The COT rubric is the scale on which DepEd’s observers rate a teacher’s classroom practice. It gives each of the 21 classroom observable strands of the Philippine Professional Standards for Teachers (PPST) nine levels, from Level 1, Not Evident, to Level 9, Synthesizing. The rubric in use is the PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (COT) of 2019, which DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025 attaches as Annex E-1 for the Performance Management and Evaluation System (PMES) from School Year (SY) 2025-2026 to SY 2027-2028.

No teacher is rated on all nine levels. A Teacher I to III is rated on Levels 2 to 6, a Teacher IV to VII on Levels 3 to 7, a Master Teacher I or II on Levels 4 to 8, and a Master Teacher III to V on Levels 5 to 9. The top of each range converts to a PMES rating of 5 (Outstanding) and the bottom to 1 (Poor), so the same level means a different rating for different positions.

The school head rates Master Teachers and Head Teachers with a teaching load, rates teachers where the school has no Master Teacher, Department Head or Assistant School Head to rate them, and approves the ratings those raters give (DM 089, Table 18). Every one of those ratings rests on what the observer wrote down, read against the rubric’s words. As of November 18, 2026, DepEd has not replaced the 2019 tool or DM 089, and it has not issued the PMES guidelines for SY 2026-2027 that its March 2026 guidance promised.

Key findings

  • One scale, nine levels. Not Evident, Building, Organizing, Developing, Applying, Consolidating, Integrating, Discriminating and Synthesizing; “each indicator in the COT uses nine (9) rubric levels based on the four (4) career stages” (PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool, 2019, p. 3).
  • Five levels for each position. Teachers I to III are rated on Levels 2 to 6, Teachers IV to VII on 3 to 7, Master Teachers I and II on 4 to 8, and Master Teachers III to V on 5 to 9 (DM 089, s. 2025, item 18 and Table 10; Memorandum DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Part C). DM 089’s Tables 10 and 13 put Master Teacher III on Levels 4 to 8.
  • The same level, different ratings. A COT score of 6 is a 5 (Outstanding) for a Teacher III and a 3 (Satisfactory) for a Master Teacher II (DM 089, s. 2025, Tables 13, 15 and 16).
  • Nine strands are observed in SY 2026-2027: 1.1, 1.4, 1.5, 1.6, 2.1, 2.2, 3.2, 3.5 and 5.3, with 1.1, 1.4 and 1.5 rated in both full-period observations (DM 089, s. 2025, Tables 3 to 5 and 7 to 9).
  • The rubric defines the words that separate levels, indicator by indicator. For the feedback indicator, MAJORITY is “more than half” and MOST is “almost all, approaching 100%” (COT, p. 61).
  • The notes decide the rating, and the final rating is not an average. The rating “shall be solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form”, and where there are several observers, “The final rating shall not be an average of the individual ratings” (DM 089, s. 2025, items 55 and 56).
  • Hiring and promotion use the same scale. Teacher I applicants are rated on Levels 2 to 6 of the recruitment subset (DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2023), and applicants for higher positions on the levels of the position they seek (DepEd Order No. 020, s. 2024, item 45; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2025, Encl. No. 2, Sec. 37).

What the COT rubric is

The COT was “finalized in July 2019 after gathering inputs from the classroom practices of Alternative Learning System, Special Education, Indigenous Peoples Education, and Kindergarten teachers” (COT, cover). The Philippine National Research Center for Teacher Quality (RCTQ) at the Philippine Normal University developed it. RCTQ’s policy note on the tool says its development “comprised the review of 14 COTs used in the world and in DepEd regions”, that 51 teachers were observed in the pilot, and that it was refined with “2,430 teachers and master teachers from NCR (1,560) and Region 5 (870)”. It adds that “Beginning 2018, COT was embedded in the RPMS of more than 700,000 in-service teachers” (RCTQ Policy Note No. 2019-002, p. 2).

Its indicators come from the PPST’s 21 classroom observable strands: six in Domain 1, six in Domain 2, five in Domain 3, two in Domain 4 and two in Domain 5. “The language used in the COT indicators is taken from the Proficient career stage indicators” (COT, p. 2), so a Master Teacher’s rubric uses the same indicator wording as a Teacher I’s. DepEd’s March 2026 guidance explains why: the rubric is “a single, comprehensive performance scale covering Levels 1–9, which includes all Career Stages”, and “The differentiation among teacher positions is reflected through the assigned COT Rubric level ranges” (DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Part C).

Each indicator’s rubric has four parts (COT, p. 10):

Part What the tool says it is
Indicator “the observable practice of teachers in the classroom”
Level descriptions “the descriptions of practice for each level”
Features of practice “illustrations of specific classroom practices at each particular level”
Clarifications “the operational definitions of selected words/phrases used in the rubric”

“The indicators in the rubric are rated independently” (COT, p. 9). A strong lesson on one indicator does not lift the rating on another.

DM 089 sends the rubric out with three forms: the COT-Rating Sheet (Annex E-2), the COT Inter-Observer Agreement Form (Annex E-3) and the COT Observation Notes Form (Annex E-4) (item 96). The tools are on a folder the memorandum links, which opens with an official DepEd email address.

The nine levels of the COT rubric

Each level has a name and a general description that the tool repeats for every indicator. The generic descriptions show the climb. Level 2 is “a limited range of separate aspects of the indicator”, Level 4 aspects “that sometimes are aligned with the learners’ developmental needs”, Level 5 aspects that “usually are aligned”, and Level 6 aspects that “consistently are aligned with student development”. From Level 7 the teacher creates “an environment that addresses individual and group learning goals”; Level 9 fosters “a teaching and learning culture that values informed feedback, critical thinking and lifelong learning” (COT, p. 3).

PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool

Nine levels, five for each position

Pick a position. A rule marks the five levels it is rated on, and each of them shows the PMES rating it converts to.

Position

Teacher I to III: Beginning towards Proficient, Levels 2 to 6.

Teacher IV to VII: Proficient, Levels 3 to 7.

Master Teacher I and II: Highly Proficient, Levels 4 to 8.

Master Teacher III to V: Distinguished, Levels 5 to 9. DM 089’s Tables 10 and 13 put Master Teacher III on Levels 4 to 8; its Table 2 puts Master Teachers III to V under Distinguished, and DepEd’s guidance for SY 2025-2026 puts them on Levels 5 to 9.

  1. Level 9, Synthesizing

    The teacher strategically applies exceptional knowledge and understanding of the indicator to foster a teaching and learning culture that values informed feedback, critical thinking and lifelong learning.

    Teacher I to III: Not on this rubricTeacher IV to VII: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher I and II: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher III to V: 5 Outstanding

  2. Level 8, Discriminating

    The teacher applies deep knowledge and understanding of the indicator discriminately to contextualize teaching and learning processes within the discipline to meet individual and group learning goals.

    Teacher I to III: Not on this rubricTeacher IV to VII: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher I and II: 5 OutstandingMaster Teacher III to V: 4 Very Satisfactory

  3. Level 7, Integrating

    The teacher uses well-connected pedagogical aspects of the indicator to create an environment that addresses individual and group learning goals.

    Teacher I to III: Not on this rubricTeacher IV to VII: 5 OutstandingMaster Teacher I and II: 4 Very SatisfactoryMaster Teacher III to V: 3 Satisfactory

  4. Level 6, Consolidating

    The teacher uses well-connected pedagogical aspects of the indicator that consistently are aligned with student development and support students to be successful learners.

    Teacher I to III: 5 OutstandingTeacher IV to VII: 4 Very SatisfactoryMaster Teacher I and II: 3 SatisfactoryMaster Teacher III to V: 2 Unsatisfactory

  5. Level 5, Applying

    The teacher demonstrates a range of associated pedagogical aspects of the indicator that usually are aligned with the learners' developmental needs.

    Teacher I to III: 4 Very SatisfactoryTeacher IV to VII: 3 SatisfactoryMaster Teacher I and II: 2 UnsatisfactoryMaster Teacher III to V: 1 Poor

  6. Level 4, Developing

    The teacher demonstrates a range of associated pedagogical aspects of the indicator that sometimes are aligned with the learners' developmental needs.

    Teacher I to III: 3 SatisfactoryTeacher IV to VII: 2 UnsatisfactoryMaster Teacher I and II: 1 PoorMaster Teacher III to V: Not on this rubric

  7. Level 3, Organizing

    The teacher demonstrates a limited range of loosely-associated pedagogical aspects of the indicator.

    Teacher I to III: 2 UnsatisfactoryTeacher IV to VII: 1 PoorMaster Teacher I and II: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher III to V: Not on this rubric

  8. Level 2, Building

    The teacher demonstrates a limited range of separate aspects of the indicator.

    Teacher I to III: 1 PoorTeacher IV to VII: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher I and II: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher III to V: Not on this rubric

  9. Level 1, Not Evident

    The teacher does not demonstrate the indicator.

    Teacher I to III: Not on this rubricTeacher IV to VII: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher I and II: Not on this rubricMaster Teacher III to V: Not on this rubric

Levels: PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (DepEd, 2019), Annex E-1 to DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, p. 3. Positions and ratings: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, item 18 and Tables 10 and 13; Memorandum DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Part C. The tool’s own Beginning rubric runs from Level 1 to 5; DM 089 rates Teachers I to III on Levels 2 to 6.

The level names and descriptions are DepEd’s, word for word. Each rating is the memorandum’s Table 13: the top of a position’s five levels is 5 (Outstanding) and the bottom 1 (Poor).

The tool sets its own five-level rubric for each career stage: “The Beginning rubric uses levels 1 to 5; the Proficient rubric uses levels 3 to 7; the Highly Proficient rubric uses levels 4 to 8; and the Distinguished rubric uses levels 5 to 9” (COT, p. 3). DM 089 departs from it for Teachers I to III, who are “Beginning towards Proficient”: they “shall be rated based on Levels 2-6 rubrics, while Proficient teachers remain to be rated at Levels 3-7” (item 18). Levels 2 to 6 are the band of the tool’s recruitment subset, which it built “to support the continuum of practice from Beginning to Proficient career stage” (COT, p. 6).

Which COT levels each position is rated on

DM 089 places each teacher position in a PPST career stage (Table 2) and gives each career stage five COT levels (item 18, Table 10). Teachers I to VII are rated on Career Stage 2 indicators; Master Teachers on Career Stage 3 or 4 indicators.

Position Career stage (DM 089) COT levels Level rated 5 (Outstanding) Level rated 1 (Poor)
Teacher I to III Beginning towards Proficient 2 to 6 6 2
Teacher IV to VII Proficient 3 to 7 7 3
Master Teacher I and II Highly Proficient 4 to 8 8 4
Master Teacher III to V Distinguished 5 to 9 9 5

Sources: DM 089, s. 2025, item 18 and Tables 2, 10 and 13; DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Part C.

