All four sections reteach comparing decimals next week with place-value charts, and the same five comparison items are given again in two weeks.

DO 015, s. 2026 has the school head "Organize Learning Action Cell (LAC) sessions and other capacity-building activities" (Sec. X.D) and has teachers base their tests "on the lessons actually covered" (para. 26). The [guide to DO 015](https://nash.com.ph/blog/deped-classroom-assessment-do-015-s-2026) covers the rest of the assessment rules.

### Example 4: a school head's reflection after the PTA general assembly

DO 44, s. 2015 has the School Report Card (SRC) presented at least twice, "during the mid-year (October) and year-end (March) general assemblies" (Encl., Sec. V.B.3), with graphs and "corresponding interpretations below", written "using the language most easily understood by the stakeholders" (Sec. V.B.1). A school head's notes after the October assembly:

- **What?** 212 of 640 families attended. Parents asked nine questions: seven about the canteen and the dismissal gate, none about the reading results on page 2 of the SRC. The interpretation under the reading graph used the terms "frustration level" and "instructional level" without explaining them.
- **So what?** The year's most important result did not reach the parents. They had no way to read it.
- **Now what?** For the March assembly, the School Planning Team rewrites the reading interpretation in Filipino, in two sentences a parent can repeat, and the school head opens the presentation with it.

The opening matters because listeners recall the start of a talk best, as [Effective Communication in School Leadership: 6 Tools](https://nash.com.ph/blog/effective-communication-school-leadership) explains. The [School Report Card guide](https://nash.com.ph/blog/school-report-card-transparency-board) has the SRC's nineteen items.

### Example 5: an aspiring school head's reflection for the NASH PDI

After the National Assessment for School Heads (NASH), takers who met the PPSSH in three domains take the Targeted Development Program (TDP), and takers With Developmental Areas take the Professional Development Intervention (PDI). In its Phase 3, a PDI participant carries out a Workplace Application Plan and reports on it in the Workplace Application Accomplishment Report (WAAR) (DM-OULS-2026-397, Encl. No. 2, Sec. III.B), which ends with a section of reflections. Its five prompts include "What went well during the implementation?", "How did your actions affect learners, teachers, or stakeholders?" and "What will you do differently in the future?" (DM-OULS-2026-397, Encl. No. 9, part IX). The first prompt is a What?, the second a So what?, the third a Now what?. Answering each with the facts, the meaning and the action makes the report a reflection rather than a narrative. The [NASH TDP and PDI guide](https://nash.com.ph/blog/nash-tdp-pdi-guide) explains the program.

## Post-observation conference: questions and sample answers

DM 089, s. 2025 sets the conference's time and purpose. It is held "immediately after the observation or within three (3) days thereafter" (item 57), and "in a manner which fosters constructive feedback" (item 58). It prescribes no agenda, script or form for the conference. The rating rests on the observation itself: "The rating for the teacher's performance shall be solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form" (item 55). So evidence brought to the conference does not change the rating; the conference is for the teacher's reflection.

The three questions give it an order. The school head asks; the teacher reflects first.

| Step | Questions the school head can ask | A weak answer | A stronger answer |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| What? | "What did you plan for this part, and what happened?" "What did the learners produce?" | "It went well, the class was participative." | "I planned 10 minutes for the motivation and it took 18. The exit slips show 21 of 40 solved the last problem." |
| So what? | "Why do you think it went that way?" "What does the learners' work tell you?" | "The learners are slow." | "The motivation ran long because the video did not load, and I explained it instead. The 19 who missed the last problem made the same sign error." |
| Now what? | "What will you do differently?" "What help do you need?" "When can I see it?" | "I will do better next time." | "Tomorrow I will open with the sign error and two worked examples. Please look at my next exit slips on Friday." |

Write the agreed next step down. DM 089 has the rater record "Significant incidents observed and feedback provided" in the PMCF (item 39), which has a "FEEDBACK/ RECOMMENDATION" column. The conference's Now what? belongs there, with its date. A teacher who disagrees with what the observer recorded has the routes set out in [Teacher Performance Feedback: A DepEd School Head's Guide](https://nash.com.ph/blog/teacher-performance-feedback-deped), and the [COT rubric guide](https://nash.com.ph/blog/cot-rubric-deped-classroom-observation) covers the ratings.

