A DepEd school head is expected to “Use validated feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance” (indicator 3.3.2 of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads, or PPSSH, adopted through DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020). The word that carries the indicator is validated. A parent’s text, a learner’s comment or a colleague’s remark is information to check, and it becomes feedback to a teacher only after the school head has checked it.

DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026 describes the method. It defines instructional leadership as “the deliberate practice of supporting teaching and learning through evidence-based feedback and contextualized coaching to systematically improve quality of teacher/ALS implementer practice and learner achievement” (Sec. III.4.c). DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, the performance system for teachers, sets the occasions: short walkthroughs that are not rated, each followed by a debriefing, and a conference within three days of every rated observation. The test of all of it is whether learners learn more. The rules below are those in force on November 17, 2026.

Key findings

  • Strand 3.3 turns on validation. At Career Stage 1 a school head shows “understanding of the use of feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders”; from Career Stage 2 the feedback used must be “validated” (DO 024, s. 2020, indicators 3.3.1 and 3.3.2).
  • DepEd asks for frequent walkthroughs that are not rated. Instructional leaders are “highly encouraged to conduct frequent, non-rated, formative walkthrough observations, typically lasting approximately ten (10) to fifteen (15) minutes” (DO 016, s. 2026, item 33), and DM 089, s. 2025 adds a debriefing after each one (item 37.d).
  • A rating rests on the observation, not on what others say. A teacher’s rating in a full-period observation is “solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form”, and observers who differ settle on a rating “through reasoned and consensual judgment”, never an average (DM 089, s. 2025, items 55 and 56).
  • A concern about a learner’s safety leaves the feedback route. An incident report goes to the proper disciplining authority “within 48 hours from its receipt”, the fact-finding report reaches the school head within 10 calendar days, and the results go to the division and regional offices within 30 (DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A.2).
  • A 7 is the top of the scale for Teachers IV to VII. They are rated on Levels 3 to 7 of the Classroom Observation Tool (COT), and a 7 converts to Outstanding (5); for Teachers I to III, Outstanding is a 6 (DM 089, s. 2025, Tables 10 and 13).
  • Learning action cells meet at least once a month to work on “shared challenges encountered in the school” (DO 35, s. 2016, items 9 and 17.5), within the term’s Instructional Block (DO 009, s. 2026, item 22).
  • A teacher may appeal a final rating. DO 2, s. 2015 sends the appeal to the Performance Management Team within 10 days of the notice, and also names a Grievance Committee at each level as the “appeals board on all issues relating to the implementation of RPMS”; either body decides within a month (items 69, 71 and 72).

What PPSSH strand 3.3 asks of a school head

Domain 3 of the PPSSH, Focusing on Teaching and Learning, “concentrates on the work of school heads in promoting quality teaching and learning” and stresses “instructional leadership towards improving competence among teachers and outcomes among learners” (DO 024, s. 2020). Of its eight strands, 3.3, Teacher performance feedback, covers what a school head does with what learners, parents and others say about a teacher’s work. The PPSSH writes it at four career stages:

Indicator Career stage Text
3.3.1 1 Demonstrate understanding of the use of feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance.
3.3.2 2 Use validated feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance.
3.3.3 3 Collaborate with school personnel in effectively using validated feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance.
3.3.4 4 Exhibit exemplary skills in effectively using validated feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance.

Read down the column, the indicator changes in two places. From Career Stage 2 the feedback must be validated before it is used. From Career Stage 3 the school head does the work “with school personnel”, such as the master teachers, department heads and coordinators whom DO 016, s. 2026 counts as instructional leaders (Sec. III.4.d). The purpose never changes: every stage ends “to help teachers improve their performance”. Feedback that only records a complaint, or only defends the school, does not meet it.

Learners are the source closest to the teaching: they sit through every lesson. In a large United States study, learners’ survey answers about their teachers “are predictive of student achievement gains”, and “results from a single survey administration proved to be significantly more reliable than a single observation” (MET Project, 2012, pp. 2 and 14). DepEd’s performance system for teachers uses no learner survey: what learners say counts as feedback for the teacher, not as part of a rating.

The PPSSH defines neither “feedback” nor “validated”. DepEd’s other rules fill in both. DO 016, s. 2026 asks that feedback rest on evidence. DM 089, s. 2025 sets how classroom observations are recorded, rated and discussed. DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2026 takes over when a concern involves a learner’s safety. The guide to PPSSH Domain 3 reads strand 3.3 with the other seven.

Improved learning outcomes: the test for every feedback session

Feedback to a teacher has done its work when learners learn more, and a school head can see that in records the school already keeps. The law puts it plainly: the school head is responsible for “Implementing the school curriculum and being accountable for higher learning outcomes” (Republic Act No. 9155, Sec. 7(E)(3)). DO 016’s definition of instructional leadership ends on the same point, “learner achievement”, and it tells school heads to “continuously assess the instructional needs of teachers, evidence of learning, and classroom realities to guide responsive instructional support, coaching, and professional development interventions” (item 41).

The evidence of learning is already in the school:

  • Reading and mathematics screening. DepEd’s academic recovery program aligns its tutorial sessions with learner needs “based on diagnostic data such as the Comprehensive Rapid Literacy Assessment (CRLA), Rapid Mathematics Assessment (RMA), Philippine Informal Reading Inventory (Phil-IRI), classroom-based assessments, and other assessments” (DepEd Memorandum No. 056, s. 2025, Encl.). The RMA assesses “foundational mathematics skills against grade-level competencies” (DepEd Memorandum No. 060, s. 2026, item 6).
  • Classroom assessment and term examinations, under the grading rules of DepEd Order No. 015, s. 2026 and the three-term calendar of DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026. The guide to the new grading rules covers both.
  • The national assessments, whose school results arrive later and describe a whole grade. The guide to the ELLNA, NAT and NCAE explains what each measures.
  • Learners’ daily work: notebooks, seatwork, exit slips. It is the quickest to look at: a school head can read it the same day.

