Walking the process is Activity 3.4 of the School Improvement Plan (SIP) Guidebook in DepEd Order (DO) No. 44, s. 2015. A project team assigned to one Priority Improvement Area (PIA) draws a flowchart of a school process as it happens now, checks it with the people who do the work, watches it directly, and marks every problem it sees with a “storm cloud”. One storm cloud, the area of focus, then goes to root cause analysis.
The guidebook tells the team to write each storm cloud “on the activity where you discovered it”. A problem is often discovered several steps after the step that made it, and sometimes outside the process altogether. The flowchart shows where to look; tracing each cloud back to its source shows what to change.
The rules below are those of DO 44, s. 2015 and of the assessment and attendance rules in force on November 20, 2026.
Key findings
- Direct observation is required. “It is important to know that brainstorming and interviews alone are not enough to map out a process. Direct observations are a must if you want to validate how the process works” (SIP Guidebook, Activity 3.4). The output is a “Flowchart of the school processes relevant to each PIA with storm clouds” and the “Documentation of interviews or observations”.
- A process gets three maps, drawn apart. Annex 7 names “What you think the process is”, “What the process really is” and “What the process should be”, and says “Each one should have a different process map.”
- A storm cloud is a fact, not a feeling. “Storm clouds are specific, measurable, and observable” (Activity 3.4). The guidebook’s own example: “10 out of 30 students’ test papers had items that were erroneously checked.”
- The guidebook writes a cloud where it was discovered, and fixes it where it was made. Its checking error is written “during the recording of the test scores”, but its sample project is a meeting “to discuss the new process of checking Periodical Test papers” (Activity 3.4; Step 6).
- One cloud becomes the area of focus. The team chooses “the one which, when addressed, will clearly affect the PIA” and writes it as a problem statement that gives its size, how often, where and when (Activity 3.5).
- The guidebook’s test process has changed. DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026 repealed DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2015 from School Year (SY) 2026-2027 (para 6 of the Order). In Grades 4 to 12, two summative tests now come before a term examination each term (DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026, para 27; DO 015, s. 2026, Tables 3 and 4).
- Principals rate this step among the weaker ones. In a study of 73 elementary school principals in the Muslim areas of Lanao del Norte, analyzing the school processes was rated 3.21 of 4, “Moderately Implemented”, one of three Assess practices below “Fully Implemented” (Abalorio, 2021, Table 4).
What the SIP Guidebook asks for
Activity 3.4, “Analyze the school processes”, comes after the team has listened to learners and other stakeholders (Activity 3.3) and before it selects an area of focus (Activity 3.5). The team looks for the school processes behind the concerns it heard, “to understand further why and where the needs and problems exist.”
The guidebook defines a process and says why it should be mapped:
A school process is a set of activities arranged together in order to deliver a service (e.g. Mathematics Periodical Test Process or Enrollment Process). We need to understand processes in order to know how a stakeholder’s needs or wants are being met. A process must also be simple enough to be repeatable and replicable. This means that how a certain process is done should be known by everyone and should not rely on just one person to work. This is why it is important for us to map the process.
The map is of the present: “Your Project Team should map out the processes involved in your assigned PIA by creating a flowchart of what is currently happening in each step of the process and NOT what the process should be. The common mistake is combining the present state with the desired outcome.” The team walks through the process “by brainstorming with the people who are involved in the process or by doing interviews or direct observations”, and it cannot stop at the first two. The Institute for Healthcare Improvement’s flowchart tool gives the same instruction to hospital teams: “Show the process as it actually works (not as it should work)” (IHI, 2017, p. 2).
The guidebook has a name for the people at the center of the walk. The process owners are “a person or group of people responsible for ensuring the efficiency of the process, who has the ability to make changes in the process and is/are highly involved in the project” (Definition of Terms). In the guidebook’s own attendance example, they are “the Grade 6 class advisers because they are the ones who check the attendance of students” (Step 9). They walk the process with the team, and in Step 10 they roll out the improved one.
The flowchart and its storm clouds are working papers. At Activity 3.7 the team presents “The flowchart of the particular school process you observed, including the storm clouds” to the School-Community Planning Team (SPT). In the SIP itself, the walk is “not required to be included in this Section, but shall be part of the Annexes of the SIP” (SIP Design Template, 2018). The guide to the SIP places Activity 3.4 among the eleven steps, and the guide to root cause analysis takes the area of focus from here to its root cause.
Three maps of one process
Annex 7 of the guidebook, the Walk the Process Guidelines, names three ways to view a process:
- What you think the process is – the team’s perspective of what is happening in the process
- What the process really is – what is actually happening in the process, validated through interviews and direct observations
- What the process should be – the actual future state of the process based on learners’ or stakeholders’ requirements
But remember to do these separately from each other. Do not combine elements of what you think a process is and what the process should be. Each one should have a different process map. For now, you will only have a map of the first one (what you think the process is).
The idea is older than the guidebook. Rummler and Brache drew “Is” and “Should” process maps in 1990, and a 1994 text on benchmarking says that every process “has three versions: what the organization thinks it is; what it actually is, and what it should be” (Bogan and English, 1994, pp. 214-215).
