A SWOT analysis and a SMART objective do two different jobs in a school’s planning, one after the other. A SWOT analysis sorts what a school knows about itself into strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. SMART is a test for the sentence that says what the school will achieve, by how much and by when. The Department of Education (DepEd) asks for both. DepEd Order (DO) No. 009, s. 2021 lists a “SWOT Analysis” among the planning documents every school keeps for the Quality Management System (QMS). The School Improvement Plan (SIP) Guidebook under DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015 tells schools that “Objective statements should be SMART – specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, time-bound” (Step 6).

A finding on a SWOT board is not yet an objective. The guidebook places four steps between a list of problems and a SMART objective: the planning team rates the improvement areas, sets a general objective, finds the root cause and chooses a solution. Most findings never become objectives. They become the means of a project, or they wait for a later year.

The rules below are those in force on November 18, 2026.

Key findings

  • DepEd names the SWOT analysis in its quality management order, not in the SIP order. The QMS Planning Documents are “1. SWOT Analysis 2. Risk Registry 3. Opportunity Registry 4. Office Performance Commitment and Review Form (OPCRF) 5. List of Relevant Interested Parties”, and “All Schools shall have their own set of Planning Documents” (DO 009, s. 2021, Sec. IX.A). DepEd’s manual for the system prints the form, a SWOT Matrix with five lines in each box. The SIP Guidebook asks instead for a Gap Analysis Template and a rating of improvement areas on four criteria (DO 44, s. 2015, Annexes 3 and 4).
  • SMART objectives are asked for in the SIP and required in the OPCRF. A project’s objective statement says “What you want to achieve and by how much” and “should be SMART” (SIP Guidebook, Step 6). For the OPCRF, “the SMART criteria, which stands for Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, Time Bound, shall be applied” (DepEd Order No. 2, s. 2015, para. 21).
  • DepEd’s own texts do not agree on what the letters stand for. R is “realistic” in the SIP Guidebook, “Relevant” in the performance management order and “results-oriented” in the grant guidelines of 2011 and 2012. A is “attainable” in some texts and “Achievable” in others, and S is “Strategic” in the Individualized Education Plan form (DO 44, s. 2015; DO 2, s. 2015; DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2012; DepEd Order No. 044, s. 2021).
  • The acronym’s earliest known author wrote “Assignable”. George T. Doran’s five words in 1981 were Specific, Measurable, Assignable, Realistic and Time-related, and he added that the acronym “doesn’t mean that every objective written will have all five criteria” (Management Review, November 1981, p. 36).
  • SWOT began as a graded process with evidence, not as a four-box list. In the 1960s method that became SWOT, every manager wrote 8 to 10 planning issues and graded each “with evidence” (Puyt, Lie and Wilderom, 2023, p. 1).
  • A SWOT that stops at the list goes unused. In a review of British companies that used one, every SWOT showed “long lists (over 40 factors on average), general (often meaningless) descriptions, a failure to prioritize and no attempt to verify any points”, and “no-one subsequently used the outputs within the later stages of the strategy process” (Hill and Westbrook, 1997).
  • Clear goals have a measured effect in schools. Across studies of school leadership, “the setting and communicating of goals for teacher and student learning” had a mean effect size of .42, which the authors read as “moderate and educationally significant” (Robinson, Hohepa and Lloyd, 2009, p. 40).

What a SWOT analysis is

A SWOT analysis sorts findings about an organization into four boxes. Two questions place each finding. Can the school change it by its own decision? Then it is inside the school: a strength or a weakness. Does it help or harm learners? That decides the side.

Helpful Harmful
Inside the school Strengths Weaknesses
Outside the school Opportunities Threats

Three trained reading teachers are a strength. A year with no Learning Action Cell (LAC) session on reading results is a weakness. Reading tutors paid by the municipal government are an opportunity, and an access road that floods is a threat.

The method comes from the Stanford Research Institute. Its originator was Robert Franklin Stewart, who led the institute’s Theory and Practice of Planning group from 1962 to 1971 (Puyt, Lie and Wilderom, 2023, pp. 1 and 4). The first version was called SOFT: “Each manager grades, with evidence, these issues as either safeguarding the Satisfactory; opening Opportunities; fixing Faults; or thwarting Threats: hence SOFT (which is later merely relabeled to Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats, or SWOT)” (p. 1). Albert Humphrey was a member of that group, and his own account says the research team was “Led by Robert Stewart” (Humphrey, 2005, p. 7).

The original was more than a list. After the managers wrote their issues, the issues were grouped into families, discussed in groups, given a priority, and assigned to one accountable person with a schedule (Puyt, Lie and Wilderom, 2023, pp. 7 and 9-10). Each of those later steps has a counterpart in DepEd’s SIP process.

The guide to organizational diagnosis models gives the rules for a sound school SWOT, guide questions for a session, and the PESTLE scan that feeds the opportunities and threats.

What a SMART objective is

SMART is a set of five tests for one sentence: the statement of what an office will achieve. The earliest known use of the acronym in print is a two-page article by George T. Doran, a former director of corporate planning, in November 1981. “Ideally speaking,” he wrote, “each corporate, department, and section objective should be”:

Letter Doran’s word Doran’s definition
S Specific “target a specific area for improvement.”
M Measurable “quantify or at least suggest an indicator of progress.”
A Assignable “specify who will do it.”
R Realistic “state what results can realistically be achieved, given available resources.”
T Time-related “specify when the result(s) can be achieved.”

Source: George T. Doran, “There’s a S.M.A.R.T. way to write management’s goals and objectives”, Management Review, November 1981, p. 36.

Two cautions follow the list in the same article. The first is about numbers: “Notice that these criteria don’t say that all objectives must be quantified on all levels of management.” The second is about the acronym itself: “It should also be understood that the suggested acronym doesn’t mean that every objective written will have all five criteria. However, the closer we get to the SMART criteria as a guideline, the smarter our objectives will be.”

The words did not stay fixed. In 2002 Robert S. Rubin looked at the first 40 websites he found on SMART goals. The most common version, on about 10 of them, was “Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant and Time-bound”, and for the letter A alone he listed “Acceptable, achievable, action-oriented, accountable, as-if-now, agreed, agreed-upon, actionable, assignable” (Rubin, 2002). When the acronym reached schools in the United States, it changed again: teachers set goals “that are strategic, measurable, attainable, results-oriented, and timebound” (O’Neill, 2000).

How DepEd spells SMART

DepEd’s issuances carry the same drift. None of them says in its own text what each word asks of an objective. DO 2, s. 2015 adds only that “The SMART criteria are illustrated in Annex G”.