DM 089 places Master Teacher III two ways. Its item 15, Table 2, list of tools (Annex C-4, “MTIII-MTV”) and SY 2025-2026 rating sheets put Master Teachers III to V under Distinguished, on Levels 5 to 9, while Tables 10 and 13 group Master Teacher III with Highly Proficient, on Levels 4 to 8. DepEd’s March 3, 2026 guidance settled SY 2025-2026: Master Teachers III to V are Distinguished, Levels 5 to 9, and “raters shall apply the appropriate performance level range when assessing teachers” (Part C). That guidance covers SY 2025-2026 only. DM 089’s own inter-observer agreement form for Distinguished teachers already has SY 2026-2027 pages headed “MASTER TEACHER III-V”, which give an unobserved indicator “a rating of 5”, the bottom of Levels 5 to 9 (Annex E-3). The implementing rules of Republic Act No. 12288, dated August 17, 2026, place Master Teacher III at Career Stage III (IRR, Sec. 6). They take effect 30 days after publication and filing with the Office of the National Administrative Register (Sec. 20); as of November 18, 2026, DepEd had announced neither, nor any order applying them to the PMES. Until DepEd issues the SY 2026-2027 guidelines, confirm the range with the Schools Division Office before rating a Master Teacher III. The guide to Master Teachers’ PMES ratings covers the rest of a Master Teacher’s rating.

The same levels apply when a teacher moves up. A Teacher I applicant’s demonstration teaching is rated with the Classroom Observation Tool for Recruitment, Selection, and Placement (COT-RSP), “focusing on Levels 2 to 6 of the COT Rubric to capture good performance in the Beginning towards Proficient career stage” (DO 007, s. 2023, Encl. No. 2, item 6). The points are the COT rating over 30, the highest score on five indicators, times the 35 points the classroom observation carries. An applicant rated 20 of 30 gets 23.333 points (item 6.d). Applicants for a higher position are rated on the levels of the position they apply for, from Levels 2 to 6 for Teacher II and III to Levels 5 to 9 for Master Teachers III to V. The bands are the same for a vacancy, under DepEd Order No. 020, s. 2024 (item 45), and for reclassification, under DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2025 (Encl. No. 2, Sec. 37). The guide to the ECP point system works through those points.

How a COT level becomes a PMES rating

DM 089’s Table 13 converts a COT score to the PMES 5-point scale. The top of a position’s five levels is 5 (Outstanding), the next 4 (Very Satisfactory), the middle 3 (Satisfactory), then 2 (Unsatisfactory) and 1 (Poor). The memorandum’s own examples show the effect of the range. A Teacher III with COT scores of 6 and 5 gets PMES ratings of 5 and 4, which average 4.500, an Outstanding. A Master Teacher II with scores of 6 and 7 gets 3 and 4, which average 3.500, a Very Satisfactory (Tables 15 and 16).

The averaging is DM 089’s rule for an indicator rated in both observations: “the final rating shall be computed by averaging the PMES ratings of the transmuted COT scores from the two (2) classroom observations” (item 77). The average then converts back by Table 14: 4.500 to 5.000 is a 5, 3.500 to 4.499 a 4, 2.500 to 3.499 a 3, 1.500 to 2.499 a 2. Each of the year’s 14 indicators weighs 6.786%, and together they are 95% of the rating (item 74).

What if the observer does not see a scheduled indicator? On DM 089’s rating sheets for SY 2025-2026, “NO stands for Not Observed which automatically gets a rating of 2” on a Teacher I to III’s sheet; the sheets for the other positions give 3, 4 and 5, the bottom of each range (Annex E-2). An indicator not scheduled for that observation is marked N/A and not rated. For SY 2025-2026 alone, the March 2026 guidance required one full-period observation and let a teacher show an unobserved indicator through a Reflection Journal with evidence (Part A). As of November 18, 2026, DepEd had not issued rating sheets for SY 2026-2027.

The indicators observed in SY 2026-2027

DM 089 fixes which strands each school year observes, and in SY 2026-2027 every position is observed on the same nine strands at its own career stage. A Teacher II is rated on 1.1.2, a Master Teacher I on 1.1.3. Two full-period observations are required, “the 1st or 2nd quarter” for the first and “the 3rd or 4th quarter” for the second (items 41 and 42). SY 2026-2027 runs on three terms under DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026; as of November 18, 2026, no issuance has restated the quarters as terms, and rater and teacher agree on the dates.

Strand COT indicator First observation Second observation
1.1 Content knowledge and its application 1. Apply knowledge of content within and across curriculum teaching areas Yes Yes
1.4 Literacy and numeracy 3. Use a range of teaching strategies that enhance learner achievement in literacy and numeracy skills Yes Yes
1.5 Critical and creative thinking 4. Apply a range of teaching strategies to develop critical and creative thinking, as well as other higher-order thinking skills Yes Yes
1.6 Mother Tongue, Filipino and English 5. Display proficient use of Mother Tongue, Filipino and English to facilitate teaching and learning Yes
2.1 Learner safety and security 7. Establish safe and secure learning environments to enhance learning through the consistent implementation of policies, guidelines and procedures Yes
2.2 Fair learning environment 8. Maintain learning environments that promote fairness, respect and care to encourage learning Yes
3.2 Learners’ backgrounds 14. Establish a learner-centered culture by using teaching strategies that respond to learners’ linguistic, cultural, socio-economic and religious backgrounds Yes
3.5 Learners from indigenous groups 17. Adapt and use culturally appropriate teaching strategies to address the needs of learners from indigenous groups Yes
5.3 Feedback to improve learning 21. Use strategies for providing timely, accurate and constructive feedback to improve learner performance Yes

Sources: DM 089, s. 2025, Tables 3 to 5 and 7 to 9; COT, pp. 12 to 60.

Indicator 1 has a rule of its own. “If there are multiple observers, only the subject specialist is expected to rate Indicator 1.1.2 / 1.1.3 / 1.1.4”, except that “Elementary teachers are generalists; all observers are expected to rate” it, and “If there is only one observer, he or she rates” it too (item 55). In a secondary school, a school head whose subject is not the teacher’s leaves the content-knowledge rating to the observer who teaches that subject.