The first map comes from the brainstorm. Interviews and observation turn it into the second, the map Activity 3.4 asks for. The third waits until the team knows the root cause and has chosen a solution.
DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 7 · an invented school
Three maps of one process
A project team maps how its school follows up a learner who stops coming to class: first as the team thinks it works, then as interviews and observation show it works, and last as it should work.
Map 1
What you think the process is
“the team’s perspective of what is happening in the process” Drawn first, in the brainstorm, on sticky notes.
- A learner is absent
- Marks the absence in School Form 2 that dayClass adviser
- Decision: Five absences in a row?Class adviser
No: Keeps marking each day
- Calls the parent the next school dayClass adviser
- Decision: Does the parent come to school?Class adviser
- YesConference with the parentFrom the brainstorm
- NoHome visit within the weekFrom the brainstorm
- The learner is back in class
From the fifth absence to the first word with the family: 1 school day later
The team believed the family heard from the school the day after the fifth absence.
Where its steps came from: from the brainstorm: 6.
Map 2
What the process really is
“what is actually happening in the process, validated through interviews and direct observations” Drawn after the interviews and at least two weeks of observation.
- A learner is absent
- Marks absences in a class notebook at the morning roll callClass adviser
- Copies the notebook into School Form 2 in the last week of the monthClass adviser
- Decision: Five absences in a row?Class adviser
No: Nothing happens
- Sends a note home with a sibling or a neighbor’s childClass adviser
- Decision: Does the note reach the parent?Class adviser
- YesThe parent comes on the day report cards are given outFound in an interview
- No, or not knownA home visit if the adviser has time after class; no record is keptFound in an interview
- Sees the month’s absences in School Form 4 by the 10th of the next monthSchool head
- The learner comes back, or stops coming
From the fifth absence to the first word with the family: 10 school days later
The streak was found when the notebook was copied, and the note went home two weeks after the fifth absence. No visit was recorded.
Where its steps came from: found in an interview: 5; found by observation: 3.
Map 3
What the process should be
“the actual future state of the process based on learners’ or stakeholders’ requirements” Drawn last, once the root cause is known and a solution is chosen.
- A learner is absent
- Marks the absence in School Form 2 the same dayClass adviser
- Decision: Fifth absence in a row?Class adviser
No: Keeps marking each day
- Calls or messages the parent that day, and writes it in a follow-up logClass adviser
- Decision: Is the parent reached?Class adviser
- YesConference within three school daysThe school's own choice
- NoHome visit within three school days, with a co-teacher (after-hours visits earn vacation service credits under DO 005, s. 2024)The school's own choice
- An intervention with the parents by the end of Term 1, or sooner when a learner reaches about twelve absencesClass adviser
- Reads the follow-up log every FridaySchool head
- The learner is back in class, or referred
From the fifth absence to the first word with the family: the same day
The family hears from the school on the day of the fifth absence, and meets the adviser within three school days.
Where its steps came from: required by a rule: 2; the school's own choice: 6.
The three maps and their descriptions are the SIP Guidebook’s (DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, Annex 7). The school, its steps and its days are invented; the rules in the third map are cited at each step.
The difference between the first two maps is what the walk is for. In the figure, the brainstorm drew a tidy process in which the family hears from the school the day after a learner’s fifth absence in a row. The interviews and the observation found a notebook copied into School Form 2 once a month, a note sent home with a neighbor’s child, and no record of home visits. Each of those steps is a place to look for a storm cloud, and none of them was on the first map.
The rules behind the third map are real. School Form 2 is the “Daily Attendance Report of Learners”, with “Daily updating and for submission to the office of the principal/registrar on or before 5th day of the succeeding Month”, and its data element 18 counts learners absent for five consecutive days, a number “which can be used as basis for home visitation” (DepEd Order No. 4, s. 2014). The new grading order adds a checkpoint: “Teachers shall monitor learner attendance and provide timely interventions in coordination with parents or guardians, particularly by the end of Term 1 or when a learner reaches approximately twelve (12) absences” (DO 015, s. 2026, para 70). Home visits done after hours count toward a teacher’s service credits under DepEd Order No. 005, s. 2024. The rest of the third map, such as acting on the fifth absence, a follow-up log and a three-day limit, is the school’s own choice.
How to walk the process
Annex 7 sets three steps in order: brainstorm, interview, observe.
1. Brainstorm with the people who do the work
The guidebook’s example is a parent-teacher dialogue: “walk the process with Grade 6 parents and teachers. Let them create the process flowchart with you because they are the ones who are involved in the process.” Use a flipchart and self-stick notes, one activity to a note, so the group can move them as it corrects itself. “Walk the process from the very start”, and keep one direction: “time should always flow from top to bottom, or from left to right.”
If the group cannot agree on the order of the steps, that is a finding. “If the team is having difficulties in mapping their process, it could mean that the sequence of their process is unclear or is undefined. An unclear or undefined process usually results in inconsistent performance” (Annex 7). The guidebook’s example is a grade level where “some teachers in the grade level have very good documentation of parent and teacher dialogues while others do not”.