Who does the talking matters as much as the order. Tannenbaum and Cerasoli's review counted "active self-learning" among the four elements that define a debrief, and listed "being told how to improve by a coach or facilitator" as what a debrief is not (2013, p. 233). In a study of 27 newly appointed principals in role-played conversations, "principals were more skilled in advocating their own position than in deeply inquiring into and checking their understanding of the views of the parent or teacher" (Le Fevre and Robinson, 2015).

## Where DepEd's forms already ask the three questions

No DepEd form is titled What? So What? Now What?, but several print columns or steps that ask the same questions in the same order. The table below sets seven of them side by side.

**The three questions in DepEd's own forms** (an interactive figure)

No DepEd issuance uses the words "What? So what? Now what?". Which question each part answers is this figure's reading; the words are the issuances' and forms' own.

| Routine | What? | So what? | Now what? |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Post-observation conference | "to discuss his or her experience and performance during the classroom observation" (DM 089, s. 2025, item 57) | "allowing the ratee to reflect on his or her strengths and areas for improvement" (DM 089, s. 2025, item 57) | *Items 57 and 58 name no next step. The coaching form's FEEDBACK/ RECOMMENDATION column is where one is written down.* |
| Walkthrough debriefing | "discuss findings" (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37.d) | "celebrate successes" (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37.d) | "outline actionable steps for improvement" (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37.d) |
| Coaching and feedback log | "SIGNIFICANT INCIDENTS DESCRIPTION" (PMCF-Teaching) | "IMPACT ON JOB" (PMCF-Teaching) | "FEEDBACK/ RECOMMENDATION" (PMCF-Teaching) |
| LAC session | "stimulus (e.g. lectures, practicum, orientation, coaching, workshops, development and utilization of instructional materials, etc.)" (DO 35, s. 2016, item 18) | "collaborative discussion" (DO 35, s. 2016, item 18) | "individual and group action planning in order to implement agreed activities in the classroom" (DO 35, s. 2016, item 18); "LAC members should be prepared to report back on the success of these activities in future LAC sessions." (DO 35, s. 2016, item 19) |
| A lesson's Ways Forward | "Pause and reflect on what happened today." (DO 016, s. 2026, Annex B) | "reflect on the teaching experience and evidence of learning" (DO 016, s. 2026, item 7.d.i) | "identify next instructional steps, such as remediation, reteaching, enrichment, among others" (DO 016, s. 2026, item 7.d.i); "Think about what you need to change for the next session based on what happened today." (DO 016, s. 2026, Annex B) |
| SIP project monitoring | "(4) Accomplishments/ Status to Date" (Project Monitoring Report Form) | "(5) Issues/Problems/ Challenges" (Project Monitoring Report Form) | "(6) Recommendations/ Action Points" (Project Monitoring Report Form) |
| School Report Card | "graphs and charts" (DO 44, s. 2015, Encl., Sec. V.B.1) | "with corresponding interpretations below to help the stakeholders understand these better" (DO 44, s. 2015, Encl., Sec. V.B.1) | *None, by design: the SRC "is not for planning and accountability; it is a communication and advocacy tool" (Sec. V.B). The next steps go in the AIP, from the monitoring reports.* |

A form's columns are a reflection's outline: a coaching log entry whose IMPACT ON JOB column only repeats the incident has skipped So what?. Where a routine leaves Now what? out, the school head supplies it elsewhere. After a post-observation conference it goes in the PMCF. After the SRC it goes in the next AIP, from the Project Monitoring Report Form's "Recommendations/ Action Points", which the SIP Guidebook uses so that "the Project Team and SPT can now adjust, modify, and write the AIP for the following year" (Step 11).

