A fishbowl discussion seats a few people in an inner circle to talk while everyone else sits in an outer circle around them and listens. Then the outer circle gets its turn: its members say what they heard, take an empty chair inside, or trade places with the people in the middle. In a Department of Education (DepEd) school, the format suits a learning action cell (LAC) session, where five to 15 teachers meet “to solve shared challenges encountered in the school” (DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016, items 9 and 17.3).

As of November 18, 2026, no DepEd order or memorandum names the fishbowl. DO 35 leaves the activities of a session to the LAC: a “stimulus”, then “collaborative discussion of possible ways forward”, then “individual and group action planning” (item 18). A fishbowl holds all three in an hour, with teachers rather than a speaker doing most of the talking.

That matters because LAC sessions can drift into lectures. An evaluation of LACs in DepEd’s ELLN Digital course for Kindergarten to Grade 3 teachers found some “resembling traditional classes with information transmission style lectures and presentations rather than genuine communities of practice” (Oakley, King and Scarparolo, 2018, p. 1).

Key findings

  • A fishbowl divides the room into talkers and listeners, then lets them trade. In the inner circle “students have a text-based discussion; students in the outer circle listen to the discussion and take notes”, and “Only students in the fishbowl are allowed to talk” (Learning for Justice). Guides for small groups put the inner circle at three to seven chairs (Liberating Structures; University of Delaware); Facing History, writing for a whole class, puts it at six to 12.
  • DO 35 sets the frame a fishbowl fills. A LAC has “a leader, a facilitator, a documenter, and members”, five to 15 of them, and a session moves from “stimulus” to “collaborative discussion of possible ways forward” to “individual and group action planning” (DO 35, s. 2016, items 17.3 and 18).
  • DO 35 sets LACs apart from top-down training. It describes most DepEd training as “top-down processes wherein expert knowledge is shared or transferred”, such as “lectures or workshops during cascaded or echoed teacher training” (item 4), wants “opportunities for both approaches to professional development programs” open to teachers (item 6), and asks school heads to “create safe spaces where teachers can engage in dialogue with each other” (item 21).
  • Philippine LACs have been seen running as lectures. In the ELLN Digital evaluation, teachers gave a mean rating of 3.67 out of 5 to “The LAC Facilitator did most of the talking during LACs”, one LAC had 50 members, and the evaluators warned that “a LAC of more than 15 members will not work as intended” (Oakley and others, 2018, pp. 20 and 32).
  • Talk alone is not enough. A review of teacher professional learning found that taking part in a community of practice “on its own was not associated with change”; the communities that worked focused on “analysing the impact of teaching on student learning” (Timperley and others, 2007, pp. xxvii and xxx). So the inner circle talks about learners’ work, not opinions.
  • The evidence for the fishbowl itself is modest. In a trial with 144 medical students, those in a virtual fishbowl spoke for 48.21 minutes of a 90-minute unit against 35.53 minutes in a seminar (Hertling and others, 2022). Other comparisons are mixed: two found no difference from a student seminar or a lecture debrief, and one found problem-based learning ahead of it. As of November 2026, no published study has tested it in teacher LACs.
  • The 2026 orders keep naming LAC sessions as the place for peer talk. DO 016, s. 2026 calls them “primary venues for peer learning, sharing effective practices, aligning competencies, and co-creating lesson plans” (item 37a), and DO 017, s. 2026 wants them used for teachers “to collaboratively discuss challenges, share best practices, and develop instructional materials or interventions to support learners” (item 27c).

What is a fishbowl discussion?

A fishbowl discussion is a group discussion run in two concentric circles. “The fishbowl can be configured a number of ways, but its defining characteristic is the use of two concentric circles,” write Garrison and Munday (2011). The few people in the inner circle discuss a question with one another. Everyone in the outer circle listens without speaking, usually with something to listen for. At a set point the outer circle speaks, and the session ends with what the whole group takes from it.

Two rules hold it together. Only the inner circle talks during a round, and the inner circle talks to one another, not to the audience. Liberating Structures, a set of facilitation methods, states the second rule as “‘no speeches’ and ‘talk to each other, not to the outer circle.’” Garrison and Munday describe the effect: “All participants are equal, yet the rules prevent a free-for-all, in which all talk and none listen, or a free-for-one, in which one or a few dominate and silence others.”

The inner circle is small. Learning for Justice selects “four or five students”; Liberating Structures uses “three to seven chairs”; a University of Delaware guide suggests a “small inner circle (5-7 chairs)”. The facilitator’s place varies as well. In Learning for Justice’s version, “The facilitator does not participate in the discussion, but poses questions along the way to prompt deeper discussion”.

The method grew out of group-dynamics training, not schoolrooms. “In psychology, the term ‘fishbowl’ first referred to the observation of one group by another group. This technique grew out of early T group experimentation,” wrote Dykeman and Sampson (1995, p. 3), citing work from 1964 and 1974. Those T-groups (training groups) began at a 1946 workshop in New Britain, Connecticut, organized by the psychologist Kurt Lewin, where participants asked to sit in on the staff’s evening discussions of what they had observed, and were let in (NTL Institute). Teachers have since used it for class discussion, and professional learning communities for watching a team at work.

Why use a fishbowl in a LAC session

DO 35 was written to add the bottom-up kind of teacher development to the top-down kind. Its rationale says most DepEd teacher development was “top-down processes wherein expert knowledge is shared or transferred”, such as “lectures or workshops during cascaded or echoed teacher training”, and that there were “fewer instances of bottom-up teacher professional development programs where colleagues study content and pedagogies together, plan lessons collaboratively, and conduct action research as a group” (items 4 and 5). A LAC was to be the bottom-up kind, though a lecture may still open a session as its “stimulus” (item 18).

