Classroom observation notes are the observer’s written record of a lesson, and in DepEd’s Performance Management and Evaluation System (PMES) for teachers they are the whole basis of a classroom observation rating. DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025 states: “The rating for the teacher’s performance shall be solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form” (item 55). That form, Annex E-4 of the memorandum, is a header and a blank space, with these directions: “Write your observations on the teacher’s classroom performance on the space provided. Use additional sheets whenever necessary.”
The STAR observation technique gives the page a structure. It is Form 4 of the BESRA handbook Instructional Supervision: Standards, Procedures and Tools, and it divides the record into four rows: the Situation, the teacher’s Task, the learners’ Action, and the Result, written in numbers and in words. Kept that way, one set of notes serves the rating, the post-observation conference and the Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form (PMCF). The rules below are those in force on November 18, 2026.
Key findings
- The notes are the rating’s only evidence. The rating rests “solely” on what the Observation Notes Form records (DM 089, s. 2025, item 55). With two or more observers, the final rating “shall not be an average of the individual ratings” but a consensus “based on actual observed practice during the classroom observation, as documented in the COT - Observation Notes Form” (item 56).
- DepEd’s notes form prescribes no layout. Its only directions are to write observations “on the space provided” and to “Use additional sheets whenever necessary” (DM 089, Annex E-4). The STAR rows of the BESRA handbook (Form 4) fit on it. The handbook carries no DepEd order number, so STAR is a method, not a required format.
- The rubric reads what was said and done. For indicator 1.5.2 (higher-order thinking), a feature of Level 2 is “The teacher asks simple yes/no questions”; one of Level 4 is “The teacher asks, “Can you please explain this idea?”” (COT rubric, p. 18). Only a note that keeps the question’s words lets the rater tell them apart.
- A scheduled indicator with nothing recorded can be rated as not observed. The SY 2025-2026 rating sheets say “NO stands for Not Observed which automatically gets a rating of 2” for Teachers I to III, and 3 for Teachers IV to VII, the lowest level of each range (DM 089, Annex E-2). As of November 18, 2026, DepEd had not issued the rating sheets for SY 2026-2027.
- SY 2026-2027 has its own indicators. The first full-period observation covers 1.1.2, 1.4.2, 1.5.2, 1.6.2, 2.1.2 and 2.2.2; the second covers 1.1.2, 1.4.2, 1.5.2, 3.2.2, 3.5.2 and 5.3.2 (DM 089, Table 7).
- Walkthroughs need notes too, but are never rated. They last “approximately 10-15 minutes”, are a “non-rated, formative, and developmental approach”, end in a brief debriefing, and are recorded in the PMCF (DM 089, item 37; DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026, item 33).
- One rater watching one lesson is a weak measure. In the Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) project, “a single observation by a single rater generated very low reliability: 0.37 or less” (Kane and Staiger, 2012, p. 37). Notes a second person can check are the part of the rating an observer controls.
What classroom observation notes are for
The notes from a rated observation do three jobs: they are the evidence for the rating, the material for the post-observation conference, and the source of the entry in the coaching record. DM 089 ties each job to the notes.
The rating. During a full-period observation, the observer must “Use the Observation Notes Form to record comments and observations on the teacher’s performance” (item 53.a), and the rating that follows rests “solely” on what the form records (item 55). The Classroom Observation Tool (COT) describes the form the same way: “Observers use this form to record their specific observations and comments during classroom observation” (COT rubric, p. 7). When observers disagree, they settle the rating against “actual observed practice during the classroom observation, as documented in the COT - Observation Notes Form, and evaluated against the criteria specified in the COT – Rubric” (item 56). A rating that the notes cannot show is a rating the observers cannot defend to each other.
The conference. The observer meets the teacher “immediately after the observation or within three (3) days thereafter”, and the conference allows “the ratee to reflect on his or her strengths and areas for improvement” (item 57) in a manner that “fosters constructive feedback” (item 58). The notes are what the two of them look at.
The coaching record. “Significant incidents observed and feedback provided to Ratees shall be recorded by the Rater using the Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form” (item 39). Each walkthrough goes there too (item 37.e). The rater, the teacher and the approving authority all sign the PMCF (Annex D), so a vague note becomes a vague record that three people have signed.
The protocol during the lesson protects the notes. Observers sit apart, do not talk with one another, and “Avoid giving any feedback on the teacher’s performance, which may include using any facial expression or any other form of non-verbal communication” (item 53.b to 53.d). For SY 2025-2026, the interim guidance went further. Indicators not rated in the year’s single observation could be rated, if the teacher preferred, from “observed practice explicitly documented in the observation notes form”, and “Observers as raters shall ensure that their observation notes forms are complete and available for reference in rating” (DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Sec. A). It also said that “Teachers shall not be required to submit or attach the observation notes form of the observers”: keeping them complete is the observer’s job.
What the STAR observation technique is
The STAR observation technique is a note-taking form with four rows. It is Instructional Supervision Form 4 of the BESRA handbook, written by the Teacher Education and Development Technical Working Group of the Basic Education Sector Reform Agenda (BESRA), which school head training materials cite as the BESRA Instructional Supervision Handbook (2010). The form introduces itself: “This is a supervisory tool which is useful to collect information from the actual teaching – learning activity in the classroom.” Its columns are “What to observe” and “Observation ( Record in detail if possible)”.
| Row | What the handbook asks the observer to record | A line from a Grade 6 Science lesson |
|---|---|---|
| Situation | The context and the teaching episode: the learning environment, the motivation, the presentation of the lesson, the evaluation | 9:02. 38 learners in 6 groups. On the board: “Separate a mixture by filtering and evaporation.” |
| Task | What the teacher does in that situation | 9:06. T: “Will the salt stay on the filter paper? Yes or no?” |
| Action | What the learners do in response to the teacher’s task | 9:12. 5 of 6 groups predicted “The salt stays on the paper”; Group 2 wrote “Salt dissolves, so it goes through with the water.” |
| Result | The outcome of the task and the action, in numbers and in words | 9:45. Exit slip: 23 of 38 wrote “evaporate” or “heat it”; 9 wrote “filter it again”; 6 left it blank. |
The handbook’s examples for the Result row are “85% of the learners were able to identify nouns” for numbers and “most of the learners participated in the class” for words. A line in words carries more when it says what learners did: “five of six groups gave a reason for their prediction” tells the teacher more than “most participated”. The form ends with “General comments of teacher support” and lines for the signatures of the observer and the teacher.