2. Interview to find what the brainstorm missed
Interviews have two jobs: “1) to identify missing elements of the process (including decision points) and 2) to validate the elements conceived during brainstorming” (Annex 7). Ask about each step: who does it, when, with what, producing what, and what goes wrong.
Some steps cannot be watched. The guidebook’s example is the test: “checking and recording the test scores are activities that the teacher may perform at home. Instead of directly observing the teacher, you can verify these elements by asking the teachers if they do these at home, for how long, producing what output, what problems they encounter, what other related activities they do, etc.” (Annex 7).
3. Observe the process directly
“Direct observations allow you to determine what the process really is from what you think the process is. This allows you to check for missing elements and, more importantly, to validate the elements identified during brainstorming and interviews” (Annex 7). Observation is also where storm clouds come from: “This step is especially important when you identify storm clouds, or problems arising in specific activities in the process.”
The guidebook’s insistence on watching has a long history in quality improvement. The first of Masaaki Imai’s five golden rules of gemba management is “When a problem (abnormality) arises, go to the gemba first”, the gemba being the place where the work is done (Gemba Kaizen, 2nd ed., 2012, p. 24). Taiichi Ohno of Toyota would advise, “Observe the production floor without preconceptions” (Toyota Motor Corporation, 2006). In schools, the Carnegie Foundation’s third principle of improvement says the same: “Go and see how local conditions shape work processes” (Carnegie Foundation, 2024).
What to record during an observation:
- The date, the time and the step, so that a storm cloud can be found again.
- Counts and times, not impressions: the number of papers, learners or minutes, as the guidebook’s own clouds do.
- What you see, not what you think of it. The authors of Instructional Rounds in Education teach observers to record “evidence of what you see — not what you think about what you see” (City and others, 2009, ch. 4).
- More than one occasion. A step watched once may have been watched on an unusual day. Watch it again on another day before writing a cloud.
Tell the teachers whose work is observed what the observation is for, before it begins. The team is studying a process, not rating a teacher, and the record should name no one. City and colleagues call walkthroughs that hunt for teachers’ deficiencies “antithetical to the purposes of instructional rounds and profoundly antiprofessional” (2009, p. 4). W. Edwards Deming put the larger point in numbers from his own experience: most troubles and possibilities for improvement, “94% belong to the system (responsibility of management)” (Out of the Crisis, 1986, p. 315).
Flowchart symbols and swim lanes
Frank and Lillian Gilbreth introduced process charts to American engineers in 1921, as “a device for visualizing a process as a means of improving it” and “a record of present conditions” (“Process Charts”, pp. 3 and 4). The symbols most flowcharts use today were standardized for information processing in the United States as ANSI X3.5-1970:
| Symbol | Meaning in the standard | In a school process |
|---|---|---|
| Terminal (oval) | “a terminal point in a flowchart, for example, start, stop, halt, delay, or interrupt” | Where the process starts and ends: “A learner is absent”, “The learner is back in class” |
| Process (rectangle) | “any kind of processing function” | An activity: “Copies the notebook into School Form 2” |
| Decision (diamond) | “a decision or switching-type operation that determines which of a number of alternative paths is to be followed” | A question with yes and no branches: “Does the parent come to school?” |
| Document | “an I/O function in which the medium is a document” | A form or record: School Form 2, the class record, the answer key |
| Connector (small circle) | “an exit to or an entry from another part of the flowchart” | A jump to another page of the map |
| Flowline (arrow) | links the symbols; “Normal direction of flow is from left to right and top to bottom” | The order of the steps |
Definitions quoted from ANSI X3.5-1970, Flowchart Symbols and Their Usage in Information Processing (FIPS PUB 24, 1973), sections 3.2.2 to 3.4.2 and 4.4.1.
The standard’s rule for direction is the guidebook’s: “time should always flow from top to bottom, or from left to right” (Annex 7). A school map needs only the first four symbols. What matters more is that every box is a real activity someone does, written with a verb.
The guidebook’s sample flowchart, a parent-teacher dialogue, uses four shapes: ovals for “Start” and “End”, rounded boxes for activities, one diamond for the decision “Parents Arrive?”, and YES and NO labels on its two branches. Its steps run: “Adviser Prepares Forms 1 and 2”, “Check Attendance: Form 1”, “Identify SARDO”, “Inform Parents (Verbal)”, then the decision, with “PTD during Card Giving” on one branch and “Drop Or Home Visit” on the other. The sample’s Forms 1 and 2 had already been replaced: the daily attendance part of Form 1, the old School Register, and Form 2, the teacher’s monthly report of enrollment and attendance, became School Form 2 in 2014, a year before the guidebook (DO 4, s. 2014). SARDO in the sample is a student at risk of dropping out; DepEd’s newer term is LARDO, “Learners At Risk of Dropping Out”, which a 2026 memorandum calls “Interchangeable with the term Students-at-Risk-of-Dropping-Out (SARDO)” (DepEd Memorandum No. 050, s. 2026).