How to read a level: the words that move a rating

Each level of an indicator differs from the one below by a few words, and those words decide the rating. On the feedback indicator, Level 4 reads “The teacher occasionally provides feedback that results in opportunities for majority of the learners to improve their learning”, and Level 5 “The teacher frequently provides feedback that results in opportunities for most of the learners to improve their learning” (COT, p. 60). Two words separate a Satisfactory from a Very Satisfactory for a Teacher I to III: “occasionally” against “frequently”, and “majority” against “most”.

The rubric defines such words, and each indicator’s clarifications page defines its own. For the feedback indicator, RARELY is “seldom occurs”, OCCASIONALLY “irregularly occurs”, FREQUENTLY “often occurs” and CONSISTENTLY “constantly occurs”; MAJORITY is “more than half” and MOST “almost all, approaching 100%” (COT, p. 61). A rater who reads “most” as “more than half” rates that indicator a level too high.

The same word can mean something else on another indicator. On fairness, respect and care, OCCASIONALLY is “learner-teacher interactions are moderately acceptable” and GENERALLY “learner-teacher interactions are mostly acceptable” (COT, p. 29). On learners’ backgrounds, SOMEWHAT APPROPRIATE is a “minimal degree of appropriateness” and PARTIALLY APPROPRIATE a “moderate degree of appropriateness” (COT, p. 43). The language indicator rates proficiency in sublevels adapted from the ACTFL Proficiency Guidelines, from Novice to Distinguished (COT, p. 21).

The features of practice under each level show what the level can look like in a classroom. The tool calls them “illustrations” (p. 10), and DepEd’s March 2026 Reflection Journal tells teachers to “Refer to the Feature/s of Practice indicated in the Classroom Observation Tool as a guide” (Annex A). The level description is the standard the rating rests on. A lesson can meet it through practice the list does not name.

PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool: the indicators of SY 2026-2027

What changes from one level to the next

Pick an indicator, then a pair of levels. The words the higher level adds are underlined.

Indicator 1, Strand 1.1: Content knowledge and its application within and across curriculum areas

Apply knowledge of content within and across curriculum teaching areas

  1. Level 5 Applying

    The teacher demonstrates accurate and in-depth knowledge of most concepts in presenting the lesson and in responding to learners’ questions in a manner that attempts to be responsive to student developmental learning needs.

    The teacher makes connections across curriculum teaching areas, if appropriate.

    PMES rating Teacher I to III 4; Teacher IV to VII 3; Master Teacher I and II 2; Master Teacher III to V 1

    Features of practice: Indicator 1, Strand 1.1: Content knowledge and its application within and across curriculum areas

    1. The teacher displays comprehensive understanding of the concepts and structure of the teaching area.

    2. The teacher presents conceptual knowledge of the subject and makes connections within the teaching area.

  2. Level 6 Consolidating

    The teacher demonstrates accurate and in-depth knowledge of all concepts in presenting the lesson and in responding to learners’ questions in a manner that is responsive to learner‘s developmental needs and promotes learning.

    The teacher makes meaningful connections across curriculum teaching areas, if appropriate.

    PMES rating Teacher I to III 5; Teacher IV to VII 4; Master Teacher I and II 3; Master Teacher III to V 2

    Features of practice: Indicator 1, Strand 1.1: Content knowledge and its application within and across curriculum areas

    1. The teacher displays extensive knowledge of content.

    2. The teacher addresses content accurately and its focus is congruent with the big ideas and/or structure of the teaching area.

Words the rubric defines for this indicator: Indicator 1, Strand 1.1: Content knowledge and its application within and across curriculum areas
SUBSTANTIAL CONTENT ERRORS
extensive or significant degree of errors in the content of the lesson
MODERATE CONTENT ERRORS
reasonable degree of errors in the content of the lesson
MINOR CONTENT ERRORS
insignificant degree of errors in the content of the lesson
KEY CONCEPTS
central ideas of the topic or lesson
COHERENCE
logical and/or developmental sequence in presenting the lesson
SIMPLE COHERENCE
basic logic in the sequence of the lesson with one part linked to the next
ACCURATE KNOWLEDGE
error-free content
IN-DEPTH KNOWLEDGE
foundational knowledge and finer details within the curriculum teaching area
BROAD KNOWLEDGE
knowledge across curriculum teaching areas
HIGH-LEVEL KNOWLEDGE
accurate, in-depth, and broad knowledge within and across curriculum teaching areas
EXCEPTIONAL KNOWLEDGE
knowledge grounded in global best practices

PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool, pp. 12 and 13.

Rubric: PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (DepEd, 2019), Annex E-1 to DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025. Indicators of SY 2026-2027 and the ratings: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, Tables 7 to 9 and 13. Master Teacher III is shown with Levels 5 to 9, as DepEd’s guidance for SY 2025-2026 placed it; DM 089’s Table 13 gives it Levels 4 to 8.

The levels, features of practice and defined words are DepEd’s, word for word. Which words count as new at a level is this figure’s own comparison with the level below.

The marks in the figure come from comparing each level with the one below. On content knowledge, Level 5 adds “and in-depth” knowledge of “most” concepts; Level 6 changes “most” to “all” and adds “promotes learning”; Level 7 adds “broad” knowledge and “a conducive learning environment”. Read a level against its neighbors before reading it alone.

How an observation is rated, step by step

DM 089 sets the order of a full-period observation. These steps apply to every rated observation; walkthroughs follow different rules (step 8).