The handbook is a reference, not a rule. It carries no DepEd order or memorandum number, and its forms were replaced by the PMES tools of DM 089, s. 2025; the guide to the BESRA handbook sets out what replaced each part. Since the current notes form prescribes no layout, an observer may write STAR rows on it.
Two different STARs in DepEd
The STAR in an observation note is not the STAR of a hiring interview. DepEd’s Behavioral Events Interview (BEI) “uses the STAR approach”, which “draws focus on actual Situations in which the applicant acted; the Task/s that the applicant faced; the Actions that the applicant took; and the Results of those actions” (DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2023, Encl. No. 3, item 8.b). There all four letters describe one person. In the observation form the Task is the teacher’s and the Action is the learners’. An observer who reads STAR the interview’s way writes four rows about the teacher and none about the class. The guide to school leadership readiness evidence covers the interview STAR.
A STAR template for the COT Observation Notes Form
The layout below joins the header of DepEd’s Observation Notes Form (DM 089, Annex E-4) to the four STAR rows. It is not a DepEd form. DepEd’s form allows additional sheets, so the rows can be ruled on the form itself or on a sheet attached to it.
Header (from Annex E-4, plus one line from the pre-observation conference)
| Field | What to write |
|---|---|
| Observer | Your name and position |
| Teacher observed | The teacher’s name and position |
| Subject and grade level taught | For example, Grade 6 Science |
| Date; time started; time ended | The whole period: DM 089 requires that rated observations “be done for the entire class period” (item 52) |
| Observation | 1st or 2nd |
| Indicators scheduled | The indicators Table 7 schedules for this observation, reviewed at the pre-observation conference (items 49 and 55), for example 1.1.2, 1.4.2, 1.5.2, 1.6.2, 2.1.2, 2.2.2 |
The rows
| Row | Time | What to write | Indicator served |
|---|---|---|---|
| S, Situation | At the start, and when the lesson changes phase | Class size and grouping, the objective as written, the materials on the desks | None, or the indicator the setting bears on |
| T, Task | At each move the teacher makes | The teacher’s words, quoted: the question, the instruction, the feedback | The code of each scheduled indicator the line serves |
| A, Action | Right after each Task line | What the learners did, counted: who answered, where they sat, how many got it right | The same |
| R, Result | At the end of an episode and of the lesson | What learners could do, in numbers and in words | The same |
| For the conference | After the lesson | Two or three lines to open with, a strength among them | |
| Signature | At the end | The observer’s signature over printed name (from Annex E-4) |
The “Indicator served” column is a margin, not a score. It lets you see before you rate which scheduled indicators have lines behind them. The COT rubric says that “The indicators in the rubric are rated independently” (p. 9), so one line may serve two indicators, but each indicator needs its own evidence.
Write learners by group, row or seat (G2, row 5, the back table) instead of by name. The rating needs the pattern, and the notes travel to the conference and may be kept with the rating sheet.
How to write evidence, not judgments
A line is evidence when another observer could check it against the lesson: a quotation, an action, a count, a time. A line is a judgment when it records the observer’s verdict, such as “good questions”, “conducive to learning” or “very participative”. The rubric can read the first kind and not the second.
The COT rubric is built from observable acts. Each indicator has “Level Descriptions” and “Features of Practice”, which the rubric defines as “illustrations of specific classroom practices at each particular level” (COT rubric, p. 10). For 1.5.2, the features run from “The teacher asks simple yes/no questions” at Level 2, through “The teacher accepts all contributions without processing the learners’ answers” at Level 3, to “The teacher ensures that all voices of learners are heard in the discussion” at Level 6 (p. 18). An observer who writes “asked good questions” has thrown away the one thing that separates those levels.
Seven habits keep a line on the evidence side:
- Put a time on every line. Times show how much of the period a strategy filled, which the frequency words in some levels (“occasionally”, “frequently”, “consistently” for 1.4.2) depend on.
- Quote the teacher’s questions and the learners’ answers. Word for word, at least for the questions that matter to a scheduled indicator.
- Give the Action row as much ink as the Task row. STAR’s second half is about learners. A note with only teacher lines cannot show what the teaching did.
- Count. Learners who spoke, where they sat, slates that were right, groups that gave a reason.
- Write the Result in numbers and in words. “23 of 38” and what the 23 wrote.
- Use short marks. T for the teacher, L for a learner, G2 for Group 2. Expand them before the conference.
- Leave verdicts for the rating sheet. “Very good”, “excellent” and “conducive” have no place in the record of what happened; a comment, which item 53.a allows, goes apart from it and marked as yours.
The figure below sets two lines side by side for six moments of one lesson. Choose the one you would write.
STAR observation notes
Write it so the rubric can read it
Grade 6 Science, a full-period observation: separating a mixture of salt, sand and water by filtering and evaporation. For each moment, choose the line you would write on the notes form. The line you choose shows what it gives the rater and the post-observation conference.
Indicator 1.5.2Apply a range of teaching strategies to develop critical and creative thinking, as well as other higher-order thinking skills.
Indicator 1.5.2: the level words, Levels 2 to 7
- Level 2
The teacher asks mostly low-order questions that require simple factual responses and/ or provides activities that are routine.
- Feature 1. The teacher asks simple yes/no questions.
- Level 3
The teacher provides straightforward questions and activities which lead learners through a single path of inquiry.
- Feature 1. The teacher asks questions that require rote-type responses such as Who, What, Where, and When.
- Feature 2. The teacher accepts all contributions without processing the learners’ answers.
- Level 4
The teacher uses questions and activities that mostly require the learners to interpret, explain, or describe ideas learned.
- Feature 1. The teacher makes some attempt to engage learners in genuine discussion rather than simple, factual, or rote-type discussion.
- Feature 2. The teacher asks, “Can you please explain this idea?”