A swim-lane chart, also called a deployment chart, adds one column (or row) for each person or office, and draws each step in the lane of the person who does it. Peter Scholtes’s The Team Handbook explained deployment charts in 1988, and Geary Rummler and Alan Brache drew cross-functional process maps in Improving Performance (1990). The guidebook’s own SIP Process Flowchart is drawn this way, with a row for each of “School Head with Team”, “School Planning Team” and “Project Team”.
Lanes show the handoffs, where a step’s output passes from one person to another: from the adviser’s School Form 2 to the school head’s School Form 4, from the subject teacher’s grades to the adviser’s report card, from the school to the parent. Rummler and Brache wrote that “the greatest opportunities for performance improvement often lie in the functional interfaces—those points at which the baton (for example, ‘production specs’) is being passed from one department to another” (1990, p. 9). Most of the evidence on handoffs comes from hospitals. In 444 surgical malpractice claims, 60 involved communication breakdowns that harmed patients, and “Forty-three percent of communication breakdowns occurred with handoffs and 39% with transfers in the patient’s location” (Greenberg and others, 2007). On a school’s map, a storm cloud seen just after a handoff is worth tracing back across it.
Writing a storm cloud
The guidebook’s test for a storm cloud is three words long: “Storm clouds are specific, measurable, and observable” (Activity 3.4). Its sample flowchart of a Grade 7 Mathematics test carries six, and they show what the three words mean.
| Step where it was written | The storm cloud, as printed | What makes it a storm cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Distributing the test papers | “Two answer sheets were missing” | A count, at one step |
| Answering the test (test proper) | “Eight students were talking to their seatmates” | A count anyone in the room could confirm |
| Retrieving the test papers | “It took an extra 5 minutes for students to submit their papers” | A time, measured |
| Recording the test scores | “10/30 students’ papers had items that were erroneously checked” | A count out of a total |
| Analyzing performance on items | “Only 2/30 students correctly answered the difficult items (items 8 to 10)” | A count out of a total, on named items |
| Identifying least mastered skills | “Only 8/30 students did not make mistakes in basic arithmetic” | A count out of a total |
Steps and storm clouds as printed in the SIP Guidebook (DO 44, s. 2015), Activity 3.4, “Sample Mathematical Periodical Test Process for Gr.7 Students”.
Every cloud is a number someone counted or a thing someone saw, and none names a person. A storm cloud describes what a process produces, and Donald Berwick’s “central law of improvement” says why that is the right target: “every system is perfectly designed to achieve the results it achieves” (1996, p. 619). A complaint becomes a storm cloud when it gets a count and a step: teachers are careless with checking says nothing a team can verify, while the guidebook’s “10/30 students’ papers had items that were erroneously checked” can be counted again next term. “Note that more than one storm cloud may be observed in an activity”, the guidebook adds.
Two of the six are of a different kind. The first four describe how the test was run. The last two describe what learners know: few answered items 8 to 10, and many made mistakes in basic arithmetic. A cloud of that kind may have been made by the test, or long before it.
Seen here, made there: tracing a cloud to its source
The guidebook places each storm cloud with care: “This is a storm cloud which you will write on the activity where you discovered it – in this case, during the recording of the test scores” (Activity 3.4). That is where the team saw it, and it should stay there on the map. But the papers were checked wrong at the checking, one step earlier, and the guidebook’s own sample project goes there. Its sample objective is “To reduce the incidence of erroneously checked Mathematical Periodical Test papers of Grade 7 students by 100%”, and its sample activity is to “meet with teachers to discuss the new process of checking Periodical Test papers” (Step 6).
DO 44, s. 2015 · the guidebook’s sample process
Seen here, made there
The guidebook writes each storm cloud on the step where it was discovered. Switch the view to see where each one was made in an invented school, and press a cloud to follow its trace.
“Two answer sheets were missing”
- Seen at
- Distributing the test papers
- Made
- Preparing the test, 1 step earlier
- The team asked
- How many answer sheets were made, and from which list?
- It found
- The teacher ran 28 answer sheets from the class list of June. Two learners who transferred in during July were not on it.
- The fix goes
- Count the copies from the current class list on the day the test is reproduced.
“Eight students were talking to their seatmates”
- Seen at
- Answering the test (test proper)
- Made
- Answering the test (test proper), on the same step
- The team asked
- Where were the eight seated, and when did the talking start?
- It found
- All eight sat at the two-seat desks by the window, and the talking began in the first ten minutes. Nothing before the test explains it.
- The fix goes
- Made where it was seen: change the seating on test day.
“It took an extra 5 minutes for students to submit their papers”
- Seen at
- Retrieving the test papers
- Made
- Preparing the test, 3 steps earlier
- The team asked
- Were learners still answering when time was called?
- It found
- Most were. The test had 60 items for a 60-minute period, so the last items were still being answered when papers were collected.
- The fix goes
- Set the number of items to the time the period allows when the test is prepared.
“10/30 students’ papers had items that were erroneously checked”
- Seen at
- Recording the test scores
- Made
- Checking the test papers, 1 step earlier
- The team asked
- Who checked the papers, where, and was any paper checked twice?