  1. Agree on the schedule. Rater and teacher set it “at least three (3) working days before the CO” (item 46).
  2. Hold the pre-observation conference. Both “review the Classroom Observation Tool (COT) Rubric appropriate to the career stage of the ratee to be observed” and the indicators of that period (item 49). The teacher’s range is part of that review.
  3. Receive the lesson plan. The teacher submits it “at least one (1) day before”, and observers “are discouraged from providing technical assistance on the teacher-ratee’s lesson plan that will be used in the actual evaluative/rated observation” (item 50).
  4. Observe the whole period. Observers use the Observation Notes Form, sit apart, do not talk with each other, give no feedback “which may include using any facial expression or any other form of non-verbal communication”, and leave when it ends (items 52 and 53).
  5. Rate alone, from the notes. Each observer rates “using the COT appropriate to the teacher’s career stage”, and “Only those indicators expected to be observed in an observation period, as specified in Tables 7, 8, and 9, shall be given ratings” (item 55).
  6. Agree on one rating. With several observers, the final rating “shall be determined through reasoned and consensual judgment based on actual observed practice during the classroom observation, as documented in the COT - Observation Notes Form, and evaluated against the criteria specified in the COT – Rubric” (item 56).
  7. Hold the post-observation conference “immediately after the observation or within three (3) days thereafter” (item 57), “in a manner which fosters constructive feedback” (item 58).
  8. Visit between observations. Walkthroughs of “approximately 10-15 minutes” are “non-rated, formative, and developmental” (item 37). They are where a teacher works on the next level. DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026 encourages the same walkthroughs, “or longer when schedules permit” (para. 33).

The March 2026 guidance adds the tone: observers keep the process “developmental and supportive in nature, emphasizing strengths and professional growth rather than punitive judgment” (Part B). The guide to classroom observation notes covers what to write in step 4.

Three observers, one rating

Ratings drift apart even among trained observers. In the Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) project, “A single observation by a single observer is a fairly unreliable estimate of a teacher’s practice, with reliability between .27 and .45”. The authors found that “The gain in reliability from adding another set of eyeballs is more than twice as large as that of adding another observation from the same observer” (Ho and Kane, 2013, pp. 13 and 22). They also found that “Administrators rated their own teachers .1 points higher than administrators from other schools and .2 points higher than peers” (p. 4). In Chicago, principals rated practice Distinguished in 17% of ratings where trained observers watching the same lessons did so in 3% (Sartain, Stoelinga and Brown, 2011, Table 3).

These studies are American and used other rubrics, and as of November 2026, no Philippine study had published how much COT ratings vary between observers. DepEd’s answer to the problem is the inter-observer agreement in step 6: observers compare their notes against the rubric and settle on one rating. The figure below runs that exercise three times. The observations are invented; the rubric’s words and the memorandum’s rules are DepEd’s.

Inter-observer agreement

Three observers, one rating

Read the three observers’ notes (T is the teacher), then choose the final rating the notes support. The panel’s reading opens once you choose.

Case 1. The average is not the rating

Grade 5 Science, a lesson on evaporation, at a central elementary school in Capiz. Thirty-eight learners work in seven groups.

Teacher
A Teacher II, rated on Levels 2 to 6
Indicator
4 (Strand 1.5): Apply a range of teaching strategies to develop critical and creative thinking, as well as other higher-order thinking skills
  1. Observer A, the school head

    • T asks the class: ‘What is evaporation?’ Learners answer together.
    • T: ‘Can you explain why the puddle on the cement dried faster than the one on the grass?’ Three learners answer.
    • Groups work with two cups of water. T moves from group to group.

    Rated 4

  2. Observer B, a Master Teacher II, Science

    • Each group has two cups of water left by the window since morning, one covered and one open. Each writes a prediction and a reason.
    • T to Group 2: ‘Why do you think so? What would make you change your answer?’ A learner revises the prediction and gives a new reason.
    • Groups check their predictions against the cups. T: ‘Which group’s reason fits what happened? Defend your choice.’
    • All seven groups report. Learners from five groups question another group’s reason, and T has them answer each other.

    Rated 6

  3. Observer C, a Master Teacher I, English

    • T asks follow-up questions group by group: ‘What do you notice? Show me.’
    • Groups lift the covers and show the drops of water inside; each group explains what it saw.
    • Group reports and a class discussion; learners talk about their reasons.

    Rated 5

The three ratings average 5.0.

Your final rating

You chose Level 2. The notes support Level 6.

You chose Level 3. The notes support Level 6.

You chose Level 4. The notes support Level 6.

You chose Level 5. The notes support Level 6.

Your rating, Level 6, is the panel’s reading.

The panel’s reading: Level 6, Consolidating, a PMES rating of 5 (Outstanding) for a Teacher II. The average, rounded, is Level 5, a PMES rating of 4 (Very Satisfactory).

The three ratings average 5, and an average is what DM 089 rules out: “The final rating shall not be an average of the individual ratings” (item 56).

Observer B’s notes record Level 6. The teacher “challenges learners to justify their thinking” (why do you think so, defend your choice), and “successfully engages most learners in discussion”: all seven groups report, and learners from five of them question another group’s reason.

Observer A wrote down only what the teacher said to the whole class, which reads as Level 4, “questions and activities that mostly require the learners to interpret, explain, or describe ideas learned”. Observer C saw Level 5’s “targeted follow-up questions and activities”, but wrote that learners talked about their reasons without writing the reasons down.

The rating rests on practice “as documented in the COT - Observation Notes Form” (item 56), and only Observer B documented the discussion. The panel settles on 6, the top of a Teacher II’s five levels.

Level 6 of Indicator 4 in the rubric

The teacher challenges learners to justify their thinking and successfully engages most learners in discussion using well-directed questions and activities.