## What? So What? Now What? compared with Gibbs, Kolb and others

| Model | Its steps | Where it fits in a school |
| --- | --- | --- |
| What? So What? Now What? (Borton, 1970; Driscoll, 1994; Rolfe and others, 2001) | Three questions | A short conference, the end of a LAC session, a review of results |
| Gibbs's reflective cycle (1988) | Description, feelings, evaluation, analysis, conclusions, personal action plans | A written reflection on an event with strong feelings, such as a conflict with a parent |
| Kolb's experiential learning cycle (1984) | Concrete experience, reflective observation, abstract conceptualization, active experimentation | Planning how teachers or learners learn from an activity, more than a conversation about one |
| Hattie and Timperley's feedback questions (2007) | "Where am I going?", "How am I going?", "Where to next?" | Feedback measured against a goal or a standard |
| Liberating Structures' W³ | The three questions, in rounds of individual writing, small groups and the whole group | A group of 4 or more, such as a LAC or a planning team |

Gibbs's cycle gives feelings a stage of their own. Its first step says "Don't make judgements yet or try to draw conclusions; simply describe", and its second asks "What were your reactions and feelings?" (Gibbs, 1988, pp. 46-47). Rolfe and his co-authors chose Borton's three steps partly because Gibbs's cycle has "no reflexive path back to the action" (2001, p. 33).

Hattie and Timperley's three questions add what the What? model lacks: the goal. "Where am I going? (What are the goals?)" comes before "How am I going?" (2007, p. 86). When the reflection is about a standard, such as a COT indicator or a SIP target, start with the goal and then ask the three questions. [Teacher Performance Feedback: A DepEd School Head's Guide](https://nash.com.ph/blog/teacher-performance-feedback-deped) shows Hattie and Timperley's questions in comments to teachers.

## What research says about structured reflection

### Most reflection stays shallow

Hatton and Smith coded the written reflections of student teachers at the University of Sydney in four types: descriptive writing, descriptive reflection, dialogic reflection and critical reflection. Descriptive writing "is not reflective at all, but merely reports literature or events". "The largest proportion (60%-70%) of coded units entailed descriptive reflection", which at least tries to give reasons, and critical reflection appeared in "only three reports from the 1991 cohort, and only five from the 1992 cohort" (Hatton and Smith, 1994, pp. 7-8). Rolfe and his co-authors note that "some critics have pointed out that most practitioners do not reflect at this deeper level, and that some will probably never progress further than the concrete thinking required for descriptive reflection", and accept that novices "might therefore remain at the first level" (2001, pp. 34-35).

### What counts as a debrief, and what debriefs do

Tannenbaum and Cerasoli pooled 46 samples with 2,136 people: "on average, debriefs improve effectiveness over a control group by approximately 25% (d = .67)" (2013, p. 231). The debriefs that counted had four elements: the people learning actively, a developmental purpose that is "nonpunitive rather than judgmental or administrative", attention to specific events, and more than one source of information, such as an observer or data (p. 233). Facilitated debriefs did about three times as well as debriefs with no facilitator, but few studies had no facilitator (p. 239).

The same review explains why a rating conversation is a poor debrief: "when ratees believe the ratings can have punitive implications, they are more likely to be defensive, less willing to share information, and less open to feedback" (p. 232). DM 089 keeps the two apart. The rating comes from the Observation Notes Form (item 55), and walkthroughs are "non-rated" (item 37).

### Coaching changes teaching, more in small programs

Kraft, Blazar and Hogan combined 60 studies of teacher coaching with causal designs and found "pooled effect sizes of 0.49 standard deviations (SD) on instruction and 0.18 SD on achievement" (2018, p. 547). They define coaching as programs "where coaches or peers observe teachers' instruction and provide feedback to help them improve" (p. 548). Effects were about twice as large on instruction in programs with fewer than 100 teachers. They also warned that "having the same person serve as both coach and evaluator can undercut the trusting relationships needed between coaches and teachers and may result in superficial and infrequent feedback" (p. 573). In a DepEd school the school head is often both, which is a reason to keep the reflection the teacher's own and the next step specific.