The LACs that evaluators have watched did not always manage it. In the ELLN Digital pilot of 2016 and 2017, observers saw sessions where “the facilitator did most of the talking and that when one teacher gave an answer, the other teachers would agree with the answer given and not provide additional detail or further elaboration” (Oakley and others, 2018, p. 25). Two LACs at one school had 35 and 33 teachers, and one teacher said, “I learned from the lectures of our LACF [LAC Facilitator] and guests” (p. 30). The same teachers also called the LACs “a safe and supportive space in which they were able to reflect on and discuss their learning and their practice” (p. 1), so the problem was the format, not the idea. A 2025 study carried out with support from the Second Congressional Commission on Education (EDCOM II) heard the same preference in group discussions with teachers in three regions: “Teachers voiced out that they value hands-on, practical training experiences far more than passive, lecture-based sessions” (Rivera and others, 2025, p. 19).

Research on teacher professional development points the same way. A review of 35 rigorous studies by the Learning Policy Institute found seven features shared by professional development that changed teaching and raised student results (Darling-Hammond, Hyler and Gardner, 2017, pp. v and vi). Four of them describe a good fishbowl: it “Incorporates active learning”, “Supports collaboration”, “Uses models of effective practice”, and “Offers feedback and reflection”. The review sets active learning “in sharp contrast to sit-and-listen lectures” (p. 7).

The New Zealand review of teacher professional learning adds a warning. Nearly all the programs it studied included some community of practice, “but such participation on its own was not associated with change”; in several cases participation reinforced “an ineffective status quo” (Timperley and others, 2007, pp. xxvii and xxx). The communities that worked helped teachers “process new understandings” and kept the focus on “analysing the impact of teaching on student learning”. A fishbowl where teachers swap opinions is still talk. A fishbowl where they pass around their learners’ work and say what they changed is closer to the communities that worked.

The evidence on the fishbowl itself is thinner than its popularity suggests. Dykeman and Sampson noted in 1995 that “There has been little research on the efficacy of fishbowl techniques”. A randomized comparison in Germany assigned 144 medical students to a virtual seminar or a virtual fishbowl: the fishbowl group spoke for 48.21 minutes per 90-minute unit against 35.53, and scored 81.4% against 78.1% on a quiz (Hertling and others, 2022). Two other comparisons, with medical and pharmacy students, found no difference between a fishbowl and a student seminar, or among a fishbowl, a jigsaw and a lecture as ways to debrief a workshop (Kagal and others, 2026; Fong and others, 2021). A third, a quasi-experimental study with undergraduate medical students, found those taught by problem-based learning scoring higher than those in a fishbowl (Vasudevan and others, 2024). As of November 2026, no published study has measured a fishbowl in teacher LACs. Choose it for what it does to who talks and who listens, not for a promise of higher scores.

How a fishbowl fits a LAC session under DO 35

DO 35 does not prescribe the activities of a session. It lists what a session “can include”, a “stimulus (e.g. lectures, practicum, orientation, coaching, workshops, development and utilization of instructional materials, etc.) followed by collaborative discussion of possible ways forward”, and fixes only the end: “The final activity of the session will involve individual and group action planning in order to implement agreed activities in the classroom” (item 18). A fishbowl fits that order.

DO 35’s part (item 18) In a fishbowl LAC session
“stimulus” The inner circle’s talk: teachers who tried a strategy say what happened, or two experienced colleagues show how they reason through a problem
“collaborative discussion of possible ways forward” The turn: the outer circle says what it heard, takes the empty chair, or trades places with the inner circle
“individual and group action planning” Everyone back in one circle; each teacher names what they will try, in which class, and what they will bring back

The roles are DO 35’s as well. “Each LAC should have a leader, a facilitator, a documenter, and members” (item 17.3), and Annex 2 lists the duties of each:

  • The LAC leader is “the Principal or School Head”. The duties a fishbowl leans on are to agree “with LAC Members on how to observe or monitor application of learning” and to meet “with facilitator to decide on next LAC topic and to prepare or plan for the next session”.
  • The facilitator “could be the Principal or School Head, a Master Teacher or a senior teacher or senior member of the faculty”, and “This role could be assigned on a rotation basis.” The facilitator “Encourages active engagement and participation of members” and “Runs and facilitates the session based on the plan and ensures that the agreed norms of behaviour are observed”.
  • The documenter, a member assigned on rotation, “Takes down minutes and captures the processes in the LAC”. In a fishbowl the documenter sits outside, where every word can be heard.
  • The members each “Prepares to share in each LAC session”, “Reflects on the implementation” and “Allows LAC leader to observe how the learning was applied”.

Size matters more in a fishbowl than in a lecture. DO 35 puts a LAC at “five (5) to 15 members” (item 17.3). With 12, an inner circle of four or five leaves seven or eight people outside, the documenter among them: enough to give three or four of the listening tasks to two people each.

Three fishbowl formats for a LAC session

The formats differ in who sits inside first and how the outer circle gets its turn. Choose by asking who in the group has something to show.