Rules: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, items 55 and 56, and Table 13. Rubric: PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (DepEd, 2019), Annex E-1 to DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025.

The schools, lessons, notes and ratings are invented. Which level fits each set of notes, and why, is this figure’s reading of the rubric; the quotations are DepEd’s.

Mistakes that move a rating off the rubric

  • Averaging the observers’ ratings. Item 56 rules it out. Discuss the notes until one level fits them.
  • Rating the teacher instead of the lesson. A teacher’s awards, seniority or last year’s rating are not in the Observation Notes Form, and the rating “shall be solely based on” it (item 55).
  • Rating from the lesson plan. The plan shows what the teacher meant to do; the rubric rates what happened in class.
  • Reading a word in its everyday sense. Look up the indicator’s clarifications before rating.
  • Rating outside the position’s range. A Teacher II cannot be rated 7, and a Master Teacher I cannot be rated 3 (DM 089, Table 13). Keep the teacher’s five levels in front of you.
  • Rating an indicator not scheduled for that observation. It is marked N/A (Annex E-2). Practice seen on it goes into the post-observation conference and the walkthroughs, not the rating.
  • Leaving a scheduled indicator without a note. The SY 2025-2026 sheets gave an indicator marked “Not Observed” the bottom of the range. At the pre-observation conference, go over with the teacher where in the lesson each scheduled indicator can be seen (item 49).
  • Using an old copy of the rubric. The SY 2024-2025 interim tools of DepEd Memorandum No. 017, s. 2025 rated Teachers I to III as Proficient, on Levels 3 to 7, and their rubric worded some levels differently. Its content-knowledge rubric put “accurate, in-depth and broad knowledge of all concepts” at Level 6, where the 2019 COT’s Level 6 reads “accurate and in-depth knowledge of all concepts” and keeps “broad” for Level 7. Rate with DM 089’s Annex E-1.

What this means for school heads

A school head who rates teachers needs to know the rubric well enough to explain why a lesson is a 5 and not a 6, with the teacher’s own lesson as the example. Republic Act No. 9155 makes the school head “both an instructional leader and administrative manager” (Sec. 7(E)). In the PPSSH, school heads “are expected to provide technical assistance on instruction that relates to curriculum, practice, and performance” (DO 024, s. 2020, Domain 3). Researchers call what it takes “leadership content knowledge”, knowledge “always anchored in knowledge of the subject, how it is learned (by adults as well as students), and how it is taught” (Stein and Nelson, 2003, abstract).

What to do each school year:

  1. Read the year’s nine indicators before the first observation. Read each one’s nine levels and its clarifications page, with the range of each position you rate.
  2. Agree with your co-observers on how to read the rubric. Before the first observations, rate one lesson together, compare notes and reasons, and settle words such as “most”, “consistently” and “generally” from the clarifications. DM 089 does not require such a session, but the ratings it requires rest on the rubric’s criteria (item 56). The MET researchers thought the larger differences between raters in their district study might be due to the absence of “the daily calibration exercises that ETS required of its raters” in its earlier study (Ho and Kane, 2013, p. 14).
  3. Put the observations on the calendar. Agree on the dates three working days ahead (item 46) and keep them; an observation deferred for a meeting must be “rescheduled immediately” (item 46).
  4. Write evidence, not verdicts. What the teacher and learners said and did, with counts, so that each line can be held against a level.
  5. Use the next level’s words in the conference. Show the teacher where the notes stand in the rubric and what the next level adds, agree on one change to try, and see it in a walkthrough (items 37 and 57).
  6. Delegate the clerical part. For SY 2025-2026, the March 2026 guidance let “The School Head or designated non-teaching personnel” upload the finalized e-IPCRF tools, which the teachers encode themselves (Part E). Where the school has an Administrative Officer or Administrative Assistant, the uploading can go to them, so your time goes to observing; the guide to DO 002 and school support staff covers who does which task.
  7. Record what you see. Significant incidents and feedback go in the Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form (item 39).

These steps serve PPSSH Domain 3, Focusing on Teaching and Learning, strand 3.2 (technical assistance on teaching standards and pedagogies), and Domain 4, Developing Self and Others, strands 4.4 (performance management) and 4.5 (professional development). The PMES guide covers the whole cycle, the PPST guide the standards behind the indicators, and the instructional supervision guide the walkthroughs and coaching between observations.

How the NASH may test this

The National Assessment for School Heads (NASH) scores each item on a 0 to 3 scale against a PPSSH indicator. The items below are original practice items, scored 3 (Relational), 2 (Multistructural), 1 (Unistructural) or 0 (Prestructural). An option that breaks a rule scores 0.

Question 1

Indicator 4.4.1, Performance management. Career Stage 1, Conceptual, Moderate.

On the same indicator, a Teacher II and a Master Teacher II each receive a COT score of 6. Transmuted to the PMES scale, the Teacher II’s rating on that indicator is Outstanding and the Master Teacher II’s is Satisfactory. Which statement gives the underlying reason?

  • A. The Master Teacher II is expected to teach at a higher level, so the observers lower the Master Teacher’s score to reflect the higher standard of the position.
  • B. The table converts scores by career stage, and the Highly Proficient column starts at Level 4, so a score of 6 converts to a lower rating for that teacher.
  • C. The COT is one nine-level scale for all career stages, and each stage is rated on its own five levels, so Level 6 tops one range and sits mid-range in the other.
  • D. The two teachers were rated on different indicators, since a Master Teacher’s classroom observation covers mentoring indicators instead of the teaching indicators.
Answer and explanation: Question 1

Best answer: C. Points: A = 1, B = 2, C = 3, D = 0.