- Level 5
The teacher employs a range of targeted follow-up questions and activities that encourage learners to explain, demonstrate, and use ideas learned.
- Feature 1. The teacher employs a range of strategies to ensure that most learners are given opportunities to give opinions about the lesson and to react to the opinions of others.
- Feature 2. The teacher creates a genuine discussion among learners, providing adequate time for them to respond, as well as to step aside when appropriate.
- Level 6
The teacher challenges learners to justify their thinking and successfully engages most learners in discussion using well-directed questions and activities.
- Feature 1. The teacher challenges learners cognitively to advance high-level thinking and discourse in an interactive exchange of views.
- Feature 2. The teacher ensures that all voices of learners are heard in the discussion.
- Level 7
The teacher provides a broad range of questions and activities, including those of higher-order, that challenge learners to analyze their thinking to promote deeper understanding.
- Feature 1. The teacher gives learners opportunities to compare and contrast ideas.
- Feature 2. The teacher gives learners opportunities to synthesize or summarize information within or across disciplines.
COT rubric, Indicator 4, p. 18, as DM 089, s. 2025 attaches it (Annex E-1). Teachers I to III are rated on Levels 2 to 6, and Teachers IV to VII on Levels 3 to 7 (DM 089, item 44, Table 10).
The rule “The rating for the teacher’s performance shall be solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form.” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 55)
Evidence does not only catch weaknesses. In the figure, the line at 9:20 records a strong move, a teacher setting one group’s answer against another’s, and the rubric’s words for Levels 5 and 6 can be held against it. Written as “asked good follow-up questions”, that strength cannot be credited, because no level of the rubric describes “good”. The guide to instructional supervision has more pairs of judgment and evidence lines, with a sample debriefing.
Notes for the indicators scheduled for the observation
Before a rated observation, the teacher and the observer hold a pre-observation conference “to review the Classroom Observation Tool (COT) Rubric appropriate to the career stage of the ratee to be observed” and to “refer to the list of classroom observable indicators to be observed in the particular classroom observation period” (DM 089, item 49). Only those indicators are rated (item 55). Writing their codes at the top of the notes tells you what to watch for. For SY 2026-2027, DM 089’s Table 7 schedules these, in the wording of the Philippine Professional Standards for Teachers (PPST, DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2017):
| Indicator | PPST strand | Observation | Lines worth writing |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.1.2 | Content knowledge and its application within and across curriculum areas | 1st and 2nd | The teacher’s explanations and answers to learners’ questions, quoted, with any error as said |
| 1.4.2 | Strategies for promoting literacy and numeracy | 1st and 2nd | Each reading, writing or computing task, with its time and how many learners did it |
| 1.5.2 | Strategies for developing critical and creative thinking, as well as other higher-order thinking skills | 1st and 2nd | Questions quoted, wait time, and what learners answered |
| 1.6.2 | Mother Tongue, Filipino and English in teaching and learning | 1st | The language of each instruction and explanation, and the language learners answered in |
| 2.1.2 | Learner safety and security | 1st | How materials, movement and routines were handled, as seen |
| 2.2.2 | Fair learning environment | 1st | Whom the teacher called on and how, counted by row or group |
| 3.2.2 | Learners’ linguistic, cultural, socio-economic and religious backgrounds | 2nd | What the teacher drew from learners’ languages and lives, quoted |
| 3.5.2 | Learners from indigenous groups | 2nd | Culturally appropriate strategies used, as seen |
| 5.3.2 | Feedback to improve learning | 2nd | The teacher’s feedback to learners, quoted, and what learners did with it |
Teachers in the Highly Proficient and Distinguished stages are rated on the same strands at their own stage (1.1.3, 1.1.4 and so on, Tables 8 and 9), and the COT forms use the Proficient wording for every position: “The language used in the COT indicators is taken from the Proficient career stage indicators” (COT rubric, p. 2). When more than one observer rates, “only the subject specialist is expected to rate Indicator 1.1.2 / 1.1.3 / 1.1.4”, except for elementary teachers, who “are generalists”, so every observer rates it (item 55).
On the SY 2025-2026 rating sheets, a scheduled indicator marked NO takes the lowest level of the teacher’s range: 2 for Teachers I to III, 3 for Teachers IV to VII (Annex E-2). Whatever the SY 2026-2027 sheets say, an indicator with no line in the notes has nothing for its rating to rest on (item 55). At the end of the period, check the margin.
From notes to the rating, the conference and the coaching form
The rating. The COT rubric has four parts for each indicator: the indicator itself, “Level Descriptions”, “Features of Practice” and “Clarifications”, the last being “the operational definitions of selected words/phrases used in the rubric” (COT rubric, p. 10). The rater holds the lines that serve an indicator against the level words and picks the level they fit, within the teacher’s range: Levels 2 to 6 for Teachers I to III, 3 to 7 for Teachers IV to VII (DM 089, item 44, Table 10). Two observers who wrote evidence can settle a disagreement by reading each other’s lines, as item 56 requires; two observers who wrote verdicts can only trade impressions. The guide to the COT rubric sets the level words of the SY 2026-2027 indicators side by side.
The conference. Open with a line the teacher will recognize, often a Result line, and ask what they make of it. The teacher reflects on “his or her strengths and areas for improvement” (item 57); your lines give that reflection something concrete. The guide to teacher performance feedback sets out how a comment answers three questions: the goal, where things stand, and the next step.
The coaching form. The PMCF’s teaching sheet (Annex D) has six columns: “Date”, “Significant incidents description”, “Impact on job”, “Coaching mechanisms”, “Feedback/ recommendation” and “Progress to date”. The coaching mechanisms it lists are “Meeting (Group), One on One, Learning Action Cell Sessions, Walk-through Observations, Workshop and Others”. The rater signs as “Conducted by”, the teacher as “Concurred by” and the approving authority as “Approved by”. The form’s own example opens its description with the competency it concerns, so naming the indicator first in a row follows the sample.
The figure below traces four sample notes, two from rated observations and two from walkthroughs, to all three uses. Each entry names the lines it rests on.
STAR observation notes
One note, three uses
Four sample notes from four classes. Pick a note, then a use: the rating sheet, the conference, or the coaching form. The lines that use rests on are marked.