- It found
- The teacher checked 150 papers from five sections at home over two nights, against a key copied by hand. No paper was checked a second time.
- The fix goes
- Change the checking: the guidebook's own sample project is a meeting on “the new process of checking Periodical Test papers” (Step 6).
“Only 2/30 students correctly answered the difficult items (items 8 to 10)”
- Seen at
- Analyzing performance on items
- Made
- Preparing the test, 6 steps earlier
- The team asked
- Which lesson do items 8 to 10 test, and had the class taken it?
- It found
- The three items test a lesson the class reached two days after the test, because the lesson before it ran long.
- The fix goes
- Build the table of specifications from the lessons actually covered, as DO 015, s. 2026 now requires.
This cloud reads as what learners know, but its trace leads back to a step of the test.
“Only 8/30 students did not make mistakes in basic arithmetic”
- Seen at
- Identifying least mastered skills
- Made
- Outside the test process, before the test began
- The team asked
- Do the same mistakes show in the class's earlier work?
- It found
- They do, in written work from the first week of Grade 7. The test showed the gap; no step of the test made it.
- The fix goes
- Map another process: how the school finds and helps learners who start Grade 7 behind in arithmetic.
This cloud is a result of what learners know, not a fault in how the test was run.
| Step | Seen | Made |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Preparing the test | 0 | 3 |
| 2. Distributing the test papers | 1 | 0 |
| 3. Answering the test (test proper) | 1 | 1 |
| 4. Retrieving the test papers | 1 | 0 |
| 5. Checking the test papers | 0 | 1 |
| 6. Recording the test scores | 1 | 0 |
| 7. Analyzing performance on items | 1 | 0 |
| 8. Identifying least mastered skills | 1 | 0 |
| Outside the process | 0 | 1 |
The eight steps and the six clouds are the guidebook’s, word for word (DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Activity 3.4). The guidebook prints where each cloud was seen. Who does each step, and where each cloud was made, are worked out for an invented school.
Shigeo Shingo, an industrial engineer who worked with Toyota, named the difference. A “judgment inspection”, which sorts finished work into good and bad, “remains inherently a kind of postmortem inspection, however, for no matter how accurately and thoroughly it is performed, it can in no way contribute to lowering the defect rate in the plant itself” (Zero Quality Control, 1986, p. 57). His alternative was the “source inspection”: “discovering errors in conditions that give rise to defects and performing feedback and action at the error stage so as to keep those errors from turning into defects” (p. 82). When the cause lies earlier in the process, the task is “to try to control upstream processes in cases where they contain the causes of defects” (p. 85).
Deming made the same point in the third of his fourteen points for management: “Cease dependence on inspection to achieve quality. Eliminate the need for inspection on a mass basis by building quality into the product in the first place” (Out of the Crisis, 1986, p. 23). The step where an error is found works as an inspection, as the recording of scores did in the guidebook’s example. It shows where to start the trace, not where to stop.
To trace a storm cloud:
- Start at the step where it was seen, and ask what that step received from the one before it. A recorder who receives wrongly checked papers records them faithfully.
- Check each step’s output as it left that step, from records where they exist (the papers, the class list, the answer key, School Form 2) and from interviews where they do not.
- Stop at the first step whose output was already wrong when it left. That step made the cloud.
- Leave the map if no step made it. A cloud about what learners already knew when they arrived points to another process, such as how the school helps learners who start the year behind. That process gets its own map.
- Write the source beside the cloud, and keep the cloud where it was seen. Both go to the root cause analysis.
In the figure, the six clouds were seen at six different steps. Traced in the invented school, three lead back to the first step, preparing the test, which shows no cloud on the guidebook’s map at all.
Why the source matters
A defect made at one step and found at a later one has passed through every step between them, and each of those steps did its work on it. The later it is found, the more work there is to redo.
DO 015, s. 2026 · an invented school
The later it is found, the more it costs
A Grade 7 Mathematics teacher gives the Term Examination (50 items) to 4 sections, 160 learners. The answer key gives the wrong letter for item 14. Choose the step where someone catches it.
Work left to redo
232pieces of work, against one line of the key where it was made
- 160 papers to check again for item 14
- 72 scores to correct in the class record
- 4 item analyses to redo, one per section
- 72 term grades to compute again
- 72 report cards to correct and give out again
Nothing to redo: the key is corrected before any paper is checked.
No family has been given a wrong grade yet.
The steps and who does them follow DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026 (assessment and grading) and DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026 (the school calendar). The school, its sections, the wrong key and the counts are invented: 72 of the 160 learners chose the right answer to item 14 and lost a point for it.
Shingo’s terms fit the checks a school already has. A school head who compares a sample of papers with the class record runs what he called an “informative inspection”, one “in which, when a defect occurs, information to that effect is fed back to the work process involved, which then takes action to correct the method of operation” (Zero Quality Control, 1986, pp. 58-59). It finds the error late, but it tells the checking step to change. A co-teacher who answers the test before it is copied runs a source inspection on the key itself.