These records give every activity the same question: which learners’ results should this move, and when will the school look? A walkthrough that ends with an agreed practice and a date to look at learner work passes it. So does a LAC session on a skill the CRLA flagged. A freshly painted classroom or a Brigada Eskwela award is worth having, but neither changes how a Grade 3 learner reads. A school head’s week has only so many hours, and the research on principals’ time puts coaching ahead of visits that end without feedback. The guide to instructional leadership sets out that evidence and a sample week.

What good feedback to a teacher looks like

Good feedback describes what happened in evidence, names the goal it is measured against, and gives one next step the teacher can try. DepEd’s rules ask for each part of that, though no single issuance lists them together:

Quality What it looks like DepEd’s words
Evidence-based Counts, quotations, learner work; no labels for the teacher Instructional leadership through “evidence-based feedback” (DO 016, s. 2026, Sec. III.4.c)
Development-oriented Aimed at the teacher’s growth, apart from any rating Walkthroughs give “timely, constructive, and developmental feedback without the pressure associated with formal performance evaluation” (DO 016, s. 2026, item 33)
Stakeholder-informed and checked Learners’, parents’ and colleagues’ views, tested against records and observation “validated feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders” (DO 024, s. 2020, indicator 3.3.2)
Constructive and actionable One step the teacher can take in the next lesson A debriefing to “discuss findings, celebrate successes, and outline actionable steps for improvement” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37.d)
Continuous Recorded, and followed at the next visit Each observation and its feedback recorded in the Performance Monitoring and Coaching Form (PMCF) “to track progress over time” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37.e)

Checking a concern against more than one kind of evidence is what researchers call triangulation: a parent’s account, the learners’ notebooks and a short observation together are stronger than any one of them.

Three questions every comment should answer

In John Hattie and Helen Timperley’s review of the research, feedback is “information provided by an agent (e.g., teacher, peer, book, parent, self, experience) regarding aspects of one’s performance or understanding” (2007, p. 81). “Effective feedback must answer three major questions”, they write: “Where am I going? (What are the goals?), How am I going? (What progress is being made toward the goal?), and Where to next?” (p. 86). The review is about feedback to learners, but the three questions fit a conversation with a teacher. The first is the goal or standard: the lesson’s objective, a Learning Design Principle, a PPST indicator. The second is what the evidence shows now, and the third is the next step.

Compare two comments after the same walkthrough. “Good job” answers none of the three questions. “Your real-life examples helped learners connect. Keep it up” answers two: it says what worked and asks for more of it. “Needs improvement” answers none; “In your next lesson, try a short formative check” answers the third. A comment written from evidence answers all three: “In the 20 minutes I observed, 8 of your 30 learners answered a question. Your plan said learners would explain their predictions to one another. Try think-pair-share before you call on anyone.”

Praise alone teaches little. The same review found that praise “carries little information that provides answers to any of the three questions and too often deflects attention from the task” (p. 96). Specific praise is different: “the jeepney-fare problem got 12 hands up” tells a teacher exactly what to keep doing.

Teacher performance feedback

Three questions in one comment

Four comments a school head might give a teacher. Switch between the way each is often said and the way it reads when it is written from evidence.

Show the comments
  • Goal“Where am I going?” the goal or standard
  • Now“How am I going?” what the evidence shows now
  • Next“Where to next?” the next step
  1. Praise

    After a walkthrough of a Grade 6 Mathematics class

    “Good job! Keep it up.”

    Goal Today’s objective was solving word problems with money. Now When you asked how much change a jeepney passenger gets from a 50-peso bill, 12 hands went up, and 9 of the 10 answers I heard were right. Next Keep one problem from the learners’ own day in each lesson this week, and let them write the next one.

    Answers none of the three questionsAnswers all three questions

    The rule behind the goal: “use accessible language and concrete examples to support understanding” (DO 016, s. 2026, Table 1, Clear Goals and Teaching)

  2. A gap in learning

    After a walkthrough of a Grade 4 English reading lesson

    “Needs improvement.”

    Goal The objective was for learners to name the problem and the solution in a story. Now When I asked ten learners after the reading, six could not say what the story’s problem was. Next In your next lesson, try a short check after the first page: everyone writes the problem in one sentence before you read on.

    Answers none of the three questionsAnswers all three questions

    The rule behind the goal: “Conduct low-stakes and timely formative checks throughout the lesson” (DO 016, s. 2026, Table 1, Checks for Understanding)

  3. Participation

    After a 20-minute observation of a Grade 9 Science class

    “Engage your learners more.”

    Goal Your plan said learners would explain their predictions to one another. Now In the 20 minutes I observed, 8 of your 30 learners answered a question, and the same three answered most of them. Next Try think-pair-share before you call on anyone, and we will count again how many answer.

    Answers none of the three questionsAnswers all three questions

    The rule behind the goal: “Use structured discussions and collaboration activities to broaden learners' perspectives” (DO 016, s. 2026, Table 1, Social Learning)

  4. A lesson plan

    After reading a Grade 7 Araling Panlipunan lesson plan

    “Make your lesson plan more detailed.”

    Goal DepEd’s lesson planning rules ask for formative checks throughout the session, not only at the end. Now Your plan’s only check of learning is the quiz in the last ten minutes. Next Add one quick check after the second source you discuss. I will visit for ten minutes on Thursday to see what it shows.

    Answers none of the three questionsAnswers all three questions

    The rule behind the goal: “Teachers and ALS implementers shall conduct formative checks throughout the learning session” (DO 016, s. 2026, Sec. V.A.7.c.i)

As often said: the 4 comments answer none of the 12 questions. A teacher learns from them only how the observer felt.