### In Philippine schools

In a study of 24 public elementary teachers in the Schools Division of Pampanga, teachers found classroom observation "both evaluative and developmental", and its feedback "supportive, yet induced stress and anxiety when perceived as judgmental"; the authors call for "valuable pre- and post- observation conversations" (Peña and others, 2026). In a study of science teachers at a large Metro Manila elementary school, the post-lesson discussions "became a venue where each member of the team shared their unique perception on the effectiveness of the lesson based on students' responses" (Gutierez, 2019, p. 1193). Neither study used Borton's three questions, and as of November 2026 no Philippine study has tested them.

## Where DepEd asks school heads to reflect

The PPSSH, adopted by DO 024, s. 2020, is a "public statement of professional accountability for school heads to reflect on and assess their own practice" (item 4). Its strand 4.2, Professional reflection and learning, reads at each career stage:

| Career stage | Indicator |
| --- | --- |
| 1 (aspiring school heads) | 4.2.1 "Demonstrate understanding of how professional reflection and learning can be used in improving practice." |
| 2 | 4.2.2 "Apply professional reflection and learning to improve one's practice." |
| 3 | 4.2.3 "Initiate professional reflections and promote learning opportunities with other school heads to improve practice." |
| 4 | 4.2.4 "Model exemplary leadership practices within and beyond school contexts in critically evaluating practice and setting clearly defined targets for professional development." |

Other rules ask the school head to lead reflection by others. DO 016, s. 2026 has school heads "organize participatory conferences and reflective discussions among teachers and instructional leaders to analyze the impact of lesson planning on learner outcomes" (item 37.d). The Basic Education Monitoring and Evaluation Framework has the school head "Conduct quarterly Program Implementation Review (PIR) in the school" ([DepEd Order No. 029, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/06/22/june-20-2022-do-029-s-2022-adoption-of-the-basic-education-monitoring-and-evaluation-framework/), Sec. VIII.f). For LAC sessions, DO 35, s. 2016 counts "critical reflection amongst teachers leading to changes in classroom practice" as the first sign that the LAC works (item 33). The [PPSSH Domain 4 guide](https://nash.com.ph/blog/ppssh-domain-4-developing-self-and-others) covers the rest of the domain, and the [leadership self-assessment](https://nash.com.ph/blog/leadership-self-assessment-school-heads) gives a school head a way to reflect on all 34 strands.

## What this means for school heads

- **Use the three questions in the order given, every time.** In a conference, a LAC or a results review, finish What? before anyone answers So what?. When someone jumps to a conclusion, ask for the fact under it.
- **Let the teacher reflect first.** At the post-observation conference, ask before you tell. DM 089 says the conference is for "allowing the ratee to reflect" (item 57).
- **Write every Now what? down with a date.** For a teacher, in the PMCF's FEEDBACK/ RECOMMENDATION column. For a SIP project, in the Project Monitoring Report Form's Recommendations/ Action Points, and from there into the AIP.
- **Open the next meeting with the last Now what?.** DO 35 expects LAC members to "report back on the success of these activities" (item 19). The report back is the next What?.
- **Keep judgments out of What?.** "Weak", "lazy", "passive" and "did not teach well" are readings, not facts. Ask what was seen or counted.
- **Reflect on your own work too.** After an assembly, an SGC meeting or a decision that went wrong, write your three answers. Indicator 4.2.2 asks a school head to "Apply professional reflection and learning to improve one's practice".
- **Do not turn the model into a form.** No DepEd issuance requires a What? So What? Now What? sheet. DO 016, s. 2026 says of its own lesson planning rubric that it "shall be used only to support professional reflection and instructional improvement, and not as a compliance checklist or scoring tool for paperwork completion" (item 9). Use the questions inside the forms teachers already fill in.

## How the NASH may test this

The National Assessment for School Heads (NASH) covers the PPSSH, and strand 4.2 asks how a school head uses reflection to improve practice. The items below are original practice items, scored 3 (Relational), 2 (Multistructural), 1 (Unistructural) or 0 (Prestructural). An option that breaks a rule scores 0.

### Question 1

*Indicator 4.2.1, Professional reflection and learning. Career Stage 1, Conceptual, Moderate.*

A Master Teacher who hopes to become a school head writes a reflection after a parent assembly: "The assembly went well. Many parents came, and the program ran smoothly. I am thankful to the teachers who helped." Which revision best shows how reflection can be used to improve practice?