Issuance Where it applies What SMART stands for
DepEd Order No. 81, s. 2011 and DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2012 Objectives in a grant proposal under the PRIME program “specific, measurable, attainable, results-oriented, and time-bounded”
DO 2, s. 2015, para. 21 Objectives in the OPCRF and IPCRF “Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, Time Bound”
DO 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Step 6 A project’s objective statement in the SIP “specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, time-bound”
DepEd Order No. 41, s. 2015 A Grade 10 learner’s plan in a career guidance module “specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, and time-bound”
DepEd Order No. 044, s. 2021, Individualized Education Plan form, Section C A learner’s goals in an IEP “Strategic, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic and Time-bound”
Memorandum DM-OUHROD-2024-0586, Annex B, para. 7 Objectives in the revised OPCRF of 2024 “Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, Time Bound”
DepEd Order No. 035, s. 2025, Sec. X Indicators for monitoring the language mapping process “Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound”

Other texts use the acronym without spelling it out. Two recent ones show how. The inclusive employment policy says “Timelines, weights, and performance indicators must be SMART, appropriate, and reasonable to all employees” (DepEd Order No. 030, s. 2025, Enclosure 1). In the ARAL reading program, the recommended weekly cycle has tutors review assessment results “to determine if SMART objectives were met, partially met, or unmet” (DepEd Memorandum No. 064, s. 2025, Enclosure No. 3, Table 6).

M and T mean the same thing in every version, and S is “specific” in all but the IEP form, which has “Strategic”. A is “attainable” or “achievable”, two words for one idea. The letter that changes most is R, and its three words ask three different questions:

  • Realistic: can the school do this with the people, time and money it has?
  • Relevant: does it serve a priority of the school and the division?
  • Results-oriented: does it name a result, not an activity?

Use the words of the form in front of you: “realistic” in a SIP project design, “Relevant” in the OPCRF. An objective that answers all three questions is safe in both.

What DepEd requires of a school

Document SWOT analysis SMART objectives Source
QMS Planning Documents Listed first among the five documents; updated annually; made on the manual’s SWOT Matrix form The set contains the school’s “quality objectives”, and the OPCRF is one of the five DO 009, s. 2021, Secs. III and IX.A; DM 014, s. 2022
School Improvement Plan Not named. The guidebook uses the Gap Analysis Template and four rating criteria Each project’s objective statement “should be SMART”, and the division’s appraisal tool looks for “SMART” general objectives DO 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Steps 2 and 6; SIP Quality Assessment Tool (2018)
Annual Implementation Plan Not named Carries each project’s objective in the column “Project Objective” DO 44, s. 2015, Annex 10
OPCRF Kept with the SWOT in the QMS set “the SMART criteria … shall be applied” DO 2, s. 2015, para. 21; DM-OUHROD-2024-0586, Annex B, para. 7

The SWOT analysis in the Quality Management System

DO 009, s. 2021 set up a National Quality Management System “certifiable to ISO 9001 standards” at every level of governance, schools included. It requires four kinds of documents. Two are for the whole Department: the DepEd QMS Manual and the Procedures and Work Instructions Manual. Two are each office’s and each school’s own: the Operations Manual and the QMS Planning Documents (Sec. IX.A).

The order defines the planning documents as “A set of documents updated annually which contain the context, risks, opportunities, and quality objectives” (Sec. III). The order adds that “These planning documents should be updated annually (i.e. during strategic plan/start of the year)”.

In the QMS the SWOT analysis is the first step of risk management. The manual issued under the order says the process holder, “with the technical assistance of the RMT, shall create a SWOT Analysis based on the scope of their process (e.g. Bureau, Service, Functional Division, School)”. The RMT is the Risk Management Team. The process holder then fills out the Risk Registry and the Opportunities Registry “based on the data from the SWOT Analysis” (DepEd Memorandum No. 014, s. 2022, Procedures and Work Instructions Manual, Risk Management, items 4.1.1 and 4.1.2). At school level the manual names the process holder as “School/Designated Teacher/Official”.

In a school, the approval runs in three steps (Sec. IX.A, item 4):

  1. The school’s Quality Management Representative secures the school head’s approval of the Planning Documents and the Operations Manual.
  2. The school head approves and signs them.
  3. The school head issues a School Memorandum approving and institutionalizing them.

The order prints no SWOT format, and the manual does. Its SWOT Matrix form has two rows, Internal and External, and four boxes, each with five numbered lines. In a school the process holder prepares it and the school head approves it. DepEd’s templates are downloaded from its QMS page, and “Any alteration of the design of the National QMS IEC materials or any revision made on the documents, manuals, and/or templates is prohibited” (DO 009, s. 2021, Sec. V, item 2). A school uses the form as DepEd provides it.

Having these documents is not the same as ISO certification. Schools without certification “are encouraged to review and streamline their processes and procedures”, and the order deferred the hiring of a certifying body until DepEd issues national operations manuals (Sec. XI.C). DepEd Memorandum No. 068, s. 2025, which added to the system’s manuals in August 2025, was issued “pursuant to DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2021”.

The SIP process names no SWOT

DO 44, s. 2015 and the guidebook enclosed with it never use the word SWOT. In its place the guidebook gives the School-Community Planning Team (SPT) two tools. The Gap Analysis Template (Annex 3) sets each division target beside the school’s performance and asks for “Inhibiting Factors”, “Projects implemented” and “Groups that require attention”. The template for identifying priority improvement areas (Annex 4) rates each area on four criteria; the sample School Improvement Plan has that rubric as a calculator for a school’s own areas.

DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2024 on School-Based Management uses neither word, SWOT or SMART. Check your division’s memoranda for its own SIP template. The guide to the School Improvement Plan covers the whole process and how the division appraises the plan.

The steps between a SWOT and a SMART objective

Step What the planning team does Where it comes from What it leaves
1. List Writes each finding in its box, with the record behind it A SWOT analysis The board
2. Pair Sets each inside finding against each outside finding and writes a strategy where two fit The TOWS matrix (Weihrich, 1982) Strategies
3. Rate Groups related problems into improvement areas and scores each on four criteria SIP Guidebook, Activities 2.1 and 2.2 Priority improvement areas (PIAs)
4. Set the general objective States what the school wants to achieve for each PIA SIP Guidebook, Activity 3.1 Planning Worksheet, second column
5. Find the root cause A project team listens to learners and stakeholders, maps the process and analyzes the cause SIP Guidebook, Steps 3 and 4 Planning Worksheet, root cause column
6. Choose a solution Brainstorms solutions that address the root cause SIP Guidebook, Step 5 List of possible solutions
7. Write the objective States the problem and a SMART project objective SIP Guidebook, Step 6 Project Work Plan and Budget Matrix (Annex 9)
8. Put it in the year’s plan Lists the year’s activities, persons responsible, schedule and budget SIP Guidebook, Step 8 Annual Implementation Plan (Annex 10)

The board below belongs to an invented elementary school. Its sixteen findings go through five stages: steps 1 to 3, then steps 4 and 5 together, then step 7.