Closed bowl, then swap. A fixed group sits inside, usually the teachers who tried the strategy agreed at the last session, and nobody outside speaks. After 15 to 20 minutes the circles trade places, and the listeners discuss what they heard while the first group listens. Facing History and Ourselves, a teacher-training organization, describes teachers seating half the class in the fishbowl “for ten to 15 minutes before announcing “Switch,” at which point the listeners enter the fishbowl and the speakers become the audience.” Liberating Structures builds a whole method on the first half: “a small group of people who have made progress on a shared challenge (the “fish”) discuss their experiences while a larger group observes.” Use it when a few teachers have evidence from their classes and the rest have not tried anything yet.

Open chair. One chair in the inner circle stays empty. Anyone outside who wants to speak takes it, and someone inside goes back out. Seeds for Change, a facilitators’ cooperative, states the rule: “If at any time one of the outer circle wants to join the discussion, they simply occupy the empty chair. At this point someone else must leave the circle.” Use it when everyone has some experience of the topic and the group is used to speaking up.

Model, then practice. Two experienced colleagues, often the school head and a master teacher, hold a professional conversation inside: they sort a stack of learners’ work aloud, disagree about one case, and settle it by reading the work again. Then a few members hold the same conversation with their own learners’ work while the leaders listen from outside. The Network for College Success at the University of Chicago recommends a fishbowl protocol “in professional learning communities or during schoolwide professional development” so that “Educators can observe a team in action and reflect on key criteria for effective team functioning.” Use it when the group is learning a routine, such as analyzing assessment results, and needs to see it done before doing it.

The figure seats one invented LAC of twelve in each format. Pick a format and a moment of the hour to see who sits where and who talks.

Three formats, one hour

The room

An elementary school’s Key Stage 2 learning action cell: the school head, a master teacher who facilitates, and ten Grade 4 to 6 teachers, one of them this month’s documenter. At the last session, four of the teachers agreed to try exit tickets in Mathematics for two weeks. The question for this session: “What did the exit tickets show, and what did you change the next day?” Choose a format and a moment, and see where everyone sits and who talks.

Format
Moment
  • School head, the LAC leader
  • Master teacher, the facilitator
  • Teacher who tried exit tickets
  • Teacher
  • Documenter
  • Empty chair
  • Talking now

0–10 minDO 35’s norms: “LAC Implementation Norms”

One circle: the question and the rules

The facilitator writes the question on the board: “What did the exit tickets show, and what did you change the next day?” Then the group reads its norms aloud, and the facilitator explains the format: five chairs inside, for the facilitator and the four teachers who tried the exit tickets, and nobody outside speaks until the swap.

EveryoneEach person who will sit outside is given one thing to listen for: the learner work a teacher cites, what a teacher changed the next day, a question nobody has answered, or one idea to try.

The facilitatorNames the time each round will take and who keeps it.

10–30 minDO 35’s part: “stimulus”

The bowl: the four who tried it talk

The four teachers who tried exit tickets talk with one another: what the tickets showed, which learners surprised them, and what they changed the next day. They bring their learners’ tickets and pass them around the inner circle.

InsideThe master teacher (facilitator), Grade 4 teacher A, Grade 5 teacher A, Grade 6 teacher A and Grade 4 teacher B.

OutsideSeven people listen without speaking and write under their listening task. The school head is one of them, as a learner in the room and not its judge.

The facilitatorAsks one follow-up question at a time (“What did you do with the learners who wrote nothing?”) and keeps the talk on the question.

30–45 minDO 35’s part: “collaborative discussion of possible ways forward”

The swap: the listeners talk

The five teachers who listened move inside and talk about what they heard: what surprised them, what they doubt, and what they would try in their own class. The four who tried the exit tickets move out.

InsideThe master teacher (facilitator), Grade 5 teacher B, Grade 6 teacher B, Grade 4 teacher C, Grade 5 teacher C and Grade 6 teacher C.

OutsideThe four now listen, and hold their answers for action planning. Hearing colleagues discuss their work without being able to defend it is the point of the swap.

The facilitatorStops anyone who turns a doubt into a verdict on a colleague, and asks for the evidence instead.

45–60 minDO 35’s part: “individual and group action planning”

One circle again: individual and group action planning

Everyone returns to one circle. Each listener reads one note from their listening task, in one sentence. Then each teacher writes the one thing they will try in a named lesson before the next session, and the group agrees on what everyone brings back.

EveryoneThe documenter reads the agreements back before anyone leaves: who tries what, in which class, and what learner work they will bring.

The facilitatorCloses on time, and asks the four who tried exit tickets whether anything they heard changes what they will do next.

0–10 minDO 35’s norms: “LAC Implementation Norms”

One circle: the question and the rules

The facilitator writes the question on the board: “What did the exit tickets show, and what did you change the next day?” Then the group reads its norms aloud, and the facilitator explains the one rule of the open chair: nobody speaks from outside; whoever wants to add something takes the empty chair, and then someone inside steps out.

EveryoneEach person who will sit outside is given one thing to listen for: the learner work a teacher cites, what a teacher changed the next day, a question nobody has answered, or one idea to try.

The facilitatorPuts the empty chair in the middle where everyone can see it.

10–30 minDO 35’s part: “stimulus”

The bowl: three who tried it, and the empty chair

Three of the teachers who tried exit tickets start the talk with the facilitator: what the tickets showed and what they changed the next day. The empty chair waits.

InsideThe master teacher (facilitator), Grade 4 teacher A, Grade 5 teacher A, Grade 6 teacher A and the empty chair.

OutsideEight people listen and write under their listening task. Anyone may get up and take the empty chair at any time.

The facilitatorInvites a listener by name if the chair stays empty for long.