- **A.** Add a list of the activities in the program, the names of the teachers who helped, and the number of parents who signed the attendance sheet that day.
- **B.** Add how the Master Teacher felt before and during the assembly, and how relieved they were when the program ended on schedule.
- **C.** Replace the reflection with the minutes of the assembly, since the minutes are the official record and a reflection is not required.
- **D.** Add which items parents asked about and which they missed, what that suggests about the presentation, and one change to test at the next assembly.

**Answer and explanation**

**Best answer: D.** Points: A = 2, B = 1, C = 0, D = 3.

- **A (2 points, Multistructural).** It adds facts, which the reflection lacked, but it stops at description and draws no meaning or action from them.
- **B (1 point, Unistructural).** It adds one element of reflection, the writer's feelings, but nothing about what happened or what to change.
- **C (0 points, Prestructural).** It misreads reflection as record-keeping. Minutes record what was decided; they do not ask what the writer learned, which is the point of strand 4.2.
- **D (3 points, Relational).** It adds facts, a reading of what they mean, and an action to try, so the reflection can change the next assembly.

**Why.** This aligns with Career Stage 1 expectations because indicator 4.2.1 asks for an understanding of how reflection improves practice. Borton described the sequence as "increasing awareness (What), evaluating intention (So What), and experimenting with new behavior (Now What)" (1970, p. 93), and Hatton and Smith classed writing that "merely reports" events as "not reflective at all" (1994, p. 7). The 2-point option gathers facts but never reaches their meaning or a change.

*Indicator 4.2.1: Demonstrate understanding of how professional reflection and learning can be used in improving practice.*

*Sources: DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020; Borton (1970), p. 93; Hatton and Smith (1994), p. 7.*

### Question 2

*Indicator 4.2.2, Professional reflection and learning. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.*

You are the school head of a 700-learner elementary school in an upland municipality. Your after-class reading sessions for Grade 4 ended their first term with fewer learners reading at grade level than you had targeted. Attendance records show that learners who walk more than an hour home missed most sessions. The School Planning Team meets next week to plan the second term. What is the most appropriate action?

- **A.** Keep the sessions as planned for the second term, since a single term is too short to judge, and review the results again at the end of the school year.
- **B.** Present the attendance and reading records to the team at the meeting, and ask the reading coordinator to prepare a written report on the results for the division office.
- **C.** Review the attendance and reading records with the team, agree on why the far-walking learners missed the sessions, and test a change in schedule for them next term.
- **D.** Require the parents of learners who missed sessions to sign an undertaking that their children will stay after class, and refer those who refuse to the barangay.

**Answer and explanation**

**Best answer: C.** Points: A = 1, B = 2, C = 3, D = 0.

- **A (1 point, Unistructural).** It keeps the program going, which is one sound element, but it sets aside facts that already explain part of the shortfall.
- **B (2 points, Multistructural).** It brings the facts to the team and reports them, but it stops before asking what they mean or what to change.
- **C (3 points, Relational).** It moves from the facts to what they mean and to a change the team can test, with the team that owns the plan.
- **D (0 points, Prestructural).** It blames families for distance and threatens families with referral, which is punitive and against learners' welfare, and it does nothing about why the learners missed the sessions.

**Why.** This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 4.2.2 asks the school head to apply reflection to improve practice. The SIP Guidebook has the project team and the School Planning Team discuss the "Recommendations/Action Points based on the results of the monitoring" so that they "can now adjust, modify, and write the AIP for the following year" (DO 44, s. 2015, Step 11). The 2-point option has the facts and the right people but never reaches a decision.

*Indicator 4.2.2: Apply professional reflection and learning to improve one's practice.*

*Sources: DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020; DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Step 11.*

Nothing in this guide reproduces or predicts examination content.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the What? So What? Now What? reflection model?

It is a three-step way to reflect on an event: What? describes what happened, So what? says what it means, and Now what? decides what to do next. Driscoll's version calls the steps "a description of the event", "an analysis of the event" and "proposed actions following the event" (Driscoll, 2000, p. 27).