The comments, the classes and their numbers are invented. The three questions are Hattie and Timperley’s (2007, p. 86); the rule under each goal is quoted from DepEd’s lesson planning guidelines.

DO 016, s. 2026 also limits what feedback may ask for. Lesson plans are “tools for developmental feedback”, and instructional leaders “shall not focus solely on checking the completeness of documents when reviewing lesson plans” (item 32). Teachers “shall not be required to include components beyond those prescribed in the framework” (item 10). “Make your lesson plan more detailed” is vague feedback, and it can also ask for something the order rules out. The guide to DO 016, s. 2026 sets out what a plan must hold.

Validate a concern before you act on it

Taking a concern seriously does not mean accepting it as a proven fact. Validation is the work between hearing a concern and acting on it, and it has four steps.

  1. Clarify the concern and its source. Ask what exactly happened, when, in which class, and who saw it. Note whether the account is firsthand (the learner) or secondhand (a parent passing on what a child said), and whether it comes from one source or several. A report of something seen is stronger than a report of something heard about.
  2. Check the records for a pattern. Look at what the school already holds: learners’ notebooks and seatwork, quiz and term results, attendance, your own walkthrough notes and the teacher’s PMCF entries. Compare the teacher’s other sections and other teachers of the same grade. Then see the lesson yourself in a short walkthrough. One story is a lead; the same thing seen in notebooks, results and a visit is a finding.
  3. Talk with the teacher, in private. Describe what you found, without a label for the teacher (“the notebooks hold three weeks of copied text”, not “you are lazy”), and ask for their account before you conclude. The teacher often knows the cause: no learning materials, a section of 50, a room shared with another class.
  4. Agree on support and a review date. Agree on one practice, the help that comes with it (a demonstration lesson, co-planning, materials) and the day you will look at the evidence again.

Validation protects both learners and teachers. A concern that holds up gets support quickly, and the learners stop paying for it. A concern that does not hold up never reaches the teacher’s record. DM 089 keeps it out in any case: a rating in a full-period observation rests “solely” on what the Observation Notes Form records (item 55), so a parent’s text cannot lower a teacher’s COT score. What a concern can do is send the school head to look.

Anonymous notes and messages need the same steps, with more weight on the records. For a disciplinary complaint, DepEd and the Civil Service Commission set their own tests for acting on an anonymous complaint, which the guide to filing an administrative complaint explains. For feedback on teaching, an anonymous note can start a check, never end one.

When a concern is not about teaching

Some concerns leave the feedback route on the day they arrive. The test is what the concern alleges, not how it arrives.

The concern alleges Where it goes The rule
Something about the teaching: pace, methods, materials, grading practice Validation, then coaching or a group venue PPSSH indicator 3.3.2; DM 089, s. 2025, items 37 to 40
Abuse, violence, bullying, discrimination or humiliating treatment of a learner by an adult The school’s child-protection response: risk assessment, incident report, referral within 48 hours DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A and Annex A; DO 40, s. 2012
Other misconduct by the teacher, such as unauthorized collections or falsified records The administrative process, through the disciplining authority DO 49, s. 2006; the administrative cases guide

A learner who says a teacher called her “stupid” in front of the class is not describing a teaching style. DepEd’s child protection policy counts as child abuse “any act by deeds or words which debases, degrades or demeans the intrinsic worth and dignity of a child as a human being”, and lists among the forms of corporal punishment “Verbal abuse or assaults, including intimidation or threat of bodily harm, swearing or cursing, ridiculing or denigrating the child” (DepEd Order No. 40, s. 2012, Sec. 3.I.2 and 3.O.9). DO 006, s. 2026 adds that “Corporal punishment or any measures that are physically, sexually, or psychologically harmful, degrading, humiliating, abusive, or violent are strictly prohibited” (Sec. VII.B.1).

For such a concern, the school’s child protection committee assesses the risk to the learner with the Initial Risk Assessment Form (DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A.1 and Annex H). The incident report and intake sheet are confidential, and the report goes to the proper disciplining authority within 48 hours (Sec. VII.A.2). Where the person complained of is school personnel, Annex A sends the case to an investigation under DepEd Order No. 49, s. 2006. A school head who first “talks it over” with the teacher, or asks the learner to face the teacher, has turned a protection case into a coaching session. The child protection and anti-bullying guide sets out each step.

The teacher keeps rights through all of it. The Magna Carta for Public School Teachers gives every teacher in a disciplinary case “the right to be informed, in writing, of the charges” and “full access to the evidence”, and says “No publicity shall be given to any disciplinary action being taken against a teacher during the pendency of his case” (Republic Act No. 4670, Sec. 8). DO 006, s. 2026 keeps the identities of everyone involved in an incident confidential (Sec. XII).

Is it the teacher or the school?

A finding about learners is not always a finding about the teacher. Low participation can come from the activity’s design, which the teacher controls. It can also come from a room of 55 learners, a missing set of materials, or a period cut short every week by another activity, which the teacher does not.

The records separate the two. When one teacher’s sections show the problem and other teachers’ sections of the same grade do not, the need is likely that teacher’s. When every section of a grade shows it, under different teachers, the cause is likely a condition: materials, class size, the schedule, or a skill the whole grade teaches the same way. A condition is the school head’s to fix. The law gives the school head the duty of “Creating an environment within the school that is conducive to teaching and learning” and of “Administering and managing all personnel, physical and fiscal resources of the school” (RA 9155, Sec. 7(E)(2) and (7)).

Coaching a teacher on a condition the teacher cannot change wastes both people’s time. So does the reverse: buying materials for a class whose teacher needs help with questioning.