From SWOT to SMART

Sixteen findings, two objectives

One school’s SWOT board. Move through the five stages and watch each finding: most become the means of a project or wait, and two become objectives.

The stage

The planning team writes each finding in its box, with the record it comes from. Nothing is decided yet.

A SWOT analysis

Each finding from inside the school is set against each one from outside. Where two fit, the pair becomes a strategy.

The TOWS matrix (Weihrich, 1982)

Related problems are grouped into improvement areas, and each area is scored on four criteria. Strengths and opportunities are not rated: they are means.

SIP Guidebook, Activities 2.1 and 2.2

Each priority improvement area gets a general objective, and a project team finds its root cause.

SIP Guidebook, Steps 3 and 4

Each project design states the problem and a SMART objective: what the school wants to achieve and by how much.

SIP Guidebook, Step 6

  • In play
  • A means
  • Waiting
  • An objective

Strengths

Inside the school, helpful

  • S1

    Three Grade 4 teachers are trained in reading remediation.

    Evidence: Training certificates; LAC records

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with O1

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    A means: Means for area 1

    A means: Project 1: who plans the lessons

  • S2

    Every Grade 4 learner has a reading record from the June assessment.

    Evidence: Class reading profiles

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with T1

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    A means: Means for area 2

    A means: Project 2: sets each learner’s tasks

  • S3

    The PTA has run a weekly feeding day for two years.

    Evidence: PTA minutes and financial reports

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

  • S4

    The school has liquidated its MOOE on time for three years.

    Evidence: Division accounting records

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

Weaknesses

Inside the school, harmful

  • W1

    41 of 180 Grade 4 learners read below grade level.

    Evidence: School reading assessment, June 2026

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with O2

    In play: Rated 4.75: Very High Priority

    In play: Priority improvement area 1

    An objective: Objective 1

  • W2

    No LAC session in the past year looked at reading results.

    Evidence: LAC plans and minutes, SY 2025-2026

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    In play: Grouped with W1

    In play: Part of area 1’s root cause

    A means: Project 1: a monthly LAC session on results

  • W3

    23 learners were absent on 10 or more days in Term 1.

    Evidence: School Form 2, Term 1 of SY 2026-2027

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with T2

    In play: Rated 2.75: Moderate Priority

    Waiting: On the list for year 2 or 3

    Waiting: On the list for year 2 or 3

  • W4

    The science room has two working microscopes for six sections.

    Evidence: Property inventory

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    In play: Rated 2.75: Moderate Priority

    Waiting: On the list for year 2 or 3

    Waiting: On the list for year 2 or 3

Opportunities

Outside the school, helpful

  • O1

    The municipal government will pay two reading tutors this school year.

    Evidence: Local School Board minutes

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with S1

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    A means: Means for area 1

    A means: Project 1: who teaches the groups

  • O2

    The rural health unit offers free eye screening for learners.

    Evidence: Letter from the municipal health office

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with W1

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    A means: Means for area 1

    A means: Project 1: its first activity

  • O3

    The barangay offers its covered court for school activities.

    Evidence: Barangay resolution

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

  • O4

    An alumni association has offered to donate storybooks.

    Evidence: Letter of intent

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    A means: A means, not a problem to rate

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

    Waiting: Not used this cycle

Threats

Outside the school, harmful

  • T1

    The access road floods in heavy rain. Classes stopped on 9 days last school year.

    Evidence: Suspension records, SY 2025-2026; barangay hazard map

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with S2

    In play: Rated 4.00: High Priority

    In play: Priority improvement area 2

    An objective: Objective 2

  • T2

    14 learners transferred out in mid-year when their families moved for work.

    Evidence: Transfer records, SY 2025-2026

    In play: Listed

    In play: Paired with W3

    In play: Grouped with W3

    Waiting: On the list for year 2 or 3

    Waiting: On the list for year 2 or 3

  • T3

    Mobile signal is weak in two sitios, so text notices do not reach those families.

    Evidence: Class advisers’ contact logs

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    In play: Rated 2.25: Low Priority

    Waiting: Recorded, no project

    Waiting: Recorded, no project

  • T4

    Kindergarten enrollment in the barangay has fallen three years in a row.

    Evidence: Enrollment records, 2023 to 2026

    In play: Listed

    Waiting: No pair

    In play: Rated 1.50: Low Priority

    Waiting: Recorded, no project

    Waiting: Recorded, no project

Which box?

Two questions place a finding. Can the school change it by its own decision? Then it is inside the school: a strength or a weakness. Does it help or harm learners? That decides the side. A finding with no record behind it stays off the board.

Four pairs, four strategies

  1. SOmaxi-maxi: use a strength to take an opportunity

    S1 with O1

    Place the two tutors under the three trained teachers, who set each week’s lessons by reading level.

  2. WOmini-maxi: use an opportunity to reduce a weakness

    W1 with O2

    Ask the health unit to screen the 41 learners’ eyesight first, before the tutoring starts.

  3. STmaxi-mini: use a strength to meet a threat

    S2 with T1

    Use each learner’s reading record to prepare take-home tasks at the right level for the days the road floods.

  4. WTmini-mini: reduce a weakness and a threat together

    W3 with T2

    Meet the families of learners with 10 or more absences before the months when families move for work, and agree on how each child will keep attending.

Six improvement areas, rated

  1. Grade 4 reading W1, W2

    • Strategic Importance5
    • Urgency5
    • Magnitude4
    • Feasibility5

    4.75 Very High PriorityTaken as priority improvement area 1

    Reading carries every other learning area, the learners move up in a year, regrouping by level reaches all 180 Grade 4 learners, and teaching is the school’s own work.

  2. Class days lost to flooding T1

    • Strategic Importance4
    • Urgency4
    • Magnitude5
    • Feasibility3

    4.00 High PriorityTaken as priority improvement area 2

    Every learner loses the day. The road is not the school’s, but what learners do on such a day is.

  3. Absences and mid-year transfers W3, T2

    • Strategic Importance3
    • Urgency3
    • Magnitude2
    • Feasibility3

    2.75 Moderate Priority

    It touches 37 learners, and a family’s move for work is only partly in the school’s hands.

  4. Science equipment W4

    • Strategic Importance2
    • Urgency2
    • Magnitude3
    • Feasibility4

    2.75 Moderate Priority

    It serves one learning area and can wait for the next equipment request.

  5. Notices that do not reach two sitios T3

    • Strategic Importance2
    • Urgency2
    • Magnitude2
    • Feasibility3

    2.25 Low Priority

    Few families are affected, and a printed notice sent home already reaches them.