The steps in the figure follow the new grading order and the three-term calendar. Examinations “shall be teacher-made, competency-aligned, and based on the lessons actually covered”, with 50 items for the term examination in Grades 7 to 10, “guided by the teacher’s Table of Specifications (TOS)” (DO 015, s. 2026, paras 26 and 27, Table 4). “Teachers shall maintain complete and accurate class records to support all grading decisions. These records shall be subject to validation by school heads and instructional supervisors” (para 54). Teachers keep “assessment tools, rubrics, raw scores, and feedback records, for at least one (1) SY”, and “School Heads shall conduct regular validation of grading practices to ensure accuracy, consistency, and integrity” (para 61).
The guidebook’s test process today
The guidebook’s example process is the “Mathematics Periodical Test Process”. From SY 2026-2027 that test is gone. DO 8, s. 2015 already called it the quarterly assessment, and DO 015, s. 2026 “repeals DepEd Order (DO) No. 8, s. 2015” (para 6 of the Order). Under the three-term calendar, “two teacher-developed summative assessments shall be administered prior to the Term Examination” (DO 009, s. 2026, para 27), and the Term Examination is “the summative assessment administered during the last week of the Instructional Block in each term” (III.f). DO 015’s Table 3 recommends “2 STs and 1 TE (per learning area, per term)” for Grades 4 to 12, and its Table 4 makes the term examination required from Grade 4, optional in Grades 1 to 3 and absent in Kindergarten. Some senior high school subjects have no summative tests or no examinations (para 46). Grade 12 classes not yet on the strengthened senior high school curriculum keep the DO 8, s. 2015 weights for SY 2026-2027 (para 49).
A team that walks a test process now maps the summative tests or the term examination. The steps are much the same as the guidebook’s, and the new order adds rules at several of them: tests based on the lessons actually covered, term examinations that are “AI-prohibited” (para 35), accommodations for learners with disabilities (para 30), and class records validated by the school head (paras 54 and 61). The guide to DO 015, s. 2026 covers the grading rules, and the guide to writing summative tests covers the tests themselves.
Choosing the area of focus
A walk usually ends with more storm clouds than a team can work on. Activity 3.5 has it choose one: “You have to select a specific storm cloud, called an area of focus, from among your storm clouds so you can aim your improvement efforts on a particular problem rather than attempting to solve all the problems at once.” The guidebook gives one test for the choice, printed in bold: “In selecting your area of focus, choose the one which, when addressed, will clearly affect the PIA.”
The chosen cloud becomes a focused problem statement that answers four questions: “What is the magnitude of the problem? How often is it happening? Where is it happening? When does it happen?” The guidebook’s example: “During the first quarter, ten out of thirty Mathematics Periodical Test papers of Grade 7 students had items that were erroneously checked.” The statement goes to root cause analysis, Activity 3.6.
The trace helps the choice. A cloud whose source is a step the school controls, such as the checking or the preparing of a test, leads to a project the team can test in one section. A cloud that leads outside the process is often a priority improvement area of its own. Clouds the team does not choose stay on the map: “For PIAs that span for more than a year, you can review the storm clouds you have identified and look at what other areas were not addressed. This can be your area of focus for the next years” (Activity 3.5).
Processes DepEd has already mapped
Some school processes have a map already. The DepEd Citizen’s Charter (2026, 2nd Edition) lists each school service in a table of “CLIENT STEPS”, “AGENCY ACTION”, “FEES TO BE PAID”, “PROCESSING TIME” and “PERSON RESPONSIBLE”. Walk-in enrollment, the guidebook’s other example process, totals 40 minutes for a regular enrollment, from checking the Basic Education Enrollment Form to telling the client the enrollment status. For a front-office service, the Charter is the map of what the process should be, with a time and a person at each step; a team walking that service compares the real process against it.
The Charter rests on Republic Act No. 11032, the Ease of Doing Business Act, which requires every government office to “regularly undertake cost compliance analysis, time and motion studies, undergo evaluation and improvement of their transaction systems and procedures and reengineer the same if deemed necessary” (Sec. 5). DepEd’s quality management system adds that “Each governance level shall document all office processes in accordance with their office functions” (DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2021, IX.B.2), and that “All Schools shall have their own set of Operations Manual”, with flowcharts among its parts. In that order the person responsible for a process is its “Process Holder”; the SIP Guidebook says process owner.
The revised School-Based Management system (DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2024) takes DO 44’s definition of continuous improvement, “a methodology to continually assess, analyze, and act on the performance improvement of key processes and service delivery”, and asks every school to “cultivate a culture of continuous improvement.” One of its indicators is the test process itself: “The school conducts test item analysis to inform its teaching and learning process” (Annex A). The guide to SBM covers the rest.
What school teams have found
In one division’s study, principals rate the walk among the weaker parts of the SIP. Of 73 elementary school principals in the Muslim areas of Lanao del Norte, the item “The SPT analyzed the school processes to understand further why and where the needs and problems exist” was rated 3.21 of 4, “Moderately Implemented”, one of three Assess practices below “Fully Implemented”. Testing each solution on a small population first was the lowest of the Act phase, at 2.99 (Abalorio, 2021, Tables 4 and 6).