Choosing the right venue for each concern

Each kind of concern has a place where it can be solved without exposing anyone:

What the evidence shows Venue DepEd’s basis
One teacher’s practice Private coaching after a walkthrough or observation Walkthroughs, each followed by “a brief debriefing session” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37.d)
A pattern in one grade or learning area Grade-level or department meeting, led by its coordinator or head Coordinators and department heads are instructional leaders (DO 016, s. 2026, Sec. III.4.d); “participatory conferences and reflective discussions” (item 37.d)
A need several teachers share A learning action cell (LAC) session “a group of teachers who engage in collaborative learning sessions to solve shared challenges encountered in the school” (DO 35, s. 2016, item 9)
A school-wide trend or condition The school head’s own action, the leadership team and the School Improvement Plan (SIP) The SIP is a plan for “three consecutive school years” (DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, item 2); RA 9155, Sec. 7(E)(7)
Possible harm to a learner The child-protection response DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A

One teacher’s need never goes to a faculty meeting with the teacher’s name or section attached. A pattern that several teachers share, on the other hand, belongs in a group, because a LAC session turns one coaching conversation into a solution for every teacher who needs it. DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016 asks for LAC sessions “at least once a month” (item 17.5), lists school data on “assessment” among the issues they discuss (item 16), and expects members to “report back on the success of these activities in future LAC sessions” (item 19). The guide to LAC sessions shows a year of them.

The desk below takes five invented concerns through the four steps of validation to the venue each belongs in. One of them, a learner’s report, leaves at the first step.

Validated feedback

The concern desk

Five concerns about teaching reach a school head. Pick one, then take it a step at a time to see where it belongs.

The concern
How far to take it

Text message

A parent, by text message, Tuesday at 7:40 in the evening

Good evening. My son says their Science teacher only makes them copy from the board the whole period, every day.

  1. Step 1:Clarify the concern and its source

    You call the parent the next morning and ask what exactly the child said, since when, and about which class.

    Grade 5 Science only, for about three weeks. One learner’s account, passed on by a parent: worth checking, not yet a fact.

  2. Step 2:Check the records for a pattern

    You look at five learners’ Science notebooks from two sections, and at the teacher’s lesson plans for the same weeks.

    Every notebook holds three weeks of copied text and no activity sheets. The plans list group experiments. The learners’ Science materials for the term have not arrived.

  3. Step 3:Talk with the teacher

    In private, you show the teacher the notebooks and the plans side by side and ask what explains the gap.

    With no materials, the teacher copies the readings onto the board so learners have something to study, and the experiments were dropped to save time.

  4. Step 4:Agree on support and a date

    You arrange printed copies of the readings this week. The teacher and a master teacher plan one hands-on activity a week together, and you will look at the notebooks again in two weeks.

    The parent hears what the school is doing, without a word about the teacher’s rating.

Partly true. The copying was real, but its cause was missing materials, which are the school head’s to supply; the teacher needs help putting the activities back.

Review: In two weeks: activity sheets and learners’ own answers in the notebooks, not copied text.

Where concerns go

Take it to step 4 to see where this one goes.

  • Private coachingone teacher’s practiceThis one goes here
  • Grade-level or department meetinga pattern in one grade or learning area
  • LAC sessiona need several teachers share
  • School head’s own actiona condition no teacher controlsThis one goes here
  • Child-protection responsepossible abuse, violence or bullying of a learner
  • No case against the teacherevidence that does not bear the concern out

Exit slips

Exit slips a Grade 8 Mathematics teacher collected after a lesson and brought to you

“The steps go too fast.” “I got lost after the second example.” “Can we do more examples together?”

23 of 41 slips say the steps were hard to follow

  1. Step 1:Clarify the concern and its source

    You ask the teacher which lesson the slips came from and what the slip asked.

    One section, after a lesson on factoring. The slip asked, “What part was hard for you today?” The slips are anonymous: they show a pattern, not who said what.

  2. Step 2:Check the records for a pattern

    You set the section’s quiz on factoring beside the teacher’s other two sections and the other Grade 8 teachers’ sections.

    17 of 41 learners in this section passed the quiz. The teacher’s other two sections did about as well; the other teachers’ sections, on the same quiz, did better. The pattern follows the teacher, not the class.

  3. Step 3:Talk with the teacher

    You ask the teacher what they notice in the slips and the quiz, and what might explain it.

    The teacher sees it at once: every example is worked on the board, then learners go straight to seatwork. The teacher asks for help with pacing.

  4. Step 4:Agree on support and a date

    You agree on one practice: one example worked with the whole class and one in pairs before seatwork. The Mathematics department head models it in a lesson, and you visit for ten minutes in two weeks.

    The support is the teacher’s own request, so the agreement is easy to keep.

Confirmed by the quiz, and asked for by the teacher. One teacher’s practice, so it goes to private coaching.

Review: In two weeks: the next exit slips and the next quiz on the same skill.

Where concerns go

Take it to step 4 to see where this one goes.

  • Private coachingone teacher’s practiceThis one goes here
  • Grade-level or department meetinga pattern in one grade or learning area
  • LAC sessiona need several teachers share
  • School head’s own actiona condition no teacher controls
  • Child-protection responsepossible abuse, violence or bullying of a learner
  • No case against the teacherevidence that does not bear the concern out

Test results

The Grade 2 coordinator, with the Term 1 examination results in Mathematics

In all three Grade 2 sections, fewer than half of the learners got the subtraction-with-regrouping items right.

Learners who got the regrouping items right (%)

HalfSection A41Section B38Section C44
  1. Step 1:Clarify the concern and its source

    You ask which items, how many learners took them, and whether the skill had been taught before the test.

    Four items, taken by all 112 Grade 2 learners, on a skill every section had covered that term.

  2. Step 2:Check the records for a pattern

    You set the three sections side by side, with last school year’s Grade 2 results.