  6. Falling Kindergarten enrollment T4

    • Strategic Importance2
    • Urgency1
    • Magnitude2
    • Feasibility1

    1.50 Low Priority

    Fewer young children in the barangay is not something a school can change.

The four criteria, in the SIP Guidebook’s words
Strategic Importance
“The number of other areas that will benefit when the improvement area is addressed”
Urgency
“The urgency or need to improve the area as soon as possible”
Magnitude
“The number of learners that will benefit when the improvement area is addressed”
Feasibility
“The degree to which the improvement area is within the school’s mandate and control”

Each is scored 5 - Very High, 4 - High, 3 - Moderate, 2 - Low, 1 - Very Low. An average of 4.5 or more is Very High Priority, 3.5 to 4.49 High, 2.5 to 3.49 Moderate, 1.5 to 2.49 Low, and below 1.5 Very Low (DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Activity 2.2).

Two priority improvement areas

  1. 1 Grade 4 reading

    General objective
    To reduce the number of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level.
    Root cause
    Remediation is given to whole classes. No one regroups learners by reading level, and the teachers have not studied the results together.
    Solution
    Small-group lessons by reading level, four days a week, planned in a monthly LAC session on the results.
  2. 2 Class days lost to flooding

    General objective
    To keep learners learning on the days the road floods.
    Root cause
    No learning tasks are ready when classes are suspended, so a flood day is a lost day. The road itself belongs to the barangay and the municipality.
    Solution
    Take-home tasks by reading level, kept ready in every classroom. The planning team raises the road with the barangay.

Two project designs

  1. 1 Grade 4 reading

    Problem statement
    In June 2026, 41 of 180 Grade 4 learners read below grade level.
    Project objective statement
    To reduce the number of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level from 41 in June 2026 to 15 by the end of Term 3 in April 2027.
  2. 2 Class days lost to flooding

    Problem statement
    In SY 2025-2026 classes stopped on 9 days because of flooding, and learners had learning tasks on none of them.
    Project objective statement
    To give every learner learning tasks on every day that classes are suspended for flooding in SY 2026-2027, up from none of 9 such days in SY 2025-2026.

Stage 1 of 5, Listed: 16 findings on the board, 4 in each box, every one with its evidence.

The school, its findings, the scores, the root causes and the statements are invented. The four pairings are those of Weihrich’s TOWS matrix (1982). The criteria, the scale and the names of the worksheet’s parts are the SIP Guidebook’s (DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015); the guidebook does not say how many areas a school takes, and this school takes the two rated highest.

Pair before you rate: the TOWS matrix

Heinz Weihrich proposed the TOWS matrix in 1982 to turn the four lists into strategies. The four sets of factors were familiar, he wrote: “what is new is systematically identifying relationships between these factors and basing strategies on them” (Weihrich, 1982). His matrix crosses the inside of the organization with the outside and names the four crossings:

Pairing Weihrich’s name What it does In the example school
SO maxi-maxi Uses a strength to take an opportunity The two tutors work under the three trained teachers
WO mini-maxi Uses an opportunity to reduce a weakness The health unit screens the 41 learners’ eyesight before tutoring starts
ST maxi-mini Uses a strength to meet a threat Each learner’s reading record sets the take-home tasks for flood days
WT mini-mini Reduces a weakness and a threat together The school meets the families of often-absent learners before the months when families move

Pairing gives a strength or an opportunity a job, which keeps it from sitting on the board as praise. It also shows which findings have no partner. In the example, eight of the sixteen findings pair with nothing, and that is ordinary.

Rate the problems, not the whole board

The guidebook’s list of improvement areas is a list of gaps and problems. It is built from “Areas where there are gaps between the school status and Division targets” and from areas that are “pressing, alarming, stagnating, or worsening”, and the team is told to “group the problems which are related to each other” (Activity 2.1). Only weaknesses and threats fit that description. A strength or an opportunity is not rated, because it is not a problem. It is what the school will work with.

Each improvement area is scored from 5 (Very High) to 1 (Very Low) on four criteria:

Criterion The guidebook’s description
Strategic Importance “The number of other areas that will benefit when the improvement area is addressed”
Urgency “The urgency or need to improve the area as soon as possible”
Magnitude “The number of learners that will benefit when the improvement area is addressed”
Feasibility “The degree to which the improvement area is within the school’s mandate and control”

Source: DO 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Activity 2.2.

The four scores are averaged. An average of 4.5 to 5.0 is Very High Priority, 3.5 to 4.49 High, 2.5 to 3.49 Moderate, 1.5 to 2.49 Low and 1.0 to 1.49 Very Low.

Feasibility is the SWOT’s own line between inside and outside, asked a second time. A threat scores low on it when the school can do nothing about it. That does not rule a threat out. The guidebook says PIAs “are not just limited to issues within the school. It can also be a community situation affecting the school and learners which needs to be addressed and brought to the attention of stakeholders such as flooding and unsafe school water source.” In the example, the flooded road is rated High Priority. The school cannot repair the road, so its objective is about what learners do on a flood day, and the planning team raises the road with the barangay.

The guidebook does not say how many areas to take. It notes that “PIAs have varying difficulties – some can be addressed within a year and some can span for three years”, and that an area set aside can be taken up in year 2 or year 3.

Find the root cause before you write the number

A weakness on a SWOT board is a symptom. “41 of 180 Grade 4 learners read below grade level” says what is wrong and nothing about why. If the school writes an objective at this point, it will choose activities by guesswork.

The guidebook has the team set only a general objective first, such as “to reduce student tardiness” in its own example (Activity 3.1). A project team then listens to learners and stakeholders, maps the process and finds the root cause. In Step 4 the SPT goes back to the general objective, “making sure that the general objectives are aligned with your root cause”.

By the time the plan is submitted, the general objective needs its figures as well. The SIP Quality Assessment Tool, with which the division appraises a plan, rates the Planning Worksheet as meeting expectation when it “presents “SMART” objectives that are responsive to PIAs” and has general objectives “broken down into annual targets” (Central Office memorandum of November 27, 2018). The SIP guide explains how the division appraises a plan.

A second finding from the board is often the root cause of the first. In the example, the weakness “No LAC session in the past year looked at reading results” is rated with the reading problem and then becomes part of its cause: remediation is given to whole classes because the teachers have never studied the results together. The guide to root cause analysis explains the fishbone diagram, the Why-why diagram and the problem tree.

Solutions come next, and the guidebook gives five considerations for them. A solution “Should address the root cause/s”, “Should be within the control of the school”, “Should be economical”, “Should be sustainable” and “Should have the support of the concerned stakeholders/process owners” (Step 5). The strategies from the TOWS matrix are candidates here, each to be judged against the root cause.