An improvement science project with school leaders in Kenya, Chile and the Philippines, 19 of them in Lanao del Sur, found the same difficulty from the inside. “In the early stages of the project, all teams struggled with the IS toolkit. At a practical level, early attempts to use fishbone and root cause analysis tended to identify the high-level systemic issues only, e.g., scarce resources, no supporting technology etc., rather than local process issues.” Many of the problems the teams chose “were separate, qualitative issues such as the lack of access to books, lack of time set aside for reading etc., rather than process issues. Hence it was more difficult to apply some analytical tools such as process mapping” (Wolfenden and others, 2023, p. 40). The lesson for a school team is to choose a problem that is made by a process, such as attendance follow-up or test checking, before reaching for the flowchart.
Studies that walked a school process step by step are few. Researchers who mapped the records offices of two public secondary schools in Pará, Brazil, by direct observation, found that in the first school, in many observations, the staff spent more than twenty minutes finding a requester’s folder, although the same records were in the state’s integrated system, which the second school used (Negrão and Barbosa, 2020, pp. 11, 15 and 18). In the first school, none of these requests was recorded in any way (p. 11).
Common mistakes
- Mapping the process as it should be. The guidebook calls combining the present state with the desired outcome “The common mistake”. Draw what happens, including the steps no memo describes.
- Stopping at the brainstorm. “Brainstorming and interviews alone are not enough to map out a process” (Activity 3.4). The first map is the team’s opinion until someone has watched the process.
- Writing a complaint as a storm cloud. Teachers are careless cannot be counted. “10/30 students’ papers had items that were erroneously checked” can.
- Naming a person. A storm cloud describes a step. The guidebook’s clouds count papers, learners and minutes, never teachers.
- Fixing the step where the cloud was seen. Write the cloud where it was seen, then trace it. A better recording form does not fix a checking error.
- Treating a learning result as a process defect. “Only 8/30 students did not make mistakes in basic arithmetic” may describe what learners brought to the test rather than anything the test did. Trace it before choosing a fix.
- Mapping alone. The process owners know the steps, and they will roll out the change in Step 10. Walk the process with them.
What this means for school heads
- Give each project team time to watch the process. The guidebook makes direct observation “a must”; a team that maps from a meeting room maps its opinion.
- Bring the process owners in from the start. The advisers who check attendance or the teachers who give the test walk the process with the team.
- Ask for numbers on every storm cloud, and for the step where each was seen.
- Ask where each cloud was made before the team chooses its area of focus. The answer decides which step the project changes.
- Keep the map. Activity 3.4 says the team can “keep doing this activity to review the process that you have improved” in later years. The old map shows whether the change held.
Records to keep: the three maps, the interview and observation notes with their dates, the storm clouds with their counts, the trace of each cloud, and the focused problem statement.
Walking the process is part of school planning, Strand 1.2 of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads (PPSSH, DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020): indicator 1.2.2 asks a school head to “Develop and implement with the planning team school plans aligned with institutional goals and policies.” The guide to PPSSH Domain 1 explains the strand.
Frequently asked questions
What is a storm cloud in the SIP?
A storm cloud is a problem the project team observes at a step of a school process while walking it. The SIP Guidebook says storm clouds “are specific, measurable, and observable” and help “locate where the issues reside” (DO 44, s. 2015, Activity 3.4). One storm cloud becomes the area of focus.
How do you walk the process in the SIP?
In three steps from Annex 7 of the SIP Guidebook: brainstorm the steps with the people who do the work, interview them to find missing steps and decisions, and observe the process directly. Draw the flowchart as the process happens now, and write a storm cloud at each step where a problem is seen.
What are the three process maps?
What you think the process is, what the process really is, and what the process should be. Annex 7 of the SIP Guidebook says to draw each one separately; at Activity 3.4 the team has the first and turns it into the second through interviews and observation.
Where do you write a storm cloud on the flowchart?
On the step where it was discovered, as the guidebook’s example does: a checking error found while recording scores is written at the recording (Activity 3.4). Then trace it to the step that made it, which is where the root cause analysis and the solution go.
Is the Mathematics periodical test still the example to use?
The steps still work as an example, but from SY 2026-2027 the periodical test is gone: DO 015, s. 2026 repealed DO 8, s. 2015 (para 6 of the Order). In Grades 4 to 12, each term now has two summative tests and a term examination (DO 009, s. 2026, para 27; DO 015, s. 2026, Tables 3 and 4).