30–45 minDO 35’s part: “collaborative discussion of possible ways forward”

A listener taps in

Grade 5 teacher B takes the empty chair to describe the learners in their class who leave the ticket blank. Grade 4 teacher A, who has said what they came to say, steps out, and a chair is empty again.

InsideThe master teacher (facilitator), the empty chair, Grade 5 teacher A, Grade 6 teacher A and Grade 5 teacher B.

OutsideThe talk now includes whoever has something to add. A teacher who tried the tickets can come back in if they are asked a question.

The facilitatorKeeps one voice at a time, and asks the newcomer’s question back to the circle.

45–60 minDO 35’s part: “individual and group action planning”

One circle again: individual and group action planning

Everyone returns to one circle. Each listener reads one note from their listening task, in one sentence. Then each teacher writes the one thing they will try in a named lesson before the next session, and the group agrees on what everyone brings back.

EveryoneThe documenter reads the agreements back before anyone leaves: who tries what, in which class, and what learner work they will bring.

The facilitatorCloses on time, and asks the four who tried exit tickets whether anything they heard changes what they will do next.

0–10 minDO 35’s norms: “LAC Implementation Norms”

One circle: the question and the rules

The facilitator writes the question on the board: “What did the exit tickets show, and what did you change the next day?” Then the group reads its norms aloud, and the facilitator explains the format: first the school head and the facilitator will look at one class’s exit tickets together, aloud; then four teachers will do the same with their own learners’ tickets.

EveryoneEach person who will sit outside is given one thing to listen for: the learner work a teacher cites, what a teacher changed the next day, a question nobody has answered, or one idea to try.

The facilitatorSets out one stack of exit tickets, with the learners’ names covered.

10–30 minDO 35’s part: “stimulus”

The bowl: the leaders show how

The school head and the facilitator sort the tickets into three piles (got it, almost, not yet), say aloud why each ticket goes where it goes, disagree about one, and settle it by reading the learner’s work again. They end by naming what they would reteach the next day.

InsideThe school head (LAC leader) and the master teacher (facilitator).

OutsideTen teachers watch how the two use the learners’ work as evidence, and note one move they could use.

The facilitatorThinks aloud. The point is to show the reasoning, not to give a lecture about exit tickets.

30–45 minDO 35’s part: “collaborative discussion of possible ways forward”

Members try it

The four teachers who tried exit tickets move in with their own learners’ tickets and hold the same conversation: sort, give reasons, name what to reteach.

InsideGrade 4 teacher A, Grade 5 teacher A, Grade 6 teacher A and Grade 4 teacher B.

OutsideThe school head and the facilitator move out and hold back their advice until the four have finished. The other listeners note where the four’s reasoning differs from the one they watched.

The facilitatorWatches the time from outside and steps in only if the conversation stalls.

45–60 minDO 35’s part: “individual and group action planning”

One circle again: individual and group action planning

Everyone returns to one circle. Each listener reads one note from their listening task, in one sentence. Then each teacher writes the one thing they will try in a named lesson before the next session, and the group agrees on what everyone brings back.

EveryoneThe documenter reads the agreements back before anyone leaves: who tries what, in which class, and what learner work they will bring.

The facilitatorCloses on time, and asks the four who tried exit tickets whether anything they heard changes what they will do next.

Closed bowl, then swap, 0–10 min: All 12 in one circle. DO 35’s norms: “LAC Implementation Norms”.

The school, its people, the question and the timing are invented. The last three moments follow the parts of a session in DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016 (item 18), quoted in each panel; the first opens with the norms DO 35 asks a LAC to set before its sessions (item 17.8). DO 35 does not name the fishbowl, and setting its parts on a fishbowl’s moments is this figure’s own.

How to run a fishbowl LAC session, step by step

The plan below is for one hour, the short end of the one to two hours a week that DO 35 “strongly” recommends (item 17.5). The minutes are a starting point.

Minutes Step What happens
Before the session Plan The leader and facilitator take the question from the LAC plan, choose the format, and ask who will sit inside first
0 to 10 One circle The facilitator writes the question on the board, the group reads its norms, and each listener gets a listening task
10 to 30 The bowl The inner circle talks; the outer circle listens and takes notes under its tasks
30 to 45 The turn The outer circle speaks: by the swap, the open chair, or a round of what it heard
45 to 60 Action planning Back in one circle, each teacher names what they will try and what they will bring back
After the session Follow-through Teachers try the strategy, the leader observes how it is applied, and the next session opens with the report back

Before the session. The question comes from the LAC’s own plan. DO 35 has members choose topics “through needs assessment” and agree on which come first (items 14 and 17.2), and the facilitator’s session plan names “the topic, objectives, materials needed, and outline of activities (at the very least)” (Annex 2). A good fishbowl question is open and answerable from experience. “What did the exit tickets show, and what did you change the next day?” works. “What is formative assessment?” does not, because it invites a lecture. Liberating Structures advises encouraging the people inside to “share concrete examples rather than opinions as well as both successes and failures.” Ask them a few days ahead, and ask them to bring their learners’ work.

One circle (minutes 0 to 10). Set two rings of chairs before people arrive: a small inner ring facing inward and a larger outer ring around it, with gaps to walk through. The facilitator states the question, the format’s one rule (who may speak, and when the circles change) and the time each part takes. Then each person in the outer circle gets one thing to listen for.

The bowl (minutes 10 to 30). The inner circle talks to one another. The facilitator asks one follow-up question at a time and keeps the talk on the question. Unless the school head is facilitating, the school head sits outside and listens.