How to write the SMART objective

The guidebook’s project design has two statements, one after the other (Step 6):

  • Problem Statement: “The selected area of focus phrased as a problem”, for example “During the first quarter, 10 out of 30 Mathematical Periodical Test papers of Grade 7 students had items that were erroneously checked”.
  • Project Objective Statement: “What you want to achieve and by how much”, for example “To reduce the incidence of erroneously checked Mathematical Periodical Test papers of Grade 7 students by 100%”.

The objective answers the problem with the same measure. If the problem statement counts learners who read below grade level in the school’s reading assessment, the objective counts the same learners in the same assessment at a later date.

Project objective statement

Proof an objective

The draft says “To improve reading.” Press a key to add what its letter asks for, and change whose SMART you are using: the letters do not stand for the same words everywhere.

Whose SMART

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Realistic, Time-bound. DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Step 6.

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, Time Bound. DepEd Order No. 2, s. 2015, para. 21; DM-OUHROD-2024-0586, Annex B, para. 7.

Specific, Measurable, Assignable, Realistic, Time-related. George T. Doran, Management Review, November 1981, p. 36.

Objective statement

To improve reading.

To improve reading by the end of Term 3 in April 2027.

To reduce the number of struggling readers from 41 in June 2026 to 15.

To reduce the number of struggling readers from 41 in June 2026 to 15 by the end of Term 3 in April 2027.

To improve the reading of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level.

To improve the reading of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level by the end of Term 3 in April 2027.

To reduce the number of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level from 41 in June 2026 to 15.

To reduce the number of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level from 41 in June 2026 to 15 by the end of Term 3 in April 2027.

  • Attainable

    Last school year, with no tutors, 9 of 38 such learners reached grade level by the end of the year. With two tutors and lessons four days a week, 26 of 41 is a stretch the school can make.

    Not argued yet.

  • Attainable

    Last school year, with no tutors, 9 of 38 such learners reached grade level by the end of the year. With two tutors and lessons four days a week, 26 of 41 is a stretch the school can make.

    Not argued yet.

  • Assignable

    The Grade 4 project team: three trained teachers and two tutors, led by the Grade 4 chairperson.

    Not argued yet.

  • Realistic

    The tutors are already funded, the three teachers are trained, and the class program has a period for the groups.

    Not argued yet.

  • Realistic

    The tutors are already funded, the three teachers are trained, and the class program has a period for the groups.

    Not argued yet.

  • Relevant

    It answers priority improvement area 1 of the school’s SIP and the division’s target for reading.

    Not argued yet.

The five keys
  • Who and what, exactly?

    “Reading” names a subject. It does not name the learners or the result.

    Written into the sentence.

    Who and what, exactly?

    “Reading” names a subject. It does not name the learners or the result.

    Written into the sentence.

    Who and what, exactly?

    Doran’s definition: “target a specific area for improvement.”

    “Reading” names a subject. It does not name the learners or the result.

    Written into the sentence.

  • How much, counted how?

    With no number, no one can say in April whether it was met.

    Written into the sentence.

    How much, counted how?

    With no number, no one can say in April whether it was met.

    Written into the sentence.

    How much, counted how?

    Doran’s definition: “quantify or at least suggest an indicator of progress.”

    With no number, no one can say in April whether it was met.

    Written into the sentence.

  • Why is this target within reach?

    Nothing says why 15 can be reached. A target with no basis is a wish.

    Argued beside the sentence.

    Why is this target within reach?

    Nothing says why 15 can be reached. A target with no basis is a wish.

    Argued beside the sentence.

    Who will do it?

    Doran’s definition: “specify who will do it.”

    No one is named, so the objective belongs to nobody.

    Argued beside the sentence.

  • Do the people, the time and the money exist?

    Nothing shows that the school has the people, time and money for it.

    Argued beside the sentence.

    Do the people, the time and the money exist?

    Doran’s definition: “state what results can realistically be achieved, given available resources.”

    Nothing shows that the school has the people, time and money for it.

    Argued beside the sentence.

    Which priority of the school and the division does it serve?

    Nothing ties it to the school’s plan or the division’s targets.

    Argued beside the sentence.

  • By when?

    With no date, it can never be late.

    Written into the sentence.

    By when?

    With no date, it can never be late.

    Written into the sentence.

    By when?

    Doran’s definition: “specify when the result(s) can be achieved.”

    With no date, it can never be late.

    Written into the sentence.

No key pressed. “To improve reading.” could mean anything. Press a key to add what it asks for.

The school, the objective and its numbers are invented. What the letters stand for is each source’s, as printed; Doran’s definitions are quoted from his article. DepEd’s two texts give the words without defining them in their text: the question under each key is this figure’s own, in the ordinary sense of the word.

Three letters go in the sentence, two beside it

Specific, measurable and time-bound can be read in the sentence: who and what, how much, by when. Attainable and realistic cannot. They are claims about the sentence, and the project design is where the school proves them.

The guidebook’s Project Work Plan and Budget Matrix (Annex 9) has a place for each proof. “Root Cause” shows that the project aims at the cause. “Activity”, “Output” and “Date of Implementation” show how the result will be reached. “Budget” and “Budget Source” show that the money exists. “Person Responsible” is Doran’s lost letter, Assignable: who will do it.

For the OPCRF’s “Relevant”, the proof is the line from the objective up to the plans above it. The guidebook asks the SPT to check that the AIP rests on the SIP’s objectives and that “the SIP is aligned to the objectives and targets of the Division goals” (Step 8).

Setting the number

The Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads (PPSSH) ask a school head to “Set achievable and challenging learning outcomes to support learner achievement and the attainment of other performance indicators” (DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, indicator 3.4.1). Achievable and challenging pull against each other, and research supports both halves.

Edwin Locke and Gary Latham summarized 35 years of goal-setting studies in 2002: “specific, difficult goals consistently led to higher performance than urging people to do their best”, with effect sizes in meta-analyses from .42 to .80 (p. 706). The same paper warns that “Goal specificity in itself does not necessarily lead to high performance because specific goals vary in difficulty.” A SMART objective with an easy target is specific and still weak. The synthesis of school leadership studies states the other limit: “If goals are seen to be too difficult or too easy, they will not be motivating” (Robinson, Hohepa and Lloyd, 2009, p. 109).

Three facts help a school place the number:

  1. The baseline. The count on the first day of the project, from a record: 41 of 180 learners in June 2026.
  2. Last year’s movement. How many such learners reached grade level in a year with no project. In the example, 9 of 38.
  3. What the project adds. Two tutors, lessons four days a week, groups by reading level.