Grade 3 English Rated, 1st full-period observation · Thursday, August 13, 2026, 8:00 to 8:50
- S136 learners. Objective on the board: “Retell the fable in your own words.” T read “The Ant and the Grasshopper” aloud from a big book.Used here
- T18:12Each pair got four picture cards of the story, mixed up. T: “Which happened first? Tell your seatmate, then hold up the card.”Used here
- A18:1330 of 36 held up the grasshopper singing in summer; 6 held up the ant carrying food.Used here
- T28:20T modeled a retelling with “First … Next … Then … Finally …” on the board, pointing to each card in turn.Used here
- A28:24 to 8:34Pairs retold the story to each other. T listened to 5 pairs: 2 used all four signal words; 1 pair retold it in Filipino, then in English when T said, “Now in English, with the words on the board.”Used here
- R18:45Exit task, put the cards in order and write one sentence about the story: 31 of 36 ordered all four; 19 wrote a sentence with a signal word.Used here
On the rating sheet: indicator 1.4.2
Use a range of teaching strategies that enhance learner achievement in literacy and numeracy skills.
The rubric words the marked lines are held against
- Level 4 “The teacher occasionally applies teaching strategies that address learners’ literacy and/or numeracy needs.”
- Level 5 “The teacher frequently applies relevant strategies that enhance learners’ literacy and/or numeracy skills.”
- Level 6 “The teacher consistently applies relevant strategies that enhance learners’ literacy and/or numeracy skills.”
These levels differ by how often: occasionally, frequently, consistently. The times on T1, T2 and A2 show how much of the period the literacy strategies filled.
COT rubric, Indicator 3, p. 16. The rating is the rater’s, from what the notes record (DM 089, s. 2025, item 55).
Post-observation conference
- Goal
- The objective on the board: retell the fable in your own words.
- Now
- 31 of 36 put the story in order, and 19 wrote a sentence with a signal word. Of the 5 pairs the teacher heard, 2 used all four signal words.
- Next
- The 17 learners who wrote no signal word.
- Opening question
- “Nineteen learners wrote a sentence with a signal word. What would help the other seventeen use the words on the board?”
A row of the PMCF
- Date
- August 13, 2026
- Significant incidents description
- PPST 1.4.2 (literacy), 1st full-period observation, Grade 3 English: picture cards and a modeled retelling with four signal words. Exit task: 31 of 36 ordered the story; 19 wrote a sentence with a signal word.
- Impact on job
- The picture cards reached nearly every learner on the order of events; a written retelling with signal words reached about half.
- Coaching mechanisms
- One on One (post-observation conference, August 14)
- Feedback/ Recommendation
- Keep the cards. Give the 17 a sentence frame with the four signal words, and listen to different pairs each day.
- Progress to date
- To be checked at a walkthrough on August 27: sentences with signal words.
Grade 4 Mathematics Walkthrough, not rated · Monday, October 19, 2026, 10:05 to 10:17
- S140 learners, each with a slate. Focus agreed with the teacher: checks for understanding. On the board: an L-shaped garden with six labeled sides; find its perimeter.Used here
- T110:07T: “Write the perimeter on your slate. Show me when I say three.”Used here
- A110:0826 of 40 slates: 20 m. 9 slates: 24 m, one side counted twice. 5 slates blank.Used here
- T210:09T: “If you got 24, compare with your seatmate.” Moved to the next figure at 10:10.Used here
- A210:13Second slate check, a T-shaped figure: 25 of 40 correct. On 7 of the wrong slates, one side was counted twice.Used here
- R1Two checks: 26 of 40, then 25 of 40 correct, with the same error both times.Used here
Not on any rating sheet
A walkthrough is a “non-rated, formative, and developmental approach” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37), meant to give feedback “without the pressure associated with formal performance evaluation” (DO 016, s. 2026, item 33).
A walkthrough goes on no rating sheet. Its notes serve the debriefing and the PMCF.
Debriefing
- Goal
- The agreed focus: checks for understanding. “Conduct low-stakes and timely formative checks throughout the lesson to gather feedback and insights that can inform instructional adjustments.” (DO 016, s. 2026, Learning Design Principles, “Checks for Understanding”)
- Now
- Two slate checks: 26, then 25 of 40 correct, and the same error both times, a side counted twice.
- Next
- The minute after a check.
- Opening question
- “Both checks showed the same error, a side counted twice. What could you do in the minute after the first check?”
A row of the PMCF
- Date
- October 19, 2026
- Significant incidents description
- Walkthrough, 12 minutes, Grade 4 Mathematics (perimeter); agreed focus: checks for understanding. Two slate checks: 26 and 25 of 40 correct; the same error both times.
- Impact on job
- The slates showed the error while there was still time in the period to reteach it.
- Coaching mechanisms
- Walk-through Observations; One on One (debriefing the same day)
- Feedback/ Recommendation
- After a check, reteach the error most wrong slates share before the next item: for example, mark each side as it is added.
- Progress to date
- Next walkthrough on October 26, same focus.
Grade 8 Araling Panlipunan Rated, 1st full-period observation · Tuesday, October 6, 2026, 1:00 to 1:50
- S142 learners in 7 rows; lesson in Filipino on early civilizations in Asia. Three discussion questions and a map on the board.Used here
- T11:10 to 1:25T called on learners by name 15 times, 13 times in rows 1 to 3 and 2 times in rows 4 to 7.Used here
- A11:18 to 1:25In rows 5 to 7, 3 learners raised their hands 7 times in all; none was called.Used here
- T21:26T: “Bawat hanay, isang sagot.” (Each row, one answer.) Each row chose its speaker.Used here
- A21:27 to 1:35All 7 rows answered once. The speakers from rows 6 and 7 tied their answers to the map: “Malapit sa ilog kaya may pagkain.” (Near the river, so there was food.)Used here
- R1Calls by row: until 1:26, 13 of 15 went to rows 1 to 3; after, one answer from each of the 7 rows.Used here
On the rating sheet: indicator 2.2.2
Maintain learning environments that promote fairness, respect and care to encourage learning.