    The same weak spot in all three sections, under three different teachers, and last year too. No one teacher explains it.

  3. Step 3:Talk with the teacher

    You meet the three Grade 2 teachers together, not one at a time, and ask what each sees when learners regroup.

    All three teach regrouping with numbers on the board alone. The school has one set of place-value blocks, kept in the office.

  4. Step 4:Agree on support and a date

    The grade-level meeting plans the reteaching, a LAC session works through teaching regrouping with objects, and you have place-value materials made for every Grade 2 room.

    No teacher is singled out, because no teacher caused the pattern.

A grade-wide pattern with a condition behind it, not one teacher’s fault. It goes to the grade level and the LAC, and the materials are the school head’s to supply.

Review: At mid-term: the same four kinds of items, and the share of learners who get them right.

Where concerns go

Take it to step 4 to see where this one goes.

  • Private coachingone teacher’s practice
  • Grade-level or department meetinga pattern in one grade or learning areaThis one goes here
  • LAC sessiona need several teachers shareThis one goes here
  • School head’s own actiona condition no teacher controlsThis one goes here
  • Child-protection responsepossible abuse, violence or bullying of a learner
  • No case against the teacherevidence that does not bear the concern out

A remark

A teacher from the next room, in the faculty room

Grade 6 Mabini is always so noisy. Their adviser has lost control of that class.

  1. Step 1:Clarify the concern and its source

    You ask the colleague what they heard, when, and whether they saw it.

    Noise through the partition in the third period, most days. Heard, not seen.

  2. Step 2:Check the records for a pattern

    You check the class’s incident records and drop in for a ten-minute walkthrough in the third period.

    No incidents on record. In the room, five groups are measuring and arguing over their results; the talk is about the task.

  3. Step 3:Talk with the teacher

    You tell the adviser what you saw, without naming the colleague, and ask how the period is planned.

    The third period is the class’s Science group work. The adviser offers to move the measuring to the far side of the room.

  4. Step 4:Agree on support and a date

    You affirm the group work and tell the colleague what you found. Both teachers agree on a signal for the days the noise carries.

    The adviser’s practice is the kind the lesson planning rules ask for, and it stays.

Not borne out. The noise was learners working; checking cleared the teacher.

Review: None for the teacher. You check once that the two rooms’ signal works.

Where concerns go

Take it to step 4 to see where this one goes.

  • Private coachingone teacher’s practice
  • Grade-level or department meetinga pattern in one grade or learning area
  • LAC sessiona need several teachers share
  • School head’s own actiona condition no teacher controls
  • Child-protection responsepossible abuse, violence or bullying of a learner
  • No case against the teacherevidence that does not bear the concern outThis one goes here

A learner’s report

A Grade 6 learner, to the class adviser, who brings it to you the same morning

A teacher shouted at me and called me stupid in front of the class. I don’t want to go to that class anymore.

  1. Step 1:See what kind of concern it is

    You note who, what, when and where from the adviser, and stop there. Words that ridicule a learner in front of a class are not a matter of teaching style.

    DepEd’s child protection policy counts as child abuse “any act by deeds or words which debases, degrades or demeans the intrinsic worth and dignity of a child as a human being” (DO 40, s. 2012, Sec. 3.I.2), and as corporal punishment “Verbal abuse or assaults, including intimidation or threat of bodily harm, swearing or cursing, ridiculing or denigrating the child” (DO 40, s. 2012, Sec. 3.O.9).

  2. Step 2:Assess the risk to the learner

    The child protection committee, through the guidance counselor, the learner formation officer or you, fills in the Initial Risk Assessment Form.

    DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A.1 and Annex H. The learner’s safety comes before any talk with the teacher.

  3. Step 3:Report and refer

    An incident report and intake sheet is made and kept confidential, and the report goes to the proper disciplining authority.

    The referral is due “within 48 hours from its receipt” (DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A.2.a). A fact-finding report follows within 10 calendar days, and the results go to the superintendent and the regional director within 30.

  4. Step 4:Support the learner; keep it confidential

    The learner gets psychological first aid or counseling. The case is not discussed in the faculty room, and the teacher learns of any charge in writing, through the investigation.

    DO 006, s. 2026, Secs. VII.B and XII; RA 4670, Sec. 8. Coaching can come later, but it never replaces this route.

Not feedback to coach on. A probable learner-protection incident leaves the feedback route on the day it arrives.

Review: On DO 006’s clock: 48 hours to refer, 10 calendar days for the fact-finding report, 30 for the results.

Where concerns go

Take it to step 4 to see where this one goes.

  • Private coachingone teacher’s practice
  • Grade-level or department meetinga pattern in one grade or learning area
  • LAC sessiona need several teachers share
  • School head’s own actiona condition no teacher controls
  • Child-protection responsepossible abuse, violence or bullying of a learnerThis one goes here
  • No case against the teacherevidence that does not bear the concern out

A parent’s text, step 1 of 4: Clarify the concern and its source.

The five concerns, the schools’ records and every number in them are invented. DepEd does not list four steps of validation or six venues: they are advice, built on the DepEd rules set out above. The learner’s report follows DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2026 (Sec. VII.A and Annex A) and DepEd Order No. 40, s. 2012.

The coaching conversation

A coaching conversation turns a validated finding into a change in the next lesson. DM 089, s. 2025 sets its timing: a debriefing after each walkthrough (item 37.d) and a post-observation conference “immediately after the observation or within three (3) days thereafter”, conducted “in a manner which fosters constructive feedback” and “allowing the ratee to reflect on his or her strengths and areas for improvement” (items 57 and 58). A good one has five moves.