A target of 15 means 26 learners must move, nearly three times last year’s 9. That is a stretch with a reason behind it. A target of zero has no reason behind it, and a target of 32, which repeats last year, would need no project.

The guidebook adds two rules. The target is not the school head’s alone: “Targets to be set should be discussed and agreed upon by the SPT based on the school context.” A PIA that takes more than a year gets a target for each year: “set incremental targets for each year” (Step 6).

Write the deadline as the school calendar has it. School Year 2026-2027 has three terms, and Term 3 ends on April 8, 2027 (DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026, para. 4 and Annex B), so an objective for this school year ends on a term, not on a quarter.

Six common faults

Fault Example Fix
No number “To improve reading.” Add the count now and the count wanted, from the same assessment
An activity written as an objective “To conduct a reading camp for Grade 4 learners in January 2027.” Name the change in learners. The camp goes in the Activity column
A percentage with no base “To increase readers by 5%.” Give the two counts beside the percentage: from 139 to 165 of 180 learners. The guidebook’s own examples give a percentage alone
No date “To reduce the number of learners who read below grade level from 41 to 15.” Add the term and the month
A result the school does not control “To have the access road repaired by December 2026.” Write the part the school controls: learning tasks on every flood day
Too many objectives Eleven objectives in one plan One objective for each project design, and fewer projects

Schools often write activities as objectives. “Most school goals are process oriented—geared toward activities, programs, and instructional methods,” Jan O’Neill wrote of schools in the United States (O’Neill, 2000). An activity can pass most of the five tests, since a reading camp has a group, a count and a date. It fails the guidebook’s definition, which asks “What you want to achieve”, and the guidebook defines activities apart from objectives as what “you need to do to implement your solution”. The guide to improved learning outcomes shows how to tell an output from an outcome.

On the last fault, the guidebook’s rule is that “One project design should contain only one solution.” O’Neill quotes the action researcher Emily Calhoun: “I’ve seen as many as 11 goals in a school improvement plan. As a result, it’s impossible for the school to achieve any of them.”

The same objective in the AIP and the OPCRF

One objective appears in three documents, and the wording changes with the form.

Document How the objective is written Where
Project design (SIP) “To reduce the number of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level from 41 in June 2026 to 15 by the end of Term 3 in April 2027.” Annex 9, Project Objective Statement
Annual Implementation Plan The same statement, with the output for the year, the activities, the persons responsible, the schedule and the budget Annex 10
OPCRF “Reduced the number of Grade 4 learners who read below grade level”, with 15 learners as the target’s value and April 2027 in the Timeline column Objectives, under a key result area

The OPCRF changes the verb. Under the revised form of 2024, “Objectives are action verbs written in past tense”, and the SMART criteria apply (DM-OUHROD-2024-0586, Annex B, para. 7). The date moves out of the sentence into its own column, since the timeline “shall define the target date for accomplishing each of the performance Objectives” (Annex B, para. 8). The number goes into the performance target, which the guidelines split into a value and a description (Annex B, para. 10).

The guidebook expects this carrying over. Its note to school heads, teachers and staff says: “Your contribution in planning and implementing the SIP and AIP should be included in the Results-based Performance Management System (RPMS).” It adds: “Make sure it is aligned with the objectives and targets of the projects in the SIP and AIP” (Step 6). The order names the forms: the work “can be incorporated in the Individual Performance Commitment and Review Form (IPCRF) of teachers and staff or in the Office Performance Commitment and Review Form (OPCRF) of the school head” (DO 44, s. 2015, para. 6). The QMS order closes the circle. A school’s Risk Management Team is to “Ensure documentation and clear implementation of quality objectives through the review of targets and indicators in the OPCRF” (DO 009, s. 2021, Sec. VIII.D.c).

The guide to the OPCRF explains the form’s parts, weights and rating.

What research says about the two tools

SWOT analysis

Terry Hill and Roy Westbrook reviewed 50 British manufacturing companies that had worked with consultants under a government scheme. More than 20 had used a SWOT, and the results had the faults quoted in the key findings above: long lists, vague descriptions, no priorities, no checking of any point, and no later use. The authors concluded that “The continued use of the SWOT analysis, therefore, needs to be questioned” (Hill and Westbrook, 1997).

A review of a decade of academic articles came to a milder view. “Research supports SWOT analysis as a tool for planning purposes,” it said, though “past research continues to lack quantifiable findings on the success of the SWOT analysis” (Helms and Nixon, 2010).

An early article on SWOT in schools names a risk that any school head will recognize: “SWOTs usually reflect a person’s existing position and viewpoint, which can be misused to justify a previously decided course of action rather than used as a means to open up new possibilities” (Balamuralikrishna and Dugger, 1995).

Each fault has a remedy in the method’s first design and in the SIP Guidebook:

Fault found in practice Remedy
Long lists Keep each box short, and rate the problems on four criteria
Vague descriptions Write each finding with its number and its record
No checking Admit a finding only with evidence, as the first version did
One person’s view Fill the board with the SPT, which seats a student, a teacher, a parent and a barangay or local government representative beside the school head
No later use Carry each finding to a strategy, a rating or a written decision to wait

SMART objectives and goal setting

The research behind SMART is research on goals, and it covers more than the five letters. Goals work through attention and effort, and they need feedback: “For goals to be effective, people need summary feedback that reveals progress in relation to their goals” (Locke and Latham, 2002, p. 708). A SMART objective that is measured once, at the end of the year, gives no feedback. The guidebook’s rule covers this: each project is “monitored at least twice by the SPT – during the middle and during the end of the implementation period” (Step 6).

Goals also need the people who will reach them. “The goal–performance relationship is strongest when people are committed to their goals” (p. 707). The synthesis of school leadership studies lists three things leaders do: they “establish the importance of the goals”, “ensure that the goals are clear” and “develop staff commitment to the goals” (Robinson, Hohepa and Lloyd, 2009, p. 40). It adds that “Goals are clearer when they include a target and a timeframe” (p. 108).

Specific goals have costs too. Four management scholars argued in 2009 that the harm done by goal setting had been largely ignored. The side effects they listed include a narrow focus that neglects areas outside the goal, more unethical behavior, and riskier choices. They proposed treating goal setting as “a prescription-strength medication that requires careful dosing, consideration of harmful side effects, and close supervision” (Ordóñez, Schweitzer, Galinsky and Bazerman, 2009). The school leadership synthesis lists the same two dangers in a table of common problems: “Accountability for goal attainment can lead to biased and inaccurate reporting” and “Important outcomes that are not set as goals may be ignored” (Robinson, Hohepa and Lloyd, 2009, p. 111).