The rubric words the marked lines are held against
- Level 3, a feature of practice “The teacher encourages social positive interactions with learners and among learners but occasional inconsistencies like favoritism, or disregard for learners’ differences are evident.”
- Level 4 “The teacher-learner interactions are generally fair, respectful, and caring, and the majority of learners feel accepted and encouraged to learn.”
- Level 5 “The teacher-learner interactions are consistently fair, respectful, and caring, and most learners feel accepted and encouraged to learn.”
The rater weighs both halves of the period: the calls before 1:26 and the row rule after it. The counts, not an impression of the class, decide which words fit.
COT rubric, Indicator 8, p. 28. The rating is the rater’s, from what the notes record (DM 089, s. 2025, item 55).
Post-observation conference
- Goal
- PPST 2.2.2: learning environments “that promote fairness, respect and care to encourage learning.”
- Now
- Until 1:26, 13 of 15 calls went to rows 1 to 3, and raised hands in rows 5 to 7 went unanswered. After the row rule, every row answered, and two learners from the back tied their answers to the map.
- Next
- The row rule, or another fair way of calling, from the start of the discussion.
- Opening question
- “After you asked each row for one answer, two learners from the back rows tied their answers to the map. What made you change how you called on learners?”
A row of the PMCF
- Date
- October 6, 2026
- Significant incidents description
- PPST 2.2.2, 1st full-period observation, Grade 8 Araling Panlipunan: 13 of 15 calls to rows 1 to 3 until 1:26; then one answer from each of the 7 rows, two from the back rows tied to the map.
- Impact on job
- The change at 1:26 brought every row into the discussion.
- Coaching mechanisms
- One on One (post-observation conference, October 7)
- Feedback/ Recommendation
- Use the row rule, or name cards drawn at random, from the start of the discussion. Keep a tally of calls by row for one week.
- Progress to date
- The teacher’s tally to be reviewed at the walkthrough of October 20.
Grade 11 General Mathematics Walkthrough, not rated · Tuesday, November 10, 2026, 2:10 to 2:25
- S140 learners. Focus agreed with the teacher: feedback during seatwork. Seatwork: write a piecewise function for the teacher’s sample fare rule, ₱15 for the first 4 km and ₱2 for each km after.Used here
- T12:10 to 2:20T walked the rows and wrote on 14 of 40 papers: a check mark on 10; a question on 4, such as “What is the fare at exactly 4 km?”Used here
- A12:20Of the 4 learners given a question, 3 had changed x < 4 to x ≤ 4 by 2:20.Used here
- A22:20In two rows the observer checked, 5 of 12 papers had x < 4; none of the 5 had been reached.Used here
- T22:21T to the class: “Many of you wrote x < 4. Who pays ₱15 at exactly 4 km?” Gave 2 minutes to recheck.Used here
- A32:23Hands up for x ≤ 4: 31 of 40.Used here
- R1Written questions led 3 of 4 learners to fix the boundary; by 2:23, after the reminder to the class, 31 of 40 raised hands for x ≤ 4.Used here
Not on any rating sheet
A walkthrough is a “non-rated, formative, and developmental approach” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37), meant to give feedback “without the pressure associated with formal performance evaluation” (DO 016, s. 2026, item 33).
A walkthrough goes on no rating sheet. DM 089, s. 2025 schedules 5.3.2 for the second full-period observation of SY 2026-2027 (Table 7), so these notes help the teacher work on it before then.
Debriefing
- Goal
- The teacher’s chosen focus, PPST 5.3.2: “Use strategies for providing timely, accurate and constructive feedback to improve learner performance.”
- Now
- Written questions reached 4 papers and 3 of those learners fixed the boundary. In two rows, 5 of 12 papers had the error and had not been reached. After the reminder to the class, 31 of 40 raised hands for x ≤ 4.
- Next
- Reaching more papers in the same ten minutes.
- Opening question
- “Your written questions worked on 3 of 4 papers. How could more of the 40 get a question like that before the reminder?”
A row of the PMCF
- Date
- November 10, 2026
- Significant incidents description
- Walkthrough, 15 minutes, Grade 11 General Mathematics (piecewise functions); agreed focus: feedback during seatwork (PPST 5.3.2). Written questions on 4 papers: 3 learners fixed the boundary. Reminder to the class at 2:21: 31 of 40 raised hands for x ≤ 4 by 2:23.
- Impact on job
- Written questions worked where they reached; most papers were not reached before the reminder.
- Coaching mechanisms
- Walk-through Observations; One on One (debriefing on November 11)
- Feedback/ Recommendation
- Scan the room first and tally the common error, give the class one question on it, then write questions on the papers that still show it.
- Progress to date
- Next walkthrough on November 24, same focus.
Grade 3 English, rating sheet: rests on 5 of the note’s 6 lines (T1, A1, T2, A2, R1).
A use that rests on no line is a warning. If a PMCF row says “needs improvement in questioning” and no line in the notes quotes a question, the row records an opinion, and the teacher has nothing to work from at the next visit.
Walkthrough notes
A walkthrough note is a short STAR note: one episode, a handful of lines, on one focus. DM 089 calls walkthroughs “monitoring by walking around strategy”, “approximately 10-15 minutes”, and sets out how they work (item 37):
- they “should occur regularly, with a focus on specific instructional practices or areas of concern” (37.a);
- their goal “is to provide constructive feedback, identify areas for growth, and support professional development” (37.b);
- “a brief debriefing session will be conducted to discuss findings, celebrate successes, and outline actionable steps for improvement” (37.d);
- “Observer-mentors shall maintain a record of each observation in the Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form (PMCF) and the associated feedback to track progress over time” (37.e).
DO 016, s. 2026 asks instructional leaders for “frequent, non-rated, formative walkthrough observations, typically lasting approximately ten (10) to fifteen (15) minutes, or longer when schedules permit, to observe how lesson plans are enacted in practice”, so that feedback comes “without the pressure associated with formal performance evaluation” (item 33). Its Learning Design Principles give walkthroughs a ready list of focuses. “Checks for Understanding”, for example, asks teachers to “Conduct low-stakes and timely formative checks throughout the lesson to gather feedback and insights that can inform instructional adjustments.” A walkthrough on that focus writes down each check, how many learners got it right, and what the teacher did next.