  1. Describe the evidence without labeling the teacher. “Six of the ten learners I asked could not name the story’s problem”, not “your reading lesson failed”.
  2. Ask for the teacher’s interpretation. The teacher saw the whole lesson and knows the class; the school head saw part of it.
  3. Focus on one practice. One change a teacher can try tomorrow does more than five suggestions.
  4. Offer support. DO 016, s. 2026 names the kinds: “instructional coaching, collaborative lesson planning sessions, mentoring on Learning Design Principles and the use of lesson exemplars or models” (item 29). Co-planning the next lesson is one of them. A demonstration lesson by a master teacher is another way to show a practice.
  5. Agree on next steps and a review date, and write them in the PMCF.

Questions carry most of the conversation. The useful ones invite the teacher to think; the others sound like an interrogation and end the thinking.

Ask Avoid
“What did you notice when the learners started the seatwork?” “Why didn’t you check if they understood?”
“What might explain the gap between the plan and the notebooks?” “Who told you to skip the experiment?”
“What could you try in the next lesson?” “Don’t you know think-pair-share?”
“What evidence would show us it is working?” “Will you do this or not?”

The guide to instructional supervision has a full debrief script, the GROW coaching model, and how support changes with a teacher’s experience.

Did the feedback work?

Feedback has not succeeded because it was given. It has succeeded when the next lesson changes and learners’ work shows it. On the review date, look at the same evidence as before: the same kind of seatwork, the same count of learners answering, the same items on the next quiz. The PMCF is where it goes: DM 089, s. 2025 has each observation and its feedback recorded there “to track progress over time” (item 37.e), along with the “Significant incidents observed and feedback provided” (item 39). The PMES guide shows how to fill in the form.

When the same note appears in three entries and nothing has changed, repeating it a fourth time will not help. The need underneath has not been met. The teacher may not know how to do what was asked, and needs to see it modeled. The materials may be missing. The class may be too large for the activity. The time may not be there. Change the support, not the volume of the feedback.

Coaching changes teaching in the research that tests it. A review of 60 studies with causal designs found that teacher coaching improved instruction by 0.49 standard deviations and learner achievement by 0.18 (Kraft, Blazar and Hogan, 2018, p. 547). Programs that coached fewer than 100 teachers did better, 0.63 on instruction and 0.28 on achievement, than larger ones, at 0.34 and 0.10. The authors note that the small programs often served teachers who volunteered, under best-case conditions, and that publication bias may explain part of the gap (p. 572). The number of coaching hours made no measurable difference (pp. 564–565). The studies are mostly from the United States, much of them literacy coaching in the early grades.

Rating honestly on the Classroom Observation Tool

Feedback and rating meet twice a year, in the two full-period observations DM 089, s. 2025 requires for each teacher (item 41). The rating is only as useful as it is honest. Before each one, the teacher and the observer hold a pre-observation conference “to review the Classroom Observation Tool (COT) Rubric appropriate to the career stage of the ratee” (item 49), so the teacher knows what each level asks before the lesson is taught. The COT has nine levels, and each position is rated on five of them. For classroom teachers:

Positions Career stage COT levels Outstanding (5) Very Satisfactory (4) Satisfactory (3) Unsatisfactory (2) Poor (1)
Teachers I to III Beginning towards Proficient 2 to 6 6 5 4 3 2
Teachers IV to VII Proficient 3 to 7 7 6 5 4 3

Source: DM 089, s. 2025, item 18 and Tables 10 and 13. Master teachers are rated on Levels 4 to 8 or 5 to 9; the PPST guide explains which.

A 7 given to every Teacher IV to VII “for peace” is an Outstanding rating on every indicator, whatever the lesson showed. It tells a teacher who needs help that none is needed, and it leaves the Individual Development Plan with nothing to work on. It also makes the rating useless as evidence when a teacher who truly is outstanding is nominated for recognition.

The full rubric is Annex E-1 of DM 089, in the tools folder the memorandum links, which opens with an official DepEd email address (item 96). It words indicator 1.4.2, “Use a range of teaching strategies that enhance learner achievement in literacy and numeracy skills”, this way at the top of the Proficient scale:

Level Descriptor
5 “The teacher frequently applies relevant strategies that enhance learners’ literacy and/or numeracy skills.”
6 “The teacher consistently applies relevant strategies that enhance learners’ literacy and/or numeracy skills.”
7 “The teacher integrates well-connected teaching strategies that promote individual and group learners’ critical literacy and/or critical numeracy skills.”

Source: DM 089, s. 2025, Annex E-1, Indicator 3 (strand 1.4), p. 16.

The step from 6 to 7 is a step in kind, not in frequency. On this rubric, a graphic organizer used in every lesson can show that a teacher applies a strategy consistently, which is the wording of a 6. A 7 also asks that learners use what they read or compute critically. The rubric defines critical literacy as the “ability to critically analyze and evaluate the meaning of text as it relates to community and global issues to inform a critical stance, response, and/or action”, and critical numeracy as the “ability to effectively use mathematical concepts in applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating ideas” (p. 17). The descriptor says “and/or”: one of the two is enough.

Indicator 1.4.2 is observed in both full-period observations in each of the three school years DM 089 covers (Table 7), so every Teacher I to VII is rated on it six times in three years.

Ratings that everyone shares tell no one anything. A 2009 study of 12 school districts in the United States found that where ratings were binary, “more than 99 percent of teachers receive the satisfactory rating”, and where there were more options, “94 percent of teachers receive one of the top two ratings”. Seventy-three percent of the teachers surveyed said their last evaluation named no area for development (Weisberg and others, 2009, pp. 5–6). When researchers later interviewed 24 principals in one large urban district in the United States about why they avoided low ratings, the most frequent answer was time: “Fourteen principals told us that a lack of time was the most frequent reason for not giving a teacher a low rating”. Others spoke of the discomfort of hard conversations (Kraft and Gilmour, 2017). EDCOM II made a related finding about the RPMS-PPST, OPCR and IPCR system that came before the PMES: “Performance management systems generate compliance, not improvement”, in a system with “weak instructional feedback loops” (Final Report, p. 31).