A reading target can be met on paper by an easier test or a generous rater, so the second assessment should be the same tool as the first, given the same way. A school that counts only Grade 4 reading may stop watching Grade 5. The SPT’s monitoring at the middle of the project is the place to ask what the objective has pushed aside.

Rubin wrote of the acronym’s drift a sentence that applies to SWOT as well: “when the tool becomes the practice, and the thinking behind it wanes, this is anything but smart” (Rubin, 2002).

What this means for school heads

Before the planning session:

  1. Gather the records first: the School-Community Data Template, the School Report Card, assessment results, School Forms and the division’s targets.
  2. For the QMS Planning Documents, use the SWOT Matrix form of DepEd’s manual and update it at the start of the year (DO 009, s. 2021, Sec. IX.A; DM 014, s. 2022).

With the SPT:

  1. Admit a finding to the board only with its number and its record.
  2. Test each finding’s box: if the school can change it by its own decision, it is inside.
  3. Pair the boxes and write the strategies.
  4. Group the weaknesses and threats into improvement areas, and rate them on the four criteria (Annex 4).
  5. Record the areas you set aside. They are the list for year 2 and year 3.

With the project teams:

  1. Set the general objective, then find the root cause before any target is written.
  2. Write the problem statement and the objective with the same measure.
  3. Agree on the target with the SPT, from the baseline, last year’s movement and what the project adds.
  4. Fill in the person responsible, the dates and the budget source for every activity (Annex 9).

Through the year:

  1. Carry the objective into the AIP and into your OPCRF, in past tense.
  2. Monitor each project at least at its middle and at its end, with the same assessment as the baseline.

Records to keep: the SWOT board with its evidence, the Gap Analysis Template, the rating matrix, the Planning Worksheet, each project design, the minutes of the SPT’s meetings, and the monitoring results.

This work serves four strands of the PPSSH (DO 024, s. 2020):

Strand Indicator Where it shows
1.2 School planning and implementation 1.2.1 “Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the phases of development and implementation of school plans aligned with institutional goals and policies.” Knowing the steps between the board and the objective
1.2 School planning and implementation 1.2.2 “Develop and implement with the planning team school plans aligned with institutional goals and policies.” Rating, root cause and objective done with the SPT
2.6 Emerging opportunities and challenges 2.6.1 “Identify emerging opportunities and challenges in addressing the needs of learners, school personnel and other stakeholders.” The outside half of the SWOT
3.4 Learner achievement and other performance indicators 3.4.1 “Set achievable and challenging learning outcomes to support learner achievement and the attainment of other performance indicators.” The target in the objective
1.7 Monitoring and evaluation processes and tools 1.7.1 “Display knowledge and understanding of monitoring and evaluation processes and tools to promote learner achievement.” Monitoring of each project at its middle and at its end

The guides to PPSSH Domain 1, Domain 2 and Domain 3 cover these strands in full.

How the NASH may test this

The items below are original practice items, scored 3 (Relational), 2 (Multistructural), 1 (Unistructural) or 0 (Prestructural). An option that breaks a rule scores 0.

Question 1

Indicator 3.4.1, Learner achievement and other performance indicators. Career Stage 1, Situational, Moderate.

You are the teacher-in-charge of a three-teacher multigrade elementary school on a small island. The school’s SWOT lists as a weakness that 18 of the 60 learners in Grades 4 to 6 met the grade-level numeracy standard at the start of the school year, up from 14 a year earlier. The division’s target is 90 percent. A project team traced the cause to a class program with no time for guided practice, and the planning team judges that about twelve more learners can reach the standard each year once it is fixed. Which project objective statement is the most appropriate for the plan’s first year?

  • A. To raise the share of Grade 4 to 6 learners who meet the numeracy standard from 30 percent to the division’s target of 90 percent by the end of the third term of this school year.
  • B. To give mathematics workbooks to the learners in Grades 4 to 6 and hold a numeracy contest each term so that they have more practice materials and a reason to use them.
  • C. To raise the number of Grade 4 to 6 learners who meet the numeracy standard from 18 to 30 of 60 by the end of the third term, with a higher target for each of the next two years.
  • D. To improve the numeracy of the learners in Grades 4 to 6 during the three years of the plan, so that the school contributes more to the division’s target than it does now.
Answer and explanation: Question 1

Best answer: C. Points: A = 2, B = 0, C = 3, D = 1.

  • A (2 points, Multistructural). It is specific, measurable and time-bound, and it looks to the division’s target. But it asks for 36 more learners in one year where the planning team judges twelve within reach, so the target does not come from the school’s context.
  • B (0 points, Prestructural). It lists activities, not what the learners will achieve or by how much. Neither activity answers the cause the project team found, the class program’s lack of time for guided practice.
  • C (3 points, Relational). It says what the school wants to achieve, by how much and by when, from the school’s own baseline. Twelve more learners is three times last year’s gain and within what the planning team judges attainable, and the target rises in the second and third years.
  • D (1 point, Unistructural). It names the result the school wants, which is a general objective. A project objective statement also says by how much, and this one gives no figure against which the planning team can check progress.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 1 expectations because indicator 3.4.1 asks the aspiring school head to set learning outcomes that are achievable and challenging. Step 6 of the School Improvement Plan Guidebook (DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015) defines the project objective statement as “What you want to achieve and by how much”, says objective statements should be SMART (specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, time-bound), with targets “discussed and agreed upon by the SPT based on the school context”, and asks for incremental targets each year when a priority improvement area spans more than one. The statement that jumps to the division’s 90 percent is measurable and time-bound, but it is not attainable from this school’s baseline.

Indicator 3.4.1: Set achievable and challenging learning outcomes to support learner achievement and the attainment of other performance indicators.

Sources: DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, School Improvement Plan Guidebook, Activity 3.1 and Step 6; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020.

Question 2

Indicator 1.2.2, School planning and implementation. Career Stage 2, Situational, Moderate.

You are the school head of a large junior high school in a highly urbanized city. Your School-Community Planning Team has finished a SWOT with teachers, parents, learners and barangay officials. It lists nine weaknesses and five threats, among them a Grade 7 failure rate of 12 percent in mathematics and flooding on the street outside the gate. To finish the School Improvement Plan this week, a team member proposes writing all fourteen items into it as the plan’s objectives. What is the most appropriate action?

  • A. Ask the team to rate each item for strategic importance, urgency, magnitude and feasibility, set a general objective for each priority, and have project teams find root causes before targets are set.
  • B. Ask the team to keep all fourteen items as objectives but add a baseline figure and a deadline to each one, so that the objectives in the plan are specific, measurable and time-bound.
  • C. Ask the team to rate each item for strategic importance, urgency, magnitude and feasibility, and write a measurable, time-bound objective for each priority at the same meeting from the figures already recorded in the SWOT.
  • D. Write the objectives yourself from the previous plan, which the division has already reviewed, and attach the SWOT as an annex so that the plan shows the stakeholders were consulted.
Answer and explanation: Question 2

Best answer: A. Points: A = 3, B = 1, C = 2, D = 0.