Keep walkthrough notes apart from the rating. DM 089 makes walkthroughs non-rated, and the rated observation’s notes come from the full period alone (items 37, 52 and 55).
What research says about observation notes
The difference between evidence and judgment has a name in research on teaching: low and high inference. Barak Rosenshine described low-inference measures as items that “focus upon specific, denotable, relatively objective behaviors”, while rating items such as “clarity of presentation” or “enthusiasm” “require that an observer infer these constructs from a series of events” (Rosenshine, 1970, pp. 1.2 to 1.3). His example still serves: “the statement that a teacher repeated student answers 7% of the time is much more specific than the statement that a teacher was sometimes helpful towards students” (p. 1.3).
Charlotte Danielson, author of the Framework for Teaching, makes the same demand of evaluators: “It’s important that what they write down actually is evidence—and not opinion, interpretation, or bias.” She names three kinds of evidence: words spoken, actions, and the appearance of the classroom. A note that “the students are engaged” is, in her words, “not, strictly speaking, evidence”. Her reason fits DM 089’s consensus rule: when observers disagree, “it’s essential to know whether the differences stem from a difference in the evidence collected or in how the observer has interpreted that evidence” (Danielson, 2012).
The note-taking methods supervisors learn have the same root. Keith Acheson wrote that “Persuasive data contain no value judgments”, and described selective verbatim, which has the observer “record what is actually said within the confines of a category previously specified by the teacher” (Acheson, 1981, p. 2). That is what a pre-observation conference sets up when it names the indicators to be observed. Madeline Hunter’s “script-taping”, “capturing with pen and pad what happened in an observed segment of teaching so that cause-effect relationships can later be examined”, lets the observer cite a moment at the conference, which “eliminates vague statements such as ‘You gave students enough thinking time’” (Hunter, 1983, p. 43).
Notes do not make one observation a reliable measure. In the MET project, one rater scoring one lesson gave “0.37 or less” on every instrument tested, and on four of the five instruments, reliability near 0.65 came “only by scoring four different lessons, each by a different observer” (Kane and Staiger, 2012, pp. 37 and 8); the authors warn against reading that as a fixed requirement (p. 9). A follow-up study found that school administrators rated their own teachers “.1 points higher than administrators from other schools” on a four-point scale, and that “First impressions matter” (Ho and Kane, 2013, p. 4). None of these studies tested written notes. What notes add is that a rating can be checked: by a second observer, by the teacher at the conference, and by the rater against the rubric.
Feedback built on observation does change teaching. A meta-analysis of 60 causal studies of teacher coaching found “pooled effect sizes of 0.49 standard deviations (SD) on instruction and 0.18 SD on achievement”, much of the evidence coming from literacy coaching for prekindergarten and elementary school teachers in the United States (Kraft, Blazar and Hogan, 2018, p. 547). In a randomized trial in eight districts, schools received three performance measures with feedback, among them feedback sessions four times a year based on a classroom observation rubric. The intervention moved teachers “from the 50th to the 57th percentile” on one of two rubrics, and raised mathematics achievement by “about four weeks of learning” in the first year (Garet et al., 2017, pp. ES-1 and ES-2). The same meta-analysis warns that one person acting as both coach and evaluator can weaken the trust that coaching depends on. In a DepEd school the rater is also the coach (DM 089, item 40), which is one more reason to keep walkthrough notes for coaching and to show the teacher, at the conference, the lines a rating rests on.
Mistakes that weaken observation notes
- The rating written into the notes. “Very good use of questions”, or a rubric phrase such as “conducive learning environment” copied in without what was seen, decides the level before the rater opens the rubric.
- A Task row and an empty Action row. The note shows what the teacher did and not what it did for learners.
- “Most”, “some” and “many”. “Most learners understood” could be 20 or 35 of 38.
- Notes on everything except the scheduled indicators. Pages on the bulletin board, and nothing on 2.2.2 when 2.2.2 is scheduled.
- Feedback during the lesson. DM 089 rules out even “facial expression or any other form of non-verbal communication” (item 53.d). Write the reaction down instead.
- Lines added after the conference. The notes record the lesson. What the teacher says at the conference goes in the PMCF.
What this means for school heads
- List the indicators before the lesson. At the pre-observation conference, review the indicators Table 7 schedules for the observation (DM 089, items 49 and 55) and write them on the notes form. Leave the lesson plan as the teacher wrote it: DM 089 discourages technical assistance on the plan for the rated observation (item 50).
- Write STAR rows for the whole period. Time every line, quote questions and answers, count learners, and close each episode with a Result.
- Check the margin before you rate. An indicator with no line beside it has nothing for its rating to rest on.
- Rate from the lines, against the level words. With other observers, compare lines first, then levels; the final rating is a consensus, not an average (item 56).
- Hold the conference within three days and open with evidence. Let the teacher interpret two or three lines before you interpret them yourself (item 57).
- Record the incident in the PMCF from the notes. Name the indicator, the lines’ facts, the coaching mechanism, the recommendation, and when you will check progress (Annex D; item 39).
- Keep walkthrough notes for coaching. Short STAR notes on one agreed focus, a brief debriefing after each visit, a PMCF entry, and no rating (item 37).
Two PPSSH strands cover this work. Writing evidence a teacher can act on is technical assistance on “teaching standards and pedagogies” (indicator 3.2.2; see PPSSH Domain 3), and rating from it is implementing “the performance management system” (indicator 4.4.2; see PPSSH Domain 4). The guide to the PMES covers the whole cycle, from the Instructional Supervisory Plan to the e-IPCRF.
How the NASH may test this
The National Assessment for School Heads (NASH) scores each item on a 0 to 3 scale against a PPSSH indicator. The items below are original practice items, scored 3 (Relational), 2 (Multistructural), 1 (Unistructural) or 0 (Prestructural). An option that breaks a rule scores 0.
Question 1
Indicator 4.4.1, Performance management. Career Stage 1, Conceptual, Moderate.
Under DepEd’s PMES for teachers, a teacher’s classroom observation rating is based solely on the actual observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form. Which statement best explains what makes an observation note usable as evidence for that rating?