### Who developed What? So What? Now What?

Terry Borton set out the sequence in *Reach, Touch, and Teach* (1970) as a model for building curriculum. John Driscoll reached the same three questions on his own in 1994, for nurses, and later learned that Borton had used them first; Gary Rolfe, Dawn Freshwater and Melanie Jasper built their reflective framework on Borton's in 2001. It is not Thomas Gilovich's.

### What is an example of a What? So What? Now What? reflection?

After a post-observation conference: What? "Two of the six groups finished the task; three asked for the instructions again." So what? "The instructions were given once, orally, so most groups lost them." Now what? "On Thursday each group gets a task card, and the school head counts how many groups finish."

### What is the difference between Rolfe's model and Gibbs's reflective cycle?

Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper use Borton's three questions, with cue questions under each, and return to the first step after acting. Gibbs's cycle has six stages and gives feelings and evaluation stages of their own (Gibbs, 1988, pp. 46-47). The three questions suit a short conference; Gibbs's cycle suits a longer written reflection.

### Does DepEd require the What? So What? Now What? model?

No. As of November 21, 2026, no DepEd order or memorandum names it. DepEd's rules ask for the same steps in their own words, such as the post-observation conference "allowing the ratee to reflect on his or her strengths and areas for improvement" (DM 089, s. 2025, item 57) and the Ways Forward of a lesson plan (DO 016, s. 2026, item 7.d.i).

## Sources

### DepEd issuances

- [DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2020/09/07/september-7-2020-do-024-s-2020-national-adoption-and-implementation-of-the-philippine-professional-standards-for-school-heads/), National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads, September 7, 2020. Item 4; strand 4.2.
- [DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2025/10/01/october-1-2025-dm-089-s-2025-guidelines-on-the-multi-year-performance-management-and-evaluation-system-for-teachers-from-school-years-2025-2026-to-2027-2028/), Guidelines on the Multi-Year Performance Management and Evaluation System for Teachers from School Years 2025-2026 to 2027-2028, October 1, 2025. Items 37, 39, 55, 57 and 58; Annex D (Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form).
- [DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2016/06/07/do-35-s-2016-the-learning-action-cell-as-a-k-to-12-basic-education-program-school-based-continuing-professional-development-strategy-for-the-improvement-of-teaching-and-learning/), The Learning Action Cell as a K to 12 Basic Education Program School-Based Continuing Professional Development Strategy for the Improvement of Teaching and Learning, June 7, 2016. Items 18, 19 and 33.
- [DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/06/04/june-4-2026-do-016-s-2026-guidelines-on-lesson-planning-and-learning-design/), Guidelines on Lesson Planning and Learning Design, June 4, 2026. Items 7.d.i, 9 and 37.d; Annex B.
- [DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2026/06/04/june-4-2026-do-015-s-2026-revised-guidelines-on-classroom-assessment-grading-system-and-awards-and-recognition-for-the-k-to-12-basic-education-program/), Revised Guidelines on Classroom Assessment, Grading System, and Awards and Recognition for the K to 12 Basic Education Program, June 4, 2026. Para. 26; Sec. X.D.
- [DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2015/09/29/do-44-s-2015-guidelines-on-the-enhanced-school-improvement-planning-sip-process-and-the-school-report-card-src/), Guidelines on the Enhanced School Improvement Planning (SIP) Process and the School Report Card (SRC), September 29, 2015. Enclosure, Sec. V.B; SIP Guidebook, Step 11 and the Project Monitoring Report Form.
- [DepEd Order No. 029, s. 2022](https://www.deped.gov.ph/2022/06/22/june-20-2022-do-029-s-2022-adoption-of-the-basic-education-monitoring-and-evaluation-framework/), Adoption of the Basic Education Monitoring and Evaluation Framework, June 2022. Sec. VIII.
- Memorandum DM-OULS-2026-397, Guidelines on the Conduct of the National Assessment for School Heads (NASH) Targeted Development Program (TDP) and Professional Development Intervention (PDI), September 7, 2026. Enclosure No. 2, Sec. III.B; Enclosure No. 9, part IX.