The turn (minutes 30 to 45). In a closed bowl the circles trade places and the new inner circle discusses what it heard. In an open chair, people come and go through the empty seat. In a model fishbowl, the members who will practice move in. In every format, the people who spoke first now listen.

Action planning (minutes 45 to 60). Everyone returns to one circle. Each listener reads one note from their task in a sentence, then each teacher writes the one thing they will try in a named lesson before the next session. The documenter reads the agreements back before anyone leaves.

After the session. Members “implement the proposed strategies or activities in their classroom” and “should be prepared to report back on the success of these activities in future LAC sessions”, and school heads “should support the LACs by doing class observations” (item 19). The report back opens the next fishbowl: the teachers who tried the strategy sit inside.

What the outer circle listens for

Listeners without a task drift. Facing History tells teachers to decide in advance: “What should they be listening for? Should they be taking notes?” Give each person outside one task, and give each task you use to two or three people so the debrief has more than one view. A session needs only three or four of these:

Listening task What to write down
Evidence Each piece of learners’ work or data a teacher cites, and what it showed
Changes What each teacher did differently the next day because of what they saw
Open questions Questions the inner circle raised and did not answer
Disagreements Where two speakers saw the same thing differently, and why
Try next One idea to use in your own class next week
Talk map Who spoke, and who spoke after whom

A talk map shows the most for the least writing. The observer draws the inner circle’s seats on a sheet, puts a tally mark at a name for each comment, and draws a line from each speaker to the next. Jon Simmons, writing in ASCD’s Educational Leadership, describes it: “draw a line inside the circle from the first speaker to the second speaker. Then draw a line linking the second speaker and the third speaker, and so on. You want a continuous web of lines that show the flow of the conversation.” Phillips Exeter Academy, which uses such maps in its Harkness discussions, adds that “frequent participants (even teachers) are often less aware of their intervening”, so “a lot of ink next to a student’s name can lead to self-reflection.”

A map where every line starts or ends at one person is what Simmons calls “a lecture in disguise”. The figure maps the same five people in two invented sessions on exit tickets, one lecture-style and one a fishbowl round. Play each turn by turn.

What the outer circle sees

The talk map

An observer outside the circle draws the talk as it happens: a tick at a person’s name for each turn they take, and a line from each speaker to the next. Map the same five people in two sessions on exit tickets, turn by turn.

Session
Turns drawn

After all 12 turnsThe facilitator took 10 of the 12 turns, and two of the four teachers spoke. No teacher ever spoke straight after another teacher: every line starts or ends at the facilitator.

After all 12 turnsThe facilitator took 2 of the 12 turns, and every teacher spoke. Eight turns came straight after another teacher’s, and lines join seven different pairs of people.

  1. 1Master teacher (facilitator) An exit ticket is two or three questions at the end of a lesson, answered on a quarter sheet.
  2. 2Master teacher (facilitator) It shows you who met today’s objective before tomorrow’s lesson begins.
  3. 3Master teacher (facilitator) Here are three sample tickets for adding fractions.
  4. 4Grade 5 teacher A Do the learners write their names on them?
  5. 5Master teacher (facilitator) Yes, so you can sort them by learner.
  6. 6Master teacher (facilitator) Sort them into three piles: got it, almost, not yet.
  7. 7Master teacher (facilitator) Then plan the first ten minutes of the next lesson around the “not yet” pile.
  8. 8Grade 4 teacher B How long does sorting take for a class of forty?
  9. 9Master teacher (facilitator) About ten minutes, once you are used to it.
  10. 10Master teacher (facilitator) Try it at least twice before our next session.
  11. 11Master teacher (facilitator) Any other questions?
  12. 12Master teacher (facilitator) Then we will look at your tickets next time.
  1. 1Master teacher (facilitator) What did the tickets show you?
  2. 2Grade 4 teacher A Half my class could add the fractions but could not say why the denominator stays the same.
  3. 3Grade 6 teacher A Mine too. Did you reteach the whole class?
  4. 4Grade 4 teacher A Only the “not yet” pile, while the others worked on two harder problems.
  5. 5Grade 5 teacher A How did you keep the others busy for ten minutes?
  6. 6Grade 4 teacher A They checked each other’s answers in pairs before checking with me.
  7. 7Grade 4 teacher B Some of my learners left the ticket blank.
  8. 8Master teacher (facilitator) What do you think the blanks mean?
  9. 9Grade 4 teacher B Some of them could not read the question.
  10. 10Grade 5 teacher A I read my questions aloud, and the blanks went down.
  11. 11Grade 6 teacher A Did reading aloud change what they wrote?
  12. 12Grade 5 teacher A There were fewer blanks and the same mistakes, so the mistakes were real.

Lecture-style session, turn 12 of 12: Master teacher (facilitator). So far the facilitator has 10 turns, and 0 turns have followed another teacher’s.

The people, both sessions and every line said are invented; the counts are worked out from the turns. A line joins two people when one speaks straight after the other, whoever the words were meant for.

Questions that keep the inner circle talking

The facilitator’s questions decide whether the inner circle talks to one another or waits to be told. Ask for a case, not an opinion of the method:

  • “Show us one ticket that surprised you. What did you expect, and what did the learner write?”
  • “What did you do differently the next day because of it?”
  • “Who else saw the same thing in their class?”
  • “Where do you disagree with what you just heard?”
  • “What would you change to try this in a multigrade class?”
  • “What will you look for in your learners’ work next week?”