  • A (3 points, Relational). It takes the steps between a list and an objective, and takes them with the team: the items are rated on the four criteria, each priority gets a general objective, and a project team finds the root cause before a target is set.
  • B (1 point, Unistructural). A figure and a deadline make each objective measurable and time-bound. But nothing is prioritized and no cause is examined, so the plan carries fourteen targets of equal weight.
  • C (2 points, Multistructural). The team prioritizes on the four criteria and writes its objectives in SMART form. But no project team has looked for a root cause, so the targets and the solutions that follow may address only symptoms.
  • D (0 points, Prestructural). It sets aside the team’s analysis and the team itself. Targets are to be discussed and agreed upon by the planning team, and an annex does not make the plan the team’s work.

Why. This aligns with Career Stage 2 expectations because indicator 1.2.2 asks the school head to develop school plans with the planning team, and the School Improvement Plan Guidebook (DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015) sets the team’s steps. Activity 2.2 rates the improvement areas, which may include a community situation such as flooding, for strategic importance, urgency, magnitude and feasibility. Activity 3.1 gives each priority a general objective, Activities 3.2 to 3.6 have a project team find the root cause, and Step 6 then writes the SMART project objective statement. The option that writes time-bound objectives at the same meeting prioritizes correctly but skips the root cause analysis, without which, Activity 3.6 warns, solutions may only address the symptoms.

Indicator 1.2.2: Develop and implement with the planning team school plans aligned with institutional goals and policies.

Sources: DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, School Improvement Plan Guidebook, Activities 2.2, 3.1, 3.2 and 3.6 and Step 6; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020.

Nothing in this guide reproduces or predicts examination content.

Frequently asked questions

Is a SWOT analysis required in DepEd schools?

The SIP process does not require one. DO 44, s. 2015 and its guidebook name no SWOT and use the Gap Analysis Template and four rating criteria. DepEd’s quality management order does list a “SWOT Analysis” first among the QMS Planning Documents, and says “All Schools shall have their own set of Planning Documents”, updated annually (DO 009, s. 2021, Sec. IX.A). Under the manual for that system, the process holder “shall create a SWOT Analysis” on the SWOT Matrix form (DM 014, s. 2022, Risk Management, item 4.1.1).

What does SMART stand for in DepEd?

It depends on the issuance. For a SIP project objective it is “specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, time-bound” (DO 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Step 6). For the OPCRF and the IPCRF it is “Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, Time Bound” (DO 2, s. 2015, para. 21). The IEP form for learners with disabilities uses “Strategic, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic and Time-bound” (DO 044, s. 2021).

What is the difference between SWOT and SMART?

SWOT describes where the school stands. It sorts findings into strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. SMART tests the sentence that says where the school is going: an objective with a group, a number and a date. A SWOT comes at the start of planning and a SMART objective near the end, after the improvement areas are rated and the root cause is found (DO 009, s. 2021, Sec. IX.A; DO 44, s. 2015, SIP Guidebook, Step 6).

Can a threat become a SMART objective?

Yes, in the part the school controls. The SIP Guidebook says a priority improvement area “can also be a community situation affecting the school and learners”, and its examples are “flooding and unsafe school water source” (Activity 2.2). The objective then names what the school will do for learners, such as learning tasks on every day classes are suspended, and the planning team brings the rest to the barangay or the local government.

How many SMART objectives should a School Improvement Plan have?

DO 44, s. 2015 sets no number. Each priority improvement area has a general objective, and each project design has one solution and one project objective statement (Step 6). The guidebook also advises making projects “manageable to provide the team with immediate results”.

Sources

DepEd issuances

  • DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2021, Institutionalization of a Quality Management System in the Department of Education (February 24, 2021): Secs. III, V, VIII.D, IX.A and XI.C.
  • DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015, Guidelines on the Enhanced School Improvement Planning (SIP) Process and the School Report Card (SRC) (September 29, 2015), with the SIP Guidebook: para. 6 of the order; Activities 1.2, 2.1, 2.2 and 3.1, Steps 4 to 8, and Annexes 3, 4, 5, 9 and 10.
  • DepEd Order No. 2, s. 2015, Guidelines on the Establishment and Implementation of the Results-Based Performance Management System (RPMS) in the Department of Education (February 6, 2015): para. 21.
  • DepEd Central Office memorandum of November 27, 2018 on the appraisal of School Improvement Plans, with the SIP Quality Assessment Tool (BHROD-SED, November 2018): Chapter 2 rows.
  • Memorandum DM-OUHROD-2024-0586, Interim Guidelines for the Office Performance Planning and Assessment for FY 2024 Onwards (March 27, 2024): Annex B, paras. 7, 8 and 10.
  • DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020, National Adoption and Implementation of the Philippine Professional Standards for School Heads (September 7, 2020): indicators 1.2.1, 1.2.2, 1.7.1, 2.6.1 and 3.4.1.
  • DepEd Order No. 007, s. 2024, Policy Guidelines on the Implementation of the Revised School-Based Management (SBM) System (May 16, 2024).
  • DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2026, Guidelines on the Implementation of the Three-Term School Calendar in Basic Education (April 16, 2026): para. 4 and Annex B.
  • DepEd Memorandum No. 014, s. 2022, The DepEd Quality Management System Manual and Procedures and Work Instructions Manual (March 15, 2022): Procedures and Work Instructions Manual, Risk Management (PAWIM-P-002), items 4.1.1 and 4.1.2, and the SWOT Matrix form (PAWIM-F-003).
  • DepEd Memorandum No. 068, s. 2025, Addendum to the DepEd Memorandum No. 014, s. 2022 (The DepEd Quality Management System Manual and Procedures and Work Instructions Manual) (August 11, 2025).
  • For the wordings of SMART: DepEd Order No. 81, s. 2011 and DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2012 (project proposal format, item 2.2); DepEd Order No. 41, s. 2015 (career guidance module); DepEd Order No. 044, s. 2021 (IEP form, Section C); DepEd Order No. 035, s. 2025 (Sec. X); DepEd Order No. 030, s. 2025 (Enclosure 1); and DepEd Memorandum No. 064, s. 2025 (Table 6).

Research and other publications

Written by Mark Anthony Llego for NASH Reviewer. Sources: DepEd Order No. 009, s. 2021; DepEd Order No. 44, s. 2015 and the SIP Guidebook; DepEd Order No. 2, s. 2015; Memorandum DM-OUHROD-2024-0586; DepEd Order No. 024, s. 2020; and the research listed above.