Sources
DepEd issuances and law
- DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, Guidelines on the Enhanced School Improvement Planning (SIP) Process and the School Report Card (SRC), September 29, 2015: SIP Guidebook, Definition of Terms, Activities 3.4, 3.5 and 3.7, Steps 6, 9 and 10, Annex 7
- DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026, Revised Guidelines on Classroom Assessment, Grading System, and Awards and Recognition for the K to 12 Basic Education Program, June 4, 2026: para 6 of the Order; Guidelines paras 24, 26, 27, 30, 35, 45, 46, 49, 54, 59, 61 and 70, Tables 3 and 4
- DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026, Guidelines on the Implementation of the Three-Term School Calendar in Basic Education, April 16, 2026: III.f and paras 27 and 28
- DepEd Order No. 4, s. 2014, Adoption of the Modified School Forms (SFs) for Public Elementary and Secondary Schools Effective End of School Year 2013-2014, January 30, 2014: School Form 2, data element 18
- DepEd Order No. 005, s. 2024, Rationalization of Teachers’ Workload in Public Schools and Payment of Teaching Overload, April 29, 2024: Enclosure A.3
- DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2024, Policy Guidelines on the Implementation of the Revised School-Based Management (SBM) System, May 16, 2024: III.3, IV and Annex A
- DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2015, Policy Guidelines on Classroom Assessment for the K to 12 Basic Education Program, April 1, 2015
- DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads, September 7, 2020: indicator 1.2.2
- DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2021, Institutionalization of a Quality Management System in the Department of Education, February 24, 2021: III and IX
- DepEd Memorandum No. 050, s. 2026, Implementing Guidelines on the Release, Utilization, Monitoring, and Reporting of the Program Support Fund for Flexible Learning Programs under the FLO-ADM Fund Source, August 25, 2026: Definition of Terms
- DepEd Citizen’s Charter 2026, 2nd Edition: Schools, service 7, Enrollment – Walk-in
- Republic Act No. 11032, Ease of Doing Business and Efficient Government Service Delivery Act of 2018, May 28, 2018: Sec. 5
DepEd’s SIP Design Template (2018), Chapter 2, is a template, not an issuance.
Process mapping and quality
- Shingo, S. (1986). Zero Quality Control: Source Inspection and the Poka-yoke System (A. P. Dillon, Trans.). Productivity Press: pp. 57, 58-59, 82 and 85
- Deming, W. E. (1986). Out of the Crisis. MIT Center for Advanced Engineering Study: pp. 23 and 315
- Imai, M. (2012). Gemba Kaizen: A Commonsense Approach to a Continuous Improvement Strategy (2nd ed.). McGraw-Hill: p. 24
- Toyota Motor Corporation (2006). “Ask ‘why’ five times about every matter”. Toyota Traditions, March 2006
- Gilbreth, F. B., and Gilbreth, L. M. (1921). Process Charts: First Steps in Finding the One Best Way to Do Work. American Society of Mechanical Engineers: pp. 3 and 4
- American National Standards Institute (1970). Flowchart Symbols and Their Usage in Information Processing, ANSI X3.5-1970, adopted as FIPS PUB 24, 1973: sections 3.2.2 to 3.4.2 and 4.4.1
- Scholtes, P. R. (1988). The Team Handbook. Joiner Associates: chapter 2
- Rummler, G. A., and Brache, A. P. (1990). Improving Performance: How to Manage the White Space on the Organization Chart. Jossey-Bass: p. 9
- Bogan, C. E., and English, M. J. (1994). Benchmarking for Best Practices. McGraw-Hill: pp. 214-215
- Institute for Healthcare Improvement (2017). QI Essentials Toolkit: Flowchart
- Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching (2024). Six Core Principles of Improvement
- City, E. A., Elmore, R. F., Fiarman, S. E., and Teitel, L. (2009). Instructional Rounds in Education: A Network Approach to Improving Teaching and Learning. Harvard Education Press: p. 4 and chapter 4
- Greenberg, C. C., and others (2007). Patterns of communication breakdowns resulting in injury to surgical patients. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 204(4), 533-540
- Berwick, D. M. (1996). A primer on leading the improvement of systems. BMJ, 312, 619-622: p. 619
Studies of schools
- Abalorio, B. E. (2021). Practices and Challenges of School Improvement Plan (SIP) Implementation amidst the Pandemic: A Case in Lanao del Norte Division. Basic Education Research Fund study: Tables 4 and 6
- Negrão, L. L. L., and Barbosa, T. S. (2020). O uso do mapeamento do fluxo de valor (MFV) na gestão organizacional de escolas públicas: um estudo multicaso (The use of value stream mapping in the organizational management of public schools: a multicase study). Journal of Lean Systems, 5(3), 1-20: pp. 11, 15 and 18
- Wolfenden, F., Walley, P., Agbaire, J., and Hartley, J. (2023). Strengthening School Leadership Towards Improving School Resiliency: An Improvement Science Approach, final technical report. FIT-ED: p. 40
Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: DepEd Orders No. 44, s. 2015, 015 and 009, s. 2026, 8, s. 2015, 4, s. 2014, 005 and 007, s. 2024, 009, s. 2021, and 024, s. 2020; DepEd Memorandum No. 050, s. 2026; the DepEd Citizen’s Charter 2026; Republic Act No. 11032; Shingo (1986); Deming (1986); Imai (2012); Gilbreth and Gilbreth (1921); ANSI X3.5-1970; Rummler and Brache (1990); Bogan and English (1994); City and others (2009); Greenberg and others (2007); Berwick (1996); Abalorio (2021); Wolfenden and others (2023); Negrão and Barbosa (2020); IHI (2017).