For the debrief, Liberating Structures uses three questions in order: “What? What happened? What did you notice?”, “So What? What does the data mean?” and “Now What? What actions or first steps make sense?” The third leads straight into DO 35’s action planning.

Norms for a fishbowl LAC

DO 35 lists six elements for a LAC’s norms (item 17.8). A fishbowl gives each a concrete form:

DO 35’s element (item 17.8) DO 35’s question In a fishbowl
Time and Venue “Where and when will we meet? Will we start on time?” Chairs set in two rings before the session; each round timed
Listening “How will we listen to our peers? How will we discourage interruptions when someone is speaking?” Nobody outside the bowl speaks during a round
Confidentiality “What content is to be held in confidence? What can be shared after the meeting?” Learners’ names covered on work samples; what a colleague says about a lesson that failed stays in the room
Decision Making “How will we arrive at a decision? What if everyone doesn’t agree with the group decision?” Each teacher decides their own next step; the group agrees on what to bring back
Participation “Is participation optional? Will we have an attendance policy?” Everyone sits inside at least once over a month of sessions
Expectations “Do we need a method for ensuring each member comes to the meeting prepared with appropriate data or other assignments?” The teachers who sit inside first bring learners’ work

Confidentiality matters more in a fishbowl than in a lecture, because the inner circle talks about lessons that did not work in front of colleagues. DO 35 wants LACs to be “positive, caring, and safe spaces” (item 9). A teacher who is criticized the first time they describe a failed lesson will not volunteer for the inner circle again. Lein (2022), writing about fishbowl coaching among instructional coaches, advises that “In certain contexts, participation in fishbowl coaching should be entirely voluntary,” and that the evidence “should not be used as part of the teacher’s formal evaluation”.

Mistakes that turn a fishbowl into a lecture

  1. The leaders sit inside every time. A school head and a master teacher talking while ten teachers watch is a lecture with better seating. The model format earns its place only when members then practice.
  2. The school head judges. A school head who sits inside and comments on each teacher’s lesson turns the session into an observation. Rated classroom observation has its own rules: DepEd lists “Classroom Observation via Learning Action Cells (LACs)” only as an alternative mode of rated observation, for when national or local pronouncements affect a school’s operations, as in a calamity or a lockdown (DepEd Memorandum No. 089, s. 2025, item 48c). A fishbowl is professional learning, not a rating.
  3. The outer circle has nothing to do. Listeners without a task check their phones, and the debrief has nothing in it.
  4. A few voices take over. Seeds for Change tells facilitators to plan “strategies to ensure that it’s not only the four or five most vocal people that dominate the discussion.” Rotate who sits inside, and use the talk map to see who has not spoken.
  5. The topic invites opinions, not cases. “Is the new grading system fair?” fills twenty minutes without changing a lesson. Ask what teachers did and saw.
  6. No action planning. A fishbowl that runs out of time before the action plans has skipped the part that reaches learners.
  7. The session is used for other business. DO 35 limits LAC sessions to its purposes and prohibits “sale of goods and other merchandise; lending transactions; political and religious meetings” (Sec. V, item 36), and it asks that administrative meetings “be scheduled separately from LAC sessions” (item 17.5).

Fishbowl LAC topics in 2026

Each of these issuances names LAC sessions as a venue for the kind of peer talk a fishbowl holds:

Issuance What it says about LAC sessions A fishbowl question
DO 016, s. 2026, lesson planning LAC sessions “may serve as primary venues for peer learning, sharing effective practices, aligning competencies, and co-creating lesson plans” (item 37a) and as “venues for collaborative planning and reflective professional discussions” (item 27) “Which part of last week’s co-planned lesson went as planned, and what did you change in the room?”
DO 017, s. 2026, Strengthened Senior High School (SSHS) Curriculum “Learning Action Cells (LACs) and collaborative expertise sessions shall be actively utilized as a venue for teachers to collaboratively discuss challenges, share best practices, and develop instructional materials or interventions to support learners” (item 27c) “What did learners in the new electives find hardest in the first term, and what helped?”
DepEd Memorandum No. 064, s. 2025, ARAL-Reading Schools “shall take advantage of the Learning Action Cell (LAC) sessions to provide a platform for those involved in ARAL-Reading to reflect on the Program’s implementation, share strategies and experiences, discuss challenges, and agree on necessary instructional adjustments” (Enclosure No. 1, item 28) “Which learners in your tutorial group moved up a reading level, and what did you do with them?”
DepEd Order No. 003, s. 2026, artificial intelligence (AI) in basic education Capacity building such as In-Service Training (INSET) and “School Learning Action Cell (LAC) sessions for teachers, collaborative expertise, coaching, and mentoring” to integrate AI “effectively and ethically” (Sec. VI.2.3, iii) “When did an AI tool help you prepare a lesson, and when did you have to correct it?”

DM 064 also encourages non-DepEd tutors “to participate in the LAC sessions” (Enclosure No. 1, item 29). A fishbowl works for a mixed group of teachers and tutors: the tutors can sit inside and describe what they see in their small groups. The ARAL program guide covers the program itself, and the guide to DO 016, s. 2026 covers collaborative lesson planning.

Documenting a fishbowl LAC session

The documenter’s minutes of a fishbowl come almost ready-made from the listening tasks: the evidence teachers cited, the changes they made, the open questions, and each member’s action plan. DO 35 asks that team meetings record, among other things, “best practices that were shared during the meeting”, “current or emerging needs and concerns” and “next courses of action to be taken” (item 35.6). The talk map can go into the LAC’s folder with the minutes as a record of participation.