- A. It covers every indicator scheduled for that observation and is signed by the observer, so each indicator, which is rated independently, has a note behind it that the observer stands by.
- B. It records what the teacher and the learners said and did, with counts and times, so each line can be held against the rubric’s descriptions of practice at each level.
- C. It states the observer’s overall judgment of the lesson, such as “very good” or “very participative”, which the rater then converts into the matching level of the rubric.
- D. It is written on the COT Observation Notes Form itself, the form that the PMES guidelines name for recording what the observer saw during the lesson.
Answer and explanation: Question 1
Best answer: B. Points: A = 2, B = 3, C = 0, D = 1.
- A (2 points, Multistructural). It gets coverage and an attested record right, since the rubric rates indicators independently and the form is signed, but an entry that holds a verdict still gives the rater nothing to match to a level.
- B (3 points, Relational). Quoted words, acts, counts and times can be matched to the practices the rubric’s level descriptions and features of practice describe, so the rater, a second observer and the teacher can all check a level against the lines.
- C (0 points, Prestructural). A verdict such as “very good” decides the level before the rubric is opened, and no level of the rubric describes “very good”; the rating rests on the observation as recorded, not on an impression of it.
- D (1 point, Unistructural). Observers do use the Observation Notes Form (item 53.a), but the right form says nothing about whether what is written on it can show a level.
Why. This aligns with Career Stage 1 expectations because indicator 4.4.1 asks for an understanding of how the performance management system works, and an observation rating is no sounder than its notes. DM 089, s. 2025 says the rating “shall be solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form” (item 55). The COT rubric calls each indicator “the observable practice of teachers in the classroom” and its features of practice “illustrations of specific classroom practices at each particular level” (p. 10), so a quoted, counted line can be matched to a level. The option that covers the scheduled indicators on a signed form gets coverage and attestation right but cannot tell evidence from a verdict.
Indicator 4.4.1: Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the implementation of the performance management system in improving school personnel and office performance.
Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, items 53 and 55, Annex E-1 (COT rubric, pp. 9 and 10) and Annex E-4 (COT Observation Notes Form); DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020.
Question 2
Indicator 4.4.2, Performance management. Career Stage 2, Situational, Difficult.
You are the school head of a central elementary school in Iloilo. You and a Master Teacher observed a Teacher II’s full-period Grade 5 Mathematics lesson. For the indicator on higher-order thinking skills, you rated Level 5 and the Master Teacher rated Level 3. Your notes read “good questioning; very participative class.” The Master Teacher’s notes quote nine of the teacher’s questions, seven answerable by yes or no, and count six of 40 learners who answered. The Master Teacher offers to accept whatever level you decide. What is the most appropriate action?
- A. Write a justification for each rating with the Master Teacher, and forward both ratings and justifications to the Schools Division Office so that it decides the final rating.
- B. Record Level 4, the average of your rating and the Master Teacher’s, so that neither observer’s judgment of the lesson is set aside and the teacher’s rating stays fair.
- C. Talk the lesson over with the Master Teacher, recalling how the teacher questioned and how the class took part, and settle on the rubric level that best fits what you both remember.
- D. Meet the Master Teacher, read both sets of notes against the rubric’s level descriptions for the indicator, and agree on the level that the recorded questions and counts support.
Answer and explanation: Question 2
Best answer: D. Points: A = 1, B = 0, C = 2, D = 3.
- A (1 point, Unistructural). Written reasons are a start, but DM 089 has the observers settle the final rating themselves (item 56), and for an elementary teacher rated by a Master Teacher the approving authority is the school head, not the division office (Table 18).
- B (0 points, Prestructural). DM 089 states that the final rating “shall not be an average of the individual ratings” (item 56), and averaging a verdict with a record also hides what the lesson showed.
- C (2 points, Multistructural). It keeps the meeting, the rubric and a consensus, but a level settled from memory rests on impressions rather than on practice “as documented” in the notes form.
- D (3 points, Relational). It joins the team process, the documented evidence and the rubric’s criteria, and yields a rating both observers can explain to the teacher at the post-observation conference, even if it is below the school head’s own.
Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 4.4.2 asks the school head to implement the performance management system with a team, here the two observers who must agree on one rating. DM 089, s. 2025 says the final rating “shall be determined through reasoned and consensual judgment based on actual observed practice during the classroom observation, as documented in the COT - Observation Notes Form” (item 56), not by averaging. The quoted questions and counts can be held against the rubric’s levels; “good questioning” cannot, even when the evidence lowers the school head’s own rating. The option that settles the level from memory keeps the meeting and the rubric but drops the documented evidence that item 56 names.
Indicator 4.4.2: Implement the performance management system with a team to support the career advancement of school personnel, and to improve office performance.
Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, items 55 to 57 and Table 18; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020.
Question 3
Indicator 3.2.2, Teaching standards and pedagogies. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.
You are the school head of an integrated school in Zamboanga del Norte. During a 12-minute walkthrough of a Grade 7 Mathematics class, you note that the teacher models two examples on the board, naming each step aloud, then asks “Do you understand?” and the class answers “Yes” in chorus. On the seatwork that follows, 11 of 36 learners solve the first item correctly. After class, the teacher, whose rated classroom observation is next month, anxiously asks whether this visit will lower their rating. What is the most appropriate action?
- A. Tell the teacher the visit is unrated, then debrief today on two lines from your notes, the steps named aloud and 11 of 36 correct, ask what they make of them, and agree on one step for the PMCF.
- B. Copy the 11 of 36 result from your walkthrough notes onto the teacher’s COT rating sheet, and tell the teacher so that the feedback on checking understanding is taken seriously.
- C. Tell the teacher the lesson went well and the visit carries no rating, and leave the seatwork result for a later visit so the teacher stays confident before the rated observation.
- D. Tell the teacher the visit carries no rating, explain that the chorus “Yes” hid the confusion the seatwork showed, give three techniques for checking understanding, and record all three in the PMCF.
Answer and explanation: Question 3
Best answer: A. Points: A = 3, B = 0, C = 1, D = 2.
- A (3 points, Relational). It answers the teacher’s worry by keeping the visit unrated, opens on a strength and a result from the notes, lets the teacher read them first, and ends in one agreed step that the PMCF can track.