Three rules keep the rating fair. The rating rests only on what the Observation Notes Form records (item 55). Where two or more observe, they settle differences “through reasoned and consensual judgment”, and “The final rating shall not be an average of the individual ratings” (item 56). And coaching comes before the rated lesson, not on it: walkthroughs and debriefings in the weeks before help a teacher prepare, but “Observers are discouraged from providing technical assistance on the teacher-ratee’s lesson plan that will be used in the actual evaluative/rated observation” (item 50). The PMES guide lists the common rating errors and how to avoid them.

When a teacher disagrees

Disagreement is normal, and it is often useful: the teacher may have seen what the observer missed. Go back to the notes, indicator by indicator. Ask what the teacher saw. Consider any evidence the teacher brings. Where the two of you still differ, record both positions and the reasons. A rating that rests on dated notes and learner work is easier to explain, and a teacher who sees how it was reached is more likely to act on it.

A teacher who disputes a final rating has a formal route, though DepEd Order No. 2, s. 2015 names two bodies for it. Its text says “Individual employees who feel aggrieved or dissatisfied with their final performance ratings can file an appeal with the PMT within ten (10) days from the date of receipt of notice of their final performance evaluation rating”, and “The PMT shall decide on the appeals within one month from receipt” (items 71 and 72).

The order also creates a Grievance Committee at each level “to act as appeals board on all issues relating to the implementation of RPMS” (item 69), and the instructions printed on its IPCRF form direct an appeal to “the Grievance Committee at their level within ten (10) working days”, decided “within one (1) month” (Annex F). No later issuance says which body prevails. An appeal filed within ten calendar days of the notice meets both periods; ask the division’s human resource office which body hears it.

DM 089, s. 2025 sets no appeal procedure of its own and lists DO 2, s. 2015 among its references. A teacher may not protest a co-teacher’s rating, though others’ ratings may be used “as basis or reference for comparison” (item 71). Other complaints about work go through the grievance machinery of DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2004, explained in the guide to DepEd’s grievance machinery.

The school head is honest about what the evidence shows and generous with the help that follows. A school where teachers and the school head get along well while learners fall further behind has a pleasant climate and a program that is failing.

What this means for school heads

  1. Treat every concern as a lead. Write down what was said, by whom, and when, and take it through the four steps before you speak to the teacher about it.
  2. Route learner-safety concerns on the same day. Abuse, violence, bullying or humiliating treatment of a learner goes to the child protection committee and its 48-hour referral, not to a coaching conversation (DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A).
  3. Keep complaints out of ratings. A COT rating rests on the Observation Notes Form alone (DM 089, s. 2025, item 55).
  4. Walk through classes regularly. Ten to fifteen minutes, not rated, each followed by a debriefing (DO 016, s. 2026, item 33; DM 089, s. 2025, item 37), with the feedback recorded in the PMCF.
  5. Write comments that answer three questions. The goal, what the evidence shows, and one next step.
  6. Name the cause before choosing the support. Compare sections and teachers; fix conditions yourself, and coach on practice.
  7. Use the right venue. Private coaching for one teacher, the grade level or department for a pattern in it, a LAC session for a shared need, the SIP for a school-wide condition.
  8. Set a review date and keep it. Look at the same evidence again. If nothing changed, change the support.
  9. Rate against the rubric. Review it with the teacher at the pre-observation conference, and give a 7 only for a lesson that showed a 7.
  10. Bring the instructional leaders in. Master teachers, department heads and coordinators share the work at Career Stage 3, and DO 016, s. 2026 names them instructional leaders.

The records to keep: the PMCF for each teacher, your walkthrough notes, the COT forms, the LAC plan and its reports, and, for a learner-safety concern, the incident report and intake sheet kept by the guidance counselor or the designated committee member (DO 006, s. 2026, Sec. VII.A.2). Strand 3.3 sits in Domain 3, which the Domain 3 guide covers; growing teachers through coaching also serves Domain 4, in the Domain 4 guide. The learning environment strand, 3.6, has its own guide to an inclusive learning environment.

How the NASH may test this

The National Assessment for School Heads (NASH) scores each item on a 0 to 3 scale against a PPSSH indicator. The items below are original practice items, scored 3 (Relational), 2 (Multistructural), 1 (Unistructural) or 0 (Prestructural). An option that breaks a rule scores 0.

Question 1

Indicator 3.3.1, Teacher performance feedback. Career Stage 1, Conceptual, Moderate.

A school head receives comments about a teacher’s lessons from learners and parents. Which statement best explains why the school head validates such feedback before using it to help the teacher improve?

  • A. It lets the school head enter the concern in the teacher’s performance rating, so the rating shows what the teacher’s stakeholders think of the lessons.
  • B. It checks the concern against learner work and a classroom visit first, so the support given meets a real need instead of an unproven claim about the teacher.
  • C. It shows the parents that the school takes their concerns seriously, so they keep their trust in the school and in its teachers through the school year.
  • D. It gathers more statements from other parents and learners in the class first, so the school head can show the teacher how widely the concern is really shared.
Answer and explanation: Question 1

Best answer: B. Points: A = 0, B = 3, C = 1, D = 2.