Keep the paperwork light. DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2025 lists the “Learning Action Cell (LAC) Plan and Accomplishment Report” among the forms for teachers’ ancillary tasks under “Coaching, Mentoring, and Provision of Technical Assistance” (Enclosure No. 2), so it falls to the teacher assigned that work, such as the master teacher who coordinates the LAC, not to every member. DepEd Order No. 005, s. 2024 lists “Attendance to Learning Action Cell (LAC) sessions” among teachers’ ancillary tasks and includes LAC coordinator among master teachers’ functions.

Fishbowls in small and multigrade schools

A school with five or six teachers can still run a fishbowl, with two or three inside and the rest outside, and with every teacher inside once in the session. With fewer than five, a school is below the smallest LAC DO 35 describes, “five (5) to 15 members” (item 17.3), and a cluster gives the bowl its listeners. Liberating Structures sets a minimum of fifteen people for its version.

DO 35 lets multigrade schools “be clustered in different ways by the district or division supervisors” (item 17.3) and allows interaction through information and communications technology (ICT) when face-to-face sessions are hard, “particularly when involving clustered schools” (item 17.5). A cluster LAC of three small schools has enough people for a proper bowl, and the inner circle can hold one teacher from each school, so every school’s classrooms are heard. The guide to leading small and multigrade schools covers cluster arrangements.

Online, the format carries over with little change. The inner circle keeps cameras and microphones on, everyone else turns theirs off and writes notes under their listening task, and the turn begins when the facilitator invites the listeners to unmute. Liberating Structures says its fishbowl “works online with no major adjustments.”

What this means for school heads

  1. Use the fishbowl for questions teachers can answer from their own classrooms. Keep a short input or demonstration for new content, and switch to a fishbowl once some teachers have tried something.
  2. Let someone else facilitate. DO 35 lets the role rotate (Annex 2), and DO 005, s. 2024 makes LAC coordination a master teacher’s function. A school head who facilitates every session can teach teachers to wait for the school head’s view.
  3. Sit outside, with a task. From the outer circle, a school head hears what teachers say to one another when the school head is not the audience.
  4. Keep the talk on learners’ work. Ask the teachers inside to bring it. A circle that trades opinions changes less than one that looks at what a lesson did for its learners.
  5. Plan the follow-through before the session ends. Every member leaves with one thing to try and one piece of evidence to bring back, and the next fishbowl opens with it. The leader agrees with members “on how to observe or monitor application of learning” (Annex 2).
  6. Keep the LAC small and protect its time. Split a group of more than 15 into two LACs. DO 009, s. 2026 keeps LAC sessions “within the Instructional Block” (item 22); the three-term school calendar guide sets out the blocks.

The work belongs to Domain 4 of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads (PPSSH), DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020. Indicator 4.5.2 asks a school head to “Implement professional development initiatives to enhance strengths and address performance gaps among school personnel”, and indicator 4.6.2 to “Provide opportunities to individuals and teams in performing leadership roles and responsibilities”; handing the facilitator’s chair to a master teacher does both. For teachers, the Philippine Professional Standards for Teachers (PPST) place the same practice in Domain 7, in strand 7.3, “Professional links with colleagues”, and strand 7.4, “Professional reflection and learning to improve practice” (DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2017). The PPSSH Domain 4 guide covers the domain as a whole, and the guide to LAC sessions under DO 35 covers the LAC plan, funding and monitoring. A school head who wants to hear more in the outer circle can start with Covey’s five levels of listening.

How the NASH may test this

The National Assessment for School Heads (NASH) may set a school head’s decision about a LAC that is not working as intended: sessions that have become lectures, teachers who stay silent, or a school head whose presence shapes what teachers say. The options then differ in whether they change how teachers learn, or only how the session is recorded.

The items below are original practice items, scored 3 (Relational), 2 (Multistructural), 1 (Unistructural) or 0 (Prestructural). An option that breaks a rule scores 0.

Question 1

Indicator 4.5.2, Professional development of school personnel. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.

You are the school head of a central elementary school whose Key Stage 2 learning action cell has 14 teachers. For months, each session has been a master teacher presenting slides on reading strategies for an hour. Your walkthroughs show that few teachers use the strategies, and teachers say they “just listen” in the sessions. Four teachers did try last month’s strategy, with mixed results. You are planning next week’s session with the master teacher. What is the most appropriate action?

  • A. Ask the master teacher to shorten the slide presentation and open a longer forum at the end, so that more teachers can raise their questions about the reading strategies.
  • B. Have the four teachers who tried the strategy discuss their learners’ work in an inner circle while the others listen for assigned points, then close with action plans.
  • C. Suspend the LAC sessions for the rest of the term and use the time for faculty meetings until the teachers show more interest in professional development.
  • D. Require every teacher to submit a written reflection after each session, so that the school keeps evidence of what teachers learned from the LAC presentations.
Answer and explanation: Question 1

Best answer: B. Points: A = 2, B = 3, C = 0, D = 1.