  • A (1 point, Unistructural). It sees that a Master Teacher is held to more, but observers do not adjust a score: they rate the observed practice against the rubric, and the career stage’s range does the rest.
  • B (2 points, Multistructural). It describes the conversion table correctly but stops at the mechanics: it does not say that the same practice sits at a different place in each career stage’s five levels.
  • C (3 points, Relational). The rubric is “a single, comprehensive performance scale covering Levels 1–9”, and positions differ only in the range they are rated on, so the same practice converts to different ratings.
  • D (0 points, Prestructural). Both are observed on the same strands in a school year, at their own career stage; Master Teachers show some indicators also through mentoring evidence, not instead of classroom practice.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 1 expectations because indicator 4.4.1 asks for an understanding of how the performance management system works. DM 089 rates Teachers I to III on Levels 2 to 6 and Master Teachers I and II on Levels 4 to 8 (item 18, Table 10), and Table 13 makes the top of each range a 5 and its middle a 3; DepEd’s guidance calls the COT “a single, comprehensive performance scale covering Levels 1–9, which includes all Career Stages” (DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Part C). The option on the conversion table describes the mechanics without the scale that explains them.

Indicator 4.4.1: Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the implementation of the performance management system in improving school personnel and office performance.

Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, items 18 and 45 and Tables 10, 11, 13 and 16; Memorandum DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Part C.

Question 2

Indicator 3.2.2, Teaching standards and pedagogies. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.

You are the school head of an elementary school in Leyte that has no Master Teacher. You observed a Teacher III’s Grade 4 Mathematics lesson and rated Level 4 on the indicator on literacy and numeracy strategies. Your notes show that the teacher had learners read the key words of a story problem aloud at the start, but during the group problem solving, several learners could not read the word problems and the teacher did not help them with the text. In the post-observation conference, the teacher asks what to do to reach a higher level. What is the most appropriate action?

  • A. Explain from your notes that the next level calls for strategies used frequently, give the teacher a copy of the rubric to study, and set the date of the second rated observation.
  • B. Show the teacher where your notes fall against the words of Levels 4 and 5, agree on one reading strategy for the problem-solving part, and observe it in a walkthrough.
  • C. Recommend that the teacher attend the division’s next seminar on reading in problem solving, and ask for a copy of the certificate of completion for the teacher’s records.
  • D. Raise the rating to Level 5 since the teacher is willing to improve, and note on the rating sheet that the teacher will apply the strategy in the next lessons.
Answer and explanation: Question 2

Best answer: B. Points: A = 2, B = 3, C = 1, D = 0.

  • A (2 points, Multistructural). It names the next level’s word and points the teacher to the rubric, but leaves the teacher to work out what that means for this lesson and offers no support before the next rated observation.
  • B (3 points, Relational). It uses the notes and the rubric’s level words to show the gap, agrees on one practice for the part of the lesson where it was missing, and follows it up in a non-rated walkthrough, the formative support DM 089 provides.
  • C (1 point, Unistructural). Training on the topic can help, but it is general, delayed, and not tied to what the observation showed.
  • D (0 points, Prestructural). The rating must rest “solely” on the observation as recorded in the notes; raising it for a promise breaks that rule.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 3.2.2 asks the school head to provide technical assistance on teaching standards and pedagogies to improve teaching practice. The rubric’s Level 4 feature of practice describes a teacher who addresses literacy and numeracy needs “In some parts of the lesson” but fails to do so “in some critical parts of the lesson”, and Level 5 a teacher who “frequently applies relevant strategies” (COT, p. 16). DM 089 requires a post-observation conference that “fosters constructive feedback” (item 58) and provides walkthroughs as “non-rated, formative, and developmental” support (item 37). The option that hands over the rubric names the next level without connecting it to this lesson or following it up.

Indicator 3.2.2: Provide technical assistance to teachers on teaching standards and pedagogies within and across learning areas to improve their teaching practice.

Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, items 37, 55, 57 and 58 and Table 18; PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (2019), Indicator 3, p. 16.

Question 3

Indicator 4.4.2, Performance management. Career Stage 2, Situational, Difficult.

You are the school head of a large national high school in Cebu. Six Master Teachers observe teachers with you under the PMES. Last school year, the ratings a teacher received from different Master Teachers on the same indicator often differed by two levels, and some teachers complained that their ratings depended on who observed them. The first full-period observations of this school year start in three weeks. What is the most appropriate action?

  • A. Ask the Master Teachers to study the COT rubric on their own during the three weeks, so that each of them knows the levels well before the first observations.
  • B. Review the rubric’s levels and the protocols with the observers at a meeting, and have each teacher keep the same observer for both observations of the year.
  • C. Set a school rule that no observer may give a rating above the middle of a teacher’s range without your approval, so that the ratings stay in line.
  • D. Have the observers rate one recorded lesson together against the rubric, compare their notes and reasons, and agree how to read the terms the rubric defines.
Answer and explanation: Question 3

Best answer: D. Points: A = 1, B = 2, C = 0, D = 3.

  • A (1 point, Unistructural). Studying the rubric is the right material, but reading alone leaves each observer with their own interpretation, which is how the ratings came apart.
  • B (2 points, Multistructural). It brings the observers together on the rubric and the protocols, but a review is not a shared reading of evidence, and a teacher kept with one observer still gets that observer’s own leniency or strictness.
  • C (0 points, Prestructural). A cap set by the school head overrides the evidence: the rating must rest on the observation as recorded in the notes and be evaluated against the rubric’s criteria.
  • D (3 points, Relational). It works with the team before any rating is made, ties their agreement to the rubric’s own words and definitions, and makes a teacher’s rating depend on the lesson, not on who observed it.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 4.4.2 asks the school head to implement the performance management system with a team. DM 089 requires ratings “solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form” (item 55) and a final rating “evaluated against the criteria specified in the COT – Rubric” (item 56), and the rubric defines, indicator by indicator, the words that separate its levels. DM 089 does not prescribe a calibration session; rating a shared, unrated lesson is a sound way to meet those rules before the season. The meeting that reviews the rubric and fixes each teacher’s observer seeks consistency without a shared reading of the evidence.