- B (0 points, Prestructural). Walkthroughs are non-rated, and a rating comes from the full-period observation’s own notes; carrying a walkthrough result to the rating sheet breaks both rules and teaches teachers to fear walkthroughs.
- C (1 point, Unistructural). The visit is indeed unrated, but praise without the evidence hides what 25 learners could not do and leaves the teacher with nothing to work on.
- D (2 points, Multistructural). The evidence, the unrated visit and the PMCF entry are right, but it skips the success the debriefing should celebrate and hands over three fixes instead of a step the teacher helped choose.
Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 3.2.2 asks the school head to provide technical assistance that improves teaching practice, here in “low-stakes and timely formative checks throughout the lesson”, as DO 016, s. 2026 describes checks for understanding. DM 089, s. 2025 makes walkthroughs “non-rated, formative, and developmental”, each followed by a debriefing “to discuss findings, celebrate successes, and outline actionable steps for improvement” and recorded in the PMCF (item 37); DO 016 asks for feedback “without the pressure associated with formal performance evaluation” (item 33). The option that explains the chorus answer and prescribes three techniques uses the evidence and the PMCF but celebrates no success and gives the teacher no part in choosing the step.
Indicator 3.2.2: Provide technical assistance to teachers on teaching standards and pedagogies within and across learning areas to improve their teaching practice.
Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, items 37, 39, 52 and 55; DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026, item 33 and the Learning Design Principles; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020.
Nothing in this guide reproduces or predicts examination content.
Frequently asked questions
What is the STAR observation technique?
It is a note-taking form with four rows, Situation, Task, Action and Result, from the BESRA handbook on instructional supervision (Form 4). The Task row records what the teacher did, the Action row what the learners did in response, and the Result row the outcome in numbers and in words. The handbook carries no DepEd order number, so STAR is a method for filling DepEd’s notes form, not a required format.
What should I write in the COT observation notes form?
Write what happened, not what you thought of it: the teacher’s questions and instructions word for word, what learners did, counts, and times. DM 089, s. 2025 bases the rating “solely” on what the form records (item 55), and the COT rubric’s features of practice describe acts, such as “The teacher asks simple yes/no questions” (p. 18). Cover every indicator scheduled for the observation.
Is the STAR template required by DepEd?
No. DepEd’s Observation Notes Form (DM 089, Annex E-4) prescribes no layout: its direction is to write observations “on the space provided” and to use additional sheets when needed. STAR rows are one way to organize that space.
Are walkthrough observations rated?
No. DM 089, s. 2025 makes walkthroughs of about 10 to 15 minutes “a non-rated, formative, and developmental approach”, followed by a brief debriefing and recorded in the PMCF (item 37). DO 016, s. 2026 asks for them “without the pressure associated with formal performance evaluation” (item 33).
What happens when an indicator is not observed?
On the SY 2025-2026 rating sheets, a scheduled indicator the observer did not see is marked NO, which “automatically gets a rating of 2” for Teachers I to III and 3 for Teachers IV to VII, the lowest level of each range (DM 089, Annex E-2). An indicator not scheduled for that observation is marked N/A and not rated. As of November 18, 2026, DepEd had not issued the rating sheets for SY 2026-2027.
Sources
DepEd issuances
- DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, Guidelines on the Multi-Year Performance Management and Evaluation System for Teachers from School Years 2025-2026 to 2027-2028, October 1, 2025: items 37, 39, 40, 49, 52, 53, 55 to 58, Tables 7 to 9; Annex D (Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form); Annex E-1 (PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool rubric, 2019: pp. 7, 9, 10, 16, 18, 28); Annex E-2 (COT rating sheets for SY 2025-2026); Annex E-4 (COT Observation Notes Form). PDF.
- DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Guidance in the Implementation of the Performance Management and Evaluation System (PMES) for Teachers for SY 2025-2026, March 3, 2026: Sec. A and the closing paragraph.
- DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026, Guidelines on Lesson Planning and Learning Design, June 4, 2026: item 33 and the Learning Design Principles.
- DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026, Guidelines on the Implementation of the Three-Term School Calendar in Basic Education, April 16, 2026.
- DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2023, Guidelines on Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment in the Department of Education: Encl. No. 3, item 8.b.
- DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2017, National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for Teachers.
- DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads: indicators 3.2.2 and 4.4.2.
Handbook
- Basic Education Sector Reform Agenda, Teacher Education and Development Technical Working Group. Instructional Supervision: Standards, Procedures and Tools (cited in training materials as the BESRA Instructional Supervision Handbook, 2010): Section 4 and Instructional Supervision Form 4, “S T A R Observation Technique”.
Research
- Acheson, K. A. (1981). Classroom observation techniques (IDEA Paper No. 4). Center for Faculty Evaluation and Development, Kansas State University. ERIC ED 202 259.
- Danielson, C. (2012). Observing classroom practice. Educational Leadership, 70(3), 32–37.
- Garet, M. S., Wayne, A. J., Brown, S., Rickles, J., Song, M., and Manzeske, D. (2017). The impact of providing performance feedback to teachers and principals: Executive summary (NCEE 2018-4000). Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education.
- Ho, A. D., and Kane, T. J. (2013). The reliability of classroom observations by school personnel (MET Project Research Paper). Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. ERIC ED 540 957.
- Hunter, M. (1983). Script taping: An essential supervisory tool. Educational Leadership, 41(3), 43.
- Kane, T. J., and Staiger, D. O. (2012). Gathering feedback for teaching: Combining high-quality observations with student surveys and achievement gains (MET Project Research Paper). Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. ERIC ED 540 960.
- Kraft, M. A., Blazar, D., and Hogan, D. (2018). The effect of teacher coaching on instruction and achievement: A meta-analysis of the causal evidence. Review of Educational Research, 88(4), 547–588. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654318759268
- Rosenshine, B. (1970). Interpretive study of teaching behaviors related to student achievement (Final Report, Project No. 9-B-010). Temple University. ERIC ED 051 116.
Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025 and its annexes, DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, DepEd Orders No. 016 and 009, s. 2026, the BESRA instructional supervision handbook, and the research listed above.