  • A (0 points, Prestructural). A teacher’s rating in a full-period observation rests “solely” on what the Observation Notes Form records (DM 089, s. 2025, item 55). Entering an unchecked complaint in the rating is contrary to that rule and turns feedback into a penalty.
  • B (3 points, Relational). It connects validation to its two purposes: support aimed at a real need, and protection of the teacher from a claim the evidence does not bear out. Both serve the indicator’s aim, helping teachers improve.
  • C (1 point, Unistructural). Parents’ trust matters, but it is a side effect. Validation exists to find out what is true before the teacher is asked to change.
  • D (2 points, Multistructural). It sees that one account is not enough, but it collects more opinions instead of evidence. Ten parents repeating a child’s account do not show what happens in the lesson; learner work and a visit do.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 1 expectations because the indicator asks for an understanding of how feedback from learners, parents and other stakeholders helps teachers improve. From Career Stage 2 the PPSSH requires that the feedback used be “validated” (DO 024, s. 2020, indicator 3.3.2), and DepEd defines instructional leadership as support “through evidence-based feedback and contextualized coaching” (DO 016, s. 2026, Sec. III.4.c). The option that gathers more statements sees the need to check but checks with opinions rather than evidence.

Indicator 3.3.1: Demonstrate understanding of the use of feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance.

Sources: DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, indicators 3.3.1 and 3.3.2; DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026, Sec. III.4.c; DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, item 55.

Question 2

Indicator 3.3.2, Teacher performance feedback. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.

You are the school head of a large elementary school in a city. Within one week, three parents of Grade 4 learners in the same section message you that the Mathematics teacher moves too fast and their children cannot finish the seatwork. The teacher, a Teacher III with good ratings, hears about the messages from a co-teacher and asks you whether a complaint has been filed. What is the most appropriate action?

  • A. Ask the Mathematics coordinator to model a lesson on pacing for the teacher this week, and have the teacher try that pacing in class, so that the seatwork gets finished.
  • B. Assure the teacher that no formal complaint has been filed, and ask the three parents to put their concerns in writing, then wait for their letters before acting.
  • C. Check the class’s seatwork and quizzes and walk through a Mathematics lesson, then share what you found with the teacher in private to agree on one practice.
  • D. Take up the parents’ messages at the next faculty meeting, so that all teachers learn to pace lessons, and name the section so the example is clear to everyone.
Answer and explanation: Question 2

Best answer: C. Points: A = 2, B = 1, C = 3, D = 0.

  • A (2 points, Multistructural). It offers real support, a lesson modeled by an instructional leader, but it acts on the messages before checking them. If the evidence shows a different cause, such as a seatwork too long for the period or a section too large for it, the modeled lesson answers the wrong problem.
  • B (1 point, Unistructural). It is fair to the teacher, but it treats the messages only as a possible complaint. The learners’ difficulty with the seatwork is left unexamined while the school waits for letters.
  • C (3 points, Relational). It validates the concern with evidence the school controls, the class’s own work and a non-rated walkthrough, shares the findings with the teacher in private, and ends with one agreed practice.
  • D (0 points, Prestructural). Naming the section at a faculty meeting identifies the teacher before anything has been checked. It exposes a colleague publicly on an unverified concern, which damages trust and the teacher’s standing and helps no learner.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because the indicator asks the school head to use validated feedback, not only to understand it. DepEd asks instructional leaders for “frequent, non-rated, formative walkthrough observations” that give “timely, constructive, and developmental feedback” (DO 016, s. 2026, item 33), each followed by a debriefing to “outline actionable steps for improvement” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 37.d). The option with the modeled lesson supports the teacher but skips the check that would show what support is needed.

Indicator 3.3.2: Use validated feedback obtained from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance.

Sources: DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, indicator 3.3.2; DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026, item 33; DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, item 37.

Nothing in this guide reproduces or predicts examination content.

Frequently asked questions

What is teacher performance feedback in the PPSSH?

It is strand 3.3 of Domain 3 of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads (DO 024, s. 2020). It asks a school head to use feedback from learners, parents and other stakeholders to help teachers improve their performance. From Career Stage 2 the feedback must be validated first (indicator 3.3.2).

What does validated feedback mean?

The PPSSH does not define it. DepEd’s other rules point to what it takes: instructional leadership rests on “evidence-based feedback” (DO 016, s. 2026, Sec. III.4.c), and a rating rests only on what an observer recorded (DM 089, s. 2025, item 55). Feedback is validated when the concern has been clarified with its source, tested against records such as learner work and test results, seen in a walkthrough, and discussed with the teacher before any conclusion.

Can a parent’s complaint lower a teacher’s performance rating?

Not directly. Under DM 089, s. 2025, a teacher’s rating in a full-period observation is “solely based on the actual classroom observation as recorded in the Observation Notes Form” (item 55). A complaint can lead the school head to observe, coach or, for a learner-safety or misconduct concern, refer the matter under DepEd’s rules for those cases.

How soon after a classroom observation should a school head give feedback?

For a rated, full-period observation, the post-observation conference is held “immediately after the observation or within three (3) days thereafter” (DM 089, s. 2025, item 57). After a walkthrough, DM 089 calls for “a brief debriefing session” (item 37.d). DM 089 sets no deadline for it; holding it the same day or the next keeps the lesson fresh for both.

Can a DepEd teacher appeal a performance rating?

Yes. Under DO 2, s. 2015, a teacher who is dissatisfied with a final rating may appeal within 10 days of receiving the notice, and the appeal is decided within one month. The order names the Performance Management Team in its text (items 71 and 72) and the Grievance Committee at the teacher’s level as appeals board (item 69; Annex F, which counts ten working days). Filing within ten calendar days meets both. A teacher may not protest another teacher’s rating.

Sources

DepEd issuances

Laws

Research

This guide explains DepEd and Civil Service Commission rules for study and professional awareness. It is not legal advice; for a specific case, consult a lawyer or your Schools Division Office’s legal unit.

Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020; DepEd Order No. 016, s. 2026; DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025; DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2026; DepEd Order No. 40, s. 2012; DepEd Order No. 2, s. 2015; DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016; Republic Act No. 9155; Republic Act No. 4670; Hattie and Timperley (2007); Kraft, Blazar and Hogan (2018).