Indicator 4.4.2: Implement the performance management system with a team to support the career advancement of school personnel, and to improve office performance.

Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, items 49, 53, 55 and 56; PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (2019), Clarifications.

Nothing in this guide reproduces or predicts examination content.

Frequently asked questions

What are the levels of the COT rubric?

Nine: Level 1 Not Evident, 2 Building, 3 Organizing, 4 Developing, 5 Applying, 6 Consolidating, 7 Integrating, 8 Discriminating and 9 Synthesizing (PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool, 2019, p. 3). Each position is rated on five of them under DM 089, s. 2025: Levels 2 to 6 for Teachers I to III, 3 to 7 for Teachers IV to VII, 4 to 8 for Master Teachers I and II, and 5 to 9 for Master Teachers III to V.

What COT score is Outstanding?

The top of the position’s five levels: 6 for a Teacher I to III, 7 for a Teacher IV to VII, 8 for a Master Teacher I or II, and 9 for a Master Teacher III to V (DM 089, s. 2025, Table 13). For an indicator rated in both observations, the two PMES ratings are averaged, and 4.500 or more is Outstanding (item 77, Table 14).

Is the COT rubric for SY 2026-2027 the same as last year’s?

Yes, as of November 18, 2026: DM 089, s. 2025 covers SY 2025-2026 to SY 2027-2028 and attaches the 2019 COT as Annex E-1. What changes is the set of indicators observed, nine strands in SY 2026-2027. DepEd’s March 2026 guidance said a separate issuance would set the PMES from SY 2026-2027, and it had not been issued by that date.

Can observers average their ratings?

No. “The final rating shall not be an average of the individual ratings; it shall be determined through reasoned and consensual judgment” based on the observation notes and the rubric’s criteria (DM 089, s. 2025, item 56). Averaging is used only later, on the PMES ratings of an indicator rated in both observations (item 77).

Where can I get the COT rubric?

DM 089 lists it as Annex E-1, COT-Full Rubric (Levels 1-9), with the rating sheet, inter-observer agreement form and observation notes form (item 96). The memorandum links the tools’ folder, which opens with an official DepEd email address; teachers without one can ask their division’s information technology officer.

Sources

DepEd issuances

  • DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, Guidelines on the Multi-Year Performance Management and Evaluation System for Teachers from School Years 2025-2026 to 2027-2028, October 1, 2025: items 15, 18, 37, 39, 41, 42, 44 to 46, 49 to 58, 74, 77, 96 and Table 18’s matrix; Tables 2 to 5, 7 to 11 and 13 to 16; Annex E-1, PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (finalized July 2019): pp. 1 to 3, 6, 9, 10, 12 to 13, 16, 18, 20, 21, 26 to 29, 42, 43, 48, 60 and 61; Annex E-2 (COT rating sheets for SY 2025-2026). PDF.
  • Memorandum DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001, Guidance in the Implementation of the Performance Management and Evaluation System (PMES) for Teachers for SY 2025-2026, March 3, 2026: Parts A, B, C and E, and Annex A (Reflection Journal).
  • DepEd Memorandum No. 017, s. 2025, Interim Guidelines for the Department of Education Performance Management and Evaluation System for Teachers in the School Year 2024-2025, February 7, 2025: items 3 to 7; Annex C-1 (COT-Rubric for Proficient Teacher).
  • DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2023, Guidelines on Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment in the Department of Education, March 22, 2023: Encl. No. 2, item 6.
  • DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2025, Guidelines on the Implementation of the Expanded Career Progression System for Teachers and School Heads in the Department of Education, August 28, 2025: Encl. No. 2, Sec. 37.
  • DepEd Order No. 020, s. 2024, Guidelines on the Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment to Higher Teaching Positions, December 20, 2024: item 45.
  • DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026, Guidelines on Lesson Planning and Learning Design, June 4, 2026: para. 33.
  • DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026, Guidelines on the Implementation of the Three-Term School Calendar in Basic Education, April 16, 2026.
  • DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads, September 7, 2020: Domain 3; indicators 3.2.2, 4.4.1 and 4.4.2.

Law

  • Republic Act No. 9155, Governance of Basic Education Act of 2001, August 11, 2001: Sec. 7(E).
  • Republic Act No. 12288, Career Progression System for Public School Teachers and School Leaders Act, September 12, 2025, and its Implementing Rules and Regulations, August 17, 2026: IRR, Secs. 6 and 20.

Reports and research

  • Philippine National Research Center for Teacher Quality (2019). The PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (Policy Note No. 2019-002). PDF.
  • Ho, A. D., and Kane, T. J. (2013). The reliability of classroom observations by school personnel (MET Project Research Paper). Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. ERIC ED540957.
  • Sartain, L., Stoelinga, S. R., and Brown, E. R. (2011). Rethinking teacher evaluation in Chicago: Lessons learned from classroom observations, principal-teacher conferences, and district implementation. Consortium on Chicago School Research. ERIC ED527619.
  • Stein, M. K., and Nelson, B. S. (2003). Leadership content knowledge. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 25(4), 423–448. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737025004423

Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025 and its Annex E-1, the PPST-based Classroom Observation Tool (2019); Memorandum DM-OSEC-OUHRODI-2026-0001; DepEd Orders No. 007, s. 2023, No. 020, s. 2024, No. 024, s. 2025 and No. 016, s. 2026; and the research listed above.