  • A (2 points, Multistructural). It gives teachers more voice, but the session still starts from a presentation, and nothing links the talk to what teachers will try in class.
  • B (3 points, Relational). It builds the session on the classroom evidence the four teachers bring, gives every listener a task, and ends in the action planning that sends the strategy back into classrooms.
  • C (0 points, Prestructural). DO 35 has LAC sessions held “at least once a month” (item 17.5), and DO 009, s. 2026 keeps them “within the Instructional Block” (item 22); suspending them for a term breaks both, and faculty meetings belong outside LAC time.
  • D (1 point, Unistructural). Reflection is a member’s duty under the LAC policy, but more paperwork leaves the one-hour lecture untouched.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 4.5.2 asks the school head to implement professional development that addresses performance gaps, not only to schedule it. DO 35, s. 2016 describes a session as a “stimulus” followed by “collaborative discussion of possible ways forward” and “individual and group action planning in order to implement agreed activities in the classroom” (item 18), and it contrasts LACs with top-down lectures (item 4). The 2-point option opens the floor but keeps the presenter at the center and leaves out the action plans.

Indicator 4.5.2: Implement professional development initiatives to enhance strengths and address performance gaps among school personnel.

Sources: DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016, items 4, 17.5 and 18 and Annex 2; DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026, item 22; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020.

Question 2

Indicator 4.6.2, Leadership development in individuals and teams. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.

You are the principal of a large junior high school. You facilitate every session of the Science department’s learning action cell yourself and sit in the inner circle of its fishbowl discussions. A teacher who mapped last month’s talk showed that most lines ran to you, and the department’s two master teachers rarely spoke. Teachers say they wait to hear your view before giving theirs. What is the most appropriate action?

  • A. Ask the teacher who drew the talk map to present it at the next faculty meeting, so that everyone can see how the department’s discussions have gone.
  • B. Stop the fishbowl sessions and assign the two master teachers to write the LAC accomplishment reports, since they rarely contribute to the discussions.
  • C. Keep facilitating the sessions but speak last in every round, and ask the master teachers to take turns presenting the topic before each discussion begins.
  • D. Rotate the facilitator role to the master teachers, plan each session with them, and take a seat in the outer circle with a listening task of your own.
Answer and explanation: Question 2

Best answer: D. Points: A = 1, B = 0, C = 2, D = 3.

  • A (1 point, Unistructural). It uses the evidence of the talk map, but showing it to the whole faculty changes nobody’s role and may embarrass the master teachers.
  • B (0 points, Prestructural). It ends a working format and answers the master teachers’ silence with report writing instead of a leadership role.
  • C (2 points, Multistructural). Speaking last helps, and presenting gives the master teachers a part, but the principal still runs every session and the master teachers never lead one.
  • D (3 points, Relational). It hands the master teachers a real leadership role with support, and it removes the principal’s presence from the center of the talk while keeping the principal informed.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 4.6.2 asks the school head to give individuals and teams opportunities to perform leadership roles. DO 35, s. 2016 says the facilitator “could be the Principal or School Head, a Master Teacher or a senior teacher” and that the role “could be assigned on a rotation basis” (Annex 2), and DO 005, s. 2024 makes LAC coordination a master teacher’s function. The 2-point option gives the master teachers a task but keeps the leadership role with the principal.

Indicator 4.6.2: Provide opportunities to individuals and teams in performing leadership roles and responsibilities.

Sources: DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016, Annex 2; DepEd Order No. 005, s. 2024; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020.

Nothing in this guide reproduces or predicts examination content. For more items in this format, see the NASH practice questions with answers and the practice sets in the NASH Reviewer app.

Frequently asked questions

What is a fishbowl discussion in a LAC session?

It is a LAC session in which a few teachers sit in an inner circle and discuss a question from their classrooms while the rest of the LAC sits around them and listens with a task. The listeners then speak, by trading places, taking an empty chair, or reporting what they heard, and the session ends with each teacher’s action plan, as DO 35, s. 2016 requires (item 18).

Is the fishbowl method required by DepEd?

No. As of November 18, 2026, no DepEd order or memorandum names it. DO 35, s. 2016 leaves a session’s activities to the LAC and requires only that it end with “individual and group action planning” (item 18). A fishbowl is one way to run the discussion part.

How many teachers sit in the inner circle?

For a LAC, three to seven. Learning for Justice seats “four or five”, Liberating Structures “three to seven”, and a University of Delaware guide “5-7”; Facing History, for a whole class, suggests “six to 12 chairs”. In a LAC of 12, four or five inside leaves seven or eight outside, enough for three or four listening tasks with two people each. A LAC of five or six seats two or three inside.

Should the school head sit in the inner circle?

Only in a model fishbowl, where the school head shows a conversation the members will then hold themselves, or as the facilitator when no one else can take the role. DO 35 lets a master teacher or senior teacher facilitate and the role rotate (Annex 2), and in Learning for Justice’s version the facilitator “does not participate in the discussion”. Otherwise the school head learns more from the outer circle, where teachers are not talking to the school head.

Can a fishbowl LAC session be held online?

Yes. DO 35 allows LAC interaction “through ICT when it is difficult to have face-to-face sessions” (item 17.5). The inner circle keeps cameras and microphones on, and the others listen and take notes until the facilitator opens the turn.

Sources

DepEd issuances

Research and guides

Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: DepEd Order No. 35, s. 2016; DepEd Orders No. 003, 009, 016 and 017, s. 2026; DepEd Memoranda No. 064 and 089, s. 2025; DepEd Order No. 006, s. 2025; DepEd Order No. 005, s. 2024; DepEd Orders No. 024, s. 2020 and 42, s. 2017; Oakley, King and Scarparolo (2018); Rivera and others (2025); Darling-Hammond, Hyler and Gardner (2017); Timperley and others (2007); Hertling and others (2022); Learning for Justice; Liberating Structures; Seeds for Change; Facing History and Ourselves; Network for College Success; Simmons (2020); Phillips Exeter Academy.