### Books and studies

- Borton, T. (1970). *Reach, Touch, and Teach: Student Concerns and Process Education*. New York: McGraw-Hill. Pages 88-90, 93, 96 and 128.
- Driscoll, J. (1994). Reflective practice for practise. *Senior Nurse*, 14(1), 47-50.
- Driscoll, J. (2000). *Practising Clinical Supervision: A Reflective Approach*. Edinburgh: Baillière Tindall. Pages 27-28.
- Driscoll, J. (Ed.) (2007). *Practising Clinical Supervision: A Reflective Approach for Healthcare Professionals* (2nd ed.). Edinburgh: Baillière Tindall Elsevier. Pages 43-44.
- Rolfe, G., Freshwater, D., and Jasper, M. (2001). *Critical Reflection for Nursing and the Helping Professions: A User's Guide*. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Pages 33-35.
- Gilovich, T., Medvec, V. H., and Savitsky, K. (2000). The spotlight effect in social judgment: An egocentric bias in estimates of the salience of one's own actions and appearance. *Journal of Personality and Social Psychology*, 78(2), 211-222. [doi:10.1037/0022-3514.78.2.211](https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.78.2.211)
- Gibbs, G. (1988). *Learning by Doing: A Guide to Teaching and Learning Methods*. Further Education Unit. Pages 46-47.
- Hattie, J., and Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. *Review of Educational Research*, 77(1), 81-112. [doi:10.3102/003465430298487](https://doi.org/10.3102/003465430298487)
- Hatton, N., and Smith, D. (1994). [*Facilitating Reflection: Issues and Research*](https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED375110.pdf). Paper presented at the 24th Conference of the Australian Teacher Education Association, Brisbane. ERIC ED375110. Pages 7-8.
- Kraft, M. A., Blazar, D., and Hogan, D. (2018). The effect of teacher coaching on instruction and achievement: A meta-analysis of the causal evidence. *Review of Educational Research*, 88(4), 547-588. [doi:10.3102/0034654318759268](https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654318759268)
- Kolb, D. A. (1984). *Experiential Learning: Experience as the Source of Learning and Development*. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
- Le Fevre, D. M., and Robinson, V. M. J. (2015). The interpersonal challenges of instructional leadership: Principals' effectiveness in conversations about performance issues. *Educational Administration Quarterly*, 51(1), 58-95. [doi:10.1177/0013161X13518218](https://doi.org/10.1177/0013161X13518218)
- Tannenbaum, S. I., and Cerasoli, C. P. (2013). Do team and individual debriefs enhance performance? A meta-analysis. *Human Factors*, 55(1), 231-245. [doi:10.1177/0018720812448394](https://doi.org/10.1177/0018720812448394)
- Lipmanowicz, H., and McCandless, K. Liberating Structures: [What, So What, Now What (W3)](https://www.liberatingstructures.com/what-so-what-now-what)
- Peña, J. T., Malit, J. M., Pineda, E. M., and Deluta, V. J. M. (2026). Classroom observation in a time of reform: A phenomenological study of public elementary school teachers' experiences in the Schools Division of Pampanga, Philippines. *International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research*, 25(9). [doi:10.26803/ijlter.25.9.2](https://doi.org/10.26803/ijlter.25.9.2)
- Gutierez, S. B. (2019). [Learning from teaching: Teacher sense-making on their research and school-based professional development](http://www.iier.org.au/iier29/gutierez.pdf). *Issues in Educational Research*, 29(4), 1181-1200.

*Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: Borton (1970); Driscoll (2000); Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper (2001); DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025; DepEd Orders No. 35, s. 2016, No. 016, s. 2026 and No. 44, s. 2015.*

---

© 2026 Mark Anthony Llego, NASH Reviewer. All rights reserved. You may quote up to 100 words from this article with the author's name, its title and a link. In research, cite it as: Llego, M. A. (2026, November 21). *What? So What? Now What? Reflection Model: DepEd Examples*. NASH Reviewer. https://nash.com.ph/blog/what-so-what-now-what-reflection-model. Any other reuse of the article, its charts or its data needs written permission: ask through our [contact form](https://nash.com.ph/contact). Terms of Service: https://nash.com.ph/terms#website-content-and-data
